User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
Jughead
Fork 'Em
offline
Link
 
Its difficult to keep players interested when they have a belief that the outcome of every game is based off the scouting bar.

More parity would help - perhaps reshuffling the teams around GLB would help this.

Also if ownership costs get jacked (i.e. $100/year) - I'd probably bail.



 
Ramius
offline
Link
 
Apparently the mods dont understand that you can talk you want about a 10 year plan, but no one is going to be around for the 10 year plan if things dont improve now. As it stands NOW, middle tier teams simply cannot compete with upper tier teams, and find it near impossible to become one of the upper tier teams. I'm simply not going to keep my team for another 6-7 seasons and struggle to make the playoffs so i can get my 100K while the top teams constantly rake in 15 million from a playoff game, in *hopes* that the game will all of a sudden fix itself.

Also, as noted before, customer service is a HUGE problem in this game. Most of the mods are on a power trip and instead of working to fix problems or listening to real issues and complaints, simply tell owners that they "dont know what they are doing."
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 13:41:01
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
I see several recurring themes in this thread which I agree with, and some proposed solutions. Great thread.

1. Gutting is a problem
- Yes it is, and I think it is contagious, and much more gutting than we've seen already will drive me away from the game (meaning one more gutted team).
-- Mitigation: I love the idea posted early on (sorry, forgot whose idea it was) to have some gutting "tripwire" at which all games for that team are forfeited (including retroactively). I'd go one bit further and say all stats against that team should be removed and/or replaced by averaged stats in other games (so statistical differences between different leagues are minimized). The "tripwire" could be something as simple as selling the team to a non-GM.

2. Free agency in its current state is a problem
- It's hard to be blind to this even as (or especially as) someone who provides all his team's players. The rate at which new teams are introduced each offseason makes experienced players so much more valuable to move to new teams, that it creates extreme hardships on all owners (existing and new) as they scramble to recruit and retain talent. Those teams who don't have much player attrition have too much of an advantage over those teams who must constantly recruit. That leads to more gutting.
-- Mitigation: Another solution I've read in the thread which unfortunately I also can't remember proper attribution for (sorry lol!), is to make CPUs viable short-term replacements. Make their performance close to that of human players of comparable levels. Maybe make them widely available at existing levels but slightly more expensive (maybe 10%) than comparable human players "should" be. This would go towards influencing free agent value to help maintain the game economy at whatever levels are intended by game design.
-- Second mitigation: Slow the release of "new" teams. Yes this directly impacts the rate of revenue growth through player development, but perhaps makes that income more sustainable. That pressure encouraging more player development is the same pressure encouraging owners to leave gutted teams behind, which makes the game as a whole less attractive.

3. The game economy is a problem
- As an owner with a $12M/season payroll and more money than I can use including finishing my stadium at the end of the season, I'm probably more aware than most how much financial disparity there is between teams. Rich teams really have no hard choices to make economically. Host a playoff game or four and you're set for the rest of the team's existence.
-- Solution: Change the distribution of playoff income. This never seems to get discussed until late in a season, and the discussion is always about the season in progress. The answer is always "wait until next season" because owners have made decisions based on predicted playoff income. Simple fix is to state now that Season 5 will have a different distribution for playoff income. Maybe also give teams an offseason bonus based on what league they will be playing in next season, which will help stabilize league performance by giving teams a more realistic chance to field a team competitive at their league's level. Call it TV revenue or whatever, but make that income a major part (maybe as much as 50%) of the team's overall budget so there isn't so much ridiculous disparity between a league's rich and poor.

4. Inconsistent and inadequate strategic communications are creating a customer relations problem
- This is the most important, and most correctable, factor determining whether agents choose to stay or go. Bort makes no single channel for communicating with the playerbase, so those who invest lots of hours reading forums have an inescapable advantage in predicting changes to gameplay. Negative perceptions also linger about admin responsiveness to customers, moderator and/or Alpha tester access to information not made publically available, lack of consistent standards for forum moderation, and unpredictability of how the game will change next.
-- Mitigation: Bort and DigitalDaggers should choose one single channel for communicating with agents and stick to it. Link interesting threads to which they might choose to refer, but don't bury their response within a few threads out of thousands. Dedicate a regular, predictable period each day to when they will address the playerbase. Aggressively address negative perceptions with positive statements to counter them. Train moderators to remain consistent with the corporate message (such as not dropping hints "Bort will be fixing that soon" etc) so as to eliminate the perception (though it may be correct) that moderators have inside information. Establish and publish strict standards for forum moderation and hold the moderators to those standards. Broadcast intentions for game modifications -- especially sim modifications -- well in advance. Never make "stealth changes to the sim.



I think there are some other changes in the works (fame, training, economics) which will also address many concerns. But each of the problems listed above poses risk to GLB's long-term outlook; of them all, strategic communications is the most important one to get right, right now.
 
Steelrain72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dxreydx
I think people are quitting and dropping their teams because its HARD AS HELL. Honestly unless you have good GMs around you then your team will not be good, PERIOD. I don't even touch my Advanced AI on defense or offense because my GMs do that. At the same time my GMs don't even touch anything involving trades, recruiting, resigning players or anything involving the team outside game planning.

Here is the thing with FOOTBALL in general. It's a team game and a lot of these owners try to do it BY THEMSELVES. I call this the Barry Sanders effect. Barry Sanders is maybe the best running back EVER. Yet he didn't get any help from upper managment to get him players around him. Barry could break a million tackles and get a million yards, but his defense could lose the game for him. He can't win games by himself.

My point is that owners are trying to do everything by themselves and in FOOTBALL that is very difficult( of course there are exceptions, but thats when a owner owns all the players or has a lot more time on his hands the most people). A corner back can't cover all the WRs and a single offensive lineman can't block every defender. I think if you are to become an owner you should have a mandtory list of who your GMs are going to be so that will solidify the stability of a well ran team.



+1
 
bignasty31
offline
Link
 
Very well written Painmaker, I agree with everything you stated.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
The most basic answer to why people are leaving is because they cannot win and do not have any hopes of winning any time soon.


I think this is a lot of it.

Plus I think there is a lot of frustration from owners who put in a lot of effort to improve a team and it doesn't make much difference. This is a game that people play for enjoyment, and people do want to be rewarded for effort in some fashion.

In some cases, I think this game is kind of akin to a team based shooter game where everyone was forced to be in a team or clan (for a set period of time) to participate. At the top end you have people who live and breath the game, and may even work exploits for all they are worth.

In the middle, you have people who put in some effort, but don't really keep up on all the trends/tweaks in the game as much as the top end, and probably don't want to spend hours scouting and setting tactics for a game.

At the bottom you have new people and people who are very casual (i.e. minimal effort) about the game.

At the moment these levels of play/interest are all pretty fairly intermingled, which isn't a good thing when everyone wants to win or at least see their players do well. If you threw the casual people together in a separate league where they could just run up stats and the competition was always tight (some behind the scenes CPU assist to the team that is down)...they would probably be happy as hell.

I'm not sure "casual" is the target audience of GLB, but I am pretty sure there are some people who wouldn't mind avoiding the rat race up the GLB ladder, and instead just have fun



 
Real LT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bignasty31
Very well written Painmaker, I agree with everything you stated.


+1

Real LT
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
issues i see

gutting-i think while its an issue could more easily be solved by the simple introduction of relivent cpu player

Free agent market-yeah its a mess but could also be solved with the cpu player issue. typical GLB players have no backbone and are going to flock to the best teams in an open market where even the top teams have holes in their roster there needs to be a way to make roster spots on lower teams just as viable an option to the player.

The glb economy-fact most NFL team do not make most of their money from ticket sales but from the leagues TV contract.the best way i see to remedy this situation is say have 60% of the teams income come via a league revenue based off the ave level of the league.this would help enforce the higher leagues having more disposable income.make it so bbb teams have no way of paying level 40 equipment bonus to their whole team and what not thus making it harder to load up in these leagues.

now back to the cpu player issues i want them to be truly viable on the same level as their human counterpart so we would need a way for them to be less desireable to the owner to use than a human playes.so lets add a small chem hit in for them where say a owner with 1-5 chem would max out at 99 and an owner with6-8 would max out at 98 to reflect zero locker room presence.and while were at it make a small change to where they would effect fan support some as well.

the way i see things now Bort newest change ideals are going to be alot more of the rich get richer


 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
i would also suggest making the cpu player database a bunch of smaller ones so that each league or level had their own this way the best ones were only available to the pro leagues and changing it from a silent auction to a league waiver system
 
FireAce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bignasty31
Very well written Painmaker, I agree with everything you stated.


Agreed +1
 
papabear
offline
Link
 
good post Pain maker
however the economy of the game, even though it is a little off right now is set up on a viable platform. Teams that invested wisely to begin with are reaping the harvest of the labor now. It is not right to punish them for that. Just as in the NFL there are wide diferences between the cash flow of the teams, that is simply good ownership. But beyond that, I do not think owners are leaving the game because of their poor managing of t heir finances.

Other thoughts people of the reasons why owners are leaving? and what we can do to see this change? Has GLB run its course? Has the structure shown it can't continue the way it is and be a viable game?
 
RoddyAbraham
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FireAce
Originally posted by bignasty31

Very well written Painmaker, I agree with everything you stated.


Agreed +1


+2

I think, that is a great thread and it is a very important thread.

But as owner of a team, which has a losing record:
I do not think, that I am expecting a championsship. I extended my ownership despite losing....So it is not about winning.

But you should get hope for the next season. If you are watching the player market, you can get no help. High level guys or active guys are not coming to a losing team. And I am understanding that.

So you must think about a draftsystem. Yes...Or would a player come to the Atlanta Falcons, if he is not drafted? I have my doubts....( I want to mention Matt Ryans comments about Atlanta.....)

And it cannot be, that a agent gets 200 messages for his player. GLB should not be a fulltime job. players should have more training options or you should have more to do....You can only count your pancakes as guard....Very interesting. There is a huge difference between owner and agent.

dxreydx is right, that a owner has his hands full. I will thank all my GMs. But as player you only set your player. I cannot blame a center getting inactive.....

A good idea is increasing the price for buying a team and extend the ownership. At least 1000 for extend.....

I cannot blame also someone, who gets a bad team and gives up. Because you cannot expect, that you are doing this as fulltime job. It should be only a game!

Edit: And so you cannot blame somebody, if he leaves, because he is only losing.(and he has no hope, that he will be better anytime)
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 15:36:14
 
- L -
offline
Link
 
it needs to be more newbie friendly.

If owners feel the need to just build their own guys with their own FPs, then the system is failing.

This is an MMORPG, but the way it is going, people are building their own guys to fill in their own needs. Every time this happens, this is one less potential spot for a newbie to fill.

I know for a fact that if I just joined this game, I'd probably quit after a couple weeks languishing in the D-Leagues.

There's no place anymore for the level < 8 player.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ramius
Apparently the mods dont understand that you can talk you want about a 10 year plan, but no one is going to be around for the 10 year plan if things dont improve now. As it stands NOW, middle tier teams simply cannot compete with upper tier teams, and find it near impossible to become one of the upper tier teams. I'm simply not going to keep my team for another 6-7 seasons and struggle to make the playoffs so i can get my 100K while the top teams constantly rake in 15 million from a playoff game, in *hopes* that the game will all of a sudden fix itself.

Also, as noted before, customer service is a HUGE problem in this game. Most of the mods are on a power trip and instead of working to fix problems or listening to real issues and complaints, simply tell owners that they "dont know what they are doing."


1) If people aren't around for year 10, that isn't a problem. Either the game will be viable or it won't, if it is, then there will be plenty of interest. I'm here now because I feel like seeing where the game has been gives me a better feel for where it's going.

Of course, if the game isn't viable, then no amount of interest will fix it.

2)What exactly would you expect the mods to do? You realize we don't code the game? We just patrol the forums. If you don't believe Bort is working on the game, or customer service doesn't meet your needs, then vote with your dollars and leave. If you think, like I do, that Bort is working, then stick around and enjoy the ride.
 
- L -
offline
Link
 
Also, i think an owner could be able to pay GLB money to hire a CPU DC/OC to take care of all that stuff at the beginning. It could be a basic script that scouts out an opponents past gameplans and makes a gameplan based on that.

Once the "teams needing players" search computer comes, then I think that will make things infinitely easier for new owners
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.