User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Jed had suggested making a new thread just for ideas, but if we're back on track, there's no need. I'll edit post one and tell people to head on up to page 20 if they want to skip the BS.

One thing missing from the rollup post is that there should be a "lower position penalty" perk for every position.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
My ideas, just because they ended up on Page 19 and people may not see them:

Acceleration: Enhances acceleration (duh). Bort's admitted he should have made it its own attribute, so it could at least be a prestige attribute.

Crease Closer: Improves a DB's performance in zone defenses (effectively a Vision booster, not speed as with Closing Speed, that helps him find receivers in creases before the throw).

Quick Feet: Improves a player's Head Fake and Juke moves at all times, as well as Quick Cuts when running with the ball.

Reliability: Decreases the chance of the player fumbling, dropping a pass, blowing coverage on defense, drawing penalties, and the like.

First Down Marker: Knows where the first down marker is, and if he needs an extra half a yard to get the first down, has a better chance of getting it.

Scat Back: Increases a HB or FB's abilities as a receiver on pass plays (maybe even making him almost...useful). When used as such, he gains a bonus to speed, agility, vision, and catching.

Comeback Kid: Provides a bonus to offensive players' making big plays when behind. This isn't Clutch, as it's when behind by 1 or by 40, and it only applies to big play potential.

So a QB or WR or TE would get bonuses from this, when behind, on long passes (but only long passes), or a HB when in the clear or trying a move or broken tackle that will put him in the clear for a big play.

Special Teamer: Bonuses across the board when playing on special teams as something other than a returner.

Energy Bounceback: When a player isn't in the game, he recovers energy faster (both "breath" and "freshness"). Not the same as Stamina as it doesn't affect how fast it's lost when in the game.

Thick Skin: The player is affected less by intimidation abilities (not the same as Confidence, because it doesn't help a player who, say, just fumbled maintain morale).


Last edited Aug 27, 2008 20:08:31
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
I guess no one thinks having a "threat" attribute would be interesting?
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
I guess no one thinks having a "threat" attribute would be interesting?


What's that?
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
I only posted it twice in here. Grrr.

"Ok, well I was trying to think of other perks to add to this idea, and I came up with one. After thinking about it for a while though, I'm not sure if it would be better off as its own separate idea.

Anyway, I was thinking of something along the lines of a "threat level". It would increase your performance very slightly (maybe a boost to vision and confidence?) just for having points in the skill , but it would also increase the amount of attention you receive on the field.

For example, a WR with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to force double coverage on the WR (if they have an extra player to cover), if it doesn't trigger double coverage, the WR gets a slight increase to his attributes for the play.

For QBs, a high "treat level" will trigger the other team to play the pass (unless in an obvious run situation), if it doesn't trigger the pass play, the QB gets an increase in attributes for the play.

For RBs, a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to play the run (unless it is an obvious pass situation), if it doesn't trigger the run play, the RB gets an increase in attributes for the play. Also, the "threat level" could trigger the other team to force a LB to cover the RB on passing plays (a lot of teams don't cover the backs), and if they don't, the RB gets the increase in attributes for the play.

I'm not sure how it could apply to FBs and TEs though since they are often two way players.

On defense, a DE (or DT/NT) with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to force two blockers on the DE (if they have an available lineman/TE/FB/HB to block), if it doesn't trigger the double team, the DE gets a slight increase to his attributes for the play.

A LB with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to pass or run plays away from him, if it doesn't, the LB gets the increase for the play.

A CB/Safety with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to avoid passing in his direction, if it doesn't trigger, the defensive back gets the increase in attributes for the play.

When I say trigger, I mean that it would work like a SA, more points means it has a higher likelihood to trigger.

These "threat levels" make it so the player has a higher likelihood of getting more attention (or less in the LB/CB/S cases) and thus less stats. It also makes it more likely that if the other team doesn't account for you, you'll perform better on that play. Finally, while the "threat level" puts the attention on you, it also opens up opportunities for other players.

If the WR forces double coverage, it'll help another player get open.

If the DE/DT forces a double team, it'll help another lineman or blitzer get a better shot at the QB or the runner.

Etc., etc.

"Threat level" could also be something that is implemented in a scouting report. That way teams have a way of knowing what they should be doing to account for the player when coming up with AI and gameplans.

Thinking about it though, the "threat level" could just be something entirely separate (maybe even performance based). It's just something off the top of my head.

Either way, great original idea though Drifter."
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
So basically, "Threat Level" could be an advanced skill called "Threatening Stance" or some crap.. and it would affect the opposing Players to perceive you as a bigger threat than you really are.... right?

The lack of any real clue as to how effective such an ability would be sounds right up Bort's alley. I suppose that if there are sufficient checks for decisions to be made based upon the "level" of an opposing player - then this could give a boost to the perceived level of a player for the duration of the game.. Linemen and LBs with a Threatening Stance might convince ball runners to try a different route.. CBs and Safeties with Threatening stance might discourage the QB from throwing their direction.

 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
So basically, "Threat Level" could be an advanced skill called "Threatening Stance" or some crap.. and it would affect the opposing Players to perceive you as a bigger threat than you really are.... right?

The lack of any real clue as to how effective such an ability would be sounds right up Bort's alley. I suppose that if there are sufficient checks for decisions to be made based upon the "level" of an opposing player - then this could give a boost to the perceived level of a player for the duration of the game.. Linemen and LBs with a Threatening Stance might convince ball runners to try a different route.. CBs and Safeties with Threatening stance might discourage the QB from throwing their direction.



Well essentially. I wasn't really going the whole "bigger threat than you really are" route though.

Just an advanced skill that would force other teams to account for you. If this sort of thing is going to be implemented with the idea that it will create something to do for high level players, then the assumption is by that level they should be pretty good already. If they are good players, why should the opposing team treat them the same as if they are playing a lvl 1?

Better player should get more attention, and since this would only be available for presumably the better (higher leveled) players, then it works to achieve that goal.

The basic premise is that the player gains a very small boost to confidence and vision just for having points in the skill. Then during the game, the skill has a chance to trigger (bigger chance for more points in the skill) for each play. If during that play the team accounts for the player (in the ways I mentioned above), then the player plays as normal (which will allow other players to get stats as I mentioned above). If during the play that the skill is triggered the other team does not account for the player, then the player receives a percentage (what would be fair 5%, maybe up to 10%?) increase in all of their attributes for that single play.

It adds strategy for both sides. A player with a high threat level increases his chances of making a big play but also decreases his chance to put up consistent stats (WR getting double teamed for example). While it helps the player on plays he isn't accounted for, it is as much of a team beneficial skill due to the fact that the other team will specifically focus in on the player (leaving someone else less attended to). On the other hand a team can game plan against someone with a high threat level (like I said, it could be another bar added to the scouting report) but will have to decide if it is worth taking a single player out of the game but freeing up someone else, or if it's better to take the risk of giving up the big play but having everyone equally accounted for.

This skill will become even more strategically significant once tactics allow teams to specifically double team players, create playbooks, etc.

Last edited Aug 27, 2008 23:05:06
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
wow they sticky this suggestion, I can see why. Great suggestion. This is exactly what the doctor should be ordering
 
Buck Nutty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Originally posted by drifter


The backup issue is no different than XP gain now so unless regular XP gain is going to be looked at, I don't think this systems should differ.


-1 in that case


hmmm so if you where a starter you would like this idea ....
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Threat level is interesting but it seems it would be better built into the "fame" effect that Bort is planning on implementing. As a performance booster it would be a two edged sword and it seems you are thinking of it more as something that could be turned on and off.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Example:

Terrell Owens is "famous" for his off-the field hijinks.
Terrell Owens gets double/triple-teamed on every play because he's a "threat."

I'm not 100% sure I like the threat idea yet, but it's definitely something different than Fame.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Example:

Terrell Owens is "famous" for his off-the field hijinks.
Terrell Owens gets double/triple-teamed on every play because he's a "threat."

I'm not 100% sure I like the threat idea yet, but it's definitely something different than Fame.


Well what about it are you unsure of? The idea itself or the details?
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Example:

Terrell Owens is "famous" for his off-the field hijinks.
Terrell Owens gets double/triple-teamed on every play because he's a "threat."

I'm not 100% sure I like the threat idea yet, but it's definitely something different than Fame.


A good example as a fellow Eagles fan might be Brian Westbrook. For years he was a "threat" and people game planned for him, but he was not famous until recently where people just couldn't ignore how good he really was anymore. So you could be a "threat" and not famous. Or as I bet we'll see when guys get near retirement in this game... we'll have guys with tons of fame build-up but with reducing stats might not be a threat anymore.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Sincerely that's completely crazy to see that. To create a new system of XP just because Bort don't want to modify his first try...

Sincerely i'm quite disapointed.

Yes the idea is good but that will be easier to just rethink the XP curve. Yes actually the system is good if we compare this to reality. IRL players increase their attributes until maturity. Then they play at their max potential for some years (with some fluctuations) then they retire. If GLB wanted to simulate reality, that's near perfection.


BUT that's a game and players are bored with this system and i understand them. What need to be a season 10 retirement if users have the impression their players are at max of normal progression (opposed to artificial=boost) within 3-4 seasons?

Of course there's people who have said, agent of player only have to wait for fame and "bling bling" options. But sincerely that's optional add-on. GLB is about building players and we stop doing so with lvl 25-30.

There's something to be done QUICK!
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Sincerely that's completely crazy to see that. To create a new system of XP just because Bort don't want to modify his first try...

Sincerely i'm quite disapointed.

Yes the idea is good but that will be easier to just rethink the XP curve. Yes actually the system is good if we compare this to reality. IRL players increase their attributes until maturity. Then they play at their max potential for some years (with some fluctuations) then they retire. If GLB wanted to simulate reality, that's near perfection.


BUT that's a game and players are bored with this system and i understand them. What need to be a season 10 retirement if users have the impression their players are at max of normal progression (opposed to artificial=boost) within 3-4 seasons?

Of course there's people who have said, agent of player only have to wait for fame and "bling bling" options. But sincerely that's optional add-on. GLB is about building players and we stop doing so with lvl 25-30.

There's something to be done QUICK!



If I'm interpreting you correctly ( I know you're not a native English speaker), you are saying that you'd rather there was some other fix for the stagnation plateau, but if there is not, this is as good an idea as any for something that can be done quickly?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.