User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Samythe41
offline
Link
 
It's my turn I guess.

Close game against the best defense we've faced this season.
I had a conservative gameplan.
We lead by 5, in opponent territory. 2 minutes left.
According to the AI tester, Here's the input and outputs :

Matching Input
Input Named: up late

Possible Outputs
25% strong I inside hb (inside_run)
25% I off tackle (outside_run_off_tackle)
50% singleback inside (inside_run)

Here's what happened :

2:00 1st & 10 OPP 44.5 Kazio D pass to Le Garde Du Corps over the middle, caught, knocked loose by Burgandy Havoc [deflected by Burgandy Havoc] (incomplete)
1:55 2nd & 10 OPP 44.5 Kazio D pass to CLaude Henry Smmoot up the right side, caught (25.5 yd gain) [tackle: Muck Fichigan]
1:48 2nd & 10 OPP 44.5 Saint Mary's School for the Blind calls timeout
1:48 1st & 10 OPP 19 Kazio D pass to Le Garde Du Corps over the middle, caught (3.5 yd gain) [tackle: Burgandy Havoc]
1:43 1st & 10 OPP 19 Saint Mary's School for the Blind calls timeout
1:43 2nd & 6.5 OPP 15.5 Kazio D pass to Lil Hercules up the right side (incomplete)
1:38 3rd & 6.5 OPP 15.5 Kazio D pass to WolFen Ferret up the left side, caught (15 yd gain) [tackle: Cuz I'Can]
1:33 3rd & 6.5 OPP 15.5 Saint Mary's School for the Blind calls timeout
1:33 1st & G OPP 0.5 Kazio D pass to Lil Hercules up the right side [deflected by Jamarkus Lynn] (incomplete)
1:30 2nd & G OPP 0.5 Kazio D pass to Le Garde Du Corps up the left side [deflected by Burgandy Havoc] (incomplete)
1:27 3rd & G OPP 0.5 Kazio D pass to Robert Clegg over the middle, caught, knocked loose by BooBoo Wilson [deflected by BooBoo Wilson] (incomplete)


game link : http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=477789&mode=pbp
 
Shayde
offline
Link
 
I had my team go for it on 4th down EVERY TIME.

and believe me... the AI does NOT say for that to happen. I'm not in PeeWees. Should I ticket this stuff?
 
tcl
offline
Link
 
i've seen this a bunch on both o and d. so i thought i might need "Follow my AI EXACTLY, even when there is no match (use with caution!)", and hence set it, but that's only on the o page. still seen weirdness since then, so i'll try to put my more obvious examples here.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=581427&pbp_id=19379464
exact info put in d tester:
Matching Input
Input Named: d1234 5wr

Possible Outputs
35% quarter c2w mlb (quarter Cover 2 man)
35% quarter c2c mlb (quarter Cover 2 man)
30% quarter c2s mlb (quarter Cover 2 man)


yes, all of those are actually quarter playcalls. as you can see from the replay, our defense is in dime. a dime cover 3 perhaps. regardless, it's definitely not quarter.
 
Link
 
I had a Kicker miss an XP, which cost me our playoff game.

This was not part of the gameplan.

...joking aside, is there anything obvious that would make a clutch Kicker (211/214 XP during the season) with Automatic SA 5 and Confidence at 2nd cap shank an XP attempt in the playoffs?
 
cashpath
offline
Link
 
A bad random number assignment by the script.
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Shayde
I had my team go for it on 4th down EVERY TIME.

and believe me... the AI does NOT say for that to happen. I'm not in PeeWees. Should I ticket this stuff?


Any chance you had some type of quarterly settings on?
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
I'm going to have a go at this. I have been seeing this kind of stuff since I started playing and have come to one conclusion -

AUTO ADJUST IS ALWAYS ON (even when you turn it off).

I almost always run with a balanced (eg roughly 50/50) gameplan. I have had auto adjust off for five seasons. Time and again I have seen the sim call run after run when I am up against a weaker team who cannot stop me. It just calls the same few plays over and over. I win, but it is obviously adjusting in favour of these plays.

HOWEVER, when the sim wants to fuck you over it gets interesting. I can tell if it is going to be 'one of those days' very early on - my team will pass and pass and pass at the start of the game, even when the odd running play succeeds. This is almost always accompanied by endless incompletions and turnovers. In the second half, when you are behind, it starts running to balance up the numbers but it is the last thing you need. The number of passes against runs in the first half is usually way beyond what could be called 'random'.

In my playoff game I had an AI that was at least 55% run. We passed 52 times (mostly incomplete) and ran 22 even though the runs were perfectly successful (and auto adjust was off anyway) and we were not behind by much. It was simply picking the play least likely to succeed to ensure we had a 'bad day'. In addition, it usually seems to impose a penalty on all your plays as well.

I do not think this is a conspiracy or an accident. I am sure this is part of how the sim works. There seems to be some sort of 'you are having a bad day' roll at the start of the game. If you are having a 'bad' day it auto adjusts TOWARDS the plays that work worst and vice versa if you are having a good day. One thing I can be sure of (good day or bad) is that the sim is not calling the plays randomly based purely on the AI.

The reason? The sim is not really accurate enough that tactics make all that much difference, despite what people like to think - the strongest team always wins. Therefore, some 'random' elements are introduced to ensure that there is some variance in the outcome, especially in the playoffs where it becomes obvious. I have no problem with this - games should NOT be predictable. The issue is that it is done in such a cackhanded way. The sim just wakes up and decides to fuck you over that day and at that stage your gameplan and tactics just get thrown out the window. Chance should play a part in the outcome of each play, and momentum and 'good/bad day' effects are fine, but it needs to be done properly, not by ignoring the plays you have called.

I think the overall problem is that this effect has to be very strong (and thus looks so suspect) to overcome the high likelihood that the stronger team will win anyway. I am pretty sure (despite the denials) that this is how so many favourites lose games in the playoffs that they would never have lost in the regular season.
Edited by ryanshaw on May 31, 2009 01:49:16
 
cashpath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
the strongest team always wins.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=530258

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=579432
Edited by cashpath on May 31, 2009 12:54:05
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Another example of not following the AI: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=614109&pbp_id=3993748

There's nothing remotely like that in our defensive design, and there is a matching output for that situation. I understand that buggy things happen, and thank god this kind of thing only happens to me maybe once a season, but it's worth noting that there are still times when the sim fails to follow the AI.
 
Jaxilon
offline
Link
 
Yeah I have the Auto-adjust at 0 and my run at 100%. The stupid QB starts chucking airballs on the first possession. It's pissin me off to be honest. but I'm new so I'm trying to figure out what I'm doing wrong. Glad to know it's something that is common and will likely be addressed.

Cuz frankly, either none of us know what we are doing and are idiots, it's convoluted and doesn't work as explained, or there is a problem that needs to be addressed. In all of these scenarios this needs to be better. (Yes, even if we are just idiots)

OR

Please allow me to call a play where I can run onto the field and beat the freaking crap out my QB before being ejected from the game because that's how I feel when I see this happening again and again.
Edited by Jaxilon on Jun 23, 2009 19:26:22
Edited by Jaxilon on Jun 23, 2009 19:25:43
 
soulellis
offline
Link
 
do any of you actually receive a reply from an admin about these problems ?

I rarely bother with the forums but i actually came to look for AI problems because i have noticed this season particularly that the teams i coach are not following exactly the AI.

I own and coach my own team and i then headcoach as a GM for another.

I have noticed that there are some random plays that are been run that are not in my AI whatsoever.

It is not all of the time for each quarter. 80 % of the time it works ok but i would say this season 20 % of the time bizarre random plays have been happening that are not in my AI.

What is going on ?
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
We played a scrimage today that I was trying to test a specific play. Not one single time did the play fire. Not once. I've been OC since season 3 and have not had this big of a problem before. I have had random plays run that were not in the AI but always figured it was an error on my part. But not this time. The offense it ran was from the previous game. Therefore I assume for some reason the new settings didn't save on the server even though it shows it did on my end.
 
Loco Moco
offline
Link
 
Just thought I'd add more evidence to this well known problem.

Casual Team (only basic settings)

100% Pass / 0% Run

82 passes / 20 runs
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=656997





 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheBear
We played a scrimage today that I was trying to test a specific play. Not one single time did the play fire. Not once. I've been OC since season 3 and have not had this big of a problem before. I have had random plays run that were not in the AI but always figured it was an error on my part. But not this time. The offense it ran was from the previous game. Therefore I assume for some reason the new settings didn't save on the server even though it shows it did on my end.


When did you update the AI? Was it a last minute addition?

Also, was the play in question in your Offensive Playbook?
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by soulellis
do any of you actually receive a reply from an admin about these problems ?

I rarely bother with the forums but i actually came to look for AI problems because i have noticed this season particularly that the teams i coach are not following exactly the AI.

I own and coach my own team and i then headcoach as a GM for another.

I have noticed that there are some random plays that are been run that are not in my AI whatsoever.

It is not all of the time for each quarter. 80 % of the time it works ok but i would say this season 20 % of the time bizarre random plays have been happening that are not in my AI.

What is going on ?


Check that you don't have any holes in your AI. You can always have 'catch alls' at the bottom of a defensive AI (or even an offensive AI for FG or 'Go for it' situations ).

For example a common mistake is to have your inputs broken by yardage and listing them 0-3, 4-7, 8-10, etc. They're leaving gaps and should have it set 0-3, 3-7, 7-10, 10+.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.