Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.
Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.
There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.
For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.
How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.
Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.
Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?
So... you're saying that a DE needs 3 attributes and SAs to be successful? Yet, we expect OL to only need 2 attributes and SAs to be successful? Sorry, I'd expect things to be fair, which it isn't atm.
OTs need agility, speed, vision, blocking and SAs... to compare to a DE that only needs agility, speed, vision and SAs. You can argue about speed for an OT, just like I can argue vision for a DE. Either way, DEs need at least one less attribute to work on to be successful.
This is the primary flaw in the "good build, bad build" argument. Make an OT that lacks one of the key attributes and they get demolished by a DE that doesn't... which would be fine if both positions were equal, but they're not atm.
Besides the fact that OL should have the advantage, simply because they know the play and have the "higher ground". Due to pathing issues though, the "higher ground" advantage is worthless for the most part.
We need SAs higher than OTs do, we need much higher agility, and we need much higher speed. We can't beat even a badly built OT if you take away any of these primary attributes, excluding vision which is really just the icing on the cake.
You see so many OTs bitching about getting beat when they have 1/3rd the agility and 1/4th the speed of the best DEs out there.
I've had players on both sides of the line, simply just retired my O-linemen because they were rather boring and I needed the FP. OTs are not hard to build at all and you can essentially neglect all SAs other than the protect skill.
Of course I remember when you stuck your head in the d-line forum before, there simply is no reasoning with you. Doubt any of this will get through that thick skull of yours.
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.
Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.
There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.
For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.
How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.
Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.
Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?
So... you're saying that a DE needs 3 attributes and SAs to be successful? Yet, we expect OL to only need 2 attributes and SAs to be successful? Sorry, I'd expect things to be fair, which it isn't atm.
OTs need agility, speed, vision, blocking and SAs... to compare to a DE that only needs agility, speed, vision and SAs. You can argue about speed for an OT, just like I can argue vision for a DE. Either way, DEs need at least one less attribute to work on to be successful.
This is the primary flaw in the "good build, bad build" argument. Make an OT that lacks one of the key attributes and they get demolished by a DE that doesn't... which would be fine if both positions were equal, but they're not atm.
Besides the fact that OL should have the advantage, simply because they know the play and have the "higher ground". Due to pathing issues though, the "higher ground" advantage is worthless for the most part.
We need SAs higher than OTs do, we need much higher agility, and we need much higher speed. We can't beat even a badly built OT if you take away any of these primary attributes, excluding vision which is really just the icing on the cake.
You see so many OTs bitching about getting beat when they have 1/3rd the agility and 1/4th the speed of the best DEs out there.
I've had players on both sides of the line, simply just retired my O-linemen because they were rather boring and I needed the FP. OTs are not hard to build at all and you can essentially neglect all SAs other than the protect skill.
Of course I remember when you stuck your head in the d-line forum before, there simply is no reasoning with you. Doubt any of this will get through that thick skull of yours.






























