User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

I just don't understand why parity is trying to be forced by punishing the good teams. The only thing that has to be done is allow more than 1 team to move up and down in each division and it will solve all these problems, reward the good teams and give the bad motivation to get better and the problem is solved.

If everyone goes .500 every season then what is the point?


This idea is not "punishing good teams," as keeps coming up as an argument. It's encouraging good players who play in crappy divisions where they have no business playing to try and find somebody their own size to pick on.

Everyone who doesn't like any of these ideas: You're honestly going to tell me that you would be ok with it if you got a new team in Eastern Europe CCC #4, where you start with some Lv 6 CPU's, and some team of lv 50's wants to come in and beat you up?

Honestly, I think the fact that this is met with dissent is proof that it strikes exactly where I thought it would: where people care. People don't seem to care much about cash, but DON'T TOUCH MY XP! That's why I think something involving XP would be so effective as a "gentle encouragement" to play in the way that we would like.


I like this idea. And I don't think I have heard a better support for this idea then this.

Originally posted by

Honestly, I think the fact that this is met with dissent is proof that it strikes exactly where I thought it would: where people care. People don't seem to care much about cash, but DON'T TOUCH MY XP!


For the record. The league median should be used as the benchmark, not the league average. The median is far less affected by outliers than the average.
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

I just don't understand why parity is trying to be forced by punishing the good teams. The only thing that has to be done is allow more than 1 team to move up and down in each division and it will solve all these problems, reward the good teams and give the bad motivation to get better and the problem is solved.

If everyone goes .500 every season then what is the point?


This idea is not "punishing good teams," as keeps coming up as an argument. It's encouraging good players who play in crappy divisions where they have no business playing to try and find somebody their own size to pick on.

Everyone who doesn't like any of these ideas: You're honestly going to tell me that you would be ok with it if you got a new team in Eastern Europe CCC #4, where you start with some Lv 6 CPU's, and some team of lv 50's wants to come in and beat you up?

Honestly, I think the fact that this is met with dissent is proof that it strikes exactly where I thought it would: where people care. People don't seem to care much about cash, but DON'T TOUCH MY XP! That's why I think something involving XP would be so effective as a "gentle encouragement" to play in the way that we would like.


ehh...I guess I understand. Still don't like the idea though haha
 
Linker2596
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

I just don't understand why parity is trying to be forced by punishing the good teams. The only thing that has to be done is allow more than 1 team to move up and down in each division and it will solve all these problems, reward the good teams and give the bad motivation to get better and the problem is solved.

If everyone goes .500 every season then what is the point?


This idea is not "punishing good teams," as keeps coming up as an argument. It's encouraging good players who play in crappy divisions where they have no business playing to try and find somebody their own size to pick on.

Everyone who doesn't like any of these ideas: You're honestly going to tell me that you would be ok with it if you got a new team in Eastern Europe CCC #4, where you start with some Lv 6 CPU's, and some team of lv 50's wants to come in and beat you up?

Honestly, I think the fact that this is met with dissent is proof that it strikes exactly where I thought it would: where people care. People don't seem to care much about cash, but DON'T TOUCH MY XP! That's why I think something involving XP would be so effective as a "gentle encouragement" to play in the way that we would like.


I like the idea. It makes the leagues more fair, so that people don't go into lttle leagues and dominate. If people really want to play in those leagues thy have to get penalized(or just no get a bonus). Too bad that there are too many people who are against it, so this might not get put through.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't necessarily base it off starters, I would base it off of # of snaps.

An owner could create a number of level 1s, with no stamina, set their playing style to hard, those guys play like 15 snaps at a max, and the real players play the rest of the game.

A lower level team could effectively lower the average level even further, hampering the teams at the top unfairly.

I do like the basis of the idea though.
Last edited Jun 9, 2008 12:11:21
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
I really do not think we shold give BONUS XP to low level players, but I do agree with a penalty for players that are to HIGH of a level for their league.

Instead of the cap level we are adding to the new leagues in Europe, we should add some sort of XP ceiling 'cap' level, where any players over this level can still play but suffer a XP % penalty that increases for each level over this ceiling.

For example if Europe A leagues have a ceiling level of 13th, all players below 13th get normal XP, but all players over this level would get a penalty and the penalty should start low and ramp up on a curve system.

LV =< 13 normal xp
Lv 14-15 -2% XP
Lv 16-17 -4% XP
Lv 18-19 -8% XP
Lv 20-21 -16% XP
Lv 22-23 -32% XP
Lv => 24 -64% XP

At -16% you'll start to notice the difference, and after that the penalty would be so great you would start to lose major ground on equal level players in higher leagues.

The numbers could be tweaked better probably, but definately start low at first, and then ramp up.
 
Nat Belmont
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
I really do not think we shold give BONUS XP to low level players, but I do agree with a penalty for players that are to HIGH of a level for their league.


I agree with that, because it'd only be encouraging people to deliberately mess up top league teams by playing their level 4 QB against level 20 opposition to powerlevel him...
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Yeah, that cherry extra 10% EXP a game is really going to look good when the team gets demoted for not being able to muster any offense.
 
Dravz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
LV =< 13 normal xp
Lv 14-15 -2% XP
Lv 16-17 -4% XP
Lv 18-19 -8% XP
Lv 20-21 -16% XP
Lv 22-23 -32% XP
Lv => 24 -64% XP


What a crock of shit. I guarantee you'll be singing a different tune when your own players are 20+.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dravz
Originally posted by EagleOtto

LV =< 13 normal xp
Lv 14-15 -2% XP
Lv 16-17 -4% XP
Lv 18-19 -8% XP
Lv 20-21 -16% XP
Lv 22-23 -32% XP
Lv => 24 -64% XP


What a crock of shit. I guarantee you'll be singing a different tune when your own players are 20+.


Easy solution, sign at a league level appropriate to your player...now you won't see ANY penalty.
 
LandfillReb
offline
Link
 
We can discuss this until everyone dies of old age, but a hard cap is the only solution that would keep level 20 player from playing in triple-B leagues.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by Dravz

Originally posted by EagleOtto


LV =< 13 normal xp
Lv 14-15 -2% XP
Lv 16-17 -4% XP
Lv 18-19 -8% XP
Lv 20-21 -16% XP
Lv 22-23 -32% XP
Lv => 24 -64% XP


What a crock of shit. I guarantee you'll be singing a different tune when your own players are 20+.


Easy solution, sign at a league level appropriate to your player...now you won't see ANY penalty.


Exactly thats for high levels staying down in low level leagues to get stats off the newer players. Its meant to be adjusted for the higher levels.
Like add +10 to the levels across the board for AA, and +20 for AAA and no limit for PRO league.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LandfillReb
We can discuss this until everyone dies of old age, but a hard cap is the only solution that would keep level 20 player from playing in triple-B leagues.


I agree...put a hard cap on BBB leagues & A leagues, a soft cap on AA and AAA leagues, and no cap on the pros. Obviously the ceiling for such caps would vary based on the region & level, but this is the only way to work for league parity.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
This is a great idea. Implementation isn't that important in terms of opponents or league average- do whatever is easiest to do.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Hopefully this isn't implemented for the pro's.

Pro's are supposed to encourage the best players. If the best players all play in the pro's on the same team, why should they be punished?
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Take Africa Pro for example. I've signed players above the league average on the assumption that this is one of the places where the high level players are supposed to go.

I can't tell them "Sorry I know this is Pro league, but apparently high level players aren't allowed here".

This would also screw up the region for a world tournament as well, if we ever got there.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.