User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > *** OFFICIAL *** North Korea blows up a Nuke
Page:
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
sorry for the length, but tired of arguing over something social studies in 7th grade teaches


To bad I just finished taking a U.S. History class and we wrote an essay on this and spent a few weeks preping for it
 
4 Lyfe
offline
Link
 
This thread is the ill-informed vs. the ill-informed. You guys all read a couple articles on the internet and are suddenly able to comprehend every aspect of the conflict. Lets just stop all these threads and keep our ill-informed opinions to ourselves.
 
iStatic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firense
This thread is the ill-informed vs. the ill-informed. You guys all read a couple articles on the internet and are suddenly able to comprehend every aspect of the conflict. Lets just stop all these threads and keep our ill-informed opinions to ourselves.


You dont need to have the "right" facts to carry a discussion, all for fun. All for fun.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin
Originally posted by Whatsdafus

sorry for the length, but tired of arguing over something social studies in 7th grade teaches


To bad I just finished taking a U.S. History class and we wrote an essay on this and spent a few weeks preping for it


it shows
 
Link
 
The fact of the matter is that a discussion on whether the atomic bombs were needed or not are going to be inevitably tainted no matter which side you're on, as it's an extremely political topic.

Traditionally we say that history is written by the victors, while the losing side is almost always in the wrong - this has completely changed now as politicians and their supporters (business interests especially) have realized that history and biased reporting can be used as a tool to further their own agendas. You only need to watch the news to see these underlying tendencies.


 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin

Originally posted by Whatsdafus


sorry for the length, but tired of arguing over something social studies in 7th grade teaches


To bad I just finished taking a U.S. History class and we wrote an essay on this and spent a few weeks preping for it


it shows


Besides the whole should we have or not is pure opinion. No one knows how hard it would have been to invade let alone just blockade
 
iStatic
offline
Link
 
Unfortunately, these things wont change... Bombs will be around, tested, and used. Its a shame that it comes down to this... the world still turns.
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin
Besides the whole should we have or not is pure opinion. No one knows how hard it would have been to invade let alone just blockade


Untrue. We know how hard it would have been to invade. Read Whatsdafus' wall of text. It's very informative.

The only remaining debate is how long a blockade would have taken to work, and whether we would have starved more civillians to death than we nuked to death.
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin

Besides the whole should we have or not is pure opinion. No one knows how hard it would have been to invade let alone just blockade


Untrue. We know how hard it would have been to invade. Read Whatsdafus' wall of text. It's very informative.

The only remaining debate is how long a blockade would have taken to work, and whether we would have starved more civillians to death than we nuked to death.


I know, what I meant by that is life wise
 
bgm1969
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot



b). Japan had a strong and overachieving army/navy. They were a power in the region, and yes they used aggressive tactics. They were able to occupy parts of China for few years during the war, and of course they had been very aggressive with Korea for a long time. But come on. Germany had surrendered, the Allies' troupes were spread thin, yes, but they could have focused on Japan. It would have cost the lives of soldiers to continue to wage war with Japan, but I maintain that I am never in favor of bombing civilian centers. Twist that however you like, it's what I believe.




Do I think dropping a nuclear bomb is a good thing? Of course not. But, given the option, it truly was less destructive. Estimates are that civilian casualties would have been in the millions due to the pre-invasion bombing that would have crippled the rail infrastructure of Japan. This would also have the effect of creating rampant food shortages, which would have been the main killer over the two to three years estimated to finally secure Japan's surrender through an invasion. Add to that the mobilization of the Japanese home defenses, which encompassed every able-bodied citizen, and their standing orders to fight to the last. Estimated military casulaties topped 1 million. Combined loss of life could easily have topped 5 million.

Consider the improbability, after such destruction, that Japan would have recovered as well as they did with the Marshall Plan, and the decision to use the nuclear bomb seems much less an act of arrogance.

I find it disrespectful to say that trading the lives of those killed and maimed in Hiroshima and Nagasaki were worth it. However, it allowed for much less death and destruction.
Edited by bgm1969 on May 29, 2009 10:41:07
Edited by bgm1969 on May 29, 2009 10:35:12
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
What he also forgets.... is this.....

What were 90% of all the homes made of in japan???


Thats right!!!!

WOOD....

a lot of the bombing runs that were done.. (remember no JDAMs.. just carpet bombing) set whole towns on fires killing tons of people.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin
Originally posted by captobvious

Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin


Besides the whole should we have or not is pure opinion. No one knows how hard it would have been to invade let alone just blockade


Untrue. We know how hard it would have been to invade. Read Whatsdafus' wall of text. It's very informative.

The only remaining debate is how long a blockade would have taken to work, and whether we would have starved more civillians to death than we nuked to death.


I know, what I meant by that is life wise


Life wise????

do you even know how many people died in those 2 hydrogen bomb blasts?

are you teling me that number of deaths is > what a conventional bombing/war/invasion would have been for both sides together?
 
Ted Buckland
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin

Originally posted by captobvious


Originally posted by Regular-Sized-Colin



Besides the whole should we have or not is pure opinion. No one knows how hard it would have been to invade let alone just blockade


Untrue. We know how hard it would have been to invade. Read Whatsdafus' wall of text. It's very informative.

The only remaining debate is how long a blockade would have taken to work, and whether we would have starved more civillians to death than we nuked to death.


I know, what I meant by that is life wise


Life wise????

do you even know how many people died in those 2 hydrogen bomb blasts?

are you teling me that number of deaths is > what a conventional bombing/war/invasion would have been for both sides together?


1 civilians lives > 10 soldier in a war tbh... i'm not saying any humans life is more valuable, but from the moral aspect, thats how i see it
Edited by ddriver80 on May 29, 2009 10:54:54
 
the stink
offline
Link
 
Neither was a hydrogen bomb....just saying.



 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
my bad hydrogen bomb was 6 years later... anyways, other then that my point stands
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.