Originally posted by sbuck143
But the thing all the non-believers dont realize.........is that every team that has one of these X-factor guys has tried to duplicate him at least 5 separate times, and you're not dealing with D-league newbies here. You're dealing with hardcore addicts, computer nerds, and math junkies that are born to analyze and compare. There are few things more motivating than trying to recreate god's gift to GLB, and we devoted several seasons of hardcore analysis to that effect.
We have an x-factor guy, and tried duplicating him 3 times now through his dot-life. We ran controlled scrimmages (before VA's so none of that junk messing up things), Putting one back in as a starter with a controlled OAI and DAI, then next scrimmage, same opponent, same players, same everything, but the other back in as starter. Not even close. Put them in another scrimmage rotating every play, same result. One guy looks like he is shot out of a cannon, and the other despite being 1" shorter and 3 lbs lighter, looks like he's wearing concrete shoes.
The clincher was that In real games, you could tell within the first few ticks of a play which HB was in, without ever looking at the roster at the side of the replay screen. The dots just moved differently. Even though their build was exactly the same, it didn't matter what time of the game or what had happened prior, you could nearly instantly tell if the X-factor was in, or if it was "the Clod".
I believe this topic is very much almost like discussing religion. You either believe or are a skeptic. For The skeptics there is not enough proof in the world to get them to believe, and the believers have so much faith in their beliefs they are not all too inclined to try to proof it to the non-believers.
Watching the dots is the best way to do it. I said this before, but I have watched two almost exactly built CBs playing in the same CB slots play in games, and I can tell who is who just by how they move. Before VAs, and they had almost identical builds, playing in the same system.
All dots are created equal, but some dots are more equal than others!