User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Wiki Beta - http://www.glbwiki.com
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Originally posted by w_alloy

It does not fit in at all. Advertisements should not be front and center on a wiki page, especially when they it's an advertisement for an overpriced guide written by an agent as universally unloved as TSE is.

It screams "I got paid under the table to put this link at the top of the page and highlight it." Which of course is impossible to prove, but it doesn't need to be. There is no justifiable reason for that advertisement to be there.


Can I assume both you and Robb have been supporting the wiki financially so that you can ensure it stays available to the public?

Should the wiki also remove its google ads? Remember, you guys are certainly free to create your own wiki. Until such time as that I'd say anything that keeps the wiki functional and available to the masses - even if that comes from the ilk of TSE, it's probably worth it.


wikipedia has always been free and refuses to use Ads, if we aren't being true to the TRUE Wikipedia spirit, than change the name, remove all affiliation or mention of Wiki or Wikipedia because Wikipedia does not put advertisements on their site and they pubcially say they don't ever plan on doing it, they ask for donations to stay afloat
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
wikipedia has always been free and refuses to use Ads, if we aren't being true to the TRUE Wikipedia spirit, than change the name, remove all affiliation or mention of Wiki or Wikipedia because Wikipedia does not put advertisements on their site and they pubcially say they don't ever plan on doing it, they ask for donations to stay afloat


A wiki is a type of website. Wikipedia is a type of wiki. Most other wikis have ads.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Robbnva

wikipedia has always been free and refuses to use Ads, if we aren't being true to the TRUE Wikipedia spirit, than change the name, remove all affiliation or mention of Wiki or Wikipedia because Wikipedia does not put advertisements on their site and they pubcially say they don't ever plan on doing it, they ask for donations to stay afloat


A wiki is a type of website. Wikipedia is a type of wiki. Most other wikis have ads.


fine but GLB wiki should not advertise garbage because it gives agents false hope and all they will be doing is wasting money.

there is no data supporting this guide has actually helped anyone
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
fine but GLB wiki should not advertise garbage because it gives agents false hope and all they will be doing is wasting money.

there is no data supporting this guide has actually helped anyone


I agree that the GLB Wiki should not have a link on the toolbar, if that is what you are getting at.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
fine but GLB wiki should not advertise garbage because it gives agents false hope and all they will be doing is wasting money.

there is no data supporting this guide has actually helped anyone


Free market is not free market?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Actually, who is paying for the Wiki? If GLB isn't, why the hell not?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joemalaka
Originally posted by Robbnva

fine but GLB wiki should not advertise garbage because it gives agents false hope and all they will be doing is wasting money.

there is no data supporting this guide has actually helped anyone


Free market is not free market?


GLB wiki is not the place for a free market, if it is a free market than TSE should have his own damn website to advertise it.

The owner of Wiki says he won't take it down either which is BS.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
GLB wiki is not the place for a free market, if it is a free market than TSE should have his own damn website to advertise it.

The owner of Wiki says he won't take it down either which is BS.


So GLB is not paying for the GLB Wiki? How did they pull this con off?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Robbnva

GLB wiki is not the place for a free market, if it is a free market than TSE should have his own damn website to advertise it.

The owner of Wiki says he won't take it down either which is BS.


So GLB is not paying for the GLB Wiki? How did they pull this con off?


no clue
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
The obvious problem is that Google isn't selling something with an association to GLB, whereas TSE is trying to do that. Because he was forbidden from advertising his fraud on these forums, he's chosen to do so on the Wiki. It's very, very shady for the Wiki people to be involved in something like that, especially when Bort has included a link to it from these forums. I'd probably pull that tab off and if the Wiki guys want to run it as a completely independent site with their own rules, that would be fine. If the Wiki guys don't want that, then they should show some respect for how Bort wants things to be handled even if they aren't technically bound by any of his edicts.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma

Can I assume both you and Robb have been supporting the wiki financially so that you can ensure it stays available to the public?

Should the wiki also remove its google ads? Remember, you guys are certainly free to create your own wiki. Until such time as that I'd say anything that keeps the wiki functional and available to the masses - even if that comes from the ilk of TSE, it's probably worth it.


I'll admit, I was pretty uninformed about GLB wiki. I didn't realize it was a for profit entity "not endorsed by or affiliated with goallineblitz.com or its licensors" (a quote from it's disclaimer page). I wish this was actually true. Bort should remove the link on the top bar.

I apologize for voicing my opinion without understanding the full situation. But it does not change my opinion of how this reflects on Hikariu. At least the side ads are under a "sponsored link" section. The link to TSE's guide looks officially endorsed, like the owner of the page is helping out people who follow the link. Instead he is directing people to the link in bad faith because he is getting paid to do it.

The only possible justification is that the google ads are not meeting server costs. That would put Hikariu in a tough spot. If that is the case Bort should step in and pay the difference instead of resorting to helping TSE scam people.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma


Can I assume both you and Robb have been supporting the wiki financially so that you can ensure it stays available to the public?

Should the wiki also remove its google ads? Remember, you guys are certainly free to create your own wiki. Until such time as that I'd say anything that keeps the wiki functional and available to the masses - even if that comes from the ilk of TSE, it's probably worth it.


I'll admit, I was pretty uninformed about GLB wiki. I didn't realize it was a for profit entity "not endorsed by or affiliated with goallineblitz.com or its licensors" (a quote from it's disclaimer page). I wish this was actually true. Bort should remove the link on the top bar.

I apologize for voicing my opinion without understanding the full situation. But it does not change my opinion of how this reflects on Hikariu. At least the side ads are under a "sponsored link" section. The link to TSE's guide looks officially endorsed, like the owner of the page is helping out people who follow the link. Instead he is directing people to the link in bad faith because he is getting paid to do it.

The only possible justification is that the google ads are not meeting server costs. That would put Hikariu in a tough spot. If that is the case Bort should step in and pay the difference instead of resorting to helping TSE scam people.


+1
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Wow. Has it seriously been a year since I started the wiki? Time flys, can't believe I'm still on here everyday. Guess something filled the void of my old warcraft addiction!

I've personally be debating this for some time and I'm not sure what the best way to approach is. I'll remove the link from the homepage for now, it would be nice to find an alternate funding solution that wasn't as controversial to be honest. I'd rather not even have ads, but I don't really have a choice at this point. I think for a beginner TSE's guide does have value though, for what it's worth.

If the GLBwiki itself put together a guide and Team/AI mentoring service would the GLB community support that?

Just a note. Ads do not support the entire amount of server costs and maintenance that is needed to keep the site running. The ads do help to pay the bill though. I pay all the fees keep the server running because I like GLB, no other reason. I think of it just like a monthly flex cost.

For what it's worth I didn't think it was a big deal or even worth a forum post. On a similar note I've seen some ads for QuickHit showing up in the google ads. Should I filter them out? or should you all click on them to bankrupt that game and fund the wiki at the same time?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Wow. Has it seriously been a year since I started the wiki? Time flys, can't believe I'm still on here everyday. Guess something filled the void of my old warcraft addiction!

I've personally be debating this for some time and I'm not sure what the best way to approach is. I'll remove the link from the homepage for now, it would be nice to find an alternate funding solution that wasn't as controversial to be honest. I'd rather not even have ads, but I don't really have a choice at this point. I think for a beginner TSE's guide does have value though, for what it's worth.

If the GLBwiki itself put together a guide and Team/AI mentoring service would the GLB community support that?

Just a note. Ads do not support the entire amount of server costs and maintenance that is needed to keep the site running. The ads do help to pay the bill though. I pay all the fees keep the server running because I like GLB, no other reason. I think of it just like a monthly flex cost.

For what it's worth I didn't think it was a big deal or even worth a forum post. On a similar note I've seen some ads for QuickHit showing up in the google ads. Should I filter them out? or should you all click on them to bankrupt that game and fund the wiki at the same time?


you should have Bort contribute money to keep it afloat since he has a damn link to it in his game.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
I'd rather not even have ads, but I don't really have a choice at this point.

Have ads out the ass. Seriously, that's not the objection. If you're not getting any support from Bort (did you ever ask about hosting?), then you've got to do what you've got to do. I've got no problem with the Wiki having even more ads than it does if that helps to pay the bills. You've just got to be selective about the content of those ads. I also wouldn't mind donating a couple of bucks, and if a lot of people did that then it could make a difference. How about replacing the TSE ad with one making the Donation link more prominent, explaining that you're not getting any financial support from GLB itself.

Originally posted by
I think for a beginner TSE's guide does have value though, for what it's worth.

Beginners can get plenty of help for free, and it doesn't help Bort if they're spending money on something related to the game instead of the game itself.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.