User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Playable Cheerleaders Compiled Suggestion
Page:
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Originally posted by awesome




I shouldn't have to spell it out for you. There are already plenty of players that have extremely sexist and/or racist names. Implementing the customizable cheerleader option reinforces this by creating a systemic method to promote sexism.



Very interested in how you see this being done. And don't say 'well, it doesnt't exist so you can't'.

You brought it up, your point, explain it.



Ask a cogent question and I will.


See the 'Very interested in how you see this being done' in response to your 'Implementing the customizable cheerleader option reinforces this by creating a systemic method to promote sexism.'

 
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
This is hilarious. I believe chackmate said he was a little drunk when he made this suggestion. Yet, it is the hottest topic in GLB.


I don't think "hottest" means what you think it means.

 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
This is hilarious. I believe chackmate said he was a little drunk when he made this suggestion. Yet, it is the hottest topic in GLB.


In vino veritas.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by awesome


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla




Originally posted by Ken1





So you're saying this site would be a sexist site if it had playable cheerleaders? It's funny, as football teams dobn't get called sexist for having them.
oh yes they do. it's an issue that is only salved by the NFL promoting women's rights all over the place. a ton of feminist groups hate cheerleading because they believe it's similar to propping women up as trophies for the men of the gridiron to conquer once they conquer the field.


So that's what it is. You think it's sexist. At least I got to the point of the irrational hatred of the idea.

I'm left of center politically, but much more of the ACLU type, who tends to believe in free speech. I like the idea, but it's not the biggest thing in the world to me. But this sort of thing is why I'm so vehemently defending it right now.

It's like Nadine Strossen, former ACLU head, was asked why she kept defending pornography, and she said, "Because everyone else keeps attacking it."


No, I don't think it is sexist. Don't read things into what I am saying that I am not saying. I am very explicit and clear with what I am saying. I think it is a bad idea because it alienates existing users. The ethical considerations are an aside. (As I have said FROM THE FUCKING BEGINNING)


If you don't think it's sexist, then you have no basis for bringing your professional code of conduct into it.


Yes, I do. The WHOLE POINT of the professional code of conduct is that IT DOESN'T MATTER what I or you think. The point is that if SOMEONE, ANYONE reasonably thinks that it is sexist, then it IS. At that point, it is an officer of the court's ETHICAL OBLIGATION to remove him/herself from any association with what is perceived as sexist or racist.


Lawyers routinely accept awards from the Playboy foundation for upholding First Amendment issues.

Alan Dershowitz (the only one I know of for sure) has attended Playboy Mansion parties, and still has his law license.

I don't see Playboy as sexist either, but there's a much better case for it being sexist than for playable cheerleaders as sexist. Yet these lawyers associate with it and keep their licenses.
 
damo8
offline
Link
 
can we make love to the cheerleaders?
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Checkmate187


I am so sick of hearing about it, I want an answer to this.

Where do you get the 'pedophile' thing? Look at Laggo's summary (first post of this thread) and show me a stat, attribute, or mechanism that could be exploited to the point that a pedophile would get a thrill.


Did someone throw 'pedophile' into this thread?

Let's give all the cheerleaders ages to start at (increasing by one each season), and start them at 18, to make it clear the characters are adults.



How about we play FOOTBALL and shove all the other nonsense to the side?


Then go play football. Shoo.
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Idea was to have cheer teams purchasable seperate. Team owners would just have to hire a squad as a whole - as opposed to individually.

Alot of you didnt read the first post did you?

I read it, then read several other posts. I must have missed that or forgot it.

Still, I stand by my assertion - the idea isn't good enough to make it worth implementing. Too much baggage comes with it. It's not a bad idea, just not good enough to overcome the rest.

Better to have it as a seperate game.
Last edited Jun 23, 2008 16:52:16
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
What baggage comes with it?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
What baggage comes with it?


Don't bother answering him--he doesn't listen.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Checkmate187


Originally posted by awesome





I shouldn't have to spell it out for you. There are already plenty of players that have extremely sexist and/or racist names. Implementing the customizable cheerleader option reinforces this by creating a systemic method to promote sexism.



Very interested in how you see this being done. And don't say 'well, it doesnt't exist so you can't'.

You brought it up, your point, explain it.



Ask a cogent question and I will.


See the 'Very interested in how you see this being done' in response to your 'Implementing the customizable cheerleader option reinforces this by creating a systemic method to promote sexism.'



Ahh, specificity and particularity makes it much more understandable now.

Creating a new role in the game (cheerleaders) creates an entirely new aspect to the game which will be viewed as predominantly female. The female role will be filled by new characters that are created by mostly males. While the system, as it stands now, does contain many objectionable user names, they are all contained within a general population of football players. By segregating out a new role which is to be predominantly female, and given the historical trend of sexist/racist player names, there will be a new batch of explicitly female, objectified, sexist characters. The system (customizable cheerleaders) will be set up in a way to promote this type of creation. Thus, sexism will become systemic on GLB.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Originally posted by awesome


Originally posted by Checkmate187



Originally posted by awesome






I shouldn't have to spell it out for you. There are already plenty of players that have extremely sexist and/or racist names. Implementing the customizable cheerleader option reinforces this by creating a systemic method to promote sexism.



Very interested in how you see this being done. And don't say 'well, it doesnt't exist so you can't'.

You brought it up, your point, explain it.



Ask a cogent question and I will.


See the 'Very interested in how you see this being done' in response to your 'Implementing the customizable cheerleader option reinforces this by creating a systemic method to promote sexism.'



Ahh, specificity and particularity makes it much more understandable now.

Creating a new role in the game (cheerleaders) creates an entirely new aspect to the game which will be viewed as predominantly female. The female role will be filled by new characters that are created by mostly males. While the system, as it stands now, does contain many objectionable user names, they are all contained within a general population of football players. By segregating out a new role which is to be predominantly female, and given the historical trend of sexist/racist player names, there will be a new batch of explicitly female, objectified, sexist characters. The system (customizable cheerleaders) will be set up in a way to promote this type of creation. Thus, sexism will become systemic on GLB.


That's crazy PC thinking. I mentioned that Dershowitz attended Playboy mansion parties. Barry Scheck and Marcia Clark did interviews with them, too. They don't lose their legal licenses from associating with a publication some crazy PC nuts view as sexist.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by awesome



Originally posted by Ken1




Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla





Originally posted by Ken1






So you're saying this site would be a sexist site if it had playable cheerleaders? It's funny, as football teams dobn't get called sexist for having them.
oh yes they do. it's an issue that is only salved by the NFL promoting women's rights all over the place. a ton of feminist groups hate cheerleading because they believe it's similar to propping women up as trophies for the men of the gridiron to conquer once they conquer the field.


So that's what it is. You think it's sexist. At least I got to the point of the irrational hatred of the idea.

I'm left of center politically, but much more of the ACLU type, who tends to believe in free speech. I like the idea, but it's not the biggest thing in the world to me. But this sort of thing is why I'm so vehemently defending it right now.

It's like Nadine Strossen, former ACLU head, was asked why she kept defending pornography, and she said, "Because everyone else keeps attacking it."


No, I don't think it is sexist. Don't read things into what I am saying that I am not saying. I am very explicit and clear with what I am saying. I think it is a bad idea because it alienates existing users. The ethical considerations are an aside. (As I have said FROM THE FUCKING BEGINNING)


If you don't think it's sexist, then you have no basis for bringing your professional code of conduct into it.


Yes, I do. The WHOLE POINT of the professional code of conduct is that IT DOESN'T MATTER what I or you think. The point is that if SOMEONE, ANYONE reasonably thinks that it is sexist, then it IS. At that point, it is an officer of the court's ETHICAL OBLIGATION to remove him/herself from any association with what is perceived as sexist or racist.


Lawyers routinely accept awards from the Playboy foundation for upholding First Amendment issues.

Alan Dershowitz (the only one I know of for sure) has attended Playboy Mansion parties, and still has his law license.

I don't see Playboy as sexist either, but there's a much better case for it being sexist than for playable cheerleaders as sexist. Yet these lawyers associate with it and keep their licenses.


And there is nothing wrong with that. The lawyers in those circumstances are not associating themselves with the "sexist" organizations in a way that promotes sexism. Rather, they are associating themselves with defending the First Amendment by performing actions in the community and courts of law.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome

Creating a new role in the game (cheerleaders) creates an entirely new aspect to the game which will be viewed as predominantly female. The female role will be filled by new characters that are created by mostly males. While the system, as it stands now, does contain many objectionable user names, they are all contained within a general population of football players. By segregating out a new role which is to be predominantly female, and given the historical trend of sexist/racist player names, there will be a new batch of explicitly female, objectified, sexist characters. The system (customizable cheerleaders) will be set up in a way to promote this type of creation. Thus, sexism will become systemic on GLB.



If you say so. I just want a cheer squad to boost my in-game morale. And if I name my cheerleader Honey Bear, who am I hurting?
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
What baggage comes with it?


 
Hagetaka
offline
Link
 
A 22 page in response to a dude with a pedobear/Lazytown avatar, awesome
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.