User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
Pickster00
offline
Link
 
This morning's sim. Latest of many almost identical plays with this WR and both our QBs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=180971&pbp_id=5817152
He has VERY high speed for his level and this doesn't seem to happen with our other WRs. Probably the 5th or 6th long TD we've missed out on this season to the same play. Both QBs are set on medium throwing, has the bullet style been helping anyone? It's hard enough to keep a drive going through the air in a first year cap league without losing what look like gimmie catches. Help?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pickster00
This morning's sim. Latest of many almost identical plays with this WR and both our QBs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=180971&pbp_id=5817152
He has VERY high speed for his level and this doesn't seem to happen with our other WRs. Probably the 5th or 6th long TD we've missed out on this season to the same play. Both QBs are set on medium throwing, has the bullet style been helping anyone? It's hard enough to keep a drive going through the air in a first year cap league without losing what look like gimmie catches. Help?


Yeah, you were definitely robbed on that play.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pickster00
This morning's sim. Latest of many almost identical plays with this WR and both our QBs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=180971&pbp_id=5817152
He has VERY high speed for his level and this doesn't seem to happen with our other WRs. Probably the 5th or 6th long TD we've missed out on this season to the same play. Both QBs are set on medium throwing, has the bullet style been helping anyone? It's hard enough to keep a drive going through the air in a first year cap league without losing what look like gimmie catches. Help?


That's a lv. 17 QB throwing to a lv. 19 WR. There are quite a bit more explanations than the SIM not calculating the ultra-fast WR and ultra-fast ball right i.m.h.o.

b.t.w.: the coverage assignments on that play are screwed up - so you sure didn`t loose anything you earned
 
Pickster00
offline
Link
 
And hitting him dead in the dot but the ball not being dropped or caught, I thought that was the discussion here.
Also like I said, it's happened 8-10 times in 11 games with the same receiver but I haven't seen it with any of our others. Sounds like a pattern to me.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
If the text description of the play would include information like:
Low pass
High pass
Bullet pass
Ball bounced off ground
Ball bobbled and dropped

It would give some direction on what to do with this problem, and shouldn't be any real work to add to the PbP system. It would also limit the postings about problems.
If Bort doesn't have time to fix the passing problem he could at least improve the PbP text to help us understand what's going on.

T
 
Hampe
offline
Link
 
I've seen that happen tons of times.


I always filed it under the "text > replay" category. I think people forget that a lot of times.
Last edited Oct 8, 2008 09:08:57
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hampe
I've seen that happen tons of times.


I always filed it under the "text > replay" category. I think people forget that a lot of times.


but yet no one's seen this issue before this season...
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Hampe

I've seen that happen tons of times.


I always filed it under the "text > replay" category. I think people forget that a lot of times.


but yet no one's seen this issue before this season...


People had seen it, but it became much more prevalent in this season so that it became worrisome.
 
Hampe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Hampe

I've seen that happen tons of times.


I always filed it under the "text > replay" category. I think people forget that a lot of times.


but yet no one's seen this issue before this season...
Does it matter? It doesn't change the fact that the text is more accurate than the replay.

Maybe Bort changed something with the dropped passes...I remember people were complaining that their WRs were dropping too many balls early this season. Maybe this is the only way Bort can keep people from having 20 drops a game, and the QBs having normal completion %s.

 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hampe
Does it matter? It doesn't change the fact that the text is more accurate than the replay.


If the text is more accurate, why not make the text more detailed so that we can see what exactly is going on?

T
 
Hampe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by Hampe

Does it matter? It doesn't change the fact that the text is more accurate than the replay.


If the text is more accurate, why not make the text more detailed so that we can see what exactly is going on?

T
I don't know....I wouldn't complain if it was more detailed.

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hampe
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Hampe


I've seen that happen tons of times.


I always filed it under the "text > replay" category. I think people forget that a lot of times.


but yet no one's seen this issue before this season...
Does it matter? It doesn't change the fact that the text is more accurate than the replay.

Maybe Bort changed something with the dropped passes...I remember people were complaining that their WRs were dropping too many balls early this season. Maybe this is the only way Bort can keep people from having 20 drops a game, and the QBs having normal completion %s.



Maybe you should read the thread.

Bort stated specifically the problem appears to come from a convergance of the addition of medium and Lofty passing (most folks were on Medium) affecting the angle the QB threw the ball to the receivers. The addition of more strength and more vision has created the calculation of angles being used to throw the ball that result in a ball that intersects perfectly with a receivers route.

The problem is, that the ball travels a certain distance per 'tic' (Timeslice) Lets say its flying 2 yards a 'tic' (six feet) at the end of the previous tic it was JUS before the receiver, so starting the next tic its going to fly 6 more feet. Problem is, the ANGLE the ball was thrown at means that additional 6 feet will result in the ball hitting the ground.

Bort stated quite plainly that there are three checks every time a ball is passed. One of those checks is if it will hit the ground. The check to see if a ball will hit the ground occurs BEFORE the check to see if the ball is caught. Indicating on these passes the receiver NEVER gets a chance to catch the ball because it will hit the ground that same tic.

The problem is that Bort needs to re-order this or tweak the angles being calculated/strength used to generate velocity so that on these routes the ball will no hit the ground before the catching check can be attempted.

He's worried about changing the order of the checks because he thinks that will incease the number of completions and up the completion rate for passes. I'm all for that because he shouldn't have a system in place that penalises perfect throws.

My solution would be to make the catch check occur before the hit the ground check and then dial up the DB's a tiny bit so they are closer to where they were before. This is win win. CLEARLY good plays where the defense has been beat will be rewarded making QB's/WR's more happy. But it will be harder to beat a defense, which will make DB's happy. (DB's like my own who are still smarting from having good builds but performing far less well than they did previously)
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Nice summary Enkidu - but I'm afraid this won't work on the "DBs up" part. Even right now, a well build DB defends passes pretty well. If this get's better, the short and medium pass will be down quite a bit (and the long ball "fixed"). This way we get back to the "speed kills" times, for the long ball will be much more worth it.

I like the "more ticks" idea better. A good long pass should have a reasonable chance to be caught by a WR that's in place, so the point it is caught best (closest / best altitude) should be a tick that's calculated.

I still doubt the passes shown are good ones (they appear too low to me), so maybe the angle should be adjusted too after the "tick problem" is solved.

In terms of the WR/DB matchups, I WANT to see DBs getting outsprinted by really fast WRs. Right now, they are getting outfaked and stop their movement rather than the better speed of the WR winning the sprint battle.

What needs to be adressed too:

Jumping catches shouldn't allow further ball advance. If the WR has to dive for the catch, his knee is down and the play over. This would help to reduce the number of big plays made out of "wide open" situations: perfect pass = TD / barely reached pass = big catch, play over.

(General problem: you never see a play ended by someone beeing grounded - not on fumble recoveries, not on jump catches. You'll never see a ball carrier pushed or intentionally going out of bounds too.)

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Upping DB's could be as simple as cutting down the penalties they get for cuts etc. So they can stick a little closer to the WR's. On short/medium patterns this would remain mostly unchanged. On long patters it just means the DB might have a better chance to be in position to make a play on the ball.

 
Pickster00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

I still doubt the passes shown are good ones (they appear too low to me), so maybe the angle should be adjusted too after the "tick problem" is solved.


Are we all watching the same two dimensional replays, or did I miss an update?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.