User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > How is JohnnyDollar not an admin of this site yet?
Page:
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by datongw


If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.

I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.



I would say Saris has it right...a little better reaction time is all that we need. No need to make rushing QBs extinct.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Ubasstards


Originally posted by Darkus Black



I did test a player build, so it is possible. But you can all see what I tested.


and you expect us to believe Deathblade didnt give inside info for Dooleys build?


How?


by testing the attributes and telling the owner of dooley what to build up



Good plan. How do you do this without everyone being able to see the stats being tested?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LQB7
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by datongw



Obviously there are several, what is the biggest?

I feel that manipulating the DC so that have running QBs only in on rushing plays and not have to pass is the biggest right now. In RL as soon as those guys come on the field, the defense would know a run is coming, but in GLB defenses can't adjust to that. Add on the fact that the any defender that is not set to blitz will practically stand there and pick their noses until the QB crosses the LOS makes this the biggest exploit in the game at the moment imo.

Sure they can be shut down, and really shut down, but that would basically mean that your defense will be exposed to a lot of other plays. I seriously hope Bort fixes this during the off season. It's really an easy fix too, just fix the DC order then everything is solved.


Wait,

You mean having to game plan to stop something is an exploit? Having to choose to sell out against a play or not is an exploit?

Wow, really??


It's not hard to stop it. But that's not the point, the point is that if a QB that runs fast but can't pass come into the game, the defense should know a run is coming. But right now not only defense can't adjust to that, they basically won't react to him running until he crosses the LOS. Vision has nothing to do with it, it's the coding. Defenders will 1 million in vision will not go after him until the QB crosses the LOS, that's just the way it's coded in the game.

If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


Datongw is right, and it's not even arguable.


Yup. It's crazy how that hasn't been fixed yet. A lot of teams don't take full advantage of the inherent exploits the offense has, so it's not as apparent as stuff like the Strong I-Slam that everyone abused.
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Hey, I'm just coming back to report what I just did while I was gone on the test server for the last 10 minutes.

Full disclosure, amirite?


The new scrim option that we tested...the games that simmed didn't have notes (since they would be impossible to add).


Will you stop with the elitist crap? Why do you ALWAYS have to be right?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Good plan. How do you do this without everyone being able to see the stats being tested?


Even better question...how do you transfer hidden attributes to the test server?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Ubasstards

Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Ubasstards



Originally posted by Darkus Black




I did test a player build, so it is possible. But you can all see what I tested.


and you expect us to believe Deathblade didnt give inside info for Dooleys build?


How?


by testing the attributes and telling the owner of dooley what to build up



Good plan. How do you do this without everyone being able to see the stats being tested?


By running the test and not posting about it? Sure, everyone can see but they have to do a fuckton of individual work to find out what the hell it was that someone was testing.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
So seeing as you hate being a mod Darkus, when can we expect that tag to go bye bye?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Saris

Originally posted by datongw



If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.

I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.



I would say Saris has it right...a little better reaction time is all that we need. No need to make rushing QBs extinct.


 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Will you stop with the elitist crap? Why do you ALWAYS have to be right?


omg don't hit me
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Good plan. How do you do this without everyone being able to see the stats being tested?


Even better question...how do you transfer hidden attributes to the test server?



you didn't have any control over height and weight? o_O
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
you didn't have any control over height and weight? o_O


1st, no
2nd, lol @ you thinking h/w is relevant
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Will you stop with the elitist crap? Why do you ALWAYS have to be right?


omg don't hit me


Mod fight! Pull his tits out!
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Good plan. How do you do this without everyone being able to see the stats being tested?


you can run tests without posting what you were testing, or even post that you were testing something different than you actually were testing.

 
Dr. Showtime
DANG
offline
Link
 
good gameplans are imo
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by DrkSandman

I've just gone to the test server and reminded people they need to fill out the notes section, and be as clear as possible.

I have also suggested testers inut their user name into the notes section so we can tell who is running the test. It was received well, and several testers have already said they'll start doing it.


We have already cleared up that issue Drk...


Still worth noting that, after all this time, this shit doesn't even happen.
I mean, we are constantly being told that we shouldn't worry.
...but the fact of the matter is that you've really done nothing but give us reasons to worry.

My point is that even if you guys are 100% legit and ONLY looking out for everyone else's best interests and not your own, you shouldn't act surprised that people question what you're doing on the test server.

Heck, SHOULDN'T WE BE QUESTIONING?
Why do the testers get so freaking upset when they're questioned?!?!?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.