User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
It sounds simple to say but in every league there will be one winner and 31 losers. Everyone can't win, everyone can't be successful, but our culture has developed this idea that everyone should be able to win. I feel exactly the same way about ti that I feel about coaches in football being fired. If a coach seems to have lost touch with his player then I say go ahead and fire him, but firing a coach just because they haven't won a championship in 7 or 8 years is insane. The people who make those decisions clearly have no idea what goes into a championship run and how difficult it is and how much it is impacted by factors totally beyond the coaches control.

The downward spiral is legit. Unless you are a PHENOMINAL recruiter, there really is no good way to break yourself out of one. You will suck, but you will never get relegated without totally gutting your team. My Intimidators have had now 4 losing seasons - I think we won 5, 8, 7, 5. That is pretty bad, but there is no chance we would ever get relegated unless we dumped all our players, because there are so many other teams in the league who have already done this. This is also why gutting leads to more gutting, because when one team guts, if you want to get relegated to where you can compete you would have to gut as well. I'm not necessarily advocating it, but that is the reasoning behind it.

Also owners think, why beat my head against the wall in this high league when I can sell my team back, put my name back on the list, and get a team in a much lower league instead? Of course if they limit the number of teams people complain nonstop about how they want a team ven though unless you have a LOT of time and patience, running a team is not really all that great.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 15:44:03
 
Link
 
Originally posted by
1. Gutting is a problem
- Yes it is, and I think it is contagious, and much more gutting than we've seen already will drive me away from the game (meaning one more gutted team).
-- Mitigation: I love the idea posted early on (sorry, forgot whose idea it was) to have some gutting "tripwire" at which all games for that team are forfeited (including retroactively). I'd go one bit further and say all stats against that team should be removed and/or replaced by averaged stats in other games (so statistical differences between different leagues are minimized). The "tripwire" could be something as simple as selling the team to a non-GM.


You start off with a great idea and then go nuts. What happend?

Originally posted by
2. Free agency in its current state is a problem
- It's hard to be blind to this even as (or especially as) someone who provides all his team's players. The rate at which new teams are introduced each offseason makes experienced players so much more valuable to move to new teams, that it creates extreme hardships on all owners (existing and new) as they scramble to recruit and retain talent. Those teams who don't have much player attrition have too much of an advantage over those teams who must constantly recruit. That leads to more gutting.
-- Mitigation: Another solution I've read in the thread which unfortunately I also can't remember proper attribution for (sorry lol!), is to make CPUs viable short-term replacements. Make their performance close to that of human players of comparable levels. Maybe make them widely available at existing levels but slightly more expensive (maybe 10%) than comparable human players "should" be. This would go towards influencing free agent value to help maintain the game economy at whatever levels are intended by game design.
-- Second mitigation: Slow the release of "new" teams. Yes this directly impacts the rate of revenue growth through player development, but perhaps makes that income more sustainable. That pressure encouraging more player development is the same pressure encouraging owners to leave gutted teams behind, which makes the game as a whole less attractive.


This (meaning releasing fewer teams) is going to happen one way or another, either Bort will reduce fewer or current lower leagues will be taken away (as their sold obviously). I have no idea which, if either, Bort is planning on, but I think everyone knows that saturating the market to there point where there's 1 team per agent is a little much.

Originally posted by
3. The game economy is a problem
- As an owner with a $12M/season payroll and more money than I can use including finishing my stadium at the end of the season, I'm probably more aware than most how much financial disparity there is between teams. Rich teams really have no hard choices to make economically. Host a playoff game or four and you're set for the rest of the team's existence.
-- Solution: Change the distribution of playoff income. This never seems to get discussed until late in a season, and the discussion is always about the season in progress. The answer is always "wait until next season" because owners have made decisions based on predicted playoff income. Simple fix is to state now that Season 5 will have a different distribution for playoff income. Maybe also give teams an offseason bonus based on what league they will be playing in next season, which will help stabilize league performance by giving teams a more realistic chance to field a team competitive at their league's level. Call it TV revenue or whatever, but make that income a major part (maybe as much as 50%) of the team's overall budget so there isn't so much ridiculous disparity between a league's rich and poor.


Not that I disagree, but let's pull this out further. What happens when bad owners still can't win and need another "DO THIS OR I QUIT" issue. What will it be and how do we fix it.

Also, as for being set for life, all teams are heading in that direction. Everyone talks about how dire it is, but no one counters the fact that income goes up much faster and costs. Everyone will have a full stadium withen 6 years with good financial management.

Originally posted by
4. Inconsistent and inadequate strategic communications are creating a customer relations problem
- This is the most important, and most correctable, factor determining whether agents choose to stay or go. Bort makes no single channel for communicating with the playerbase, so those who invest lots of hours reading forums have an inescapable advantage in predicting changes to gameplay. Negative perceptions also linger about admin responsiveness to customers, moderator and/or Alpha tester access to information not made publically available, lack of consistent standards for forum moderation, and unpredictability of how the game will change next.
-- Mitigation: Bort and DigitalDaggers should choose one single channel for communicating with agents and stick to it. Link interesting threads to which they might choose to refer, but don't bury their response within a few threads out of thousands. Dedicate a regular, predictable period each day to when they will address the playerbase. Aggressively address negative perceptions with positive statements to counter them. Train moderators to remain consistent with the corporate message (such as not dropping hints "Bort will be fixing that soon" etc) so as to eliminate the perception (though it may be correct) that moderators have inside information. Establish and publish strict standards for forum moderation and hold the moderators to those standards. Broadcast intentions for game modifications -- especially sim modifications -- well in advance. Never make "stealth changes to the sim.


Another "starts well, ends oddly" suggestion. Don't make "stealth changes"? What do you think players will do when they realize how many changes Bort makes. He's damned both ways here. If he tells us, then everyone jumps on him for changing the game, and if he doesn't, then everyone jumps on him for not telling them.

Heavy sits the crown.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by she didnt choke on a salad
Also, i think an owner could be able to pay GLB money to hire a CPU DC/OC to take care of all that stuff at the beginning. It could be a basic script that scouts out an opponents past gameplans and makes a gameplan based on that.



Damn, I don't even know how that could be coded. I would hope Bort does, but that sounds ridiculously complicated.
 
- L -
offline
Link
 
it doesn't have to be all that complicated, I don't think. There's already a greasemonkey script that parses all play by play data into run/pass, inside/outside, short/medium/long passing.

It wouldn't be too hard to get data for the past 3 games, take averages, then spit out a defensive gameplan.

Offense would work the same way, only it would look at the yards per carry averages and yards per attempt averages and make a basic offensive gameplan.

Autoadjust already does this to some extent, so I can see this as a total possibility.

Of course, a human OC/DC would always be better, but in the meanwhile, a new owner can use a computer coordinator until he finds a viable human coordinator.
 
RoddyAbraham
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
I have no idea which, if either, Bort is planning on, but I think everyone knows that saturating the market to there point where there's 1 team per agent is a little much.



suppy should not the same as demand. Of course should more demand than supply. That is a player market. I do not want, that a player has to search 10 days for a team.

But at the moment the situation hurts owners and agents. As agent of a level 20 player you get 150 messages...(if he is a good build)

Have fun with 150 messages.......If you have real good player, you get 300 at one day...You need a agent as agent for your player.

Good post by tpaterniti
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 15:52:49
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RoddyAbraham
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

I have no idea which, if either, Bort is planning on, but I think everyone knows that saturating the market to there point where there's 1 team per agent is a little much.



suppy should not the same as demand. Of course should more demand than supply. That is a player market. I do not want, that a player has to search 10 days for a team.

But the situation at the moment hurts owners and agents. As agent of a level 20 player you get 150 messages...(if he is a good build)

Have fun with 150 messages.......If you have real good player, you get 300 at one day...You need a agent as agent for your player.

Good post by tpaterniti


Yep there are a lot of teams, and not enough players. I don't think anyone is disagreeing there. It's not as simple as just not releasing teams though. Then you have 900 people starting another of these threads.

I had suggested something that would've allowed people to make "back-up" level players a while back to help fill out lower tiered teams, but that didn't go over so well, so I'm out of ideas.
 
Jagmind
offline
Link
 
Without a salary cap, free agency will continue to be hell for teams with little cash. I don't see why this has taken this long. It would help everyone out. Owners won't get as frustrated as without it.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 15:55:48
 
Veblen
offline
Link
 
I have no intention of selling my team back, but it is frustrating. I'm able to deal with the ridiculousness of the recruiting process which we ended up doing ok at last season (took a lot of time as everyone knows though). I think the AI is just way too time consuming. I feel like I'm never done tweaking things on it and could spend 20 hours between games if I had the time or wanted to. When we lose to similarly ranked teams I'm not sure if it's me and my gm's fault with strategy or if we were just overpowered. I also agree with people that the only way to compete on here if you own a newer team is to have a bunch of players yourself that you boost and/or have some friends who are willing to do the same. Good luck recruiting a powerhouse team from scratch anymore.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jagmind
Without a salary cap, free agency will continue to be hell for teams with little cash. I don't see why this has taken this long. It would help everyone out. Owners won't get as frustrated as without it.


Salary Caps won't help until we see an increase in monetary utility.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Veblen
I have no intention of selling my team back, but it is frustrating. I'm able to deal with the ridiculousness of the recruiting process which we ended up doing ok at last season (took a lot of time as everyone knows though). I think the AI is just way too time consuming. I feel like I'm never done tweaking things on it and could spend 20 hours between games if I had the time or wanted to. When we lose to similarly ranked teams I'm not sure if it's me and my gm's fault with strategy or if we were just overpowered. I also agree with people that the only way to compete on here if you own a newer team is to have a bunch of players yourself that you boost and/or have some friends who are willing to do the same. Good luck recruiting a powerhouse team from scratch anymore.


You don't have to use the AI, you'll still do fine. We wanted to try it though, so against my better judgement (I like being the only one accountable), I have 2 GMs helping me with it. I can def. be time consuming.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
VT, thanks for the response. My point with economics changes is that they should shrink but not close the gap between well-managed and poorly-managed teams. Yes, stupidity should be its punishment, but I'd rather my competition not remove itself entirely just because they can't do simple math. The $40M my team grosses this year (before playoffs) over doubles the <$20M some other AA-league teams take in. If there was a $60M base to all AA teams (for example), then I would have 25% more than my worst competition but not over twice as much. That's what I'm talking about. It's not just stadium size either; as islander1 pointed out earlier, fan support plays a HUGE role in your take. I'm just talking about reducing these advantages to something that doesn't prevent competition altogether.



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Don't make "stealth changes"? What do you think players will do when they realize how many changes Bort makes. He's damned both ways here. If he tells us, then everyone jumps on him for changing the game, and if he doesn't, then everyone jumps on him for not telling them.

Heavy sits the crown.


Yeah, he'll have to have a thick skin no matter what he does when he's running an enterprise such as this. While there will certainly be more discussion when each change is made above-board, transparency and predictability are two things customers look for in a business provider. GLB should make a commitment to providing both.
 
Veblen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Veblen

I have no intention of selling my team back, but it is frustrating. I'm able to deal with the ridiculousness of the recruiting process which we ended up doing ok at last season (took a lot of time as everyone knows though). I think the AI is just way too time consuming. I feel like I'm never done tweaking things on it and could spend 20 hours between games if I had the time or wanted to. When we lose to similarly ranked teams I'm not sure if it's me and my gm's fault with strategy or if we were just overpowered. I also agree with people that the only way to compete on here if you own a newer team is to have a bunch of players yourself that you boost and/or have some friends who are willing to do the same. Good luck recruiting a powerhouse team from scratch anymore.


You don't have to use the AI, you'll still do fine. We wanted to try it though, so against my better judgement (I like being the only one accountable), I have 2 GMs helping me with it. I can def. be time consuming.



I've spent a lot of time with my GM creating advanced AI tactics, but it's difficult to figure out if we're doing a good job or not. It just seems like if you go with the basic settings and don't have a far superior team to your competition then you're probably going to lose.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
VT, thanks for the response. My point with economics changes is that they should shrink but not close the gap between well-managed and poorly-managed teams. Yes, stupidity should be its punishment, but I'd rather my competition not remove itself entirely just because they can't do simple math. The $40M my team grosses this year (before playoffs) over doubles the <$20M some other AA-league teams take in. If there was a $60M base to all AA teams (for example), then I would have 25% more than my worst competition but not over twice as much. That's what I'm talking about. It's not just stadium size either; as islander1 pointed out earlier, fan support plays a HUGE role in your take. I'm just talking about reducing these advantages to something that doesn't prevent competition altogether.


I just don't get this. We just had a team with an AWFUL stadium beat the #1 team in our league. I'm not saying it's consistant, but the idea that all this extra money my team has is the reason we're winning is silly. There seem to be very few "bad" owners that are rich, and yet most of the people that would seem to be "good" owners have enough money.

Certainly there are other factors (Is it a "friends" team, is it a single player team, etc. etc) that could sway the money situation, but the idea that a bunch of useless money makes teams win is hard to believe.

As for reducing the gap, yeah I'd like to see that. Maybe do a 50-25-25 split in the playoffs where the home team gets 50, the visitors 25, and the league pool (divided amount 16 or 32 teams) gets 25. There are problems with it (the team playing the guys with the best stadium get more money) but most stadiums will be equal soon anyway. Also, I suppose I, as a team with a lot of money, could just not sell any tickets to cheat everyone out of money. Lots of loopholes, but there are fixes (making a home-field advantage based on ticket sales counters the problem I mentioned).

Originally posted by
Yeah, he'll have to have a thick skin no matter what he does when he's running an enterprise such as this. While there will certainly be more discussion when each change is made above-board, transparency and predictability are two things customers look for in a business provider. GLB should make a commitment to providing both.


Predictability, sure. Transparency, meh. It doesn't matter how transparent Bort is, he'll still get beat up for it. I firmly believe that a lot of people who complain about things are unable to win anyway. Not all of them obviously, but there seems an undercurrent in this game (and life) with "My guy/team didn't/isn't doing well, it's someone elses fault." Occasionally it is, but many times it's the failure of the individual that they're looking to pin on something or someone else.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Veblen
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Veblen


I have no intention of selling my team back, but it is frustrating. I'm able to deal with the ridiculousness of the recruiting process which we ended up doing ok at last season (took a lot of time as everyone knows though). I think the AI is just way too time consuming. I feel like I'm never done tweaking things on it and could spend 20 hours between games if I had the time or wanted to. When we lose to similarly ranked teams I'm not sure if it's me and my gm's fault with strategy or if we were just overpowered. I also agree with people that the only way to compete on here if you own a newer team is to have a bunch of players yourself that you boost and/or have some friends who are willing to do the same. Good luck recruiting a powerhouse team from scratch anymore.


You don't have to use the AI, you'll still do fine. We wanted to try it though, so against my better judgement (I like being the only one accountable), I have 2 GMs helping me with it. I can def. be time consuming.



I've spent a lot of time with my GM creating advanced AI tactics, but it's difficult to figure out if we're doing a good job or not. It just seems like if you go with the basic settings and don't have a far superior team to your competition then you're probably going to lose.


My team doesn't use the Def. Tactics and we're 11-2 having played the season (save for the last two games) unboosted in CPL. It's not a requirement, but I won't deny if done right it can help.
 
RoddyAbraham
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


I had suggested something that would've allowed people to make "back-up" level players a while back to help fill out lower tiered teams, but that didn't go over so well, so I'm out of ideas.


Everybody is talking about owner leaving the game. But how many agents has left this game?

I think, that also a lot of agents are leaving. Why they are doing this?

Personally I do not like, that a player can do almost nothing. The training settings should get improved. A player should allow to train more than one skill. A second skill should be trained.(but the first skill improves faster)
I think, that long snapper was not a bad addition. So I can say to a FA, who I wants as backup center. You will be also long snapper. So he has a role more. But where is the feedback? I do not know, how he is working as long snapper. Feedback and the players stay in the game!

Players should get more involved. Where are the team captains? Where are Pro Bowl elections? (yes there should be a script, which choses the best player and if it is only statswise) But the player should get more options and more feedback. players could get more experience, if they are fitting their role.

Nobody wants to play on special teams. It is boring....So a special teamer should get a bonus in experience. Where is the special ability special teamer?

Everybody is talking about owners leaving..... agents leaving and owners leaving.....If all players would stayed, we would have enough players.

The player should get more features...If you are creating a guard, and he is blocking his whole life. It is really boring. So you can think about, that a guard cost only 50 flex points....So we would have more guards..
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 16:27:27
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.