User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #2 > Canada AAA#2 East Power Rankings
Page:
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lazer Noble
Passing Receiving

Not complaining. Just saying 2 7-0 teams and the one who has an advantage in the Matchup gets an Upset bonus.
I really appreciate the formula, the time and all. Just thought that bonus was odd.

the PM talk was just to get you pissed off...we meet soon.


As for the PM talk, I saw what you were doing but apparently Reading didn't, so well played

As for using the matchup screen to judge ANYTHING, lol. It is true that Reading had an edge in passing and receiving though. Their passing offense graded at 94.3 and their rushing offense at 92.2, while Niagara was only 91.1 and 87.7 respectively. Reading's offense, overall, rated at 93.2, while Niagara's rated at 89.4. On defense though, the Jeanhorns had a 93.5 pass D, and a 90.9 run D, for a 92.2 overall defense rating, which averaged with their offense to give them a 90.8 overall roster rating. Reading's defense graded at 84.9 vs. the pass and 79.5 vs. the run, for a net defense of 82.2, making the team rating 87.7.

When an 87.7 beats a 90.8, that's an upset. Of course there is more to a team than just how my formula grades the starting lineup, and the Redskins proved that today with a very solid win over the higher rated team, and accounting for that is the entire point of the upset adjustments. So that's why they get credit for one.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ziot
Ah, nice, we were doing something similar to this awhile ago and it was not as accurate, this is a great formula.

We have wrote a new formula based off of what you have done with some additions to factor for kickers and punters. We are going to be doing something similar for Pro - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=206654.


Glad you like it. I'm amazed by how many people have PMed me about using this formula, or a slightly modified version thereof. It's now being used in Canada Pro, both Canada AAA leagues, at least one or two Canada AA leagues, somewhere in Oceania, and in I believe 3 USA leagues. Just for the record, yes, the formula is intended to be available for public use, and anyone who wants to use it is welcome to do so. Also, at the end of this season I plan to re-evaluate the methods, refine things a little, and come up with version 2.0 of the formula (it will include kickers and punters). Once I've done that I'll probably be posting it on the main GLB forum, along with links to some sample spreadsheets to help people get it set up. So keep your eye out for that
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by Lazer Noble

Passing Receiving

Not complaining. Just saying 2 7-0 teams and the one who has an advantage in the Matchup gets an Upset bonus.
I really appreciate the formula, the time and all. Just thought that bonus was odd.

the PM talk was just to get you pissed off...we meet soon.


As for the PM talk, I saw what you were doing but apparently Reading didn't, so well played

As for using the matchup screen to judge ANYTHING, lol. It is true that Reading had an edge in passing and receiving though. Their passing offense graded at 94.3 and their rushing offense at 92.2, while Niagara was only 91.1 and 87.7 respectively. Reading's offense, overall, rated at 93.2, while Niagara's rated at 89.4. On defense though, the Jeanhorns had a 93.5 pass D, and a 90.9 run D, for a 92.2 overall defense rating, which averaged with their offense to give them a 90.8 overall roster rating. Reading's defense graded at 84.9 vs. the pass and 79.5 vs. the run, for a net defense of 82.2, making the team rating 87.7.

When an 87.7 beats a 90.8, that's an upset. Of course there is more to a team than just how my formula grades the starting lineup, and the Redskins proved that today with a very solid win over the higher rated team, and accounting for that is the entire point of the upset adjustments. So that's why they get credit for one.

aight, see, now we all know we aren't dealing with favoritism. All good.

I like Defense.

 
MrTea
offline
Link
 
the reason we fell for the PM talk der are teams dat wud PM you about upsets and things. no naming names but its obvious who would do it. its just ofensive and not very funny but itll just make are victory over the packers that little bit sweeter
 
atlasofpugs
offline
Link
 
PUGZO THINK EVERYONE TOO ANGRY INT HREAD

PUGZO THIIIIINK
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atlasofpugs
PUGZO THINK EVERYONE TOO ANGRY INT HREAD

PUGZO THIIIIINK


Thanks Pugzo, we all need a reminder once in a while
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
its just ofensive and not very funny but ....

lol...mom will give you a hug...it'll all be better then.
 
MrTea
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lazer Noble
its just ofensive and not very funny but ....

lol...mom will give you a hug...it'll all be better then.


no itll be better when we destroy your team
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
its shaping up to be a doozy
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/13

1. Iqaluit Packers (5-3, 91.5 [89.6 + 1.9])
2. Reading Redskins (8-0, 90.3 [87.8 + 2.5])
3. West Texas Widowermakers (7-1, 88.2)
4. Niagara Jeanhorns (7-1, 87.2 [89.7 - 2.5])
5. Arctic Bay Yetis (7-1, 86.5 [88.4 - 1.9])
6. Brown Trout (7-1, 86.0 [81.7 + 4.3])
7. Ottawa Bills (7-1, 83.4)
8. The Usual Suspects (4-4, 82.8 [85.4 - 2.6])
9. Hudson Howlers (2-6, 80.8 [75.6 + 5.2])
10. Dallas Desparados (5-3, 79.6 [86.5 - 6.9])
11. Ottawa Ambassadors (1-7, 74.3)
12. Vancouver Darksiders (1-7, 67.2)
13. Iowa Blackhawks (1-6-1, 66.0 [69.1 - 3.1])
14. Halifax United (1-6-1, 57.6 [48.3 + 9.3])
15. Niagra Falls Cascade (0-8, 55.6 [61.8 - 6.2])
16. Sparta Mustangs (0-8, 39.8)

Today's Games
Brown Trout vs. West Texas Widowermakers [-1]
Vancouver Darksiders vs. Dallas Desperados [-17]
The Usual Suspects vs. Niagara Jeanhorns [-6]
Iqaluit Packers [-63] vs. Niagra Falls Cascade
Sparta Mustangs vs. Arctic Bay Yetis [-72]
Ottawa Ambassadors [-7] vs. Iowa Blackhawks
Reading Redskins [-7] vs. Ottawa Bills
Hudson Howlers [-27] vs. Halifax United

Iqaluit's #1 ranking felt wrong to me at first, but thinking more about it I realized it points out something about this ranking system that I may not have ever clearly stated or even fully conceptualized myself. It is NOT meant to rate how likely teams are to make the playoffs, or assess performance over the course of the whole season. It is designed to rate how dangerous of an opponent a team is RIGHT NOW. Earlier in the season, Iqaluit's starting lineup was less impressive on paper than it is now, and each of their three losses came to teams that had a higher roster rating *at the time* than Iqaluit did, so they received no upset penalties. They did receive an upset bonus for one of their wins, since Arctic Bay rated as the better team when they played. In other words, they have played at or above their roster rating in every game this season, indicating the intangibles that my formula doesn't account for are a net positive for them, so their net adjustment factor is positive. They have, since then, increased their base roster rating to within a tenth of a point of the league lead, and after the adjustment they now rank #1. This does not mean they are the "best" team, certainly the aren't having the best season so far, but it does mean that, as far as the formula can tell so far, they are the most powerful team RIGHT NOW.

Sorry for the long essay, I was mostly just thinking aloud to myself, but it is an interesting case study to help indicate just exactly what the rankings are (and aren't) meant to assess.
 
SGRHewitt
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the love Bob .
 
sdubord
offline
Link
 
BJJ: I know it's not a perfect science, and you've taken some flak over these, but I gotta say, I love being able to check these out before each game, and get a solid feel for how our Conference is doing. Great job!
 
Wylker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lazer Noble
its shaping up to be a doozy


Its shaping up that my dog is smarter than you.
 
DrunkenOne
offline
Link
 
Great job as always BJJ
 
MrTea
offline
Link
 
yeh nice job but i still think you are under estimating FBs and especially TEs, just posting so mayb you can rejig this in your next load of algorithms. im not critisising im just trying to help, i really enjoy your power rankings keep up the brilliant work
Last edited May 13, 2008 12:18:01
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.