User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
WORST IDEA EVA!
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
From Bort's post, emphasis mine"

Originally posted by

I can hear the complaints coming already, but if you're playing in a fair way (in the spirit of the game, and you know very well what it is) and are around the right level to compete with your league, you will see ZERO to little effect on your team and players


You could STILL be effected EVEN if you are "around the right level."

Total crap.

How is it realistic to tell people to choose between winning and maximizing player performance? Those things should go hand-in-hand, not be forced into opposition.


You seem to have some sense to you. Least wait and see how it affects everyone before you get all huffed up about it.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
Originally posted by chad13

This is like forcing Tom Brady to throw with his left hand when he plays against the Dolphins.

Please Bort, stop penalizing the good teams/players/owners just because the bad teams/players/owners are whining about getting beat!

Very bad analogy. This is like Tom Brady not improving when he goes and plays against the Boston High School Goof Balls. You improve by playing against people who challenge you; not by playing far below your talent level.



People don't improve in training camp or in practice when they run an offense against no defense?
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Note, I'm just trying to understand a bit of the other side here too, the people upset with this.

RPGs give rewards for defeating more challenging content, I agree. Tom Brady learns more playing against the, say, Giants than he would playing against a college team. I'm sure that NCAA teams learn more playing stronger ones than weaker ones. However, all of these systems have something in common -- the person has the choice as to where they're going to play.

That high level warrior in World of Warcraft can choose to take on monsters 5 levels above him or 10 levels below him. Tom Brady could decide if he really wants to mess around and play a college team. NCAA teams can choose parts of their schedule and decide if they want to learn more against stronger teams or pad their record against weaker ones.

Of course, as I've said before, I do support this to a degree, as I feel Bort is accomplishing just that with the formula. People choosing to go to a weak league and play weak teams as a high level will be penalized. Those that joined a team awhile ago when the league was stronger but saw it get weak won't be penalized for that choice.

I'm sure this has been tested many times and the formula tweaked so that it only hits Joe Chucklefuck that brings level 16 characters from a gutted team into a brand new league.
 
Ra4xGambit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maksim
WORST IDEA EVA!


Gtfo, then.
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maksim
WORST IDEA EVA!


I think everyone understands your view. You're only sounding like a whiner now. Looking at your team anyways I don't know why you're worried.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
can we all just wait to the first game of the season and see what kinda effect this has befor we all go crazy? lol , we are not even sure what kinda exp effect this has yet on higher players in lower leagues. might not be that bad .. really...
 
Paul Kemp
offline
Link
 
I would just like to say that if any of Tecmo's players want to come to Africa Pro, I have slots available.


 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ra4xGambit
Originally posted by secondeye

Originally posted by Leahmic223


Originally posted by Ra4xGambit



Am I th eonly one who thinks the update is completely logical, anyway? Does Charles Woodson get as much practice covering the 11th grade second-stringer as he does lining up against Terrel Owens? No, he doesn't.

It's completely parallel to the xp system in every RPG across the universe... better xp for stronger opponents. Little (or no in some games) xp for facing things you really shouldn't even be wasting your time on in the first place.


Lol, you are exactly right. It is the same as every other MMO.

If you are a lvl 50 Warlord you don't get jack squat for going to the noob area and trying to grind....



And Charles Woodson isn't forced to play with one hand tied behind his back when he's covering Troy Williamson.. And the Warlord doesn't have his Season 3 epic daggers taken away when he fights a holy priest.


Once again... you are assuming far too much. As is everyone in this thread.


It's not our fault information hasn't been presented fully for us to make an informed stance.

What else are we going to do.. Game plan against our Season 3 opponents?

....
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatZeppelin
This still has flaws, have an AAA team that's a few years away from competing or just assigned? Fill it up with level 1's screw over the top teams by dropping the league average and then get knocked down a league and rebuild.


If this comes into affect I think ANYTHING that slightly even resembles gutting collusion needs to result in a site ban as that could potentially affect a leagues average


Think about what you are saying. Why would anyone do this? Fill your team with first rounders to "screw over the top teams"? O yeah, that will really help when you get relegated again down to AA.
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by FBGProfessor

Originally posted by chad13


This is like forcing Tom Brady to throw with his left hand when he plays against the Dolphins.

Please Bort, stop penalizing the good teams/players/owners just because the bad teams/players/owners are whining about getting beat!

Very bad analogy. This is like Tom Brady not improving when he goes and plays against the Boston High School Goof Balls. You improve by playing against people who challenge you; not by playing far below your talent level.



People don't improve in training camp or in practice when they run an offense against no defense?


Good call, nfrat. Smart players improve against all (inferior or not) competition.
 
jvacc26
offline
Link
 
I really dont understand why people are freaking out about this...lets say they dock you 10%...and you get 250 exp per game, thats freaking 25 XP points! thats 1/40th of a level, it's not even a full level in an entire season!

Why dont we see how "horrible" this really is, before we threaten to quit GLB, and if you are spending 200 a month, and stop spending that...well ok, that sucks, but personally I'd rather have the guy that spends 2.50 a month and plays the game competitively, and within reason, rather than the guy who outspends the people infront of him. MLB anyone?
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dudeamis
Originally posted by Bigmo6967

Originally posted by Dudeamis


Originally posted by seven7



Originally posted by Dudeamis




Originally posted by djfivenine





This is not the right area to target Bort!
I know this game has a big problem with the higher level team always winning. But averaging out the levels of the teams is NOT the answer.
It is the ability to give us more options for TACTICS!
3-4 defense, cover 2 defense, spread offense, power running offense, option offense.
Blitz options, special substitutions, better predictions for the other team's strategy.

If those things are implemented, teams will start winning because their owner and coordinators are smarter and they out witted the other team.

I, for one, will not feel good beating a higher level team if I knew this rule was the reason.


seriously this new rule is a waste of your time. Try making the game better instead of nerfing good recruiters.

so you think a lv 8 going up against a lv 19 is fair? just because you recruited better? i don't own a team yet , all i have is players and i want to see an even playing field for us all , no sense in higher players beating up on the low league guys at all =( lets keep this game balanced and maybe it'll be more fun for us all.


Yes its fair because that lvl 19 could've been recruited just as easly by the other team. Is it fair that the Pats have Randy Moss? Is it fair that the Chargers get LT? This is basically the same as the NFL making the rule that the best players in the league have to sit out of the game more, to make it far to the other teams.


Fake money penalties mean nothing here. Neither does chemistry hits to most players. I would doubt Randy Moss would play on an arena team now would he? Thats kinda the equivalent of some playing there high level guys in low level league intentionally just to stroke their own egos.


Maybe to help a friend out... maybe because he's tired of welfare rules in the NFL. lots of reasons. Maybe he got paid a bunch of money to help turn the arena leagues into a big money marketplace.


Yep where as before there was all pros and no cons to doing just that now there is a negeative. Weigh it out and decide. If playing on the same team as your buddy is all that important then have your GM give him a backup role on the team you should be playing for. If he owns the lower team then fine. Play for him and the longer you stay there the less effect it should have on you. plus you will have your friend there with you offewring his support during your tramatic loss of XP.
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Paul Kemp
I would just like to say that if any of Tecmo's players want to come to Africa Pro, I have slots available.




Hehe.
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ra4xGambit
Originally posted by Maksim

WORST IDEA EVA!


Gtfo, then.


ahh, I see now. You are in favour so that your players catch up without having to spend any $$$
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.