User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 
I don't know why everyone is bitching about this. Bort will put it in place then Nerf it halfway through next season just like everything else.

When all else fails NERF IT!!!
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed
I don't know why everyone is bitching about this. Bort will put it in place then Nerf it halfway through next season just like everything else.

When all else fails NERF IT!!!


Some may be bitching or see it as bitching. I for one am trying to have a conversation with others about possible solutions. Think of it as a debate. Either way I will adapt as I always have. Keep it as is I win because my team is set to make playoff money (unless a total collapse). Change it I still win because I feel more balance will be in game (financial balance that is). I mean the other solution that I know Bort likes but not many others do is a Salary Cap based on league you are in. This will keep teams spending (on personnel) equal regardless of the bucketloads of money you have.
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
Playoff profit sharing should have been done a long time ago. The difference between home and away was ridiculous and up to 50x, if the visiting team doesn't show up then there is no game and hence no revenue for anyone, it was always ridiculous that the home team kept everything and the visitors showed up for free.

The timing sucks, but the sooner it is corrected the better I guess. Personally the timing really sucks as my team has been a 5 seed two years in a row and now will be a 3 or 4. Oh well after the first 2 years it really isn't a big deal, the stadium will already be paid for but the extra money would help with the dang equipment bonuses that are getting huge!
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
Originally posted by Knightman

OK, I think we disagree on the issue of punishing the 1-4 seeds. WHY do you think home teams need to lose some revenue? Why shouldn't they be able to reap the fruits of their hard labor? Shouldn't this be one of the perks of finishing in the top 4?

I think we're probably going to end up just not agreeing on this point, because I tend to think that "parity" is GROSSLY overrated. Do you think the NBA was happy to see the Lakers and the Celtics in the Finals? You bet your ass they were. Having GREAT teams tends to elevate interest in leagues because, (well, this is just my theory) people want to see GREAT teams, not just very good ones. Would you have wanted to see Bird and Magic or Chauncy Billups and Derek Fisher? Brady/Moss or Trent Dilfer/Qadry Ismael? Parity ends up diluting quality because it rewards inefficiency--it assumes that the overall level of play is a constant. I'd say that when other teams see a superteam, they have to try to keep up, try something new and innovative to compete, and the overall level of competition increases as a result. But enough of my rant...

Bottom line is that I have absolutely no problem with rewarding high achieving teams richly as long as other teams aren't shut out to the point that they can't compete. Bort's suggestion allows for this, and I don't think the punitive aspect of revenue sharing on the higher seeds is--nor should it be--the focus for most people.


Let me chime in on this. I do not think it is about punishing anybody. One of the fundamental issues is the divide between teams at the top and and the bottom. Now teams that are better managed, recruited, etc should be towards the top and those that are poorly run or recruited should be towards the bottom. I think we can all agree on this. Now what about in a 'perfect' beginning scenario where 10 of the 16 teams were well run and recruited and had a season long dogfight for playoffs. Now what if the difference in record between #1 and #8 is like 2 wins and most of this was decided by tiebreakers and head-to-head match-ups. Most would agree this would be a fun league to participate in and would have a much more active forum then the league that everybody knows from day one who will win and who is in playoffs with little debate.

Now in this scenario using the old financial system those top 4 teams would get stronger financially and thus be able to recruit easier. They already have the "look I won my league", or "We lost 2 games and are a contender" arguments for recruiting but NOW they also can outright buy whatever they want in trades and offer ridiculous contracts. Now if managed correctly (and we already agree all these teams were) those top teams are now even stronger and win even more and the lower teams struggle a bit more and again after the 2nd season same story and the gap widens between the top teams and the other. This continues (already has in seasons 1-4 on GLB) to cause this rift.

The rift causes sold and gutted teams and once competitive teams to fold and lose interest in owning a team or many of the other secondary issues that come up on GLB. So back to the point you make about just adding money to these teams. I feel this is a solution and definitely heading in the right direction (better then nothing) but does not lessen the divide I mentioned as much as I feel necessary to create more competitive and entertaining leagues without 'punishing' those that succeeded earlier and got the 1-4 seeds.

The revenue sharing where you only split the money already generated but still give bonuses to all teams like Bort does accomplishes two things. 1) It allows for less total money to be in the game then your proposal and thus allows the trade and free agency market to not continue to get ridiculous. 2) It Narrows the gap between the well run (but unlucky in a sim or two) teams that are 5-8 seed and the well run (but more luck in a sim or two) teams that are 1-4 seed thus creating more parity thus creating more interest in league as a whole or the league forum thus creating more discussion and positive energy about wanting to have players on teams in this conference thus increasing positive outlook of GLB as a whole.


Re: punishing This was a response to GMathias who posted that higher seeds NEED to lose money because they're making too much, so even if there was a way to provide lower seeds with adequate and fair compensation, if it allowed the higher seeds to keep their money, he would be against it, i.e., punishment of the higher seeds is a necessary component of any restructuring (in his opinion)

Re: your ideas Your first two paragraphs just rehash facts not in dispute. Certainly those who win can have a "compounding" effect of their winnings as they can use them to further improve their team. Fine. You fail to take into account, though, the fact that these teams that get the most money will very likely be moving up to a new league, allowing the teams left behind to compete on a more level playing field. The promotion/relegation system provides a remedy for disproportionate distribution of revenue in and of itself. Higher revenue teams, assuming cash gives a team an advantage (which I think we all agree it does), are more likely to improve dramatically and therefore more likely to be promoted OUT of the league that they are dominating.

However, most people are not satisfied with this method alone.

I disagree with your contention that adding money to the "pot" does nothing to address the disparate nature of revenue earnings. You can set the visiting team's ticket sales maximums to whatever you see fit, thus allowing the visiting team to earn as close to the home team's revenue as is considered proper. There will be more of a gap between playoff and non-playoff teams, but here I philosophically have no problem. Many of the bottom tier teams in many leagues are abandoned, gutted or otherwise noncompetitive teams. I see no reason to subsidize their incompetence. Asking them to get to the playoffs is asking them to finish in the top HALF of their conference. I don't see that as such an unreasonable or onerous burden. And here again, promotion/relegation comes to the rescue as many of these non-playoff teams will be demoted to a less competitive league.

Regarding one of your last points, I've already made it clear that I don't worship at the altar of Parity.I think that EXCELLENCE should be the goal, not EQUALITY. If one team is so dominant, it won't stay in that league for very long and it's earned it's booty. Once it's gone, the other teams will have a chance at the prize, and they will be motivated to improve in order to claim it. I do not accept your claim that the difference between a #1 seed and a #8 seed is a "lucky sim or two". I also don't think that interest in a league is generated by parity. In the friendly tournaments that are run, teams boast about their league being the best NOT based on the fact that all the teams in their league are the same caliber, but because the teams in their league win more tournament games, allowing "bragging rights" about their conference having the BEST teams. No one cares if the bottom eight are all gutted with L1 players when they're crowing about "our league is the best". How ridiculous would an owner look if he said, "I think our conference is the best because although our team is mediocre, all the other teams in our conference are just as mediocre so we have parity!!!" Does that really make you want to be a part of that league? Does that statement fill you to bursting with pride? I don't think so.

Yikes! I think my tone is getting a little harsh here. Sorry. My point is that a remedy for the dearth of revenue for the 5-8's is something I agree needs to be done, but I don't see increasing the total number of dollars in the GLB world as being enough of a negative to warrant taking away money from higher seeded teams who earned their place according to the rules as they were.

Whew! Off to bed!
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 22:44:16
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 
I think the issue that most teams have with this is the fact that most teams have had to fight, put in the time, recruit, study, watch game film etc. to get good. I know my team is a perfect example of that (Botswana Bugeaters Africa Pro) we have been HOUSED in levels since the league formed. We have put in MASSIVE amounts of time and effort into getting the right recruits, players, player builds, setting tactics, AI and all of the stuff that goes into being a well run team. We have been the #2 seed in playoffs the last two years. Look at our stadium. We have that due to money management, making smart moves, building at the right times, and all of that was done through research and finding out what to do and how to do it the best way possible.

Why should the teams that put in half the time and effort that my team does receive the benefit of my hard work? I don't think people have that big of an issue with the money at the pro level. To me it is more of a slap to my face to say, our team put in hours and hours of time and effort in this game, instead of being rewarded for it we are going to PENALIZE our team for it and let the guy who does half as much as me get a free ride off of me.

It hurts the teams at the top that are busting their ass to get there and stay there and are rewarding those teams that may be doing less and just sliding in.

Do I think something needs to be done for the 5-8 seeds? Sure do a reverse payout for 1st round of playoffs 1 -4 seed 100K plus tix and concessions, 5-8 seeds 800k to 1 mil for making playoffs FIRST round only. Make second and third round bonuses = for all.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Not going to quote again because will be very long. I never said the bottom (non playoff teams) should get anything. If I stated being average was better overall again I apologize for making a incorrect statement. What I meant by parity was strictly for the interest in GLB as a whole. The bigger picture of the forum culture. My point was the more teams that CAN make the playoffs the more interest they show in the game and the more THEY WANT to improve. Reducing the divide as I stated allows this to be more of a reality. So in essence it would be best if all teams were very good could dominate other conferences yet some were on the outside looking in on the playoffs. However, since that is a slow solution that promotion is helping get to quicker I felt bringing more balance would increase interest thus create many more future top teams then the way it is now.

As for the promotion taking care of those teams with all the money the only problem is 4 teams benefited from this (some more then others) and 3 of those teams stay in league they are in with a HUGE advantage over the other teams. I mean we agree for the most part that a #4 and #5 seed are fairly close and competitive so my 'one or two lucky sims' does hold true more often in these games. Now the 4th seed is even further ahead of the 5th seed in the current system. That is all I am saying.

Finally after rereading part of my initial post I also say it is more then a few lucky sims here and there that goes into producing a quality team and product. In my above scenario (which is a made up one at that) said that all teams were equal in the beginning with top recruiting and GM's and ownership and teamwork and gameplanning. Yet the top 4 could have been decided by a few very good tactics and well timed changes and a lucky sim here or there. That is a minor difference yet the bonus or reward is so great. That was the point I was trying to make.

Again, I will state again your proposal is good do not get me wrong. Part of what helps is you take a bit from the rich and give a bit to the poor (again excluding the gutted/sold/quitter teams that are most likely non-playoff anyways).

I mean if Parity is so bad in professional sports or in general then why does Baseball have a luxury tax and football have salary caps and revenue sharing in all major sports for the most part. Yet the fans are more in love with it then ever. I mean back in the 60s the Packer fans loved it and in the 70s the Steeler and Cowboy fans loved it and then in the 80s the Niner fans loved it and in the 90s and currently (except Patriots for a few seasons there) it is difficult to know who is going to win. We still know the Rams (yes my team sucks), Chiefs, Bengals, Lions, etc are not good (compare them to those slow build/gutted teams) but you can honestly say that about 22 of the 32 teams have a legitimate shot of winning it all (now some are clearly more favored). So that is 22 teams fans more interested longer spending money, etc. That is all I am saying with my parity comment is more good then bad comes from it and this good affects more people than not.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed
I think the issue that most teams have with this is the fact that most teams have had to fight, put in the time, recruit, study, watch game film etc. to get good. I know my team is a perfect example of that (Botswana Bugeaters Africa Pro) we have been HOUSED in levels since the league formed. We have put in MASSIVE amounts of time and effort into getting the right recruits, players, player builds, setting tactics, AI and all of the stuff that goes into being a well run team. We have been the #2 seed in playoffs the last two years. Look at our stadium. We have that due to money management, making smart moves, building at the right times, and all of that was done through research and finding out what to do and how to do it the best way possible.

Why should the teams that put in half the time and effort that my team does receive the benefit of my hard work? I don't think people have that big of an issue with the money at the pro level. To me it is more of a slap to my face to say, our team put in hours and hours of time and effort in this game, instead of being rewarded for it we are going to PENALIZE our team for it and let the guy who does half as much as me get a free ride off of me.

It hurts the teams at the top that are busting their ass to get there and stay there and are rewarding those teams that may be doing less and just sliding in.

Do I think something needs to be done for the 5-8 seeds? Sure do a reverse payout for 1st round of playoffs 1 -4 seed 100K plus tix and concessions, 5-8 seeds 800k to 1 mil for making playoffs FIRST round only. Make second and third round bonuses = for all.


The only flaw with your statement is you assume those teams that finished 5-8 put in less work then you? How do you know this? Do I think some put in less work and would be rewarded for it in a revenue sharing system - absolutely I do. However, do I think more dedicated teams that put in their time to come up short and continue to get further behind I definitely do.

Furthermore even in college the home teams pay the visiting team money to come play it is not that hard to see this is what happens everywhere. It is not (other then jumbo tron situations) extra money but how to split or use the money already generated. If Bort decides to just give extra bonus or allow visiting team to sell seats in their stadium, etc that is definitely an improvement. We can agree on that.
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 


The only flaw with your statement is you assume those teams that finished 5-8 put in less work then you? How do you know this? Do I think some put in less work and would be rewarded for it in a revenue sharing system - absolutely I do. However, do I think more dedicated teams that put in their time to come up short and continue to get further behind I definitely do.

I agree with that statement as well that is why I said give the 5-8 seeds a higher payout for making the playoffs 800k to 1 mil, then give the 1-4 seeds 100K plus tix and concessions, That should get those owners who are putting in the same time and effort as me, more resources to use that money to get better players/build more stadium. The flunkie owners who just slid in are still going to fail with the extra cash because they don't care or try.

The cash would not be coming out of my team to get flushed down the toilet.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
OK, I think we disagree on the issue of punishing the 1-4 seeds. WHY do you think home teams need to lose some revenue? Why shouldn't they be able to reap the fruits of their hard labor? Shouldn't this be one of the perks of finishing in the top 4?


Because it's absolutely absurd how much they are rewarded. My team went 20-0 last season in A ball for god sake's and we're pretty much set financially forever. One season of success and good financial management and I did the math and after equipping my entire team and saving money for maximum stadium construction again next season, I gave my entire team 50% raises and will still end the season with a few million in the bank. After maxing out construction last season and selling tickets we'll never have to worry about money again. Do we deserve some financial reward for our time and efforts? Of course we do. Do we receive that much? You can't seriously think that it makes sense for this to be the case. On the flip side, a team I GM on I worked MUCH harder with (competition level is much higher) and went 12-4 in season 1 getting the 5th seed. The following season we were better but got screwed by some tough sims to go 10-6 and get the 6th seed. We WERE lucky enough that we won our first playoff game and the 7th seed won, so we "earned" a home playoff game in the 2nd round. Despite being a 5th and 6th seed and working our asses off AND getting lucky to get one home playoff game, I still picture a tough road paying for all the level 32 equipment we'll need unless we get a home playoff game this season. My team had one great season and is set for life, while the team I GM on has had 2 very good seasons and had to get lucky to even be in the decent financial situation that we're in.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
With all due respect, I am not missing the point. In your example, the team you GM has been financially responsible in focusing on building a stadium. Good for you. However, you admit that this focus has prevented you from being competitive, going on 4 seasons now. So here you sit as a lower tier team, which is financially responsible and presumably "working hard" at recruiting and game planning and player building, and after four seasons you still are not competing.

Meanwhile, teams like mine, who played home playoff games, have a 100% complete stadium, unlimited income, and 4 years of success, primarily due to being able to attract and keep agents with big salaries and bonuses.

And this strikes you as fair? We're killing you, and I would go so far as to project that at current rates of "growth", you will not be competitive for at least another 4 seasons, because that's how long it will take you to complete your stadium and begin bringing in the necessary revenue to compete for free agents.


1. We didn't win that many games, but never said we are not competitive. It takes time to turn gutted team around. We are just around the corner.
2. We are recruiting, our focus is not just on building stadiums. Building stadium is been fiscally responsible.

We are fighting for a playoff spot this season, and our goal is to challenge for the championship next season. Trust me, having more money does not mean we would have been more successful on the field. Good agents do not care about how much money they make as long as they have enough to upgrade equipments. Agents who asks for money usually have shitty builds anyways.

PS: not competitive for 4 more seasons? Let's scrimmage, I bet you will find us more competitive than you think.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=19
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 01:48:59
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by datongw



Originally posted by McGruffHawk




Originally posted by Tito716





If every team that missed the playoffs in the first season of every league put a full roster of level 1s on the field and spent all their revenue on stadium upgrades, would anyone in the league be poor?


Yes . . . because those teams would not reap the benefit of playoff revenue.

I'd be willing to bet that if you asked those owners who have maxed out stadiums "What is the #1 factor in completing your stadium build?" the overwhelming majority would not say "fielding a full roster of level ones." They would say, almost across the board . . . "Playoff Revenue."



Wrong. I GM'ed a gutted team, we have not made playoff in 3 seasons, the most we have won was 6 games in a season, but we still manage to build our stadium and are getting competitive without asking or receiving handouts. We are going to complete the level 2 at the beginning of next season. Playoff Revenue is nice, but not having it is not the end of the world. The #1 reason teams can't build their stadiums is because they pay insane amount of salaries to shitty players.


Wrong. You are not even the exception. I am owner of a successful team that has never been less than a #2 seed. Where it took you 4 seasons to complete you 2nd level, it took us two. At the end of season 4, we'd complete our entire stadium. All while giving out huge bonuses and generous salaries.

Why? Because of Playoff income.


You are missing the point here. I too GM a very successful team that has won the league each year, so I know how much we can make during the playoffs. My point here is that even if you don't make the playoffs, you can still be financially responsible and compete. If there were NO CHANCE for lower teams to compete, I would say there is something wrong. But that is not the case. If the economy is tough and there are just no jobs around, yeah, I would support the welfare system. But if there are plenty of jobs around, and people are just lazy or looking for handouts, you bet I'll be against the welfare system.

BTW, we could have completed the level 2 this season had we not made a mistake in building sections. Building a stadium is not as hard as people making it sounds, a team that have never had a winning season can still build their stadium and be financially sound. People need to stop coming up with excuses for their failures, or "nerf" others so they can be "better".


No offense man, but if the team you GM on is the Angola Dream then you did not receive the ridiculous financial windfall that comes with being a 1 seed throughout the playoffs. Sure, you guys won and I have the utmost respect for your team, but I believe you were the 3 seed and I believe had 2 home games (game 1 and the league championship). I actually think the biggest problem with the current system is NOT the financial weakness of the lower teams, it's the ridiculous financial advantage that getting home playoff games is. My A team last season actually received more revenues from 4 home playoff games than from our 8 regular season games. You tell me how that system makes sense.


Wrong team, try this one: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=19
 
Bill Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps
Originally posted by Bill Jack

Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


My team was on the top where I hosted every game except the final, made millions while the lower seeded teams made a few hundred thousand?

Don't think so.

Disparity is way too much between home and away team.
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bill Jack
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps

Originally posted by Bill Jack


Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


My team was on the top where I hosted every game except the final, made millions while the lower seeded teams made a few hundred thousand?

Don't think so.

Disparity is way too much between home and away team.


Yes there is a disparity that needs to be fixed for sure. I don't think taking away from the teams that worked their asses off to get there is the answer. I think changing the playoff bonus structure is a much better solution. As I have stated before in my other posts on this forum. Seeds 1-4 100K plus tix and concessions. Seeds 5-8 800K - 1.5mil depending on league, size, etc. That would close the gap for those teams that are run well and know how to manage that cash and get max benefit out of it. The teams that just skated into the playoffs and don't have a clue will still use that money in appropriately and not improve.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed
Originally posted by Bill Jack

Originally posted by BerkeyTerps


Originally posted by Bill Jack



Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


My team was on the top where I hosted every game except the final, made millions while the lower seeded teams made a few hundred thousand?

Don't think so.

Disparity is way too much between home and away team.


Yes there is a disparity that needs to be fixed for sure. I don't think taking away from the teams that worked their asses off to get there is the answer. I think changing the playoff bonus structure is a much better solution. As I have stated before in my other posts on this forum. Seeds 1-4 100K plus tix and concessions. Seeds 5-8 800K - 1.5mil depending on league, size, etc. That would close the gap for those teams that are run well and know how to manage that cash and get max benefit out of it. The teams that just skated into the playoffs and don't have a clue will still use that money in appropriately and not improve.


For the sake of realism, where do you propose that bonus money comes from? What revenue stream provides for teams receiving those large bonuses?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed

Originally posted by Bill Jack


Originally posted by BerkeyTerps



Originally posted by Bill Jack




Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


My team was on the top where I hosted every game except the final, made millions while the lower seeded teams made a few hundred thousand?

Don't think so.

Disparity is way too much between home and away team.


Yes there is a disparity that needs to be fixed for sure. I don't think taking away from the teams that worked their asses off to get there is the answer. I think changing the playoff bonus structure is a much better solution. As I have stated before in my other posts on this forum. Seeds 1-4 100K plus tix and concessions. Seeds 5-8 800K - 1.5mil depending on league, size, etc. That would close the gap for those teams that are run well and know how to manage that cash and get max benefit out of it. The teams that just skated into the playoffs and don't have a clue will still use that money in appropriately and not improve.


For the sake of realism, where do you propose that bonus money comes from? What revenue stream provides for teams receiving those large bonuses?


Bort can wave his superior yellow wand - Creates Playoff Prizes +1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.