User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by the man of doom



Originally posted by jamz




If you're really concerned about the short term.

Randomly shuffle the Pro Leagues this season, speed up the process. People would either
A) Really rage then
B) Be happier, because now every team would have the 'same' best shot at making the WPL like they want.


+1


This would be very entertaining. : popcorn :


nb4 OPL whine imo


My team is leaving OPL, but I would welcome the competition if we were staying.


I think he is still bitter... -shrugs-

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=483245
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by Galkuris


Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Not likely. If they're almost a playoff team in WPL, and they go to the worst Pro League, isn't it likely that their presence in said league would be fleeting? That's not a recipe for long-term parity. It's just a recipe for giving the best demotees the quickest and easiest path back to WPL.


Right, so that means if they really are better then the rest of the teams in the league, those teams don't actually deserve to move up. It will force the weakest conferences to improve themselves to get a chance to move up. The weakest conferences should also in theory have the easiest time recruiting top talent as it will be the quickest route to the WL.

Parity =/= sending the best non-playoff team back to the best conference if that was their original home. This means you may be sending the 13th WL seed to the worst conference where they may end up back in the WL. Makes more sense to give the 9th seeds that opportunity over someone lower then them (Bonus for finishing higher in the WL?)


Why is this an issue? Parity will be determined by player movement, not by relegation:

1. The best players (by and large) will want to play in the WPL.
2. Player decline and retirement will enforce a constant rotation of the "best" players; even the best teams will struggle to continually refill their talent bases.
3. If a lack of parity is caused by agents WANTING to be in a particular Pro league (USA, Canada, South America, etc.) then no amount of random relegation will fix that; borderline WPL teams will keep hopping back up, and free agent talent will naturally drift towards the most desirable Pro leagues.

Implement the WPL at all and we won't have to worry about Pro league parity in a couple seasons. The best teams will all focus on joining and remaining in the WPL, as will the best players. And unlike the game's first ten seasons, where the best players were generally the same from season to season, the advent of player decline will force the retirement of even the most legendary GLB players in another 3-4 seasons, and from then on players will have a 4-5 season window at best where they are truly elite.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


in case you missed it
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Edited by the man of doom on Jul 27, 2009 19:50:05
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken

I think he is still bitter... -shrugs-

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=483245


wat
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
The whole "region" idea will not exist with this sort of WL.. not that it matters much, but its basically just one PRO league, with 8 AAA leagues (or AAAA leagues if you will.........). If you do this, it would make some sense to change the whole league name thingy to World League, Earth League or whatever... in 2-5+ seasons Eastern Europe will only be a name ... with teams from all around GLB.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by HULK

Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.


If you move a WPL-eligible USAPL team to SEAPL right now they'd go 14-2 at worst, and more likely would run the table. How would that promote parity?


Bort needs to answer this question....

Is the plan to have the World League represent "the best of the best", or just to be "some of the best and the best of the rest"?

As it is right now, his top 4 teams from each conference is just going to be some of the best and the best of the rest. It's gonna leave out a whole lot of top teams that really won't have a realistic chance of making it to the World League for another 3-4 seasons if ever thanks to player decline and recruiting issues (from not being in the WL and not being in an easy league to get to the WL).

If Bort wants the World League to be the best of the best, he needs to start it out that way. Take a look at the "Top 25 Pro Teams", how many of those are missing from the current list of 32 teams? These are the teams that have poured their hearts and souls into build a GLB community. It would be a real shame if Bort screwed them because they play in a tougher league because there hasn't been a world league for the past 10 seasons.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by HULK


Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.


If you move a WPL-eligible USAPL team to SEAPL right now they'd go 14-2 at worst, and more likely would run the table. How would that promote parity?


Look to the future. It might not next season but it will promote parity to come much much faster 2/3 seasons from now.


No, it would not promote parity. Whether or not the type of parity you're talking about happens would be completely independent of that event.

Moving dominant teams to regions they outclass doesn't promote parity. The advent of the World Pro League DOES promote parity from teams who want to get into it. But parity from teams trying to get promoted can get impeded by, as I mentioned before, moving dominant teams to regions they outclass via demotion.

People don't seem to get that promoting parity via the promise of an easier promotion is not something that requires random demotion to facilitate it.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by ICRockets


Originally posted by Galkuris



Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Not likely. If they're almost a playoff team in WPL, and they go to the worst Pro League, isn't it likely that their presence in said league would be fleeting? That's not a recipe for long-term parity. It's just a recipe for giving the best demotees the quickest and easiest path back to WPL.


Right, so that means if they really are better then the rest of the teams in the league, those teams don't actually deserve to move up. It will force the weakest conferences to improve themselves to get a chance to move up. The weakest conferences should also in theory have the easiest time recruiting top talent as it will be the quickest route to the WL.

Parity =/= sending the best non-playoff team back to the best conference if that was their original home. This means you may be sending the 13th WL seed to the worst conference where they may end up back in the WL. Makes more sense to give the 9th seeds that opportunity over someone lower then them (Bonus for finishing higher in the WL?)


Why is this an issue? Parity will be determined by player movement, not by relegation:

1. The best players (by and large) will want to play in the WPL.
2. Player decline and retirement will enforce a constant rotation of the "best" players; even the best teams will struggle to continually refill their talent bases.
3. If a lack of parity is caused by agents WANTING to be in a particular Pro league (USA, Canada, South America, etc.) then no amount of random relegation will fix that; borderline WPL teams will keep hopping back up, and free agent talent will naturally drift towards the most desirable Pro leagues.

Implement the WPL at all and we won't have to worry about Pro league parity in a couple seasons. The best teams will all focus on joining and remaining in the WPL, as will the best players. And unlike the game's first ten seasons, where the best players were generally the same from season to season, the advent of player decline will force the retirement of even the most legendary GLB players in another 3-4 seasons, and from then on players will have a 4-5 season window at best where they are truly elite.


There are a few here that seem to understand that setting up the WL this way will result in parity across GLB (something I am sure Bort wants). It will also allow each team to keep their regional affiliation. Everyone wins IMO. I am not sure where the problem is.
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25

Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


I think any solution which FORCES teams to play more games each season is doomed to failure. I love the idea of friendly scrimmages and optional tournaments, but some of us have a hard enough time gameplanning every two days, especially in leagues where everyone is good enough to be a threat (WPL would definitely fall in this category). Making the best Pro teams jump through more hoops for the WPL will discourage team owners and GMs who are already debating whether or not to keep investing so much of their time (and money) into this game.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25

Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


ok, so you want to have it as the winner of the tournament has to make the conference finals at least? if he doesn't, then you go down the tournament chain..
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by HULK


Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.


If you move a WPL-eligible USAPL team to SEAPL right now they'd go 14-2 at worst, and more likely would run the table. How would that promote parity?


Bort needs to answer this question....

Is the plan to have the World League represent "the best of the best", or just to be "some of the best and the best of the rest"?

As it is right now, his top 4 teams from each conference is just going to be some of the best and the best of the rest. It's gonna leave out a whole lot of top teams that really won't have a realistic chance of making it to the World League for another 3-4 seasons if ever thanks to player decline and recruiting issues (from not being in the WL and not being in an easy league to get to the WL).

If Bort wants the World League to be the best of the best, he needs to start it out that way. Take a look at the "Top 25 Pro Teams", how many of those are missing from the current list of 32 teams? These are the teams that have poured their hearts and souls into build a GLB community. It would be a real shame if Bort screwed them because they play in a tougher league because there hasn't been a world league for the past 10 seasons.


Yes.................................
Edited by kwankwan on Jul 27, 2009 19:55:13
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by HULK


Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.


If you move a WPL-eligible USAPL team to SEAPL right now they'd go 14-2 at worst, and more likely would run the table. How would that promote parity?


Bort needs to answer this question....

Is the plan to have the World League represent "the best of the best", or just to be "some of the best and the best of the rest"?

As it is right now, his top 4 teams from each conference is just going to be some of the best and the best of the rest. It's gonna leave out a whole lot of top teams that really won't have a realistic chance of making it to the World League for another 3-4 seasons if ever thanks to player decline and recruiting issues (from not being in the WL and not being in an easy league to get to the WL).

If Bort wants the World League to be the best of the best, he needs to start it out that way. Take a look at the "Top 25 Pro Teams", how many of those are missing from the current list of 32 teams? These are the teams that have poured their hearts and souls into build a GLB community. It would be a real shame if Bort screwed them because they play in a tougher league because there hasn't been a world league for the past 10 seasons.


That's extremely short-sighted. Over time the teams that deserve to be in the WPL will be. The only fair way to start it out is the way it is being started out. Anything else would be an absolute clusterfuck.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by HULK


Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.


If you move a WPL-eligible USAPL team to SEAPL right now they'd go 14-2 at worst, and more likely would run the table. How would that promote parity?


Bort needs to answer this question....

Is the plan to have the World League represent "the best of the best", or just to be "some of the best and the best of the rest"?

As it is right now, his top 4 teams from each conference is just going to be some of the best and the best of the rest. It's gonna leave out a whole lot of top teams that really won't have a realistic chance of making it to the World League for another 3-4 seasons if ever thanks to player decline and recruiting issues (from not being in the WL and not being in an easy league to get to the WL).

If Bort wants the World League to be the best of the best, he needs to start it out that way. Take a look at the "Top 25 Pro Teams", how many of those are missing from the current list of 32 teams? These are the teams that have poured their hearts and souls into build a GLB community. It would be a real shame if Bort screwed them because they play in a tougher league because there hasn't been a world league for the past 10 seasons.


The WL should give each region an equal shot and should be the best teams in the game. It should be both. If each region gets 4 teams into the WL, it will benefit the weaker regions with recruiting (players want a shot at the WL). Within 2-3 seasons, we will see parity across the pro leagues of GLB.

Think about what we do now will result in 2-3 or even 10 seasons down the road.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.