User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37


Essentially, the best possible combos of majors/minors were eliminated as possible options by the archetype system.



At some positions perhaps, but not at others.
 
Eagle0415
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37
Originally posted by Eagle0415

I dont think you are getting my point. I spent money on CE on 49 players regardless of weather it is equiped yet or not. I created these players the way the system is now not for the new system they want to implement. As for thinking i should play entire season with CE and not pay anything for it. If you dont see them equiped it because i have not equiped them and dont plan on it till next season i purchased the CE in advance so i had it done i dont feel it would benifet me this first season even if it was equiped so i didnt equip them but, keep in mind if we change the way a player is created i would retire current players as is and rebuild them with new system and in that case i dont feel i should be penalized by losing 10% on what i spent if they wanna give me a full refund now i would sell every piece of CE but i want it at full price and end of season ill retire and recreate new players with new system


1. I understood your point just fine, I was just pointing out why its ridiculous to expect to get "free" CE for a season.

2. You shouldn't have invested money you knew you couldn't get a complete refund on until you needed to. What if you didn't like a particular build after this season or something and wanted to retire a guy or two? You'd have to eat the loss then whether or not you used to CE

3. Like I said, if you really aren't going to use the CE at all, I have no problem with you getting a full refund.


I said i wasnt gonna use it till next season as for my builds i know for the fact they are good i won a championship with my players and only decided last seaosn to rebuild
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
This.

And nixa -- I wasn't the one arguing for being able to choose majors/minors. I do believe that...

A. A larger list of SA's, some position specific

and

B. The ability to customize one's own trees (outside of the mandated SA's by archetype)

Would lead to far more variation in player building, esp. when you add VA's and AEQ on top of that (though both need some work as well imo).

I'm not arguing against the new system, I'm just saying it does not go far enough...its just plugging a hole while the pressure builds up and creates new ones...or as it was put before, its window dressing that tries to hide some of the major underlying flaws.


Well I addressed the post you quoted, though I still don't quite understand why it was necessary. The archetypes we're getting are essentially balanced with different strengths and weaknesses. If you allow people to choose whatever they want, at most positions its obvious what's best, so they end up with the strengths of the other archetypes combined without the weaknesses. Why is this so hard to understand?

As for the issue with your system, well its not really backwards compatible with existing players. Without redoing a lot of stuff, there is no way to let already created players go back and create custom SA trees, and if you did they'd have unfair knowledge as to what AEQ they already rolled, thus allowing them to better leverage their AEQ with compatible custom SA's. That's the difference between what's happening and what you're proposing. The only thing that changes for current players is a new one time option to switch over to the new system by simply choosing an archetype and an SA. You're system requires them to undo all the SA's they've already done, completely rebuild their SA tree's, and then refill them with SP's they may or may not get back. See the difference in complexity?
 
cooljesture20
offline
Link
 
All I've read on the subject so far is the thread linked in the announcement. I'm cool with it. I've been playing this game for 2 years now and been looking forward to more diversity since I started, but my only questions come sin terms of older players. What does this mean for them?
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

At some positions perhaps, but not at others.


Which ones? Certainly there will be certain archetypes that will fit better in certain systems, but as far as the meta-game goes I don't see any archetypes that are overpowered compared to others at the same position. If you see possible issues why not let Catch know so it can actually be addressed before this is rolled out?
 
Eagle0415
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Eagle0415

I dont think you are getting my point. I spent money on CE on 49 players regardless of weather it is equiped yet or not. I created these players the way the system is now not for the new system they want to implement. As for thinking i should play entire season with CE and not pay anything for it. If you dont see them equiped it because i have not equiped them and dont plan on it till next season i purchased the CE in advance so i had it done i dont feel it would benifet me this first season even if it was equiped so i didnt equip them but, keep in mind if we change the way a player is created i would retire current players as is and rebuild them with new system and in that case i dont feel i should be penalized by losing 10% on what i spent if they wanna give me a full refund now i would sell every piece of CE but i want it at full price and end of season ill retire and recreate new players with new system


Go equip all 49 players with their CE so that we can all believe your story. If true, I will gladly support you in your cause. Until you equip them, its just hot air.


Scace i did as you asked however i only did defense players only as it is time consuming they will be coming back off shortly
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagle0415
I said i wasnt gonna use it till next season as for my builds i know for the fact they are good i won a championship with my players and only decided last seaosn to rebuild


So how did you know that nothing major would change in terms of sim mechanics? It happens all the time and can easily neuter a once great build. If that happened, would you stick it out with every single guy, or might you consider retiring a few? I don't know. I just don't understand why in the world you put almost 30,000 FP into something you weren't going to be using for over a month, especially knowing that if something went wrong you couldn't get a full refund.
 
Team Nucleus
Draft Man
offline
Link
 
sim is screwed with boost and non boost leagues and new Archetypes screw over current players.I think the new archetype system is an improvement but current higher level player owners are screwed, thats my 2 cent on the whole new deal.

 
NY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagle
For those who don't beleive me i equipped Defense side only with the CE but i do have it for Offense as well i will be unequipping them in 30 minutes so feel free to take a look for those who thought it was all hot air


As his Head Coach i know he has it on all players..I have seen it on all of them when he first set the team up and then we decided he wasn't gonna win so he un-equipped them all..Like Honestly..you go build 55 Players and put them in a 14 Cap..so that's Level 1's V.s. Level 14's...CE Equipment is not really needed for that season so why should he have to pay for it if now we are going to have a new system?
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Team Nucleus
sim is screwed with boost and non boost leagues and new Archetypes screw over current players.I think the new archetype system is an improvement but current higher level player owners are screwed, thats my 2 cent on the whole new deal.



Higher level players probably won't have to deal with these newer players anyways. If you're young enough to deal with the S15 dots, you'll have long enough with the new archetypes to be relatively close. Plus, you don't have to adopt a new archetype for your current player.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagle0415
Scace i did as you asked however i only did defense players only as it is time consuming they will be coming back off shortly


In that case - my advice to you would be to file a ticket with support - be calm - be reasonable - and explain that you purchased 48 sets of custom equipment - in preparation of a 11 + season career - and now, because of the changes to player creation - you'd really like to get a full refund now (as opposed to 90% in 40 days).

I don't know what they will do - but you certainly make a VERY compelling case for a 'bend the rules' type scenario
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sborats
Here is the problem as I see it ... flame me if I am not 100% correct ... whatever.

Here is a QB I created for one season (pee wee) ... assume for argument sake he played this year (even though he played in season 8).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1257703

When I rolled him, he these skills at minimum: jumping, carrying, catching ... all at 10.

end of season, he went up 2 in each category ... from leveling.

... the Archtype S15 QB ... wouldn't have meaningless points dumped into jumping, carrying, catching for a Pocket Passer.

So, his core attributes would be more efficient.

The S12 and S13 QB would be even more inefficient (older, yes ... but still a "bad" build relative to the new ArchType).

... so, it just seems to encourage everyone to retire all their S12-S14 created players? Why not total reset while we are at it?

Only reason to keep say a S14 QB is for bragging rights to say my QB can jump higher than your S15 QB?


No, because my level 14 QB has been built efficiently to this point, I know I'm not taking a big hit on ALG up to this point, I can choose an archetype to compliment what I've capped so far, and I'll always have the advantage of extra levels, SP, and VAs to help make up for the hit I took early due to less concentrated level gains. No, I won't be quite as good as S15 dots when they're the same age, but luckily I'll be a season older than those guys my entire career.
 
WalterManning
offline
Link
 
Dam this thread is taking off like the one last night. By the time you get reading it to where you saw the page number it has gone 10 more pages.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagle0415
Scace i did as you asked however i only did defense players only as it is time consuming they will be coming back off shortly


I see -- and I support a full refund should you choose to retire and recreate. The tough thing is the PeeWee leagues where players actually use CE and would expect the same treatment. So while I support you, I think you are SOL on this one.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tigam
Originally posted by nixa37

As for my argument against complete customization, it basically comes down to the fact that you can't have the best possible combination of majors and minors at any single position with the system we're currently discussing. Therefore people are forced to weigh pros and cons of different archetypes and decide how they want to build. If we could just choose anything we wanted you'd end up with the vast majority of people just choosing the best possible combo of majors and minors and working from there. That isn't possible in this system.

I'm confused as to why you would think that people just won't choose the same archetype based on the same logic you just laid out.


EXACTLY !

The biggest issue with this game is no dot is different in the sim and to me that's where the problem lies. In football every team is not full of all exact players , in dotball they are. A slow guy should have a spot right next to the strong guy and so on. All this is a shirt of a different color.

I seriously think it's time to wipe this thing and recode it and stop with the window dressings imo.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.