User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk


How is selling tickets to the away team better than sharing? Its the same thing, just from a different end of the stream.

Bort's idea is okay, but a bit unrealistic. The best idea so far IMO is the selling of merchandise for away teams. Teams sell more merchandise through team stores during the playoffs.


Selling tickets is different from sharing in that the home playoff team does not have to sacrifice any revenue (I know my post was long, but I'm pretty sure I covered this). Unless your intent is to PUNISH the higher seeds, giving the lower seeded playoff teams tickets to sell accomplishes the same purpose as sharing, only it does it by increases the total revenue pie rather than making people fight over what's currently there.

That being said, selling merchandise accomplishes virtually the same thing. The point is that visiting teams have an ALTERNATE source of playoff derived revenue that does not require them to TAKE money from someone else.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
They are sharing revenue. They're just doing it in the form of tickets.

Whether you give tickets or money, it still ends up being money lost by the home team and gained by the visiting team.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Not meaning to be difficult, but you're wrong, but maybe you don't understand what I'm trying to say.

Playoff game between #1 and #8 seed:
#1 seed sells tickets and collects revenue from both ticket sales and concessions as they currently do. NO CHANGE FROM THE CURRENT SETUP! However, #8 seed ALSO gets to sell tickets to their home stadium (presumably for fans that couldn't make the trip???) for them to watch the game in the company of other fans of their team on the Jumbotron of the #8 seed's stadium. This is all ADDITIONAL money that doesn't take money from the #1 seed---it's newly generated money that doesn't exist in the current system.

This addresses ALL practical issues that have been raised. The #1 seed loses NO revenue at all! The #8 seed gets an opportunity to generate revenue as a result of having qualified for the playoffs. Ticket prices would be capped at some number to be determined by Bort, say 1 x "Expected" prices. It might be less than they'd get in a regular season game, but then again, they're watching a big TV. OTOH, it's more revenue than they would've gotten before and a HECKUVALOT more than $100,000. If you don't like the ratio between the 1-4's and the 5-8's, you can simply adjust max ticket price ratios, i.e. higher seeds max ticket prices are 3.5 x expected and lower seeds at "1.5 x Expected" or "1 x Expected" or "2 x Expected"---whatever ratio the GLB Powers-That-Be think is fair. Now we've addressed not only the ridiculously inadequate current playoff compensation for the 5-8's, but we've also got a mechanism to adjust the ratio between the revenues generated by the higher seeds and the lower ones.

Hope this clarifies things.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 20:21:54
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Okay . . . I was initially responding to the post by laxdawg which said:


laxdawg
online
Send PM
Sep 30, 2008 19:19:17
Quote

Maybe for seating, you could do like college. Sorry if this was already suggested, but i didn't feel like reading through 4-5 pages of this. But like College, you could put apart a small amount of the stadium for the away team and they'd get their ticket income from that. Sure the home team would get penalized a bit, but it's sure as hell better than sharing revenue. Also somewhat like the idea of TV contracts, but if one team sells gear, so does the other. That's the only way to make it fair for both sides. Personally, i think splinting it anyway is horrible. Reason being is that the 1-4 seeds recruited and spent all the hard work in the off-season trying to get the top 4 seeds for money and now it's gunna be taken away from them. I just hope this doesn't turn out like the new equipment threads.




Your idea (bort's idea) was different.

I'm curious. Do colleges charge admission for Jumbotron events, or are those more of a student rally type thing?
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 20:04:14
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
OK, this kinda dates me, but when Florida won the National Championship with Spurrier, Wuerfel and the "Fun-n-Gun" Offense, they played Auburn in an Away game and this idea was tried. I think about 20,000-25,000 fans showed up in the rain to watch the game on the Florida Jumbotron (which was not as nice as the ones that currently exist) and it was a lot of fun even though we lost to the stupid Tigers (hey, at least we won the National Championship). We did have to pay admission as I recall, but it was a relatively modest fee, $15 IIRC.

Also, (and someone correct me if I'm wrong) Duke and North Carolina often do this at their basketball venues sometimes when they're in the Final Four.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 20:08:39
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
Not meaning to be difficult, but you're wrong, but maybe you don't understand what I'm trying to say.

Playoff game between #1 and #8 seed:
#1 seed sells tickets and collects revenue from both ticket sales and concessions as they currently do. NO CHANGE FROM THE CURRENT SETUP! However, #8 seed ALSO gets to sell tickets to their home stadium (presumably for fans that couldn't make the trip???) for them to watch the game in the company of other fans of their team on the Jumbotron of the #8 seed's stadium. This is all ADDITIONAL money that doesn't take money from the #1 seed---it's newly generated money that doesn't exist in the current system.

This addresses ALL practical issues that have been raised. The #1 seed loses NO revenue at all! The #8 seed gets an opportunity to generate revenue as a result of having qualified for the playoffs. Ticket prices would be capped at some number to be determined by Bort, say 1 x "Expected" prices. It might be less than they'd get in a regular season game, but then again, they're watching a big TV. OTOH, it's more revenue than they would've gotten before and a HECKUVALOT more than $100,000. If you don't like the ratio between the 1-4's and the 5-8's, you can simply adjust max ticket price ratios, i.e. higher seeds max ticket prices are 3.5 x expected and lower seeds at "1.5 x Expected" or "1 x Expected" or "2 x Expected"---whatever ratio the GLB Powers-That-Be think is fair. Now we've addressed not only the ridiculously inadequate current playoff compensation for the 5-8's, but we've also got a mechanism to adjust the ratio between the revenues generated by the higher seeds and the lower ones.

Hope this clarifies things.


See. I think that the home teams NEED to lose some revenues. They make way too much. That is as or more important than the other teams getting some revenues.
 
Bill Jack
offline
Link
 
Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.
 
slakker381
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf

See. I think that the home teams NEED to lose some revenues. They make way too much. That is as or more important than the other teams getting some revenues.


I have to disagree, considering that top 4 teams now have an even greater chance of moving up in conference...they will NEED the extra money to be able to keep up with the higher leveled teams. Teams that are finishing 5-8 need to step their game up and stop making excuses .
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 21:35:53
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
OK, I think we disagree on the issue of punishing the 1-4 seeds. WHY do you think home teams need to lose some revenue? Why shouldn't they be able to reap the fruits of their hard labor? Shouldn't this be one of the perks of finishing in the top 4?

I think we're probably going to end up just not agreeing on this point, because I tend to think that "parity" is GROSSLY overrated. Do you think the NBA was happy to see the Lakers and the Celtics in the Finals? You bet your ass they were. Having GREAT teams tends to elevate interest in leagues because, (well, this is just my theory) people want to see GREAT teams, not just very good ones. Would you have wanted to see Bird and Magic or Chauncy Billups and Derek Fisher? Brady/Moss or Trent Dilfer/Qadry Ismael? Parity ends up diluting quality because it rewards inefficiency--it assumes that the overall level of play is a constant. I'd say that when other teams see a superteam, they have to try to keep up, try something new and innovative to compete, and the overall level of competition increases as a result. But enough of my rant...

Bottom line is that I have absolutely no problem with rewarding high achieving teams richly as long as other teams aren't shut out to the point that they can't compete. Bort's suggestion allows for this, and I don't think the punitive aspect of revenue sharing on the higher seeds is--nor should it be--the focus for most people.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 21:41:09
 
valakar
offline
Link
 


Do I think it is fair? Hmm, no I do not think it is fair, but that is the way the game has been played for at least the amount of time that you and I have been here. I know that if my team does not make a 1-4 seed then it will be more difficult next season without that revenue. I know that trying to convince your players who want to look out for themselves and wait until the end of the season to boost that if they do that they hurt the team as a collective. Try convincing people in the "me" generation they should take an exp loss so your team makes a better seeding in the playoffs... difficult. I know that I don't give every player I sign a huge bonus and "equipment money" on day one... they need to commit to winning and to the team before I spend the teams money on an individual. Starting to rant again... back to topic...

Is it unfair? Yes. I have adjusted to the current system and built my team around the current system, recruited players and agents and GMs around the current system. If the system changes I will adjust, my team and players will adjust. I am really overwhelmingly against so much constant change. The changes, in my opinion, are making every player, team and agent equal and that just sucks. If all the players, agents and teams are equal then I will have to spend more time helping old ladies across the street and less time playing GLB...



Now one point to make on this comment. Just because it has always been a certain way does not mean change is not needed. Just because you survived and adapted and did what you needed to do does not mean the system in place is not broken or at least out of balance. Many problems mentioned in other threads would be better by implementing some kind of revenue sharing or luxury tax. Could and should lead to less gutted teams and more overall competition. So lets see Bort wants to do a realignment and also wants to demote gutted teams to the bottom. Seems like he is trying to fix some of what the lack of balance in the financial system has caused.

I mean in U.S. Government (lets use this bailout proposal). Just because most of us know it is wrong to bail out Wall Street or the bankers for being stupid does not mean it isn't necessary. Certain things have a greater long-term good thus have to be implemented even if it was always another way in the past.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bill Jack
Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
OK, I think we disagree on the issue of punishing the 1-4 seeds. WHY do you think home teams need to lose some revenue? Why shouldn't they be able to reap the fruits of their hard labor? Shouldn't this be one of the perks of finishing in the top 4?

I think we're probably going to end up just not agreeing on this point, because I tend to think that "parity" is GROSSLY overrated. Do you think the NBA was happy to see the Lakers and the Celtics in the Finals? You bet your ass they were. Having GREAT teams tends to elevate interest in leagues because, (well, this is just my theory) people want to see GREAT teams, not just very good ones. Would you have wanted to see Bird and Magic or Chauncy Billups and Derek Fisher? Brady/Moss or Trent Dilfer/Qadry Ismael? Parity ends up diluting quality because it rewards inefficiency--it assumes that the overall level of play is a constant. I'd say that when other teams see a superteam, they have to try to keep up, try something new and innovative to compete, and the overall level of competition increases as a result. But enough of my rant...

Bottom line is that I have absolutely no problem with rewarding high achieving teams richly as long as other teams aren't shut out to the point that they can't compete. Bort's suggestion allows for this, and I don't think the punitive aspect of revenue sharing on the higher seeds is--nor should it be--the focus for most people.


Let me chime in on this. I do not think it is about punishing anybody. One of the fundamental issues is the divide between teams at the top and and the bottom. Now teams that are better managed, recruited, etc should be towards the top and those that are poorly run or recruited should be towards the bottom. I think we can all agree on this. Now what about in a 'perfect' beginning scenario where 10 of the 16 teams were well run and recruited and had a season long dogfight for playoffs. Now what if the difference in record between #1 and #8 is like 2 wins and most of this was decided by tiebreakers and head-to-head match-ups. Most would agree this would be a fun league to participate in and would have a much more active forum then the league that everybody knows from day one who will win and who is in playoffs with little debate.

Now in this scenario using the old financial system those top 4 teams would get stronger financially and thus be able to recruit easier. They already have the "look I won my league", or "We lost 2 games and are a contender" arguments for recruiting but NOW they also can outright buy whatever they want in trades and offer ridiculous contracts. Now if managed correctly (and we already agree all these teams were) those top teams are now even stronger and win even more and the lower teams struggle a bit more and again after the 2nd season same story and the gap widens between the top teams and the other. This continues (already has in seasons 1-4 on GLB) to cause this rift.

The rift causes sold and gutted teams and once competitive teams to fold and lose interest in owning a team or many of the other secondary issues that come up on GLB. So back to the point you make about just adding money to these teams. I feel this is a solution and definitely heading in the right direction (better then nothing) but does not lessen the divide I mentioned as much as I feel necessary to create more competitive and entertaining leagues without 'punishing' those that succeeded earlier and got the 1-4 seeds.

The revenue sharing where you only split the money already generated but still give bonuses to all teams like Bort does accomplishes two things. 1) It allows for less total money to be in the game then your proposal and thus allows the trade and free agency market to not continue to get ridiculous. 2) It Narrows the gap between the well run (but unlucky in a sim or two) teams that are 5-8 seed and the well run (but more luck in a sim or two) teams that are 1-4 seed thus creating more parity thus creating more interest in league as a whole or the league forum thus creating more discussion and positive energy about wanting to have players on teams in this conference thus increasing positive outlook of GLB as a whole.
 
hork
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps
Originally posted by Bill Jack

Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


Agreed.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps
Originally posted by Bill Jack

Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


I think half is ridiculous also. I always thought 70/30 or even 75/25 as low as even 80/20 with all concessions going to home team. The loss is minor compared to the larger overall gain for the competition of the league, etc. I must be in the minority which is fine. I will continue to discuss and if I am wrong will admit it but I feel this is best option (only option almost). I worked my ass off also as many of you have and yes while I am very annoyed this might take place now the very season I stand to benefit the most from my hard work I am still in support of some remedy for this growing divide between those teams that have and those teams that do not have (assuming equal investment, time, recruiting, etc) if the teams does not care or try then I say forget them. However sometimes you cannot implement any policy or change without rewarding some bad seeds but overall you will reward many more quality active owners that had some bad luck along the way and less of those bad owners who don't care.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
50/50 is too much. Needs to be a decent reward for winning in regular season.

75/25 with home team getting concessions is still my opinion.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.