User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Knicksfan20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knicksfan20

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Iceman16



Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.


Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.





good? because that isnt a missed tackle


if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle


That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"





if they are upset, then they need to fix their build.


but build isnt about everything...there are a few more things that need to be done to make the game = on defense for stopping the run.


balance and algo change...momentum needs to play a huge factore IMO..i will preach this to my grave.


and one way defensive players should suck...if you start to make defensive players need tons of strenght, thens peed backs will dominate...if you make them need high speed/agility...power backs will dominte....Tackling needs to be made more imporatant...and a variety of other skills to balance with the tackling

SPEED to catch players and get full momentum when tackling
AGILITY to move around without tripping and being able to move latterally..build up speed
VISION to know surroundings, to know your apponents, and to read moves and find angles avoid blocks
STRENGTH avoid being plowed and dragged, % to tackling bigger stronger players, added to causing fumbles...




a player who is 100 strength and 50 tackle...should be no where as good a tackler as somone who is 100 tackle 50 str....


and the tackle settings need to be changed...wrap up is OP
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
Most powerbacks are stopped by multiple defenders bringing them down. You'd have to make part of the tackling process a "slow" part of the missed tackle roll. If they miss tackle, a "slow" roll should take place that hinders the power backs speed for a duration giving other defenders a chance to catch up and bring him down as a pack.


That is already the case - but if you fail the roll miserably you don't slow him down much at all.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16

And strength. But yeah, that's what I'm trying to say. BIG mismatch.


Why do they need strength if they are elusive backs?
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Iceman16


Yeah Bort, Brandon Jacobs runs in the mid-4.5s. Do you really think 50 speed and 60 agility is 4.5 territory?


 
Negronic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Knicksfan20


Originally posted by Iceman16



Bort, the running game is CURRENTLY overpowered. Why make it harder for defenses to keep up?





hes trying to find an answer to stop the running game...the question he is asking how to stop them...not how to make rbs unstopable


Isn't he asking that the defense put more points into strength and tackling?


I'm trying to get a feel for what people think as far as what it should take to stop these types of players, independent of how it currently works.


its all situational.

lets assume the power back is plowing full steam ahead. lets also assume that there is some sort of momentum calculated from size, strength, and speed.

situation 1: Defender is coming head on
in this situation its basically a roll-off. momentum/tackling (def) vs momentum/carrying (off). if the defender wins, he makes the tackle and possibly forces a fumble. if the HB wins, he breaks the tackle and looses some fraction of his speed and, therefore, momentum. that makes it easier for him to get tackled by subsequent defenders if they get to him before he gets back up to speed.

situation 2: Defender is in front of the power back coming at an angle
this situation is similar to the first, with the exception that the tackler has less chance of getting plowed by the RB. the catch is that he needs higher tackling to wrap him up and bring him down.

situation 3: Defender is coming from the side
In this situation the defender isn't going to get steamrolled, but needs a high amount of tackling and potentially less strength than a head-on confrontation.

situation 3: Defender is behind the power back coming from an angle
In this situation a powerful back is likely to be able to get a pretty good stiff arm on the tackler. however, since the RB is running AWAY from the tackler he has little momentum to power through him aside from the afore mentioned stiff arm.

situation 4: Defender is catching the power back from behind
In this situation any tackler should be able to bring him down, with stronger, heavier tacklers bringing him down faster. a weak corner could bring him down but likely would get carried a bit.



I don't know what the momentum calculations, if any, look like right now, but i think if you use some simple math you can get something pretty simple. lets say 0 degrees is behind the RB and counts up in each direction until you get 180 degrees straight ahead of the RB. divide that by 1.8 and get the % of full momentum. calculate momentum something like mass * velocity^2, with mass being some combination of weight and strength. then in any confrontation between a tackler and a runner you multiply the momentum by the angle/1.8 and you get the percentage of the momentum that will come to bear on the tackler. straight ahead is 100%, from the side is 50% and from behind is 0%.

that would make it more logical that a powerful back would be great in short yardage where his full force tried to power through DTs, LBs, and SSs, but if he starts to break free, weaker players can bring him down instead of him unrealistically breaking every tackle.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Iceman16


And strength. But yeah, that's what I'm trying to say. BIG mismatch.


Why do they need strength if they are elusive backs?


Not every HB in the game is an elusive back.

Case in point? OP.
 
Korwin
offline
Link
 
i think strength, agility, jumping, confidence, and tackling should be in the tackle equation.
 
Duo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cyred
It is simple. You want to tackle this big lumbering monster you need high tackling. If you know how to tackle does it really matter how fast you are if you run into this other person. You can tackle or you can not. It is pretty simple.


But that's not true at all. A small 5'11 190 pound DB isn't going to try to go head up and face a big 230 pound "big lumbering monster" in a battle of strength. They're going to try and take their legs out, which is more of a "hit" than a tackle. Of course tackling should still count, but it shouldn't be the same across the board for every defensive player.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16

Not every HB in the game is an elusive back.

Case in point? OP.


Follow the conversation

Someone said "Then speed offense kills all", someone said "How so?", I replied.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.


That's kinda why I'm asking this, Larry. People complain about missing tackles, but missing 3-4 tackles in a game vs one of these guys when you have 30 strength and 40 tackling and aren't running full speed with your 90 spd/agility doesn't really seem that out of line to me, even with "wrap up" settings.

I mean, you don't want power backs to be the end-all build, but you want to make their skills worthwhile as well, so a tiny weak CB doesn't take him down every time.



My problem isn't so much with a tackler breaking a tackle. I get that. It's breaking them one after the other. Their likelihood to break another tackle after breaking the first one should be reduced drastically as a missed tackle would typically slow down and/or get the RB off balance.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:19:48
 
bberyquiet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.


That's kinda why I'm asking this, Larry. People complain about missing tackles, but missing 3-4 tackles in a game vs one of these guys when you have 30 strength and 40 tackling and aren't running full speed with your 90 spd/agility doesn't really seem that out of line to me, even with "wrap up" settings.

I mean, you don't want power backs to be the end-all build, but you want to make their skills worthwhile as well, so a tiny weak CB doesn't take him down every time.


I agree. But at the same time, these slower, stronger RB's should also be TFL by big, strong D-lineman equally as often if that's the case. They're just not going to hit the hole as quickly.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:20:06
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
I think "consistently" should be 60-70 strength/tackling.

However, I think the "plow" should have more effect. So that if they get hit at the line, they still get a few yards the majority of the time, unless they get hit by 2-3 guys, or they get hit hard by someone.


Yeah. Strength can get you that extra lean/yard, but strength != breaking a tackle. Neither do you need to be strong to be a good tackler. Tackling is more technique and speed than strength.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Korwin
i think strength, agility, jumping, confidence, and tackling should be in the tackle equation.


Pretty sure they are, along with vision.
 
Link
 
honestly i would think many things would factor, first off should proximity of defender to the ball carrier(farther distance should amke a diving tackle and a tackle penalty) next should be tackle to see if you can latch on to the offensive player. these would be to see if you are able to talke the player.

Then angle of persuit should come into play, its obvious that if you do a leg tackle on someone from behind and they fall forward thats 2-3 more yards. Then strength to see how far you can carry the defensive person before they get you down. The longer you drag the player the more chance a fumble should occur.

over all id say power backs with 100 str should take atleast 75+ tackle to take down consistently and atleast 50+ to be able to make 50% of all tackles on that player.

STR should determine how quickly you bring them down or if you can reverse their momentum. in this case 80+ to stop them cold and atleast 50 to stop them within 2-3 yards.

speed should be used to see if you can close the gap enough to make a tackle and agility should be to avoid fakes, cuts, falling players and blocks.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Themain problem I see is that any LB without 75+ speed at a high level just gets torched by TE's and Speed backs.

GLB's main focus to do well revolves heavily around speed/agil. Until that changes, not much else can
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.