User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Proof that Agility, Catching and Vision are overrated. Level 18 WR dominates higher level corners build revealed. (Colon Grifter)
Page:
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by mcnorth

Yeah - but that's the build. Kinda like a homerun hitter in baseball. He's not gonna lay down a bunt or have a .400 avg. But every couple of games he gets some pts all by himself. It's a good build and part of the reason the Aces are so good. Perfect in the #3 spot. I wouldn't want him out there when I ran the ball, especially with the WR block so key on pitches, but with 3 receivers and 15 yds to go I'd love the option.

The Lake Oswego (their opponent this week)defense is awesome, BTW.


That and my defensive tactics were terrible for that game, was an experimental defense that failed against a good team, they drove the field on us and held onto the ball for long chunks of time.

Full credit to the Bulldogs and we did get 1 WR open for a long pass just not enough plays for our offense to click. 10 points is actually the lowest we've ever been held to, by miles.


you scored 13 pts earlier this season...not exactly "miles"
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Dannyg28

he did give credit to the team that beat him. not sure why you jumped all over him for no reason.


No way, you can't give credit to another team and offer an excuse in the same sentence. That's crap.
What you're really doing there is saying, "I beat myself because I was experimenting and you just happened to take advantage. It was really me that decided the fate of that game because I have that power, but I'll give you credit because I'm such a big man and it's the right thing to say... though that's not true."

I think that's crap.


The only reason Flathead is 0-8 is because me and Sam were being nice and letting the other teams win!
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Dannyg28

he did give credit to the team that beat him. not sure why you jumped all over him for no reason.


No way, you can't give credit to another team and offer an excuse in the same sentence. That's crap.
What you're really doing there is saying, "I beat myself because I was experimenting and you just happened to take advantage. It was really me that decided the fate of that game because I have that power, but I'll give you credit because I'm such a big man and it's the right thing to say... though that's not true."

I think that's crap.


Let me clarify the "Excuse"

We played an experimental defense, the exact same one we used the week before. That means they probably did their homework on it and took advantage.

They'd probably beat us even with a real defense being played but it would be closer than that game was.

Lastly it's one game, and it's not a playoff game. Therefore it doesn't bother me at all.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
You need help then you shoulda just asked, dude. Want me to explain anything about tactics or anything then just PM me. Seriously.
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
The issue with Colon Grifter is twofold:

One, the lack of an ability for defenses to specify which cornerbacks cover which receivers. Colon Grifter works because sometimes he plays against guys with barely half his speed. If the defense can put a CB with 70 speed on him he won't do so well even if he has an advantage. All it would mean is that the best teams would need a variety of builds in their cornerback corps, which is not a bad thing.

The second problem is that the other skills (agility, catching, vision, strength) are clearly not as important as they should be. This is a direct result of trying to make the game fun at all levels. Really, you should drop 9 out of 10 balls if your catching is 15 or 20... except that this would mean that level 1 or 2 WRs can't catch anything. And that's no fun for newbies. So Bort had 20 catching mean you drop maybe 20% of passes instead.

Except that this seriously devalues the skill; you can pump 40 more points into catching and get your drop rate from 20% to 5% or something, or you can pump those 40 points into speed and still drop 20% of passes but make TONS of touchdowns and many more yards on the 80% of passes you do catch. This is a no brainer and a direct result of the fact that strength, vision, and agility are seriously undervalued by the game right now in the WR corps.

So the solution here is more difficult; If it were my game, I'd say that newbies at level 1 and 2 SHOULD suck, and a 20 catching means you drop 90% of passes even with nobody around. But Bort probably wants to keep newbies from quitting because they are so sucky so here's another solution: Let the cornerbacks bash into the WRs at the line like they do in the NFL. If your wimpy WR has 15 strength and 20 agility he's going to end up on his ass and be out of the play for 5 seconds.

That would help a lot.
Last edited Jun 28, 2008 23:23:55
 
alshiba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheCrew
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=64335

i have agility catching and vision all at 50+... and it works well...damn well


how is it working well? you haven't had a TD in three seasons and that's out of three seasons!!!!!
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AgentTBC
The issue with Colon Grifter is twofold:

One, the lack of an ability for defenses to specify which cornerbacks cover which receivers. Colon Grifter works because sometimes he plays against guys with barely half his speed. If the defense can put a CB with 70 speed on him he won't do so well even if he has an advantage. All it would mean is that the best teams would need a variety of builds in their cornerback corps, which is not a bad thing.

The second problem is that the other skills (agility, catching, vision, strength) are clearly not as important as they should be. This is a direct result of trying to make the game fun at all levels. Really, you should drop 9 out of 10 balls if your catching is 15 or 20... except that this would mean that level 1 or 2 WRs can't catch anything. And that's no fun for newbies. So Bort had 20 catching mean you drop maybe 20% of passes instead.

Except that this seriously devalues the skill; you can pump 40 more points into catching and get your drop rate from 20% to 5% or something, or you can pump those 40 points into speed and still drop 20% of passes but make TONS of touchdowns and many more yards on the 80% of passes you do catch. This is a no brainer and a direct result of the fact that strength, vision, and agility are seriously undervalued by the game right now in the WR corps.

So the solution here is more difficult; If it were my game, I'd say that newbies at level 1 and 2 SHOULD suck, and a 20 catching means you drop 90% of passes even with nobody around. But Bort probably wants to keep newbies from quitting because they are so sucky so here's another solution: Let the cornerbacks bash into the WRs at the line like they do in the NFL. If your wimpy WR has 15 strength and 20 agility he's going to end up on his ass and be out of the play for 5 seconds.

That would help a lot.


I think you'll find that Bort has been tinkering with the success rates at different levels of skill for that reason. Could well be the reason that we are seeing more drops and more fumbles this season than last. Could also have it tied to level, so that the lower level guys now don't have to suffer but as you level you have to keep improving those skills.
 
carumba10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner
Originally posted by AgentTBC

.


Could also have it tied to level, so that the lower level guys now don't have to suffer but as you level you have to keep improving those skills.


That's exactly how you do it.

An example. Assume a base drop rate of 10%.

(Level x 2 - catching)+ 10% = drop rate

A. So a level 1 with 10 catching = 2% drop rate
B. A level 10 with 10 catching = 20% drop rate
C. A level 20 with 10 catching = 40% drop rate
D. A level 20 with 20 catching = 30% drop rate
E. A level 20 with 40 catching = 10% drop rate.

Obviously the formula would need to be tweaked, but that's the way you deal with not training catching.
 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by carumba10

That's exactly how you do it.

An example. Assume a base drop rate of 10%.

(Level x 2 - catching)+ 10% = drop rate

A. So a level 1 with 10 catching = 2% drop rate
B. A level 10 with 10 catching = 20% drop rate
C. A level 20 with 10 catching = 40% drop rate
D. A level 20 with 20 catching = 30% drop rate
E. A level 20 with 40 catching = 10% drop rate.

Obviously the formula would need to be tweaked, but that's the way you deal with not training catching.


Problem is you ll have to do that with every attributes. Carrying, takling .. what about physical attribute then ? speed jumping ?

My opinion is that normally your drop rate, or at least the pass deflected rate should increase when playing against better competition. That mean at low level you ll got as much pass deflected in front of you than at higher level, if both the WR and CB have a good build. If CB is good and WR isn t, there should be more passe deflected, and vice versa.
Btw i m not telling it s not the case yet

 
carumba10
offline
Link
 
No, you don't have to do it for every attribute. Why would you have to ? Mmorgs by their very nature are always in development. Things are constantly getting tweaked and tuned up..that's if the developers are serious about making a great game. If changing the way catching/drops works needs a *specific* adjustment it doesn't mean everything else does.

The bottom line is to have a game with options and choices. That's what makes a game interesting. If it turns out that speed trumps every other atrribute, then the game will have a very short shelf life.
 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by carumba10
No, you don't have to do it for every attribute. Why would you have to ?


Because the next post will be a HB with 80 speed, 20 carrying and 20 agility, not having enough fumble compared to his attributes

 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by neverdodge
Because the next post will be a HB with 80 speed, 20 carrying and 20 agility, not having enough fumble compared to his attributes



I've seen that HB. He sucks really hard.
 
carumba10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by neverdodge
Originally posted by carumba10

No, you don't have to do it for every attribute. Why would you have to ?


Because the next post will be a HB with 80 speed, 20 carrying and 20 agility, not having enough fumble compared to his attributes



If that proves to be faulty also, then yes, it should be changed. If it doesn't, then no, it doesn't need to be changed. Each situation should be treated as a single entity and adjusted accordingly. You don't balance everything with one change fits all, it's on a case by case basis...like all mmorgs.

 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by carumba10

If that proves to be faulty also, then yes, it should be changed. If it doesn't, then no, it doesn't need to be changed. Each situation should be treated as a single entity and adjusted accordingly. You don't balance everything with one change fits all, it's on a case by case basis...like all mmorgs.


I mainly agree with you, but i still think when facing better players, those stats should naturally drop.

 
Dee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by carumba10
Originally posted by Donner

Originally posted by AgentTBC


.


Could also have it tied to level, so that the lower level guys now don't have to suffer but as you level you have to keep improving those skills.


That's exactly how you do it.

An example. Assume a base drop rate of 10%.

(Level x 2 - catching)+ 10% = drop rate

A. So a level 1 with 10 catching = 2% drop rate
B. A level 10 with 10 catching = 20% drop rate
C. A level 20 with 10 catching = 40% drop rate
D. A level 20 with 20 catching = 30% drop rate
E. A level 20 with 40 catching = 10% drop rate.

Obviously the formula would need to be tweaked, but that's the way you deal with not training catching.


I'd just make the Catching skill needed relative to the Throwing/Strength of the QB. I can catch a ball thrown by someone of my own talent level, but if a NFL QB throws a bullet pass at me, i doubt i'd be able to hold on.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.