User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Thanks Bort, but revenge on customers isn't exactly good business. If someone were smart it wouldn't be too hard to run this game out of business with a better product for far less money.

Think about it. Bort is changing this game and not letting his beta testers change along with it without spending even more money.


If you built right you don't have to change.

We balanced-builders put up with three seasons of "speed kills", "tackling's worthless, just use wrap-up", "90 strength is enough, don't bother with blocking", and we never got respecs. Suddenly 12 days into the regime change that makes the game play more realistically than ever, we're supposed to be OK with all the exploiters getting a free pass? We built the right way, got screwed for 3 seasons and we got nothing, why should we turn around and help the people that screwed us?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Its a BETA Game Oldskool. There is no such thing as 'exploiters' but people who are demonstrating the validity or invalidity of various builds. All some people believe is that if it is a BETA game, and they are going to be treated like game testers...

ASIDE: you can not argue the fact that people creating imbalanced builds (I'm not one of them btw) helped Bort tune the SIM to being more accurate in many ways

... by having the systems changed significantly in progress that either A) they shouldn;t be being charged money to help provide a testing environment or B) if they are going to be paying money to help provide the testing environment.. the least that can be offered is respecs etc, so that they can test the game under the present rules set.

You've been a steadfast contrarian though, all along.. so you are at least consistent.

But, what is occurring is bad business and will damage the games viability.

Also, the Business model is completely fubar, and as more people realise the value for their dollar, and the way they will be treated as long as the game is labeled 'BETA'... significant long term viability concerns exist.

I've continued buying flexpoints though I recognised these flaws early on, because I felt I was helping to invest in a product and the dividend was the amusement I derived from testing.

I don't need respecs for my players. I did not follow the one attribute build guides. I did focus on just a few attributes n some players, but kept them balanced and so I am not suffering as much as some. That does not mean though I will blind myself to their concerns out of some demented schadenfreude now that my player build philosophy has been justified/vindicated.

Bort needs to understand and acknowledge that the mechanics for granting Respecs should be in place in any game of this nature, as if it does grow beyond its present size, and changes are made/foreseen he's going to face a customer base with a louder voice and a bigger impact on his bottom line. If the SIM is going to change, and builds invalidated completely, a method to recover needs to be available. It is good business sense.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Revelation

Thanks Bort, but revenge on customers isn't exactly good business. If someone were smart it wouldn't be too hard to run this game out of business with a better product for far less money.

Think about it. Bort is changing this game and not letting his beta testers change along with it without spending even more money.


If you built right you don't have to change.

We balanced-builders put up with three seasons of "speed kills", "tackling's worthless, just use wrap-up", "90 strength is enough, don't bother with blocking", and we never got respecs. Suddenly 12 days into the regime change that makes the game play more realistically than ever, we're supposed to be OK with all the exploiters getting a free pass? We built the right way, got screwed for 3 seasons and we got nothing, why should we turn around and help the people that screwed us?


To some the "right way" was the way that was working the best. Now with changes to what is the best, those who knew the guides were faulty and built to win are being forced to pay even more money because what's best is no longer best.

Now winners lose and have to pay even more money to win again. To contiue to change a game is a great way to keep the money rolling in...that is temporarily. As the title of this thread indicates, many people will be leaving because of what has transpired here.

You can't change a game without allowing your customer to change along with it and expect your business to last. It's like buying a car, then finding out a month later a few parts in that car are now defective. Then when you go to get the parts replaced, the dealer tells you "I'm sorry, but if you want this fixed then you're just going to have to pay us more money". It's not good business. Auto companies offer respecs (aka recalls) and replace the defective parts for free for those who bought a defective product. Those who did not do this are probably not car companies anymore and I expect nothing less from this game if it keeps up.

Last edited Aug 14, 2008 14:27:22
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TOS
You acknowledge and agree that your use of the GoalLineBlitz.com Web site and the services offered therin is at your own risk. Without limiting any other provision contained in these Terms of Use, everything on the Web site is provided to you "AS IS" AND "AS AVAILABLE," WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, WHETHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED.

If you have no warranty, you pay for your repairs.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Of course there's no warranty, but that takes nothing away from what has been previously said.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
If you offer no warranty and repairs cost a lot.. you have no customers.

As long as they are labeling the game BETA, and making large changes to the way the game plays, they need to be aware of how changes affect their paying customers/testers and be willing to offer recourse.

Recourse is NOT offering refunds.

Instead, its saying you already bought the points, he're let us help you re-arrange them to better fit the game as it is now, as opposed to when you purchased your points.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
If you offer no warranty and repairs cost a lot.. you have no customers.

As long as they are labeling the game BETA, and making large changes to the way the game plays, they need to be aware of how changes affect their paying customers/testers and be willing to offer recourse.

Recourse is NOT offering refunds.

Instead, its saying you already bought the points, he're let us help you re-arrange them to better fit the game as it is now, as opposed to when you purchased your points.


Are you kidding me?

Tell me where someone from the game, ie, Admin, said, told, forced players to put put ALL their points in ONE attribute of the game? Show me that and I will agree to a respec.

I know, you are gonna say, but they built it that way because it worked, and they won, you're right, they did win, they didn't build it that way because that is how FOOTBALL WORKS, they built it, so they can WIN NOW, and now, they have to pay for it because the game is being played HOW FOOTBALL WORKS,

How is this anyone's fault but their own??

How do you come to a FOOTBALL GAME, and say to yourself, all I need is speed, because I can win this way, all I need is strength, I have a Linebacker, I dont need tackling, I have a WR, I don't need catching,

How does this even compute in people's minds? Did someone seriously think football players could play with only speed? Or only strength???
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
My team went from absolutely sucking, to being a playoff team, straight back to sucking again.

What's great is there's almost no way to know why. We are the same team we were last season, just added a few good players who are playing well.

It's all a big mystery - like the female orgasm. I thought we were in like flint with the importance of balanced builds, we stomped our competition in the preseason, regular season hits - we suck ass.

Bummer.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
My team went from absolutely sucking, to being a playoff team, straight back to sucking again.

What's great is there's almost no way to know why. We are the same team we were last season, just added a few good players who are playing well.

It's all a big mystery - like the female orgasm. I thought we were in like flint with the importance of balanced builds, we stomped our competition in the preseason, regular season hits - we suck ass.

Bummer.


We are in the same boat, expansion team 5-11, playoff team 12-4, we are now 3-3-1, it sucks lol, but that has more to do with the AI and certain builds than the game just randomly being changed.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
People did come to play a football game. They made balanced players and they 'sucked'. They learned the secret to success was to focus on one/two attributes.. then they did really well. that happened for two seasons. Then the game was changed (because its beta and being tested/refined) and now players find that what was done eliminated their build that the game/competitive spirit encouraged with previous game system.

If you do not understand this, you likely have little experience with MMO's and the audience they attract.

Ny point would simply be, because the game is marked 'BETA' but still requires cash to play competitively, then allowances being maed are only good business on Bort & Crew's part.

Once a game goes to release, then I would say.. make your bed, lay in it. Unless of course the game goes live, is being played and after a few seasons Bort decides to overhaul the entire sim engine, destroying the builds from a good portion of his community and doesn't want to lose paying customers. At which pint, he will be glad he's already put in place a 'respec' system he created during game testing stages.

It's just good business sense that while you are pulling down likely 150,000$ a month, gross, from your FP sales for your BETA game, that any major changes you make in the engine go hand in hand with the ability for players to adapt to the changes in a timely manner while remaining competitive. If this was free.. no one would care. They'd scrap a character and start again.. that's what you do in _testing_ phases of a game. But since they are paying for the privilege of testing they expect higher standards of MOD/Developer conduct and methods by which they are allowed to remain competitive without additional costs.

And again, my players are all fairly balanced, so a respec wouldnt affect me and is not personally deisred. This does not preclude me from unerstanding the wisdom of having the system in place.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
http://tinyurl.com/notthisagain

Please show me where you HAD to "pay for the 'privilege' of testing". If you CHOSE to pay then it's your own fault that you "paid for the privilege".

You keep bouncing back and forth between "beta game" and "pay to be competitive". It's beta, why the hell are you trying to compete, and why the hell would you PAY to do so? Dumb, IMO.

And there's no way Bort et al. are pulling in $150k/month. Bort still has a day job, as does DD as I recall; something tells me they wouldn't keep their day jobs with those "hobby" salaries.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 15:48:15
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
My question is when are we going to start seeing some of the powers that be within Bort and his crew start to respond to some of these posts?
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
It's not screwing, it's revenge for game exploitation.


WE'RE BETA TESTING - WE ARE *SUPPOSED* TO FIND EXPLOITS SO THAT BORT CAN CLOSE THEM.

When he does, he should be rewarding us for finding them, and giving us full respecs so that we can move along to finding the next exploit(s) for him. That's the service we are SUPPOSED to be providing him. We're BETA TESTERS, remember?


Originally posted by oldskool
We built the right way, got screwed for 3 seasons and we got nothing, why should we turn around and help the people that screwed us?


If anyone should be punished, it's you - for not actually BETA TESTING the game, which is our job (that we are paying to have). Don't crab about the testers out here fighting the good fight and finding exploits for Bort to close so he can release his game for people to actually play.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 16:04:08
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by oldskool

It's not screwing, it's revenge for game exploitation.


WE'RE BETA TESTING - WE ARE *SUPPOSED* TO FIND EXPLOITS SO THAT BORT CAN CLOSE THEM.

When he does, he should be rewarding us for finding them, and giving us full respecs so that we can move along to finding the next exploit(s) for him. That's the service we are SUPPOSED to be providing him. We're BETA TESTERS, remember?


So then why are you CHOOSING to pay $200 every 45 dollars to COMPETE?
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
The Beta excuse has gotten a little old.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.