User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
So then why are you CHOOSING to pay $200 every 45 dollars to COMPETE?


Because I'm not a BETA TESTER. I'm a paying customer. Duh.

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by oldskool

It's not screwing, it's revenge for game exploitation.


WE'RE BETA TESTING - WE ARE *SUPPOSED* TO FIND EXPLOITS SO THAT BORT CAN CLOSE THEM.

When he does, he should be rewarding us for finding them, and giving us full respecs so that we can move along to finding the next exploit(s) for him. That's the service we are SUPPOSED to be providing him. We're BETA TESTERS, remember?


Originally posted by oldskool

We built the right way, got screwed for 3 seasons and we got nothing, why should we turn around and help the people that screwed us?


If anyone should be punished, it's you - for not actually BETA TESTING the game, which is our job (that we are paying to have). Don't crab about the testers out here fighting the good fight and finding exploits for Bort to close so he can release his game for people to actually play.


You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.


It does when I'm being incredibly sarcastic when I claim to be one of the two ways.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by sjmay

You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.


It does when I'm being incredibly sarcastic when I claim to be one of the two ways.


LOL,

True, I've been staring at a spread sheet all day so I didn't catch it.

But the point remains You can't claim that the game should be about beta testing, which you are doing, and then turn around and complain about all the money you are spending on it

Also, point remains is that Bort does have a test server that he runs tests on, I think your bone of contention is that he doesn't allow any "common" ie, non admin, to look at it.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
http://tinyurl.com/notthisagain

Please show me where you HAD to "pay for the 'privilege' of testing". If you CHOSE to pay then it's your own fault that you "paid for the privilege".

You keep bouncing back and forth between "beta game" and "pay to be competitive". It's beta, why the hell are you trying to compete, and why the hell would you PAY to do so? Dumb, IMO.

And there's no way Bort et al. are pulling in $150k/month. Bort still has a day job, as does DD as I recall; something tells me they wouldn't keep their day jobs with those "hobby" salaries.


I'm not sure about DD, but I'm pretty sure Bort quit his day job quite a while ago (season 2 if I'm not mistaken) to focus on this game.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by RunningMn9

Originally posted by sjmay


You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.


It does when I'm being incredibly sarcastic when I claim to be one of the two ways.


LOL,

True, I've been staring at a spread sheet all day so I didn't catch it.

But the point remains You can't claim that the game should be about beta testing, which you are doing, and then turn around and complain about all the money you are spending on it


I see nothing wrong with doing both. We are his beta testers and customers at the same time. It's a very good system for making money while you develop a game IMO and I'm sure others will follow this example. However, it will be found out eventually by someone that you can't keep changing a game and not freely allow your customers to change with it to the extent of your changes. Sure it makes Bort more money now, but it will not in the long run and makes the beta version of this game much more expensive than the full version for those who would like to be competitive in every season.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by RunningMn9


Originally posted by sjmay



You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.


It does when I'm being incredibly sarcastic when I claim to be one of the two ways.


LOL,

True, I've been staring at a spread sheet all day so I didn't catch it.

But the point remains You can't claim that the game should be about beta testing, which you are doing, and then turn around and complain about all the money you are spending on it


I see nothing wrong with doing both. We are his beta testers and customers at the same time. It's a very good system for making money while you develop a game IMO and I'm sure others will follow this example. However, it will be found out eventually by someone that you can't keep changing a game and not freely allow your customers to change with it to the extent of your changes. Sure it makes Bort more money now, but it will not in the long run and makes the beta version of this game much more expensive than the full version for those who would like to be competitive in every season.


Besides making the game more realistic, what changes were there?

If the people clamoring for a respec, had thought they were building a football player, just tell me this then, what football player relies soley on speed, or solely on strength, what defensive player ignores tackling?

All Bort did was make the game realistic, it is a much much better game now than it was, and the ONLY people who are whining about it, are the ones who got hit hard because they didn't build a realistic football player.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
What you're saying would be true if it WERE realistic changes that were being made.

But there are, undoubtedly, many, MANY loopholes that have never been addressed, and many, MANY coding issues that need fixing.

So - let's take one example to keep it simple - and we'll focus on the whole 'realism' thing.

KR/PR. I have two more than 'realistic' players, one a CB with the requistite points in the 'return speciast' SA tree and another, a FS, who got dumped into KRs by his CPU team and ended up getting better than league average yardage at that position, so I've focussed his points on the 'realistic' settings I deem worthy of a kick returner (vision, agilty, speed and SAs first step and change direction, with some stamina thrown in now STs is causing such a huge energy drain). Neither are min/max players and are pretty rounded, albeit focussed on their PRIMARY role, that of returning Kick Offs.

Now - shouldn't I be rewarded for building 'realistic' players?? And I mean 'reward' as in getting enjoyment from knowing that my 'realistic' build works?? But the thing is, due to the changes, my players are worse than they've ever been - and reaching the point of being useless. Any half-arsed, super-strong lineman or power back, regardless of agility or speed, can now lumber his lardy arsed way back up the field for a more productive gain than my idiotic specialist who runs into the first defender.

So what should I do??

Continue to pour points into a useless player who has been built honestly and realistically in the hope that one day it might get fixed, or try to work with the way the game currently is playing so that I don't waste 1/10 of my player's limited career (or more) just out of some sense of decency??

I'd love to take the latter route, but in the meantime, the '1337 kids' will be saying 'F**k this - I'll play my HB at KR and score shit loads of return TDs' and the game remains unbalanced in favour of those that DO take the exploiting route - just as, unfortunately, it does with all online games that aren't TESTED and POLICED properly.

Now - where does this fit into the 'beta' argument??

Simple really. Using the same example, my KR 'specialists' have had REAL money invested into them for boosting, etc. It seems as though that money has been wasted, as they simply don't do what they're supposed to do. So I can struggle on and I don't HAVE to throw any MORE money at it - but that doesn't alter the fact that it's taken money to realise that it's broken....and at any point in the future I could find any one of my other players, again who've had money invested into them, being made useless because they don't fit with what currently 'works' in the GAME - realistic or not!

***((A simple analogy would be putting money into a vending machine and pressing the button for 'coffee - white, one sugar' - and all that comes out is some crappy decaf with no milk and no sugar.

It's STILL coffee - and no-one FORCED you to sepnd money on it, but you did because you expected to get what you paid for. But due to the machine f**king up, you didn't.

Are you going to throw more money into it in the hope that it get's your order right next time, or are you going to go somewhere else for your coffee??))***

And at the end of this, or if I choose to retire this 'broken player', I lose 30% of my money? That would be one thing if I'd got my '30% worth' out of him in terms of value for money and enjoyment, but with him being 'broken', that simply isn't the case.

Now - extend that to ALL the players that are good one season, then piss poor the next - whether that's because they chose to build to exploit and the exploit has been blocked, or build to be realistic, when no realism has been coded in - it still amounts to paying customers investing money where the 'return' for that money can be taken away at the drop of a hat......

By all means keep improving this 'beta' game - I'm all for that.

But whilst changes are being made, I don't believe that ANYONE should lose any FPs that they've paid for from buying or boosting their players. At the end of the beta period, or when the player's time comes to retire, then the FPs used in his creation and/or boosting and equipment should be redeemed IN FULL as a show of thanks for helping bring the game through it's testing period.

Just my 2p.............
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 17:35:28
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
So, it is more realistic for a DB to stand there drooling 'frozen in place' because a QB Pump Faked?

It's more realistic because a level 15 OT can keep a level 26 DE with Str and Agility and Speed all over the soft cap significantly, from reaching the QB, all game even though they are exceeded by double digits in the relevant skills/stats?

Sure, the numbers are matching NFL games a little more closely in some areas, but the game/sim itself is not more realistic.

Realisitic is 2+2 = 4 Not 5(.5)+1-17*.12/4 = some number in the vicinity of 4 (Mind you I just slammed down numbers and didn't actually try to make a real wonky equation)

The 'results' being close to valid does not validate the input system to create the results. They are being gained through some really crappy/questionable methods. The O-Line changes, the D-Line Changes, the Running Game Changes the Receiving game changes etc are all 'off' in some way.

I've accepted that. Its BETA. Its not a release game yet and I understand that things will be changing constantly until things are tweaked to a point where the results and the METHODS OF ACHIEVING the results are more realistic.

But if they are going to be running this as a true MMORPG/BUSINESS they need to understand that while it is innovative to (over)charge for their BETA experience, it is likely also good customer service philosophy to make allowances for players and their builds when major systems are _changed completely_. If they were not charging for BETA, I would agree with you. Just make a new character and start again. Since BETA is being treated as quasi-live and people have the ability to pay an this ability to pay HAS BENEFIT for the developers not just financially but in their ability to test multiple scenarios and builds and adjust the sim to match these imbalanced builds to make them perform more like they should... then it is only reasonable that they supply respec systems and methods.

And Oldskool you just must not be good at math. That 150,000$ figure was based off of only 25% of the players being boosted. Just a simple look at the pro-leagues and top teams in other leages on down the scale show that it is likely more than 25% of the population boosting. Thos figures also did not include any team ownership costs or flex point expenditures for custom equipment. And I know for a fact many people have repurchased their custom equipment at least a few times on multiple characters as the game system changed and they wanted to be more competitive.

They are doing very well, but I predict they wont for long if the same level of customer service continues and the SIM remains in this same state for an extended period of time.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Respecs aren't going to happen.

If they cost money, people will bitch that it's not fair you have to pay for "reaiming at a moving target", so they need to be free.

If they happen during the season, people bitch that it makes scouting impossible due to "reaiming at a moving target" (sound familiar?), so you have to limit them to the offseason.

BUT WAIT only allowing respecs in the offseason leads to bitching because you don't know how the offseason changes will change the game, so you don't know if you have to respec or what to respec into, so the fact that you CAN respec is made irrelevant.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Respecs aren't going to happen.

If they cost money, people will bitch that it's not fair you have to pay for "reaiming at a moving target", so they need to be free.

If they happen during the season, people bitch that it makes scouting impossible due to "reaiming at a moving target" (sound familiar?), so you have to limit them to the offseason.

BUT WAIT only allowing respecs in the offseason leads to bitching because you don't know how the offseason changes will change the game, so you don't know if you have to respec or what to respec into, so the fact that you CAN respec is made irrelevant.


No, you actually get all the changes done and implement them BEFORE the preseason scrimmages.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
What you're saying would be true if it WERE realistic changes that were being made.

But there are, undoubtedly, many, MANY loopholes that have never been addressed, and many, MANY coding issues that need fixing.

So - let's take one example to keep it simple - and we'll focus on the whole 'realism' thing.

KR/PR. I have two more than 'realistic' players, one a CB with the requistite points in the 'return speciast' SA tree and another, a FS, who got dumped into KRs by his CPU team and ended up getting better than league average yardage at that position, so I've focussed his points on the 'realistic' settings I deem worthy of a kick returner (vision, agilty, speed and SAs first step and change direction, with some stamina thrown in now STs is causing such a huge energy drain). Neither are min/max players and are pretty rounded, albeit focussed on their PRIMARY role, that of returning Kick Offs.

Now - shouldn't I be rewarded for building 'realistic' players?? And I mean 'reward' as in getting enjoyment from knowing that my 'realistic' build works?? But the thing is, due to the changes, my players are worse than they've ever been - and reaching the point of being useless. Any half-arsed, super-strong lineman or power back, regardless of agility or speed, can now lumber his lardy arsed way back up the field for a more productive gain than my idiotic specialist who runs into the first defender.

So what should I do??

Continue to pour points into a useless player who has been built honestly and realistically in the hope that one day it might get fixed, or try to work with the way the game currently is playing so that I don't waste 1/10 of my player's limited career (or more) just out of some sense of decency??

I'd love to take the latter route, but in the meantime, the '1337 kids' will be saying 'F**k this - I'll play my HB at KR and score shit loads of return TDs' and the game remains unbalanced in favour of those that DO take the exploiting route - just as, unfortunately, it does with all online games that aren't TESTED and POLICED properly.

Now - where does this fit into the 'beta' argument??

Simple really. Using the same example, my KR 'specialists' have had REAL money invested into them for boosting, etc. It seems as though that money has been wasted, as they simply don't do what they're supposed to do. So I can struggle on and I don't HAVE to throw any MORE money at it - but that doesn't alter the fact that it's taken money to realise that it's broken....and at any point in the future I could find any one of my other players, again who've had money invested into them, being made useless because they don't fit with what currently 'works' in the GAME - realistic or not!

***((A simple analogy would be putting money into a vending machine and pressing the button for 'coffee - white, one sugar' - and all that comes out is some crappy decaf with no milk and no sugar.

It's STILL coffee - and no-one FORCED you to sepnd money on it, but you did because you expected to get what you paid for. But due to the machine f**king up, you didn't.

Are you going to throw more money into it in the hope that it get's your order right next time, or are you going to go somewhere else for your coffee??))***

And at the end of this, or if I choose to retire this 'broken player', I lose 30% of my money? That would be one thing if I'd got my '30% worth' out of him in terms of value for money and enjoyment, but with him being 'broken', that simply isn't the case.

Now - extend that to ALL the players that are good one season, then piss poor the next - whether that's because they chose to build to exploit and the exploit has been blocked, or build to be realistic, when no realism has been coded in - it still amounts to paying customers investing money where the 'return' for that money can be taken away at the drop of a hat......

By all means keep improving this 'beta' game - I'm all for that.

But whilst changes are being made, I don't believe that ANYONE should lose any FPs that they've paid for from buying or boosting their players. At the end of the beta period, or when the player's time comes to retire, then the FPs used in his creation and/or boosting and equipment should be redeemed IN FULL as a show of thanks for helping bring the game through it's testing period.

Just my 2p.............



You have a point, and it is being addressed I believe, so what happens when that is fixed, and your special teams FS doesn't tackle the KR now for whatever reason?

Or that it is fixed, and now KR are being returned 40-50 yards, wait, that's happening now.

Unfortunately our team can't stop the freaking returns against us and that is setting them up for great field advantage.

While you have a point the KR/PR doesn't cut like he should, and doesn't follow the blocks like he should, there are also plenty of teams that can't set up the ST effectively, we are one of them, go figure, we are lucky to get 20 yarders while our opponents are getting 30-40 yarders.

So while yes it is a bug and a coding problem, there are effective ways to deal with it NOW rather than just bitch and whine, which is ALL you seem to be doing,

I challenged you yesterday, why don't you go help some people with "bugs" rather than bitch and whine and moan because you feel your 70 speed 10 agility guy isn't effective now. Yes I am making those numbers up, don't be an anal Brit tonight.

But let's take this a bit further, because you picked the one coding bug that actually exists, once this is fixed, what are you going to bitch about next?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
So, it is more realistic for a DB to stand there drooling 'frozen in place' because a QB Pump Faked?

It's more realistic because a level 15 OT can keep a level 26 DE with Str and Agility and Speed all over the soft cap significantly, from reaching the QB, all game even though they are exceeded by double digits in the relevant skills/stats?

Sure, the numbers are matching NFL games a little more closely in some areas, but the game/sim itself is not more realistic.

Realisitic is 2+2 = 4 Not 5(.5)+1-17*.12/4 = some number in the vicinity of 4 (Mind you I just slammed down numbers and didn't actually try to make a real wonky equation)

The 'results' being close to valid does not validate the input system to create the results. They are being gained through some really crappy/questionable methods. The O-Line changes, the D-Line Changes, the Running Game Changes the Receiving game changes etc are all 'off' in some way.

I've accepted that. Its BETA. Its not a release game yet and I understand that things will be changing constantly until things are tweaked to a point where the results and the METHODS OF ACHIEVING the results are more realistic.

But if they are going to be running this as a true MMORPG/BUSINESS they need to understand that while it is innovative to (over)charge for their BETA experience, it is likely also good customer service philosophy to make allowances for players and their builds when major systems are _changed completely_. If they were not charging for BETA, I would agree with you. Just make a new character and start again. Since BETA is being treated as quasi-live and people have the ability to pay an this ability to pay HAS BENEFIT for the developers not just financially but in their ability to test multiple scenarios and builds and adjust the sim to match these imbalanced builds to make them perform more like they should... then it is only reasonable that they supply respec systems and methods.

And Oldskool you just must not be good at math. That 150,000$ figure was based off of only 25% of the players being boosted. Just a simple look at the pro-leagues and top teams in other leages on down the scale show that it is likely more than 25% of the population boosting. Thos figures also did not include any team ownership costs or flex point expenditures for custom equipment. And I know for a fact many people have repurchased their custom equipment at least a few times on multiple characters as the game system changed and they wanted to be more competitive.

They are doing very well, but I predict they wont for long if the same level of customer service continues and the SIM remains in this same state for an extended period of time.


Being frozen on a pump fake, happens.
Being frozen on a head fake, happens.
Not being able to get to the QB, happens.
Being able to destroy O-Linemen, happens.
Not being able to destroy O-Linemen, happens.

Apparently you expect Levels to win no matter what, you don't take into consideration the RNG factor that is in place, if it wasn't in place, why the hell would ANYONE play the game?

The Running game changes? Running game hasn't been touched, as far as I have read, it's the tackling that has been touched, and that needed to happen, why is it realistic for guys that have NEVER practiced tackle, to NEVER MISS A TACKLE? It's not, plain and simple.

DE's are effective, even after the O-Line got better, The Receiving changes, Bort is testing it out now, but that was never mentioned by you, why?

As far as being overcharged, are you kidding me?? I have enough FP to last a good 10 seasons, and I haven't spent much at all on this game. Would you rather pay $20-30 bucks a month? I know I wouldn't.

As far as customer service, not sure what you expect when you have 4 admins, 20something mods, and a customer base of at least 125,000 + most of them kids and fly by nighters, half of them trouble makers, and a quarter of them whine about everything from A-Z, I think you are from the school of the customer is always right? Yea, that doesn't work too well anymore.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Respecs aren't going to happen.

If they cost money, people will bitch that it's not fair you have to pay for "reaiming at a moving target", so they need to be free.

If they happen during the season, people bitch that it makes scouting impossible due to "reaiming at a moving target" (sound familiar?), so you have to limit them to the offseason.

BUT WAIT only allowing respecs in the offseason leads to bitching because you don't know how the offseason changes will change the game, so you don't know if you have to respec or what to respec into, so the fact that you CAN respec is made irrelevant.


I agree that it will never happen.

But, if you weigh the complaints that you have brought up, one person has paid for a product (FP) and have had the company eliminate the value of their product.

While the other complaint is about gameplanning?!?!?!? Really?

Yeah, the one side already has the lemons, let them have lemons for the remainder of their time here, as opposed to fixing the problem, and having someone salty about it for a couple of days.

Is it alot of work to implement this? Probably. I don't know.

Do they owe it to some? Arguable. But they did sell a product (SPEED) and then take part of the product back.

Will it cost them, if they don't? Again, probably. You just don't do things like this to your core of customers.

It has been stated before, that someone else is going to duplicate the product that GLB has. Many will stay here until then, but what happens then? If GLB has taken back the product that they were selling, how many disgruntled customers continue to buy a product that gets taken from them, when there is another option?

Last edited Aug 14, 2008 19:23:45
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by oldskool

Respecs aren't going to happen.

If they cost money, people will bitch that it's not fair you have to pay for "reaiming at a moving target", so they need to be free.

If they happen during the season, people bitch that it makes scouting impossible due to "reaiming at a moving target" (sound familiar?), so you have to limit them to the offseason.

BUT WAIT only allowing respecs in the offseason leads to bitching because you don't know how the offseason changes will change the game, so you don't know if you have to respec or what to respec into, so the fact that you CAN respec is made irrelevant.


I agree that it will never happen.

But, if you weigh the complaints that you have brought up, one person has paid for a product (FP) and have had the company eliminate the value of their product.

While the other complaint is about gameplanning?!?!?!? Really?

Yeah, the one side already has the lemons, let them have lemons for the remainder of their time here, as opposed to fixing the problem, and having someone salty about it.

Is it alot of work to implement this? Probably. I don't know.

Do they owe it to some? Arguable. But they did sell a product (SPEED) and then take part of the product back.

Will it cost them, if they don't? Again, probably. You just don't do things like this to your core of customers.

It has been stated before, that someone else is going to duplicate the product that GLB has. Many will stay here until then, but what happens then? If GLB has taken back the product that they were selling, how many disgruntled customers continue to buy a product that gets taken from them, when there is another option?



Please tell me where an Admin specfically said, BUILD FOR SPEED ONLY, then you have an argument.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.