User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Speed De's Deserve an Answer Bort
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snark
Yup. I think at least part of the issue is that football fans hope something exciting will happen every play ~ and when they do happen, those exciting moments are the memories they take away from games, and what they associate with their favorite players. It's natural for all of the "boring" plays to fade into the background.

In his best year, Dwight Freeney recorded 16 sacks. Charles Haley? Also 16. In fact, there are only 35 individual seasons on record in modern NFL history in which a player's recorded *more* than 16 sacks...


Yeah, I know...everybody wants their player to be a superstar in every game. I understand that feeling of wanting to be able to talk about how awesome your guy is, but they really shouldn't get 5 sacks and 10 hurries in every game, just like a WR sometimes only gets targeted once in a game.

Sack numbers in season 2 were probably more in line with what was reasonable. I think that in season 3 we started to see higher level guys find holes in the system that didn't really show up when players only had 40/50 in a stat, instead of having 80+ like a lot of guys do.
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
I'm all for the POV of trying to make stats fairly reflective of the real world.

When this goes live for all leagues you'll make a post in the Recent Updates thread right? It will probably affect how I look at the game plan for tomorrow afternoon's game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Snark

Agreed. As agile, fast, and generally dominant as Magnus may be, there were sacks recorded in that game on plays in which basic tactics by the OT and QB should've been able to give the QB time to get rid of the ball. Not saying Magnus could've been completely stymied, but there did appear to be more room for balance. I realize that working this out may take time and trial and error, though ~ and thanks for implementing this so quickly, Bort!



Yeah, it's a tough balancing act.

One thing I've been thinking about: People want to see their players get sacks, but the top sack guys in the NFL only get like 14-15 sacks in a season. We had guys in GLB get 30-40 or more sacks last year, even in top leagues, which maybe spoiled them a little? I'd like to see things maybe a little more down to earth.


I agree with that to an extent. QBs are told they have 3 seconds to get rid of the ball. Very rarely do they get much more than that. OTs shouldn't be able to sustain their blocks for much more than 3 or 4 seconds. A large number of hurries, yes, but tons of players with more than 20 sacks, not really realistic.

As a DE owner, I would be happy if my player got 2-4 hurries a game even without a sack. At least I'd know he put pressure on the QB, maybe even hit him after the throw. That is really what is missing here. The QB only gets hit when he gets sacked. If the pass rushers could still hit the QB, cause some morale/energy problems, without getting a sack necessarily, that would be a realistic upgrade. Something to think about for season 5. Adding QB hits along with sacks/hurries would provide more realism to the pass rush.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eljefedelamancha

As a DE owner, I would be happy if my player got 2-4 hurries a game even without a sack. At least I'd know he put pressure on the QB, maybe even hit him after the throw. That is really what is missing here. The QB only gets hit when he gets sacked. If the pass rushers could still hit the QB, cause some morale/energy problems, without getting a sack necessarily, that would be a realistic upgrade. Something to think about for season 5. Adding QB hits along with sacks/hurries would provide more realism to the pass rush.


That's a good idea - # of knockdowns.
 
G35
offline
Link
 
theres a flip-side to that coin. what O-lineman do u see in rl pancake a guy 20+ times a game? sure pancakes are not the end all be all for O-line but as of now, its the only stat that registers for them.

this is a RPG game, u allocate stat points to skills and of course its only gonna be natural as the seasons go by u gonna see beefed up stat numbers. D-linemen particularly only start coming into thier own after thier 2nd, 3rd season. it took my guy a season and a half to really start doing anything.

point is, if u look at one side of the coin, dont forget to look at the other side.
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
I would say as an O-lineman I didn't mind the large number of sacks (maybe because my line didn't allow very many). The numbers may be superinflated but I think that's part of what makes this game fun, having the ability to get good numbers in any game.
 
G35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
I would say as an O-lineman I didn't mind the large number of sacks
(maybe because my line didn't allow very many). The numbers may be
superinflated but I think that's part of what makes this game fun,
having the ability to get good numbers in any game.


there u go, a good o-line stops anything cold already. a good o-line allows what, just a guess here but 10-15 sacks a season

chances are, the guys with 30+ sacks they got them against teams they dominated, or gutted, or just against plain bad builds.
 
merk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Darkstrand

Hey bort,

I wanna say thanks for addressing my thread. I'm glad to know you aren't secretly trying to pwn guys


It was definitely not intentional to make DE's so sucky. But hey, we get some new advanced player tactics out of it!


Thanks a ton Bort! I started one of the major threads pointing out this problem...and am thankful for your impressive response!
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Snark

Yup. I think at least part of the issue is that football fans hope something exciting will happen every play ~ and when they do happen, those exciting moments are the memories they take away from games, and what they associate with their favorite players. It's natural for all of the "boring" plays to fade into the background.

In his best year, Dwight Freeney recorded 16 sacks. Charles Haley? Also 16. In fact, there are only 35 individual seasons on record in modern NFL history in which a player's recorded *more* than 16 sacks...


Yeah, I know...everybody wants their player to be a superstar in every game. I understand that feeling of wanting to be able to talk about how awesome your guy is, but they really shouldn't get 5 sacks and 10 hurries in every game, just like a WR sometimes only gets targeted once in a game.

Sack numbers in season 2 were probably more in line with what was reasonable. I think that in season 3 we started to see higher level guys find holes in the system that didn't really show up when players only had 40/50 in a stat, instead of having 80+ like a lot of guys do.




I agree 100 percent. DE sacks were out of hand last season.
 
TurboBoxer
offline
Link
 
im all for decreasing sack, as the best players should only get at max 16-18 a season. But at the same time, i think hurries should be increased (confidence and vision become a bigger factor for QBs)
 
Snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by G35
Originally posted by Motiak

I would say as an O-lineman I didn't mind the large number of sacks
(maybe because my line didn't allow very many). The numbers may be
superinflated but I think that's part of what makes this game fun,
having the ability to get good numbers in any game.


there u go, a good o-line stops anything cold already. a good o-line allows what, just a guess here but 10-15 sacks a season

chances are, the guys with 30+ sacks they got them against teams they dominated, or gutted, or just against plain bad builds.


I'm not so sure. Go back and check out the stats and rosters from the Paris-Berlin game from which Bort posted a play earlier. Berlin was clearly the better team, but trailed after one quarter, and didn't put the game away until late in the 4th. The Ballers shut down the Colonels' offense, but it certainly wasn't a 200-0 blowout.

Magnus, at level 28, was obviously one of the top guys on the field. But 5 sacks in one game (and in one half), all of them in competition with a level 26 OT and a level 25 QB? Those'd have to be bad builds and worse tactics. That's Derrick Thomas-against-the-Seahawks territory. Sure, it happens, but how frequently? Even the hapless David Carr was "only" sacked 76 times in 2002.

I'm not saying that the game needs to perfectly mirror reality, or that stellar performances should be ruled out. Even if you consider Magnus a Strahan (or Thomas) type, though, there's a limit to what you can reasonably expect from him when playing against a relatively competitive team.

FWIW, I think introducing QB knockdowns into the game ~ both as a stat and with an in-game impact ~ is a great idea.
 
qubanti
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by G35
Originally posted by Motiak

I would say as an O-lineman I didn't mind the large number of sacks
(maybe because my line didn't allow very many). The numbers may be
superinflated but I think that's part of what makes this game fun,
having the ability to get good numbers in any game.


there u go, a good o-line stops anything cold already. a good o-line allows what, just a guess here but 10-15 sacks a season

chances are, the guys with 30+ sacks they got them against teams they dominated, or gutted, or just against plain bad builds.


For the record, over the last 5 years, the average NFL Oline allowed 2.2 sacks A GAME, or about 35 a SEASON.

If sacks are reduced now, then how few sacks will players get in season 7-10? Olines will be unbeatable by then.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TurboBoxer
im all for decreasing sack, as the best players should only get at max 16-18 a season. But at the same time, i think hurries should be increased (confidence and vision become a bigger factor for QBs)


Right...hurries from the pass rush should remain a large factor even if sacks are held down to keep things from getting out of control.

I think a key also is making it much harder to DT's to get sacks. DE's get most of the sacks in real life, and it took until Season 3 for them to get their share. DT's are getting too many now, and penetrating too easily; but a good DE who isn't outclassed should be at least getting hurries every game. DT sacks, on the other hand, need to be kept low.
Last edited Aug 2, 2008 17:17:01
 
t-money
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by qubanti
Originally posted by G35

Originally posted by Motiak


I would say as an O-lineman I didn't mind the large number of sacks
(maybe because my line didn't allow very many). The numbers may be
superinflated but I think that's part of what makes this game fun,
having the ability to get good numbers in any game.


there u go, a good o-line stops anything cold already. a good o-line allows what, just a guess here but 10-15 sacks a season

chances are, the guys with 30+ sacks they got them against teams they dominated, or gutted, or just against plain bad builds.


For the record, over the last 5 years, the average NFL Oline allowed 2.2 sacks A GAME, or about 35 a SEASON.

If sacks are reduced now, then how few sacks will players get in season 7-10? Olines will be unbeatable by then.


I very much agree with this sentiment. The best of the best builds should get 15-18 sacks in a season when going against top flight competition. The thing of it is that no one is consistently going against top flight competition -- not even in USA Pro.

Do you remember what happened Dana Stubblefield played for the 49ers in '97 and had a monster 15 sack season? It turns out that he was really just another mediocre DT who had the luxury of playing a bunch of stiffs that year. Stick John Randle (one of Stubblefield's contemporaries) in Stubblefield's spot that year and records would've shattered.

This fixation of focusing on the end result stats seems counter-productive. Until we have leagues that day in and day out match the best of the best against each other, the realism argument doesn't hold weight because in real life, you don't have pro-bowlers (which in the GLB world would be well-built high 20's and low 30's players) playing against pee wee teams (lvl 1's).
 
Snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by t-money
This fixation of focusing on the end result stats seems counter-productive. Until we have leagues that day in and day out match the best of the best against each other, the realism argument doesn't hold weight because in real life, you don't have pro-bowlers (which in the GLB world would be well-built high 20's and low 30's players) playing against pee wee teams (lvl 1's).


In the level-30-versus-level-1 scenario, you'd realistically expect a huge number of sacks, and there's only so much anyone can do about this situation emerging.

The larger concern is with situations like the one described earlier, in which a level 28 DE goes up against a level 26 RT and level 25 QB and comes away with 5 sacks in a half. Perhaps that can be attributed simply to poor builds and tactics, but I'm skeptical ~ and while I don't know how prevalent this is, it seems as if it's something to keep an eye on in terms of the in-game models.

I'll try to avoid being "fixated" on end-result stats, but when the simulation comprises lots of dots moving around a screen (and I'm not complaining about that!), it's a bit difficult to figure out how else to judge the dynamics of the game. What alternatives would you suggest?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.