User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hm...some sort of "remembered" chemistry or something along those lines? Maybe a coach could have a "comfort" bar that fills up over time as he stays with a team, which would limit the amount of points he has to spend or makes skills act if they are lower leveled if it is not full. One of the coaching styles could even make it fill quicker, as a wrinkle.


I'm totally against a player from a "top" team having greater influence/bonues/chemistry working for that team...it keeps the top teams getting stronger and the top league/team players/agents locking up those positions due to getting that bonus, even though other coaches may have better tools in their possession....

All coaches should have the same general affect on a team, based on how the coach is "built" not based on who the coach played for or the level/league at which the player played.
 
Azhreixxx
offline
Link
 
I'm sure this has been mentioned over and over, but I like the idea of the coach being able to purchase AEQ and sell them to the team.

Perhaps add a BT cost for the coach to buy the item, so that the coach can't just spam AEQ, or the coach is the only person that can UPGRADE the piece, so you buy it, upgrade it (using BT), then sell it... that still gets you the 1-3 pieces per season that you were looking for, Bort.

And I did defend "crafting" items in another thread, but I more provided a counter-argument than an actual defense... I like the idea of crafting items in theory, but if you want something for coaches to spend money on, AEQ shopping is staring you in the face.
 
RANDOC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
Originally posted by Bort

Hm...some sort of "remembered" chemistry or something along those lines? Maybe a coach could have a "comfort" bar that fills up over time as he stays with a team, which would limit the amount of points he has to spend or makes skills act if they are lower leveled if it is not full. One of the coaching styles could even make it fill quicker, as a wrinkle.


I'm totally against a player from a "top" team having greater influence/bonues/chemistry working for that team...it keeps the top teams getting stronger and the top league/team players/agents locking up those positions due to getting that bonus, even though other coaches may have better tools in their possession....

All coaches should have the same general affect on a team, based on how the coach is "built" not based on who the coach played for or the level/league at which the player played.


Just another example of widening gap between have & have nots = less parity = more blowouts = crap.
I'm tryin' to get onboard with this (because I have to) but I am very skeptical about effects on gm, not so much actual gm play but real people aspect & a lot of recently added members leaving.
I know, as an active owner, that it takes a great deal of time & dedication to be a winner. If you slip up, even for a few days during recruiting, you are in a big hole.
Now owners must also recruit 10 "coaches" per tm. I am more active than most owners & this will be difficult still, even with the contacts I have built up. (most of their poss coaches will go Pro / AAA).
I feel really sorry for relatively new & moderately active owners with minimal connections.
I will manage to get thru this, but I can see many owners just giving up & not renewing tms or giving up on gm completely.
Just my 2 cents. (about what it's worth because sensilble advice is ignored. IMO)
 
Jonny do good
offline
Link
 
idk but im just kinda throwin it out there but i think that if your player retires and wants to be a head coach that the higher your fame the less it would cost to be a coach..

But obviously there would be a minimum fee so the cant make a coach for free

Like 300 min
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Equipment costs money, but doesn't spend that money on anything.

Treat coaches as equipment.

Please don't have my coach going shopping!
 
Link
 
Number per account and total number seems vague at the moment, along with any required activity level to remain a coach. if these were addressed somewhere else (I got a stock reply from Jed that they were), please forgive me. Pretty sure my suggestions werent all covered. I'll cut him some slack, poor guy. anyway...

Something that needs implemented is a limit per account. I dont see any other way. I think this is the biggest priority. read on if interested.

My suggestion would be 1 coach per account with the option of creating a coach before the 440 day cutoff.

anything else would simply be favoritism. I'd probably never make one before 440 days, but if I'm told I can't no matter what... I'm stubborn like that. it smacks of favoritism to a small few vs a reward for loyalty in this case. I buy a lot of flex, i.e., show loyalty, and that would most likely halt.

a minor reward for taking that player all the way is reasonable. along with a limit on number of coaches per account, and activity level rules for coaches (read on for that)

adding these restrictions would be something that wouldn't turn off a majority of the people buyin flex these days and actually add somethin fun to it. coaches will be a necessity for winning teams, it appears, so this is no minor consideration. this isn't just frosting on the cake, the way it stands. this is changin the cake into a pie. it could land in someone's face, if they aint careful

as far as rewards for 440ers, nothing game breaking, or there is more assache fodder for someone to complain about.

The reward should be something nice, though, that makes it worth it to go to 440. or no one would wait.

a piece of gear with "top tackler season whatever, +1 percent bonus to tackling to coaches defense oriented" that wouldnt break the game into smithereens, but would give spice to that coach and make them desirable as a D coach, and probably tend to make them focus in that area instead of being QB coach, or somethin. they could choose a trophy and convert it to somethin like that

those without trophies could get somethin similar for stats or SA. workout specialist for strength or speed, etc. possibly give them 2 or 3 bonuses, they make the choice what to use. if they go inactive, the team loses those bonuses. hey, the guy's on vacaction.

bonuses to starting stats sounds like a permanent thing. I'd avoid that, unles they would also risk losing them if they went inactive.

I personally could give a crap what a coach's past is. a trophy for winnin somethin in world league wouldn't, or at least shouldn't, matter in any meaningful way. Singletary's rings dont help his team win. it'd add spice and may give them notoriety for the first few days, so a title they can have on their profile might be nice. they'd still get replaced if they were inactive or suck at the job, from an owner's standpoint.

Younger players: they should be able to choose. wait to get the bonuses, or decide the game is too rough on the bod and start coachin early. flex point cost would be more than 440ers, maybe 50 or even 100 more per 40 days (reflects seasons of play) this would still allow those who want to try it soon to do so, if they want to spend the flex and get no bonuses for accomplishments. like one poster said, how many NFL coaches actually did anything worthwhile IN the NFL? not many. a 240 day player that has to spend 250 or 500 more flex, some will go for it just to try it out.

1 per account would also have the effect of deterring players from retiring, while they check out this coaching thing, and keep that "perfect coaching" player in the game until they read up on and perfect their coaching, if they intend to at all. top level teams wouldnt lose 10 or more players suddenly, once it's implemented, which I think may happen if number per account isnt severely limited.

the way it is now, from what I see, hundreds of players would retire as soon as this is implemented and grab the coaching spots, of which there can only be so many, and be assured they would be at the top for 9 seasons, if not forever. that would kill any desire by me to ever want to make a coach. I'd never hire one, and I'd probably quit being an owner. uh oh, there goes more flex.

and how to get rid of inactive coaches if there is a cap on the total number? HUGE problem. I imagine there will have to be a cap on number of coaches, since there are only so many teams. 1000 coaches without a job would be ludicrous, especailly if there are hundreds who are inactive (which WILL happen) who gives a crap what percentage a coach can give a team in whatever if they cant get ON a team. this is especailly important.

Solution: simply put an activity requirement on accounts with coaches, two tiers is my sugestion.
tier 1 - 10 days inactive: if they exceed this, their coach cannot give bonuses to teams they are on. zippo zilch nada. keeps the butts in the seats, if they wanna be a coach. teams can cut the coach with no penalty. signing a new one would incur a penalty, though. so get the active ones!
tier 3 - 30 days inactive: their coach is "inactivated", cut from the team, and doesnt count toward the cap number. if they come back, they can join a "waiting list" at the bottom, and be reactivated and get a job again once a spot opens. possibly a grace period during which they can re-sign with the old team, but not a new one. I personally woudlnt be scrambling to get an inactive coach back, myself, but sometimes life has a way of makin things tough on gaming. so this little bit of love should be given.

somethin along those lines for these two issues. maybe 2 coaches per account would work, I have no idea how many accounts there are in this game.

I want to get on board with this. I think it will be fun to add. but it will turn into a mess and cause a lot of discontent if basic stuff like this aint dealt with. coaching tiers, percentages, rewards for someone who landed here day 1 and wants to carry glory into the next millenium, yada yada, all that will mean zilch if it doesnt work.

so lets quit yammerin about those things and encourage Bort to start at the ground level and work up. simple at first, and if it aint a mess, THEN add in more detail. dont add GLB to the list of online games that add expansions and simply create a huge turd ball that creates problems and inequities (heh, like there aint some already) and takes weeks or months to fix.

"oh, we didnt think of THAT! so sorry. keep playing, send more money, and we'll fix it"

heh.

Jack
 
Guernon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by treee
Spend money...


that's what it 's all about

Edited by Guernon on Sep 7, 2009 05:30:40
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azhreixxx
I'm sure this has been mentioned over and over, but I like the idea of the coach being able to purchase AEQ and sell them to the team.

Perhaps add a BT cost for the coach to buy the item, so that the coach can't just spam AEQ, or the coach is the only person that can UPGRADE the piece, so you buy it, upgrade it (using BT), then sell it... that still gets you the 1-3 pieces per season that you were looking for, Bort.

And I did defend "crafting" items in another thread, but I more provided a counter-argument than an actual defense... I like the idea of crafting items in theory, but if you want something for coaches to spend money on, AEQ shopping is staring you in the face.


This is the best idea really. Make it offense/defense specific So that D Coach can't sell a +3 blocking + 1 protector to the offense or visa versa, if you want to limit it.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Great, we have a thread for adding more complication and nonsense to a Idea that should have been squashed.

Coaches are a bad Idea, people need to stop being dazzled by the shiny thing and see it for what it is. A poorly thought out Idea that will amplify all of the problems we already have.
 
feedy
offline
Link
 
holy shit im so against that idea of making us pay for coaching positions. thats the worst fucking idea i've ever heard of. if that goes through i will actually sell my team
 
Link
 
I thinks the new coach idea is great , but did have a question about an idea previously addressed along these same lines. When a player is ready to retire, could there be a way to without automatic coaching being the only option. What about, and I saw this subject talked about a bit a couple sessions ago, a field or button on the team page for "Hall of Fame" or Team Archvs. , or something to that effect... Not as much as another application, as a record if owners wanted to showcase previous players... Just something to throw in the pile...
 
modred
offline
Link
 
Too lazy to read through everything here, so I'll shout into the wind.

Ten coaches sound like too many per team. Consider reducing it to maybe head coach, offense, defense, and special teams. Ten coaches at the start will widen the divide between the haves and have-nots. At least please consider consider phasing in the cap of ten, start at 3 or 4 and add one or two per season.

Only allow coaches to be converted in the offseason. This will keep the number of 440 day players requesting their release on day 440 down. This would increase the initial pool of coaches in the offseason between 12 and 13. Having coaches sign all during season 12 feels like a bad and unbalanced idea.

Keep coaches only to 440 day players of a "reasonable" level.

ETA: Not sold on the whole item crafting thing. If it is going to be there it should be like most of the other proposed skills and be designed to provide a per-game temporary boost. Maybe a "coach's item" slot that 1 offense, 1 defense, and 1 special teamer could wear.
Edited by modred on Sep 7, 2009 12:32:30
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I have added many, MANY things to the OP. If there are any others from THIS thread that needs to be added, please pm me with the quote/link. NO more threads, as the warning thread states (stickied and put up yesterday). Let us help you by helping Bort to see all your concerns here (which is why I'm editing the majority of stuff into the OP).

 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
Coachs need to be available to EVERYONE not 440 day players for this to ever work. There is no legit reasoning behind the 440 day thing other than to appeal to the s1 players. VA's were at least lvl 25, this is just flat out ridiculous.

If someone just joined the game today, they would have to create a player and have that player not technically play any games but rot on his home screen for almost A YEAR AND 3 MONTHS.

How is this going to help bring new users to the game?

This is a bullshit addition that only caters to specific agent's agendas.
 
ramart103
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
Coachs need to be available to EVERYONE not 440 day players for this to ever work. There is no legit reasoning behind the 440 day thing other than to appeal to the s1 players. VA's were at least lvl 25, this is just flat out ridiculous.

If someone just joined the game today, they would have to create a player and have that player not technically play any games but rot on his home screen for almost A YEAR AND 3 MONTHS.

How is this going to help bring new users to the game?

This is a bullshit addition that only caters to specific agent's agendas.

The Zen Master is wise.
If this bad idea goes through, I'll give it a season. If it's a one-sided game to appease S1 players, I'll sell my team, retire my players and find another place to play sim football.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.