User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
Link
 
Sounds good Bort, thanks a lot for listening
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Bort

It's pretty hard to program AI as to when it's "safe" to go for the pick as to a PD, etc.

I mean, it's easy for us to look at it and say "he shoulda gone for it" but you have turn that into a discrete set of rules the computer can follow.


That would require a check "can I get the pick?", including...

- the estimated time the ball travels
-- estimating speed of the ball [vision, Super Vision]
-- seeing the QB throw / ball traveling [vision, Super Vision]

- the estimated position the ball will end up
-- estimated speed and direction [vision, Super Vision]
-- estimated altitude of the pass along its way [vision, Super Vision]

- the estimated position of the WR and defenders around
-- estimated movements [vision, Super Vision, confidence]

- the estimated position the CB can reach [agility, speed, confidence, SA Change Direction, SA First Step)

- the estimated likeliness to get at least a hand on the ball [jumping, catching, confidence, SA Hands, Swat Ball)

... and of course all these estimations should fail / be less accurate quite a good bit of time.


If the result of this check ends up...

100 % - the CB always goes for it (he's sure he makes it - but might just be plain wrong... still he believes so)

90+ % - unless ordered to play loose

90+/30+ % - medium without help / with help

50+ % - new setting

20+ % - aggressive


(...just an idea to be discussed.)


Yes.. This is what I was trying to say, albeit not as eloquently.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by Bort


Buk's idea actually gives me some more ideas for some veteran skills now.




What do you mean, Veteran Skills?


Check out drifter's thread in epic suggestions - it's a whole new set of unlockable abilities for higher level players.

Edit: he calls them "prestige attributes."




prestige attributes for only the veterans...I like it!
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by RAPB

Originally posted by Bort


It's pretty hard to program AI as to when it's "safe" to go for the pick as to a PD, etc.

I mean, it's easy for us to look at it and say "he shoulda gone for it" but you have turn that into a discrete set of rules the computer can follow.


That would require a check "can I get the pick?", including...

- the estimated time the ball travels
-- estimating speed of the ball [vision, Super Vision]
-- seeing the QB throw / ball traveling [vision, Super Vision]

- the estimated position the ball will end up
-- estimated speed and direction [vision, Super Vision]
-- estimated altitude of the pass along its way [vision, Super Vision]

- the estimated position of the WR and defenders around
-- estimated movements [vision, Super Vision, confidence]

- the estimated position the CB can reach [agility, speed, confidence, SA Change Direction, SA First Step)

- the estimated likeliness to get at least a hand on the ball [jumping, catching, confidence, SA Hands, Swat Ball)

... and of course all these estimations should fail / be less accurate quite a good bit of time.


If the result of this check ends up...

100 % - the CB always goes for it (he's sure he makes it - but might just be plain wrong... still he believes so)

90+ % - unless ordered to play loose

90+/30+ % - medium without help / with help

50+ % - new setting

20+ % - aggressive


(...just an idea to be discussed.)


Yes.. This is what I was trying to say, albeit not as eloquently.


you gotta love the eggheads.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
I'm worried if you bump SV and Vis up further, you're going to make it very OP.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
I'm worried if you bump SV and Vis up further, you're going to make it very OP.


Well.. I don't think it would have to be bumped up, really.

It would just keep it relevant, no matter what Coverage Style a person decided they wanted to play.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Adderfist

I'm worried if you bump SV and Vis up further, you're going to make it very OP.


Well.. I don't think it would have to be bumped up, really.

It would just keep it relevant, no matter what Coverage Style a person decided they wanted to play.


Here's a thought. have Vis/SV help in the calculations on int/no int.
SV/Vis would reduce the deviation range.

The sliders would be.
1) Go for int if you have help over the top
2) Go for int if no help sliders.

the value marked would be the "acceptable risk" value, and CB's wouldn't go for int's if the didn't identify the risk % they're willing to go for.

AKA. Recognizing they can possibly get an int.

Last edited Nov 28, 2008 22:47:08
 
Plax_Are_Meth
offline
Link
 
Bort, there is a small argument in the private DC forum concerning the semi-aggressive setting.


I am positive that the old medium does not exist anymore, since this semi-aggressive does not have the CB route jumping as the old medium did.

He however, is convinced that this semi-aggressive is 100% the same as the old medium, including the route jumping issue of CB.

We are arguing because you said this :
Originally posted by Bort


No, "semi-aggressive" is the old medium. Medium is the fixed version like I had intended it in the first place.

Edit: ninja'd


But your change log says the route jumping issue is eliminated.

So which is it?


 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plax_Are_Meth
Bort, there is a small argument in the private DC forum concerning the semi-aggressive setting.


I am positive that the old medium does not exist anymore, since this semi-aggressive does not have the CB route jumping as the old medium did.

He however, is convinced that this semi-aggressive is 100% the same as the old medium, including the route jumping issue of CB.

We are arguing because you said this :
Originally posted by Bort



No, "semi-aggressive" is the old medium. Medium is the fixed version like I had intended it in the first place.

Edit: ninja'd


But your change log says the route jumping issue is eliminated.

So which is it?




Jumping in front to get the ball won't take place on semi-aggressive, though there may be times when it looks like it if the defender doesn't have enough agility, etc. The code is basically:

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = receiver.intercept(+ 2 feet outside)
move_to(x,y)
}

as opposed to (in aggressive setting)

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = ball.intercept
move_to(x,y)
}

in some cases, ball intercept and receiver intercept could be the exact same spot, and other times not, depending on where the defender is and the angle of the throw, etc.

Tests I've been doing all look like the examples given earlier of old plays of what people liked on medium, unless the guy gets beat by a fake or something of course.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
::headache::

It's all too confusing
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 23:04:49
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Jumping in front to get the ball won't take place on semi-aggressive, though there may be times when it looks like it if the defender doesn't have enough agility, etc. The code is basically:

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = receiver.intercept(+ 2 feet outside)
move_to(x,y)
}

as opposed to (in aggressive setting)

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = ball.intercept
move_to(x,y)
}

in some cases, ball intercept and receiver intercept could be the exact same spot, and other times not, depending on where the defender is and the angle of the throw, etc.

Tests I've been doing all look like the examples given earlier of old plays of what people liked on medium, unless the guy gets beat by a fake or something of course.


I like how that sounds. Is there any chance you could change the coverage in the red zone so they play underneath on the WR?

In the mid field you protect the deep ball and stay over the top.
In the red zone, you protect underneath, and don't let them get those short passes off.


Basically what the code says is on semi-agressive, you run to where the WR is going and a bit to the right.
On agressive, the CB runs to where the ball is going to intercept it.
Really the difference is reacting to the WR or the ball.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 23:13:55
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Bort


Jumping in front to get the ball won't take place on semi-aggressive, though there may be times when it looks like it if the defender doesn't have enough agility, etc. The code is basically:

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = receiver.intercept(+ 2 feet outside)
move_to(x,y)
}

as opposed to (in aggressive setting)

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = ball.intercept
move_to(x,y)
}

in some cases, ball intercept and receiver intercept could be the exact same spot, and other times not, depending on where the defender is and the angle of the throw, etc.

Tests I've been doing all look like the examples given earlier of old plays of what people liked on medium, unless the guy gets beat by a fake or something of course.


I like how that sounds. Is there any chance you could change the coverage in the red zone so they play shallow on the WR?

In the mid field you protect the deep ball and stay over the top.
In the red zone, you protect underneath, and don't let them get those short passes off.


IMO things like this should be handled via Individual AI with Inputs/Outputs (further down the road of course). Basically each player would have a system similar to the current AI for GM's to handle specific situations. So maybe on 3rd and 10 you will gladly give your man a 5 yard gain, and keep a cushion until he passes that mark to get the sure tackle and force a punt. On the other side, a balanced HB may want to run on "Power" rush style for 3rd and short, while mixing it up with Elusive and Balanced for Screens and Pitches. In addition to situation, this could also be done based on the play selection. If the TE knows they are running Off Tackle to his side he may want to block on run focus, if he's staying in to stop that monster DE then pass focus would be better.... etc.


Bah...Sorry guys, just kind of thought of an idea and kept typing Back to the original discussion since as a DC and CB owner, it is the biggest thing on my mind!
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 23:19:07
 
Plax_Are_Meth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Plax_Are_Meth

Bort, there is a small argument in the private DC forum concerning the semi-aggressive setting.


I am positive that the old medium does not exist anymore, since this semi-aggressive does not have the CB route jumping as the old medium did.

He however, is convinced that this semi-aggressive is 100% the same as the old medium, including the route jumping issue of CB.

We are arguing because you said this :
Originally posted by Bort




No, "semi-aggressive" is the old medium. Medium is the fixed version like I had intended it in the first place.

Edit: ninja'd


But your change log says the route jumping issue is eliminated.

So which is it?




Jumping in front to get the ball won't take place on semi-aggressive, though there may be times when it looks like it if the defender doesn't have enough agility, etc. The code is basically:

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = receiver.intercept(+ 2 feet outside)
move_to(x,y)
}

as opposed to (in aggressive setting)

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = ball.intercept
move_to(x,y)
}

in some cases, ball intercept and receiver intercept could be the exact same spot, and other times not, depending on where the defender is and the angle of the throw, etc.

Tests I've been doing all look like the examples given earlier of old plays of what people liked on medium, unless the guy gets beat by a fake or something of course.


Ah, I see now.
Thanks, I was certain that it wasn't 100% like the old medium. Just got confused by how you worded it in this thread a page back.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 23:30:07
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Plax_Are_Meth

Bort, there is a small argument in the private DC forum concerning the semi-aggressive setting.


I am positive that the old medium does not exist anymore, since this semi-aggressive does not have the CB route jumping as the old medium did.

He however, is convinced that this semi-aggressive is 100% the same as the old medium, including the route jumping issue of CB.

We are arguing because you said this :
Originally posted by Bort




No, "semi-aggressive" is the old medium. Medium is the fixed version like I had intended it in the first place.

Edit: ninja'd


But your change log says the route jumping issue is eliminated.

So which is it?




Jumping in front to get the ball won't take place on semi-aggressive, though there may be times when it looks like it if the defender doesn't have enough agility, etc. The code is basically:

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = receiver.intercept(+ 2 feet outside)
move_to(x,y)
}

as opposed to (in aggressive setting)

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = ball.intercept
move_to(x,y)
}

in some cases, ball intercept and receiver intercept could be the exact same spot, and other times not, depending on where the defender is and the angle of the throw, etc.

Tests I've been doing all look like the examples given earlier of old plays of what people liked on medium, unless the guy gets beat by a fake or something of course.
Bort, is there any way I would be able to help going over test games? or just help in general?
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Plax_Are_Meth


Bort, there is a small argument in the private DC forum concerning the semi-aggressive setting.


I am positive that the old medium does not exist anymore, since this semi-aggressive does not have the CB route jumping as the old medium did.

He however, is convinced that this semi-aggressive is 100% the same as the old medium, including the route jumping issue of CB.

We are arguing because you said this :
Originally posted by Bort





No, "semi-aggressive" is the old medium. Medium is the fixed version like I had intended it in the first place.

Edit: ninja'd


But your change log says the route jumping issue is eliminated.

So which is it?




Jumping in front to get the ball won't take place on semi-aggressive, though there may be times when it looks like it if the defender doesn't have enough agility, etc. The code is basically:

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = receiver.intercept(+ 2 feet outside)
move_to(x,y)
}

as opposed to (in aggressive setting)

if (ball_thrown) {
(x, y) = ball.intercept
move_to(x,y)
}

in some cases, ball intercept and receiver intercept could be the exact same spot, and other times not, depending on where the defender is and the angle of the throw, etc.

Tests I've been doing all look like the examples given earlier of old plays of what people liked on medium, unless the guy gets beat by a fake or something of course.
Bort, is there any way I would be able to help going over test games? or just help in general?


why would u name your wr joseph adai?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.