User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Page:
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by blln4lyf

Originally posted by turnit643


Yes. As many as needed to make room. If four begin in the WL from each region and all four get sent back, then two will be replaced by the incoming conference champs and room would have to be made for the other two. One extra demotion to make room from each conference isn't much with the standard piles at the bottom we see now.


If the Pro League holds up, as of now this is the best way to go about it then imo. Not that they'd be right, but I would expect a lot of bitching from the 3-13 team trying to avoid relegation though.


Is there a situation you can imagine that wouldn't result in a bunch of bitching from someone? Bitching is going to happen.


Polls tend to lessen the bitching imo.
 
Outlawz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by blln4lyf

Originally posted by turnit643


Yes. As many as needed to make room. If four begin in the WL from each region and all four get sent back, then two will be replaced by the incoming conference champs and room would have to be made for the other two. One extra demotion to make room from each conference isn't much with the standard piles at the bottom we see now.


If the Pro League holds up, as of now this is the best way to go about it then imo. Not that they'd be right, but I would expect a lot of bitching from the 3-13 team trying to avoid relegation though.


Is there a situation you can imagine that wouldn't result in a bunch of bitching from someone? Bitching is going to happen.


True.
Bort just needs to make his decision & that's that. I don't even see the need for a poll tbh.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Sticky plz
 
meathead013
offline
Link
 
i may actually be the first person to suggest a world league. i think its even in the suggestion forum from way back in S02 or 03, or perhaps it was just in our team forum, cant remember for sure

but it always seemed like an inevitable logical conclusion to me, it changes the dynamics of the entire league structure
 
Gronert
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Sticky plz


 
odg62
offline
Link
 
lottery? (NBA draft style)

just throwin it out there...fairest way i can think of.
Edited by odg62 on Jul 9, 2009 00:01:09
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by chronoaug

I still don't understand. So you're already admitting opl, seapl, wepl, and eepl are shitty? People here are trying to say otherwise. They shouldn't worry if they actually perform. The shittier regions don't need handicaps, they just need to play well.


Ok, let's try it this way:

If you promote an equal number of teams:

Half the WPL is shitty and it sucks.

If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.


that's why you split the difference

4 from each region initially, every conference's regular season and playoff champ (or runner up)

both conferences get one team from every conference in the game.

all non playoff teams relegate back to where they came from

every conference's playoff champ goes up to replace them

for example, 4 USA teams go up and all make the playoffs. 2 more will join them the next season. then all 6 make it. two more USA teams will join them. the most possible teams a league can have in the world league is 18 and that's if no USA team ever misses the world league playoffs

this way every league is represented with one team at least, and you can gain teams depending on how you perform

in the event of gutjobs, new teams are handpicked by bort using the rankings we do on here
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by chronoaug


I still don't understand. So you're already admitting opl, seapl, wepl, and eepl are shitty? People here are trying to say otherwise. They shouldn't worry if they actually perform. The shittier regions don't need handicaps, they just need to play well.


Ok, let's try it this way:

If you promote an equal number of teams:

Half the WPL is shitty and it sucks.

If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.


For a moderator you always sound pretty negative about the game and everything really for some reason. It also seems like you just post whatever thoughts you have rather than try to understand what other people are posting.


There is no way someone your position should seriously think that scenario gives you only the two options of having either 1) A league where "half of it is shitty" according to you, or 2) the lesser PRO leagues will lose teams and interest to the point they will "wilt and die."

Wow, you really sound like someone I would want representing my company. I'm guessing you have a solid Marketing background. Or maybe it's Advertising but what's the diff, haha i mean it's all the same am I right?

I'd be very interested to hear what you think about my couple of posts on Page 3 in the USA Pro forum regarding the World League.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2959328&page=3

I can't really keep up well with threads like this so I'd appreciate it even more if you wouldn't mind sharing your thoughts in that thread so they don't get lost like they might here.
 
Link
 
Even the idea that top teams in any Pro League are by any means "shitty" is so utterly ridiculous I mean seriously. Even the worst Pro League team with a reasonable shot at qualifying for a promotion to the WPL is still far from a "shitty" team, even if they aren't the best or even if they can't compete with the top tier of teams it doesn't make them "shitty" by any means. If it did then everyone might as well give up on their teams because they suck and are a waste of time.
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
Even the idea that top teams in any Pro League are by any means "shitty" is so utterly ridiculous I mean seriously. Even the worst Pro League team with a reasonable shot at qualifying for a promotion to the WPL is still far from a "shitty" team, even if they aren't the best or even if they can't compete with the top tier of teams it doesn't make them "shitty" by any means. If it did then everyone might as well give up on their teams because they suck and are a waste of time.


Happening at exponentially rising rates
Edited by MonkeyMan on Jul 9, 2009 03:46:43
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
the world leagues will only work if the USA people stop thinking there shit doesn't stink(big surprise this would happen). WPL should be about the WORLD not you egomaniac USA teams. Anything then equal representation at the beginning and an equal and fair system of promotion will be a deathblow to GLB. First season should be 4 teams from each league. It get's harder after that, but each league should have someone promoted the next season. There should also be a high team turnover rate in the WPL, all teams not in the playoffs should be dropped down or something along those lines.

im not for or against this league. I just think it's going to cause a lot of headaches and unneccasry forum wars. Basically Bort is trying to take our attention away from the fact he should be working on his sim. We all know theres enough things with that he could spend his time on.
Edited by HurricaneBear on Jul 9, 2009 05:48:57
Edited by HurricaneBear on Jul 9, 2009 05:39:11
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
the world leagues will only work if the USA people stop thinking there shit doesn't stink(big surprise this would happen). WPL should be about the WORLD not you egomaniac USA teams. Anything then equal representation at the beginning and an equal and fair system of promotion will be a deathblow to GLB. First season should be 4 teams from each league. It get's harder after that, but each league should have someone promoted the next season. There should also be a high team turnover rate in the WPL, all teams not in the playoffs should be dropped down or something along those lines.

im not for or against this league. I just think it's going to cause a lot of headaches and unneccasry forum wars. Basically Bort is trying to take our attention away from the fact he should be working on his sim. We all know theres enough things with that he could spend his time on.


I think most people like the idea of eliminating 8 teams all at once and promoting the conference winners or eliminating 16 and promoting the top 2 from each conference (regardless of if one region got 4 teams demoted because they'd have 2 coming up still). Gives teams a chance to earn their keep in wpl.

Also, nothing will stop teams from gutting. If you're a good team, you have a chance of winning your pro region already. There are plenty of teams who make a pro league and have no shot of winning a title. It's not necessarily a bad thing. USAPL has had a lot of parity in their winners over the years and arguably the 2 best teams in usapl (Shockers and MEM) have yet to win the title.

In USAPL, the team i'm on Alpine (and Lincoln Navs did it too but shitty last year and good this year) was a top 25 team in GLB in most all the rankings last season and this year are in danger of not making the playoffs. We're still gonna regroup and keep fighting, not just gut because we hit a bump in the road like Vanilla Thunder suggests. We've already seen some of the potential problems and it not be a big deal in usapl. I think a WPL would be fine. The only thing hurt would be some egos but people should get over it.

Not all teams go into the gut spiral. The teams that do probably had it coming. And then again, it happens now with current pro leagues at a pretty high rate (6 last season in usapl, 4-5 already midway in sapl) so it's not like the current system is very good for preventing guts. Guts will always happen no matter what. A lot of it is because teams aren't good enough and they finally realize it or real life problems.
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 9, 2009 10:28:11
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 9, 2009 10:27:25
 
Cylon
offline
Link
 
I've only lightly skimmed this thread and it doesn't affect me at this time but for the inaugural World League selection I'd consider not only include this season's performance in the selection but go back another season including playoffs, maybe even two, for selection and just maybe weight this season slightly higher. Increase chances the team has some longevity and not get teams that are a product of other teams tanking because they don't want to face the World competition or one season wonders. Sucks for a team that came up just short for two or three seasons though.

As far as taking prestige away from regional Pro Leagues I mean really? I see people rag on half the Pro Leagues already for being generally "weak"...and that's just this thread! I don't think the Pro leagues that are considered tough lose much given the remaining competition.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by chronoaug



I still don't understand. So you're already admitting opl, seapl, wepl, and eepl are shitty? People here are trying to say otherwise. They shouldn't worry if they actually perform. The shittier regions don't need handicaps, they just need to play well.


Ok, let's try it this way:

If you promote an equal number of teams:

Half the WPL is shitty and it sucks.

If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.


For a moderator you always sound pretty negative about the game and everything really for some reason. It also seems like you just post whatever thoughts you have rather than try to understand what other people are posting.


There is no way someone your position should seriously think that scenario gives you only the two options of having either 1) A league where "half of it is shitty" according to you, or 2) the lesser PRO leagues will lose teams and interest to the point they will "wilt and die."

Wow, you really sound like someone I would want representing my company. I'm guessing you have a solid Marketing background. Or maybe it's Advertising but what's the diff, haha i mean it's all the same am I right?

I'd be very interested to hear what you think about my couple of posts on Page 3 in the USA Pro forum regarding the World League.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2959328&page=3

I can't really keep up well with threads like this so I'd appreciate it even more if you wouldn't mind sharing your thoughts in that thread so they don't get lost like they might here.


Vt is not a real mod, but he plays one in CPL forums.
 
Gronert
offline
Link
 
more AAA teams will now be admitted into the Pros
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.