Originally posted by AgentTBC
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by britdevine316
Do you not see how huge of an advantage the test server is
Yes, it is a huge advantage for the entire community. Allowing us to get most bugs and balanced figured out before things go live is a huge advantage. I'm glad you can see this.
-Thorn
I've been in your position; it's easy to get defensive because you know most people are trying to help the game as best they can and thus ignore the very real potential for abuse this provides the testers. I hope you don't fall into that trap.
The thing you and the mods are ignoring is that it is possible to both actively want to improve the game and work towards that goal AND to use knowledge you gain on a test server to gain an unfair advantage for your players and possibly your friends.
If you run a lot of tests on various builds and it turns out that increasing vision on a halfback from 40 to 70 provides very little improvement in performance (note: NUMBERS MADE UP) you can't forget that information when building your player. If you have a halfback, you're going to put those points somewhere else. Someone who isn't a tester won't have that inside information any may "waste" those points.
You can't handwave that away by addressing only the crazy ranters.
Well said.
The key to building a great player is secret per Bort's wish. That's fine. But a select group of people have access to a sandbox that enables them to figure it all out - likely coming up with incredible player builds using combinations that Bort never imagined.
So the software gets tested, and a handful of people get inside knowledge on what can make an awesomely good build, and they can use that to their advantage in the game - a game which, by the way, they are directly competing vs. paid customers who have no such information.
How can they not see the unfairness here?
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 14:27:21