User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA

You have really good built DEs who can beat the best of the best OTs, and these are what the O-line guys are complaining about.

Then you have the decent but not quite over the hill DEs, who complain about being able to do nothing.

There seems to be a fine line between success and complete defeat.

For anyone who has played football, you should know a pancake while in a pass blocking assignment is nearly impossible, you are supposed to hold your ground not drive back, that gives you the nice little illegal receiver down field penalty.

How often do you see really good D-linemen draw double teams? Pretty often right? Well don't expect to get any sympathy if you are getting beat 1 on 1 if you send the FB or HB off.

Just because you are strong, and because you can block does not mean you are either quick or simply fast enough to use either of those little attributes. Surprising how much OTs neglect speed and agility, not mentioning vision.

Fact is to be a dominant DE like this guy now you need high agility, speed, vision and more than a decent amount in the pass rushing tree. What exactly makes OTs think that just agility, blocking, and the protect sa is enough to stop this?


So... you're saying that a DE needs 3 attributes and SAs to be successful? Yet, we expect OL to only need 2 attributes and SAs to be successful? Sorry, I'd expect things to be fair, which it isn't atm.

OTs need agility, speed, vision, blocking and SAs... to compare to a DE that only needs agility, speed, vision and SAs. You can argue about speed for an OT, just like I can argue vision for a DE. Either way, DEs need at least one less attribute to work on to be successful.

This is the primary flaw in the "good build, bad build" argument. Make an OT that lacks one of the key attributes and they get demolished by a DE that doesn't... which would be fine if both positions were equal, but they're not atm.

Besides the fact that OL should have the advantage, simply because they know the play and have the "higher ground". Due to pathing issues though, the "higher ground" advantage is worthless for the most part.


We need SAs higher than OTs do, we need much higher agility, and we need much higher speed. We can't beat even a badly built OT if you take away any of these primary attributes, excluding vision which is really just the icing on the cake.

You see so many OTs bitching about getting beat when they have 1/3rd the agility and 1/4th the speed of the best DEs out there.

I've had players on both sides of the line, simply just retired my O-linemen because they were rather boring and I needed the FP. OTs are not hard to build at all and you can essentially neglect all SAs other than the protect skill.

Of course I remember when you stuck your head in the d-line forum before, there simply is no reasoning with you. Doubt any of this will get through that thick skull of yours.
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
I can't go through 21 whole pages -- but our ROT (38 speed / 65 agility) gave up 11 sacks today against a team that rushed 4 or maybe 5 guys the whole game - no extensive blitzing required. That kind of sucked.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 23:43:18
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Reggie Smash
I can't go through 21 whole pages -- but our ROT (38 speed / 65 agility) gave up 11 sacks today against a team that rushed 4 or maybe 5 guys the whole game - no extensive blitzing required. That kind of sucked.



11 sacks is accessive, however, what was the DE build. My guess is he was a 90 speed 70 agility DE. Did you scout the other team? If so, why didn't you have TE block. Why weren't you running more.

If you are a passing team and your OT is level 35+ he should have 60+ agility and 50+ speed especially if playing ROT. LOT it can be a little lower if you have protect SA jacked up.

My biggest complaint is that these speed DEs with 55 strength aren't getting knocked 5 yards off the LOS every time an OT with with 75 strength blocks them on running plays. Then again, the teams with speed rush LDEs are also the ones that are whining about the strong I HB OT play being so effective.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch
Originally posted by Gyuri1

By the way, I should add that if Bort made changes to the sim during the offseason that makes speed/agility rushers more effective, then disregard everything else I've written above. My argument is against nerfing what has been status quo for a long time (as there were ways to counter the fast speed rushers), but if things have changed making speed/agility DEs more overpowering, then I'm all for toning it back down to what it had been in the past. My OT and two higher-level DEs played against a terrible team today, so it's hard to decipher whether things have changed. The preseason games, however, made it look as if things hadn't changed much.


I think that is part of the problem here. This didn't happen last year at all and we played a lot of teams that had great pass rushers and great D's. We gave up a total of 9 sacks last year in the regular season. We played a lot of really good teams and good DE's while doing that and never got abused like this. It just seems like something changed.

I am stuck by two things in these. One our guy barely moved, ever. I mean it looks like he is on a different snap count. I don't mind getting beat but to get beat like that just looks stupid.




SE Asia Pro AA? Likely you were playing against mostly slow-build teams before. Maybe you are playing against more teams trying to win this year.

Nothing has changed. If anything, it is harder for DE's to get sacks this year.
 
baumusc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Reggie Smash

I can't go through 21 whole pages -- but our ROT (38 speed / 65 agility) gave up 11 sacks today against a team that rushed 4 or maybe 5 guys the whole game - no extensive blitzing required. That kind of sucked.



11 sacks is accessive, however, what was the DE build. My guess is he was a 90 speed 70 agility DE. Did you scout the other team? If so, why didn't you have TE block. Why weren't you running more.

If you are a passing team and your OT is level 35+ he should have 60+ agility and 50+ speed especially if playing ROT. LOT it can be a little lower if you have protect SA jacked up.

My biggest complaint is that these speed DEs with 55 strength aren't getting knocked 5 yards off the LOS every time an OT with with 75 strength blocks them on running plays. Then again, the teams with speed rush LDEs are also the ones that are whining about the strong I HB OT play being so effective.



The stat lines in this game are becoming/have been pretty retarded. They are going to have to stop calling this a football "simulator" soon.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
We need SAs higher than OTs do, we need much higher agility, and we need much higher speed. We can't beat even a badly built OT if you take away any of these primary attributes, excluding vision which is really just the icing on the cake.

You see so many OTs bitching about getting beat when they have 1/3rd the agility and 1/4th the speed of the best DEs out there.

I've had players on both sides of the line, simply just retired my O-linemen because they were rather boring and I needed the FP. OTs are not hard to build at all and you can essentially neglect all SAs other than the protect skill.

Of course I remember when you stuck your head in the d-line forum before, there simply is no reasoning with you. Doubt any of this will get through that thick skull of yours.


So I have a thick skull, because I think it's unrealistic (and stupid), that a DE built like a defensive back, is a super-duper pass rusher? We encountered one another in Miked33's thread... his advice was to completely ignore strength and his DE was dominating back in season 3 (and probably still dominating).

Spare me the "we need SAs" BS, OTs need an extra attribute to soft cap (at a minimum, probably 2 is more accurate). A DE needs two maybe three SAs to work on. Do the math and get back to me.

My RT has 56 agility, 35 speed, 48 vision, etc... He wasn't destroyed like some people were, but he got beat a couple times (it was like he was standing still on those plays). Builds aren't the only problem, it's just a piece of the puzzle.

Here's my list of the issues with the game...

#1 Agility > Strength for linemen. It should be Agility = Strength.
#2 How acceleration is figured out, needs to be tweaked. Or pathing needs to be adjusted to help fix all the flying dots. Changing direction should slow a player down, more than it currently does. This in turn would make vision more important, angles would be much more important.
#3 SAs need to become more effective, across the board.
#4 Pathing needs work in many areas (primarily RB pass blocking and OL/DL stunts/pick-ups).
#5 Blitzers need to stop running through other players and/or fitting through small gaps 100% of the time. It should happen, but they should also fall down on occasion or not make it through. Or a novel concept, maybe have to use vision and scheme to actually effectively blitz.
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Or how about you use the tools you have available to you and quit ramming your head into a brick wall...move the TE over to help block, keep a back in. Maybe run shorter passes or *gasp* run right at the lightning bolt and bulldoze his ass into the ground.

The whine about speed rushers were valid last year but now there are so many ways to gameplan and stop them it is time for some of your whiners to give it a rest.
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Or how about you use the tools you have available to you and quit ramming your head into a brick wall...move the TE over to help block, keep a back in. Maybe run shorter passes or *gasp* run right at the lightning bolt and bulldoze his ass into the ground.

The whine about speed rushers were valid last year but now there are so many ways to gameplan and stop them it is time for some of your whiners to give it a rest.


would work if blitzing wasnt currently overpowered against the run as well
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
Originally posted by 5STAR

Or how about you use the tools you have available to you and quit ramming your head into a brick wall...move the TE over to help block, keep a back in. Maybe run shorter passes or *gasp* run right at the lightning bolt and bulldoze his ass into the ground.

The whine about speed rushers were valid last year but now there are so many ways to gameplan and stop them it is time for some of your whiners to give it a rest.


would work if blitzing wasnt currently overpowered against the run as well


really? so you are telling me they can magically blitz to every gap possible? Look where they blitz and run the other way...come on people it is not that hard
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Or how about you use the tools you have available to you and quit ramming your head into a brick wall...move the TE over to help block, keep a back in. Maybe run shorter passes or *gasp* run right at the lightning bolt and bulldoze his ass into the ground.

The whine about speed rushers were valid last year but now there are so many ways to gameplan and stop them it is time for some of your whiners to give it a rest.


Or how about you understand that, I've tried keeping two backs in to block (a FB and a TE on the majority of passing plays), we gave up 11 sacks anyways.

The tools aren't working against the better built DEs and good DCs. Theorycrafting is cool and all, but it doesn't always translate from paper to practice.

Actually, let me clarify... 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 passing attempts... most (like 75% of them) had 7 blockers. I refuse to run every single play as well. We had 180+ yards on the ground, but only ~6 completions... I don't think taking out all pass plays because of some BS is an acceptable answer to the problem.
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 05:04:55
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by 5STAR

Or how about you use the tools you have available to you and quit ramming your head into a brick wall...move the TE over to help block, keep a back in. Maybe run shorter passes or *gasp* run right at the lightning bolt and bulldoze his ass into the ground.

The whine about speed rushers were valid last year but now there are so many ways to gameplan and stop them it is time for some of your whiners to give it a rest.


Or how about you understand that, I've tried keeping two backs in to block (a FB and a TE on the majority of passing plays), we gave up 11 sacks anyways.

The tools aren't working against the better built DEs and good DCs. Theorycrafting is cool and all, but it doesn't always translate from paper to practice.

Actually, let me clarify... 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 passing attempts... most (like 75% of them) had 7 blockers.



I watched your first 2 passing plays.
Back blocked complete:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1261904

Back didn't block you got sacked:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1262050

I am not going to watch anymore because the very first 2 pass plays proved what I said.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Originally posted by Warlock

Originally posted by 5STAR


Or how about you use the tools you have available to you and quit ramming your head into a brick wall...move the TE over to help block, keep a back in. Maybe run shorter passes or *gasp* run right at the lightning bolt and bulldoze his ass into the ground.

The whine about speed rushers were valid last year but now there are so many ways to gameplan and stop them it is time for some of your whiners to give it a rest.


Or how about you understand that, I've tried keeping two backs in to block (a FB and a TE on the majority of passing plays), we gave up 11 sacks anyways.

The tools aren't working against the better built DEs and good DCs. Theorycrafting is cool and all, but it doesn't always translate from paper to practice.

Actually, let me clarify... 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 passing attempts... most (like 75% of them) had 7 blockers.



I watched your first 2 passing plays.
Back blocked complete:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1261904

Back didn't block you got sacked:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1262050

I am not going to watch anymore because the very first 2 pass plays proved what I said.


No clown, like I said... 75% of the pass plays had 7 blockers, the other 25% had 6 blockers. We still gave up 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 passing attempts (i.e. a sack every 3 passes and/or a sack/hurry every other pass).

Taking a two play sample size won't be anywhere near accurate data. By all means though, keep thinking you're so smart and know everything... Mensa just called, you owe some dues.
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 05:09:04
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by 5STAR

Originally posted by Warlock


Originally posted by 5STAR



Or how about you use the tools you have available to you and quit ramming your head into a brick wall...move the TE over to help block, keep a back in. Maybe run shorter passes or *gasp* run right at the lightning bolt and bulldoze his ass into the ground.

The whine about speed rushers were valid last year but now there are so many ways to gameplan and stop them it is time for some of your whiners to give it a rest.


Or how about you understand that, I've tried keeping two backs in to block (a FB and a TE on the majority of passing plays), we gave up 11 sacks anyways.

The tools aren't working against the better built DEs and good DCs. Theorycrafting is cool and all, but it doesn't always translate from paper to practice.

Actually, let me clarify... 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 passing attempts... most (like 75% of them) had 7 blockers.



I watched your first 2 passing plays.
Back blocked complete:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1261904

Back didn't block you got sacked:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1262050

I am not going to watch anymore because the very first 2 pass plays proved what I said.


No clown, like I said... 75% of the pass plays had 7 blockers, the other 25% had 6 blockers. We still gave up 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 passing attempts (i.e. a sack every 3 passes and/or a sack/hurry every other pass).

Taking a two play sample size won't be anywhere near accurate data. By all means though, keep thinking you're so smart and know everything... Mensa just called, you owe some dues.


I must be smart because I am not the one whining because my gameplan got absolutley destroyed. Carry on blaming Bort
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 05:12:19
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
I must be smart because I am not the one whining because my gameplan got absolutly destroyed. Carry on blaming Bort


Says the person whose teams, played cup cakes. Wait until you play some decent competition bud.

Btw, the gameplan didn't get destroyed. The failed pathing on the blocking RBs, combined with the ridiculous builds of their DEs... completely removed our passing game. We rushed for almost 200 yards. There was nothing I could have done, besides run 100% of the time, to get a different outcome. When 6/7 blockers cannot pick up a 4/5 man rush, there's a problem in the sim.
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
BTW the team my team beat is the same overall ranking thanks for trying...

Look at this awesome gameplan:

You run a 3 man route all double covered = sack:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1262074

Again 3 man route all double covered:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1262441

More of the same:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1262483

Again:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1262950

Again
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219881&pbp_id=1263453

Keep running 3 man routes and you will do well Exactly who is the QB supposed to throw to in these plays? Everyone is double covered.

Your gameplan and offense = suck
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 05:20:20
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.