Last edited Dec 10, 2008 19:45:42
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
william78
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by TheInfinity
I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.
First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.
If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"
I wasn't actually thinking about DE/OT actually, though I guess it would apply some. I was thinking it would be an interesting way to show the effect of weight and add another customizability option.
Also, how many 250 lb linebackers can run the same 40 as a 170 lb WR?
Very few as long as it's balanced in the secondary not every great WR has burning speed in fact most don't , love him or hate him TO is a great receiver when he's on not because he's fast but because he's physical he creates separation with his body and hands catches the ball and generally does not go down to arm tackles by second tier defensive backs. As long as someone can essentially counter the 160 pound DB with a 220 pound WR and create a mismatch then it would work.
Also HB's should be able to run over those midget DB's and LB's some would go for as well.
Just my 2 cents
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by TheInfinity
I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.
First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.
If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"
I wasn't actually thinking about DE/OT actually, though I guess it would apply some. I was thinking it would be an interesting way to show the effect of weight and add another customizability option.
Also, how many 250 lb linebackers can run the same 40 as a 170 lb WR?
Very few as long as it's balanced in the secondary not every great WR has burning speed in fact most don't , love him or hate him TO is a great receiver when he's on not because he's fast but because he's physical he creates separation with his body and hands catches the ball and generally does not go down to arm tackles by second tier defensive backs. As long as someone can essentially counter the 160 pound DB with a 220 pound WR and create a mismatch then it would work.
Also HB's should be able to run over those midget DB's and LB's some would go for as well.
Just my 2 cents
LionsLover
offline
offline
I think the bonuses/penalties for weights are off, here is what they should be
LW Base 4.0 -10% blocking
MW Base 4.2 -5% blocking
LHW Base 4.4 0% blocking
HW Base 4.6 +5% blocking
SHW Base 4.8 +10% blocking
OMGHW Base 5.0 +15% blocking
20 and 30% blocking is too much. At 50 blocking that puts you up to 60 and 65 blocking. At 15% it puts you up to 58.
LW Base 4.0 -10% blocking
MW Base 4.2 -5% blocking
LHW Base 4.4 0% blocking
HW Base 4.6 +5% blocking
SHW Base 4.8 +10% blocking
OMGHW Base 5.0 +15% blocking
20 and 30% blocking is too much. At 50 blocking that puts you up to 60 and 65 blocking. At 15% it puts you up to 58.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























