User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buck Nutty
Originally posted by TreMetal

Originally posted by drifter



The backup issue is no different than XP gain now so unless regular XP gain is going to be looked at, I don't think this systems should differ.


-1 in that case


hmmm so if you where a starter you would like this idea ....


Pretty much everyone of my characters that is on a human team is a starter (or a ST only player I created for the team). Just because I personally would not lose out on this, does not mean that I would want others to.
 
kingofgod
offline
Link
 
fricking awesome
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Cedo

Sincerely that's completely crazy to see that. To create a new system of XP just because Bort don't want to modify his first try...

Sincerely i'm quite disapointed.

Yes the idea is good but that will be easier to just rethink the XP curve. Yes actually the system is good if we compare this to reality. IRL players increase their attributes until maturity. Then they play at their max potential for some years (with some fluctuations) then they retire. If GLB wanted to simulate reality, that's near perfection.


BUT that's a game and players are bored with this system and i understand them. What need to be a season 10 retirement if users have the impression their players are at max of normal progression (opposed to artificial=boost) within 3-4 seasons?

Of course there's people who have said, agent of player only have to wait for fame and "bling bling" options. But sincerely that's optional add-on. GLB is about building players and we stop doing so with lvl 25-30.

There's something to be done QUICK!



If I'm interpreting you correctly ( I know you're not a native English speaker), you are saying that you'd rather there was some other fix for the stagnation plateau, but if there is not, this is as good an idea as any for something that can be done quickly?


Yes that's a pretty good cedo's translation You missed "the unhappy part" because i don't think it's normal to do another XP.
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 11:24:15
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Great idea, the trick is to make it not over balancing, but still have a point.

I like the idea of getting 1 VP per level after a certain point.


I think they should have increasing costs like the current SAs, so the higher level you get them, the better they are, but to specialize in one it would take a bunch of levels to get it to high levels.


I'm against any of them raising soft-cap levels, thats just another min/max nightmare.


Here's some ideas off the top of my head

CLOCK MANAGER: gives players a chance to make better plays during a 2 minute drill, have them step out of bounds to conserve clock, allow the team to gather faster for the next play, etc..

FAST HEALER: If injuries ever make it in the game, this guy does not get hurt much and heals faster, also maybe smaller energy drain from playing against very strong competition.

SPECIAL TEAMS SPECIALIST: already mentioned, I like this idea alot, I would like to see an ability to reduce the energy decrease from playing special teams, so a player could still get more non-ST plays in the game.

Hmm, i'm sure others have better ideas actually.

But good idea all around, interested to see how it turns out.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Example:

Terrell Owens is "famous" for his off-the field hijinks.
Terrell Owens gets double/triple-teamed on every play because he's a "threat."

I'm not 100% sure I like the threat idea yet, but it's definitely something different than Fame.


What I don't like about it (as written) is that it's an all-around booster.

The player draws extra attention, which would make it a team-helper; but if he doesn't get it he actually becomes the threat, so it also is an individual helper.

I'd be okay with it as a "team helper" attribute, making the other team misread the player as more of a threat than he is, combatted by Vision/Super Vision. If Vision/Super Vision doesn't see through it, then he helps the team by drawing extra attention; but if it does, then it fails on that play.

Oh, and it shouldn't change the call "from the sidelines." There are enough (at times valid) "It didn't call my play!" complaints at it is. It should just affect how the opposing team's players react.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
Great idea, the trick is to make it not over balancing, but still have a point.

I like the idea of getting 1 VP per level after a certain point.


I think they should have increasing costs like the current SAs, so the higher level you get them, the better they are, but to specialize in one it would take a bunch of levels to get it to high levels.


I'm against any of them raising soft-cap levels, thats just another min/max nightmare.


Here's some ideas off the top of my head

CLOCK MANAGER: gives players a chance to make better plays during a 2 minute drill, have them step out of bounds to conserve clock, allow the team to gather faster for the next play, etc..

FAST HEALER: If injuries ever make it in the game, this guy does not get hurt much and heals faster, also maybe smaller energy drain from playing against very strong competition.

SPECIAL TEAMS SPECIALIST: already mentioned, I like this idea alot, I would like to see an ability to reduce the energy decrease from playing special teams, so a player could still get more non-ST plays in the game.

Hmm, i'm sure others have better ideas actually.

But good idea all around, interested to see how it turns out.


I don't think you need to make it only 1 VP a level after a certain point. Just like with regular levelling, it will slow down dramatically once the player reaches VP levels in the 20s (which will be in their 8th or 9th year in the league without boosting). Keep it at 5 but there should be some sort of soft cap or escalating cost - I agree completely with that. If the performance boosters works as I intended when I came up with it, the effect is pretty minor. Putting 1 pt into clutch does not suddenly make the guy clutch any more than having 1 pt in Throwing would make a QB great. It would need to be pretty high, just like any other attribute, to work well.

In this, they differ from SAs. I think of them really being more like attributes than SAs in how they accumulate points because I think you really need to focus on a few to be really good at them. You can't spread out your points all over the place and expect it to work well.

As for the soft caps, as I've posted several times, if a player did nothing but pump points into raising a soft cap, by the time they were season 10, they would have pumped their cap up to around 70 AT THE EXPENSE OF DEVELOPING ANYTHING ELSE. I don't think there's that much advantage in that.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by EagleOtto

Great idea, the trick is to make it not over balancing, but still have a point.

I like the idea of getting 1 VP per level after a certain point.


I think they should have increasing costs like the current SAs, so the higher level you get them, the better they are, but to specialize in one it would take a bunch of levels to get it to high levels.


I'm against any of them raising soft-cap levels, thats just another min/max nightmare.


Here's some ideas off the top of my head

CLOCK MANAGER: gives players a chance to make better plays during a 2 minute drill, have them step out of bounds to conserve clock, allow the team to gather faster for the next play, etc..

FAST HEALER: If injuries ever make it in the game, this guy does not get hurt much and heals faster, also maybe smaller energy drain from playing against very strong competition.

SPECIAL TEAMS SPECIALIST: already mentioned, I like this idea alot, I would like to see an ability to reduce the energy decrease from playing special teams, so a player could still get more non-ST plays in the game.

Hmm, i'm sure others have better ideas actually.

But good idea all around, interested to see how it turns out.


I don't think you need to make it only 1 VP a level after a certain point. Just like with regular levelling, it will slow down dramatically once the player reaches VP levels in the 20s (which will be in their 8th or 9th year in the league without boosting). Keep it at 5 but there should be some sort of soft cap or escalating cost - I agree completely with that. If the performance boosters works as I intended when I came up with it, the effect is pretty minor. Putting 1 pt into clutch does not suddenly make the guy clutch any more than having 1 pt in Throwing would make a QB great. It would need to be pretty high, just like any other attribute, to work well.

In this, they differ from SAs. I think of them really being more like attributes than SAs in how they accumulate points because I think you really need to focus on a few to be really good at them. You can't spread out your points all over the place and expect it to work well.

As for the soft caps, as I've posted several times, if a player did nothing but pump points into raising a soft cap, by the time they were season 10, they would have pumped their cap up to around 70 AT THE EXPENSE OF DEVELOPING ANYTHING ELSE. I don't think there's that much advantage in that.



I mostly agree with you, especially on keeping 5 per level; but I think the soft cap boosters (not the others) need rapidly escalating VP costs (and in my ideal, a hard cap).

There's otherwise too much of a risk that conventional wisdom will become, "Use your VP's exclusively to raise soft caps. The VA's only work in certain situations, and just like with SA's, it's better to keep to the fundamental attributes instead."

And if that's what most people do, the goal of more customization will be lost.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
As for the soft caps, as I've posted several times, if a player did nothing but pump points into raising a soft cap, by the time they were season 10, they would have pumped their cap up to around 70 AT THE EXPENSE OF DEVELOPING ANYTHING ELSE. I don't think there's that much advantage in that.


I think it would be easier and probably less confusing (since we're not referring to a name that's been assigned by the community) if you could just use VP's to add to VS's that just gives you a +1 to an attribute as if they were equipment. Like, you can use 3 VP's to get a +1 to a "strength" skill and it gives you a +1 to strength just like equipment does.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Jed

Example:

Terrell Owens is "famous" for his off-the field hijinks.
Terrell Owens gets double/triple-teamed on every play because he's a "threat."

I'm not 100% sure I like the threat idea yet, but it's definitely something different than Fame.


What I don't like about it (as written) is that it's an all-around booster.

The player draws extra attention, which would make it a team-helper; but if he doesn't get it he actually becomes the threat, so it also is an individual helper.

I'd be okay with it as a "team helper" attribute, making the other team misread the player as more of a threat than he is, combatted by Vision/Super Vision. If Vision/Super Vision doesn't see through it, then he helps the team by drawing extra attention; but if it does, then it fails on that play.

Oh, and it shouldn't change the call "from the sidelines." There are enough (at times valid) "It didn't call my play!" complaints at it is. It should just affect how the opposing team's players react.


Fair enough. I was thinking about maybe splitting it into two ideas, a team helper and a threat, but how many people would actually want to get double coverage all game long with no chance to make a big play?

Also, it doesn't necessarily have to change the call from the sidelines. It just adjusts the assignments. A cover 2 defense would have one of the safeties shadow the WR (if the WR was the threat). It wouldn't so much change the call from the sidelines as it would create a necessity for the sidelines calls to account for the player ahead of time.

If the team only calls cover 0 all game long, then the WR would have a big day. If the team adjusts the defense and calls more cover 2, then the skill doesn't have a chance to trigger. And the skill would only have a CHANCE to trigger if the team doesn't account for him. It isn't like every time the team ran a cover 0 he'd get the skill bonus.

I would imagine the skill would have to give very small gains (or at least small gains in the first few levels of the skill). It would be the type of skill where you'd really need to invest most, if not all of your points to see significant returns. That way not everyone is spending a point or two on it and changing the game. It adds a bit of realism to the game and helps players separate themselves from the rest of the pack. It wouldn't be too powerful and there would be people who would avoid it due to the likely decrease in stats.

It would add a new element to game planning and further help decrease the likelihood of cookie cutters. You can have 2 DEs with the exact same attributes and SAs, but one has a high threat level and the other evenly balanced out his veteran attributes. One DE would force double teams, help create mismatches, and occasionally burn a team that doesn't account for him, while the other would consistently put up good numbers by himself.

It's almost a consistency variable. If you don't put any points into the skill, you'll play like you would always play consistently. If you pump points into it, you'll either boom or bust on a play (boom because of the attribute increase on trigger, bust if you get double teamed).

Maybe there could even be a slight decrease to overall attributes on plays where the other team does account for you. It would be like simulating frustration on the player's part for being double teamed or having the play go away from him.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by drifter

As for the soft caps, as I've posted several times, if a player did nothing but pump points into raising a soft cap, by the time they were season 10, they would have pumped their cap up to around 70 AT THE EXPENSE OF DEVELOPING ANYTHING ELSE. I don't think there's that much advantage in that.


I think it would be easier and probably less confusing (since we're not referring to a name that's been assigned by the community) if you could just use VP's to add to VS's that just gives you a +1 to an attribute as if they were equipment. Like, you can use 3 VP's to get a +1 to a "strength" skill and it gives you a +1 to strength just like equipment does.


Good point
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Sincerely that's completely crazy to see that. To create a new system of XP just because Bort don't want to modify his first try...

Sincerely i'm quite disapointed.

Yes the idea is good but that will be easier to just rethink the XP curve. Yes actually the system is good if we compare this to reality. IRL players increase their attributes until maturity. Then they play at their max potential for some years (with some fluctuations) then they retire. If GLB wanted to simulate reality, that's near perfection.


BUT that's a game and players are bored with this system and i understand them. What need to be a season 10 retirement if users have the impression their players are at max of normal progression (opposed to artificial=boost) within 3-4 seasons?

Of course there's people who have said, agent of player only have to wait for fame and "bling bling" options. But sincerely that's optional add-on. GLB is about building players and we stop doing so with lvl 25-30.

There's something to be done QUICK!


A lot of professional athletes will tell you that they didn't really get good until after they made the pros. The attributes we add points to don't really change much over a real pro career, except for vision and confidence. But other, less obvious attributes start being learned and developed - and this is what's being discussed with these "prestige" or "veteran" attributes. It reflects real life, and most importantly, provides a new and interesting and engaging twist for users who are hitting that L25 wall.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Some ideas for "veteran" attributes. I've tried to avoid those that mimic existing SAs, but there's going to be some overlap.



Gameplay attributes

One-handed catch - self-explanatory

Ball stripper - Makes a strong player even more adept at stripping the ball from a ball carrier

Cammo - makes the player able to mask his intentions - whether its a receiver who doesn't let on the ball is going to him till its in his hands, the LB who doesn't let on that he's blitzing, or an o-lineman whose knuckles don't turn white on run plays, this player slightly decreases the vision on the player opposite him.

Throw it where they ain't - a QB trait that gives the QB extra ability to put the ball where the defender can't get it.

Short yardage monster - for DL, this is a guy who is extra good at coming out of the four point stance and clogging up the line. For an LB or SS, it means extra ability to make the tackle at the LoS. There could be a comparable attribute for o-linemen.

Special teams missile - mentioned before, I really like it.

coffin corner punting - ditto

Sideline catch - increases ability of receiver to make catches and stay in bounds (does this even come into play with GLB?)

Locker-room and huddle attributes

Calming influence - player would reduce in-game confidence hits and perhaps increase something like everyone's stamina or confidence during tight situations - close games, two-minute drills, etc.

Rookie helper - gives a boost in confidence or vision to any player at his position more than x levels below him. May also slightly reduce the chemistry hit when there's a personnel change.

Clock manager - QBs only, self explanatory






Workout warrior - boost to stamina and strength


Video junkie - although this might just be like super vision SA.

Wise Veteran - gives a slight boost to all the players at his position on the team -
because he's a defacto additional position coach.

 
dpell
offline
Link
 
One of my players leveled up today! I was able to put two SP into vision and 3 into tackling. For 3 minutes it was great. I can't wait until next season when I get to do it again.

Seriously, we need something like this for next season. Having high level players is completely boring now.
 
reimero
offline
Link
 
I love the idea of Calming Influence, Rookie Helper and Wise Veteran. They're like the General SAs that QBs and MLBs have.
 
Buck Nutty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'd like to see some more ideas on the specific abilities the player could choose, and what they would do. Basically just throw ideas out there and we can pick and choose what's good and what isn't.

Also, I wonder if it would be a good idea to have certain ones "unlock" at certain levels, like the first set unlocks at level 18, the second set at 25, the third set at 30, maybe another at 40? Would possibly help to make it feel like you earned them.

Also, you said Ken had posted about a "perks" system at some point. Would like to see more on that idea somewhere.



What ever we do here bort make themdifferent from the Gear lvls ... Like maybe half way on every 8 lvls ...

LVL 20, 28, 36, 44 ect ... and if you wanted to do the lower I would start at lvl 12 maybe with One thing opening up and go every 8 lvls to help make the "Looking forward too" lvls now be every 4 lvls and more of an acheivement to reach and get pumped about.

Right now we all work our butts off to get 8 lvls and better equipment at like lvl 7 your almost peeing your pants to hit lvl 8 ... that sort of thing then you hit lvl 8 and your like damn it I got 8 more lvls to go ... Like I siad this cuts in down to every 4 lvls something kool unlocks for your player.

Ideas for things to give people ... I think that the LT is a great position but so is the other RT so why not give OT's another one for Line Protector where either spot you play you get similiar +'s like Protector. MLB great spot to but ROLB and LOLB are they not important? They are not a Defensive general BUT they are Strong blitzers and Run Crushers ... How about Intense Vision for them Help them pick up the run and get on it.




Last edited Aug 29, 2008 09:16:23
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.