User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Pass Rushing WAY to much
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life



The experimentation, and when you find out what works often times dominating the opposition.


There is no experimentation anymore. People just read info on the forum and know to build a DE with 100+ agility.

Seriously, pass rushing DE builds are one of the least diverse things in this game. Don't try to make it into something it's not.


You'd be very surprised.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life




The experimentation, and when you find out what works often times dominating the opposition.


There is no experimentation anymore. People just read info on the forum and know to build a DE with 100+ agility.

Seriously, pass rushing DE builds are one of the least diverse things in this game. Don't try to make it into something it's not.


You'd be very surprised.


Ding. Trying to keep my mouth tight on some things.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The_Warden
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by The_Warden
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by The_Warden
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by The_Warden
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by fallingmercury
If speed factors into acceleration then this game is even more about speed than I thought.

i've always been under the impression that speed is the largest factor in acceleration.

well it is, you can not accelerate if you dont have a speed to accelerate to

i don't think there's a single person here confused about that.

There you are wrong again, read into the quote where it says "If speed factors into acceleration then this game is even more about speed than I thought."
Sounds to me like someone was NOT understanding, so I was helping him to understand

false. all you're doing is pointing to the effects of low top speed. once again: no one is confused about that.
what we're discussing here is whether agility has more or less marginal utility than speed in terms of acceleration.
and "again"?

Well its really common sense if you have built a few different kind of players. Build a player with all 80 speed, and 20 agility, vs 80 agility and 20 speed. see where it gets you

yes, the effects of low top speed are indeed common sense -- which is why no one is confused about it... and why no one is talking about "20 speed".
instead of 80/20 vs. 20/80, imagine 60/60 instead or something. the discussion here is whether an increase in agility from that point has more or less effect on acceleration than an increase in speed.

both tbh
I made my FB ass backwards then the traditional way. I built up my speed 1st. When I did start doing agility, or if I continue to do my agility, I still see him running at what appears to be faster IMO


indeed. both have an effect... and perhaps jumping does as well ← unverified rumor

but the question was which had a greater effect... and i was saying i've always been under the assumption that acceleration is primarily governed by speed.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
ZOMG very good DEs are actually beating very bad OTs, NERF THEM, NERF THEM, that's not how Football should be!!! In Football, bad OTs shut down great DEs like Winston Justice vs. Osi Umenyiora...oh wait.


The best part of this whole original post was the irony in it. The pass rushing was made TOO powereful (but my team had 0 sacks in the game against equal level competition).
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life





The experimentation, and when you find out what works often times dominating the opposition.


There is no experimentation. People just read info on the forum and know to build a DE with 100+ agility.

Seriously, pass rushing DE builds are one of the least diverse things in this game. Don't try to make it into something it's not.


Not what I did. My CB has been fairing well in CPL.


We're talking about pass rushing DEs here. CBs have more legit options. But DEs clearly have a "best build".


Eh. We'll see.

My 24 was built very much against the "best build" notion - I capped all four majors before I started investing in any of the multi-caps.

 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
Originally posted by jrry32

ZOMG very good DEs are actually beating very bad OTs, NERF THEM, NERF THEM, that's not how Football should be!!! In Football, bad OTs shut down great DEs like Winston Justice vs. Osi Umenyiora...oh wait.


The best part of this whole original post was the irony in it. The pass rushing was made TOO powereful (but my team had 0 sacks in the game against equal level competition).


Agreed.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I see a lot of people saying you need close to 90 agility. Really? Because for 4 seasons you didn't need more than 70 on a LOT with a nice dose of Protector and he'd never give up a sack as long as you had good blocking and strength.

Wouldn't it be nice if Bort descended down his Ivory Tower and discussed these things with his customers once in awhile? I'm not asking for a specific play-by-play of how the mechhanics work, but it would be nice to see Bort lay out what he thinks makes a balanced build. I find it insane that over a year into this game and we still don't even know the link between speed and agility, and it seems it's changed a few times since season 1.

I'm not going to argue that OL agility shouldn't be higher, but damn it Bort, don't put in a system that allows OT's with 60-70 agility to not give up more than a couple sacks for 4 seasons, then change it overnight so you need 90 agility and those guys are turnstiles. That's what pisses people off. It's the arbitrary changes whenever Bort sees fit with no real warning. Sorry you've got a player already to level 40, you should just retire him," shouldn't ever be a result of a change, yet it's happened repeatedly in this game.

My other beef here is that OL seem to be nerfed in the running game on top of the buff for DL. I've got OL with 115+str and a ton of blocking built for run-blocking and they're putting up just a couple pancakes so far. Down a good bit from last season in the limited sample size of data. I have no problem if the pass rush is freed up. I can buy that a DE with 100+ agility should be blowing by my LOT with 75 agility, but then my ROT with 108 strength should be pancaking those DE's with less than 70 strength on almost every single running play.

What this game never has is balance. An OT with 80/80/80 str/blk/agl should be decent but not great at everything. Tip him one way or another and he should become better at pass-blocking but worse at run-blocking. That's never been the case. So far this season it appears that strength and blocking don't mean much in the running game.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
considering this is an OT thread, i've got to ask... who here has slowbuilt an OT?

i ask because speed is a non-leveling skill for o-linemen, so it's something you don't even touch (on a slowbuild) until you're through all your majors/minors.

my point is that anyone properly slowbuilding an OT should know first-hand the effects of raising speed from nothing on a high-agility player... and would thus know for sure that speed is the major factor in acceleration.


Speed is the major factor in top speed. Agility is how you get to that top speed, ie, acceleration.

Remember, acceleration didn't exist in the game till Bort made agility the acceleration attribute.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life

Everything has a "best build", doesn't mean that is the popular build. There is a reason why some DEs, and other positions, are better than their peers.


DEs clearly have only one real legitimate (pass rushing) build. The new pass rush mechanic just enforces that. Extreme agility is heavily rewarded while balance is punished.

So there's no fun in experimentation here. Sure, experiment all you want. Make three DEs and come to the conclusion that the cookie cutter DE build is indeed the best just like the rest of the community. So waste flex on experiments everyone already knows the answer to. But you're not going to have fun doing it, right? Paying real life money to do it?
Edited by fallingmercury on Jun 15, 2009 22:17:51
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I see a lot of people saying you need close to 90 agility. Really? Because for 4 seasons you didn't need more than 70 on a LOT with a nice dose of Protector and he'd never give up a sack as long as you had good blocking and strength.

Wouldn't it be nice if Bort descended down his Ivory Tower and discussed these things with his customers once in awhile? I'm not asking for a specific play-by-play of how the mechhanics work, but it would be nice to see Bort lay out what he thinks makes a balanced build. I find it insane that over a year into this game and we still don't even know the link between speed and agility, and it seems it's changed a few times since season 1.

I'm not going to argue that OL agility shouldn't be higher, but damn it Bort, don't put in a system that allows OT's with 60-70 agility to not give up more than a couple sacks for 4 seasons, then change it overnight so you need 90 agility and those guys are turnstiles. That's what pisses people off. It's the arbitrary changes whenever Bort sees fit with no real warning. Sorry you've got a player already to level 40, you should just retire him," shouldn't ever be a result of a change, yet it's happened repeatedly in this game.

My other beef here is that OL seem to be nerfed in the running game on top of the buff for DL. I've got OL with 115+str and a ton of blocking built for run-blocking and they're putting up just a couple pancakes so far. Down a good bit from last season in the limited sample size of data. I have no problem if the pass rush is freed up. I can buy that a DE with 100+ agility should be blowing by my LOT with 75 agility, but then my ROT with 108 strength should be pancaking those DE's with less than 70 strength on almost every single running play.

What this game never has is balance. An OT with 80/80/80 str/blk/agl should be decent but not great at everything. Tip him one way or another and he should become better at pass-blocking but worse at run-blocking. That's never been the case. So far this season it appears that strength and blocking don't mean much in the running game.



Wouldn't it be nice if Bort descended down his Ivory Tower and discussed these things with his customers once in awhile?

On this? No. Stop bitching and moaning about why some things work better for some than others.
As for the speed and agility thing, that has been mentioned by Bort. Agility is the major contributor to acceleration, but is not the only factor.

There, I descended down my own ivory tower.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by The_Warden
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by The_Warden
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by The_Warden
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by fallingmercury
If speed factors into acceleration then this game is even more about speed than I thought.
i've always been under the impression that speed is the largest factor in acceleration.
well it is, you can not accelerate if you dont have a speed to accelerate to
i don't think there's a single person here confused about that.
There you are wrong again, read into the quote where it says "If speed factors into acceleration then this game is even more about speed than I thought."
Sounds to me like someone was NOT understanding, so I was helping him to understand
false. all you're doing is pointing to the effects of low top speed. once again: no one is confused about that.
what we're discussing here is whether agility has more or less marginal utility than speed in terms of acceleration.
and "again"?
Well its really common sense if you have built a few different kind of players. Build a player with all 80 speed, and 20 agility, vs 80 agility and 20 speed. see where it gets you
yes, the effects of low top speed are indeed common sense -- which is why no one is confused about it... and why no one is talking about "20 speed".
instead of 80/20 vs. 20/80, imagine 60/60 instead or something. the discussion here is whether an increase in agility from that point has more or less effect on acceleration than an increase in speed.

Well, again, it's about the SP investments, as to whether in this (unknown, really) situation, the 30-odd SP's the OP's ROT spent on speed could have been better spent in Agi.
If we look at best-case scenario, those SP's were all spent recently (which we all know is BS, as evidenced by his SA tree) and we can say "well, would the 30 SP's invested in speed to get it to 55 have been better invested in getting Agility to 77" which they very well could have, when we take level-ups into account.
So at what point is extremely high AGI/extremely low Spd better than roughly 50/50 of both?
Who would you sign faster as a level 38 OT? A 77/10 guy? Or a 58/50 guy?
More importantly, if you look at their track records (which, I guess, we'll really see shake out this season) who was the worse performer?


for sure.

but i wasn't suggesting 60/60 in terms of build. i was just trying to get warden to think beyond his point about low top speed.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I see a lot of people saying you need close to 90 agility. Really? Because for 4 seasons you didn't need more than 70 on a LOT with a nice dose of Protector and he'd never give up a sack as long as you had good blocking and strength.

Wouldn't it be nice if Bort descended down his Ivory Tower and discussed these things with his customers once in awhile? I'm not asking for a specific play-by-play of how the mechhanics work, but it would be nice to see Bort lay out what he thinks makes a balanced build. I find it insane that over a year into this game and we still don't even know the link between speed and agility, and it seems it's changed a few times since season 1.

I'm not going to argue that OL agility shouldn't be higher, but damn it Bort, don't put in a system that allows OT's with 60-70 agility to not give up more than a couple sacks for 4 seasons, then change it overnight so you need 90 agility and those guys are turnstiles. That's what pisses people off. It's the arbitrary changes whenever Bort sees fit with no real warning. Sorry you've got a player already to level 40, you should just retire him," shouldn't ever be a result of a change, yet it's happened repeatedly in this game.

My other beef here is that OL seem to be nerfed in the running game on top of the buff for DL. I've got OL with 115+str and a ton of blocking built for run-blocking and they're putting up just a couple pancakes so far. Down a good bit from last season in the limited sample size of data. I have no problem if the pass rush is freed up. I can buy that a DE with 100+ agility should be blowing by my LOT with 75 agility, but then my ROT with 108 strength should be pancaking those DE's with less than 70 strength on almost every single running play.

What this game never has is balance. An OT with 80/80/80 str/blk/agl should be decent but not great at everything. Tip him one way or another and he should become better at pass-blocking but worse at run-blocking. That's never been the case. So far this season it appears that strength and blocking don't mean much in the running game.


dpell, OTs don't need 90 agility. People saying that are the ones that said before DEs were nerfed that OTs need 80 speed to stop DEs. It's untrue. An OT with agility in the 70s and speed in the 50s will fare well. They may give up a sack or 2 to the absolute elite but they should be fine. Now OTs with 90 agility will of course be better pass blockers.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life


Everything has a "best build", doesn't mean that is the popular build. There is a reason why some DEs, and other positions, are better than their peers.


DEs clearly have only one real legitimate (pass rushing) build. The new pass rush mechanic just enforces that. Extreme agility is heavily rewarded while balance is punished.

So there's no fun in experimentation here. Sure, experiment all you want. Make three DEs and come to the conclusion that the cookie cutter DE build is indeed the best just like the rest of the community. So waste flex on experiments everyone already knows the answer to. But you're not going to have fun doing it, right? Paying real life money to do it?


I already know the answer, and you're wrong. I don't need to experiment.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by The Purpose Driven Life





The experimentation, and when you find out what works often times dominating the opposition.


There is no experimentation anymore. People just read info on the forum and know to build a DE with 100+ agility.

Seriously, pass rushing DE builds are one of the least diverse things in this game. Don't try to make it into something it's not.


You'd be very surprised.


Ding. Trying to keep my mouth tight on some things.


I won't because there's no reason to. Logically, there are about 5 different combinations on how to build a successful DE. That's more than most positions.

 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32


dpell, OTs don't need 90 agility. People saying that are the ones that said before DEs were nerfed that OTs need 80 speed to stop DEs. It's untrue. An OT with agility in the 70s and speed in the 50s will fare well. They may give up a sack or 2 to the absolute elite but they should be fine. Now OTs with 90 agility will of course be better pass blockers.


very true...there is a ton of BS in any thread discussing how high certain attribute needs to be to avoid suckage...generally, the numbers stated for agility seem to be around 10-20 higher than what you really need, IMO.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.