Originally posted by valakar
Originally posted by Knightman
OK, I think we disagree on the issue of punishing the 1-4 seeds. WHY do you think home teams need to lose some revenue? Why shouldn't they be able to reap the fruits of their hard labor? Shouldn't this be one of the perks of finishing in the top 4?
I think we're probably going to end up just not agreeing on this point, because I tend to think that "parity" is GROSSLY overrated. Do you think the NBA was happy to see the Lakers and the Celtics in the Finals? You bet your ass they were. Having GREAT teams tends to elevate interest in leagues because, (well, this is just my theory) people want to see GREAT teams, not just very good ones. Would you have wanted to see Bird and Magic or Chauncy Billups and Derek Fisher? Brady/Moss or Trent Dilfer/Qadry Ismael? Parity ends up diluting quality because it rewards inefficiency--it assumes that the overall level of play is a constant. I'd say that when other teams see a superteam, they have to try to keep up, try something new and innovative to compete, and the overall level of competition increases as a result. But enough of my rant...
Bottom line is that I have absolutely no problem with rewarding high achieving teams richly as long as other teams aren't shut out to the point that they can't compete. Bort's suggestion allows for this, and I don't think the punitive aspect of revenue sharing on the higher seeds is--nor should it be--the focus for most people.
Let me chime in on this. I do not think it is about punishing anybody. One of the fundamental issues is the divide between teams at the top and and the bottom. Now teams that are better managed, recruited, etc should be towards the top and those that are poorly run or recruited should be towards the bottom. I think we can all agree on this. Now what about in a 'perfect' beginning scenario where 10 of the 16 teams were well run and recruited and had a season long dogfight for playoffs. Now what if the difference in record between #1 and #8 is like 2 wins and most of this was decided by tiebreakers and head-to-head match-ups. Most would agree this would be a fun league to participate in and would have a much more active forum then the league that everybody knows from day one who will win and who is in playoffs with little debate.
Now in this scenario using the old financial system those top 4 teams would get stronger financially and thus be able to recruit easier. They already have the "look I won my league", or "We lost 2 games and are a contender" arguments for recruiting but NOW they also can outright buy whatever they want in trades and offer ridiculous contracts. Now if managed correctly (and we already agree all these teams were) those top teams are now even stronger and win even more and the lower teams struggle a bit more and again after the 2nd season same story and the gap widens between the top teams and the other. This continues (already has in seasons 1-4 on GLB) to cause this rift.
The rift causes sold and gutted teams and once competitive teams to fold and lose interest in owning a team or many of the other secondary issues that come up on GLB. So back to the point you make about just adding money to these teams. I feel this is a solution and definitely heading in the right direction (better then nothing) but does not lessen the divide I mentioned as much as I feel necessary to create more competitive and entertaining leagues without 'punishing' those that succeeded earlier and got the 1-4 seeds.
The revenue sharing where you only split the money already generated but still give bonuses to all teams like Bort does accomplishes two things. 1) It allows for less total money to be in the game then your proposal and thus allows the trade and free agency market to not continue to get ridiculous. 2) It Narrows the gap between the well run (but unlucky in a sim or two) teams that are 5-8 seed and the well run (but more luck in a sim or two) teams that are 1-4 seed thus creating more parity thus creating more interest in league as a whole or the league forum thus creating more discussion and positive energy about wanting to have players on teams in this conference thus increasing positive outlook of GLB as a whole.
Re: punishing This was a response to GMathias who posted that higher seeds NEED to lose money because they're making too much, so even if there was a way to provide lower seeds with adequate and fair compensation, if it allowed the higher seeds to keep their money, he would be against it, i.e., punishment of the higher seeds is a necessary component of any restructuring (in his opinion)
Re: your ideas Your first two paragraphs just rehash facts not in dispute. Certainly those who win can have a "compounding" effect of their winnings as they can use them to further improve their team. Fine. You fail to take into account, though, the fact that these teams that get the most money will very likely be moving up to a new league, allowing the teams left behind to compete on a more level playing field. The promotion/relegation system provides a remedy for disproportionate distribution of revenue in and of itself. Higher revenue teams, assuming cash gives a team an advantage (which I think we all agree it does), are more likely to improve dramatically and therefore more likely to be promoted OUT of the league that they are dominating.
However, most people are not satisfied with this method alone.
I disagree with your contention that adding money to the "pot" does nothing to address the disparate nature of revenue earnings. You can set the visiting team's ticket sales maximums to whatever you see fit, thus allowing the visiting team to earn as close to the home team's revenue as is considered proper. There will be more of a gap between playoff and non-playoff teams, but here I philosophically have no problem. Many of the bottom tier teams in many leagues are abandoned, gutted or otherwise noncompetitive teams. I see no reason to subsidize their incompetence. Asking them to get to the playoffs is asking them to finish in the top HALF of their conference. I don't see that as such an unreasonable or onerous burden. And here again, promotion/relegation comes to the rescue as many of these non-playoff teams will be demoted to a less competitive league.
Regarding one of your last points, I've already made it clear that I don't worship at the altar of Parity.I think that EXCELLENCE should be the goal, not EQUALITY. If one team is so dominant, it won't stay in that league for very long and it's earned it's booty. Once it's gone, the other teams will have a chance at the prize, and they will be motivated to improve in order to claim it. I do not accept your claim that the difference between a #1 seed and a #8 seed is a "lucky sim or two". I also don't think that interest in a league is generated by parity. In the friendly tournaments that are run, teams boast about their league being the best NOT based on the fact that all the teams in their league are the same caliber, but because the teams in their league win more tournament games, allowing "bragging rights" about their conference having the BEST teams. No one cares if the bottom eight are all gutted with L1 players when they're crowing about "our league is the best". How ridiculous would an owner look if he said, "I think our conference is the best because although our team is mediocre, all the other teams in our conference are just as mediocre so we have parity!!!" Does that really make you want to be a part of that league? Does that statement fill you to bursting with pride? I don't think so.
Yikes! I think my tone is getting a little harsh here. Sorry. My point is that a remedy for the dearth of revenue for the 5-8's is something I agree needs to be done, but I don't see increasing the total number of dollars in the GLB world as being enough of a negative to warrant taking away money from higher seeded teams who earned their place according to the rules as they were.
Whew! Off to bed!