Do we have to sling around the foul language in a forum called Christianity Club! I mean the come on, how about a little more respect for those of us that don't use the "F" word every other time we say something! Not telling anyone how to talk, just asking for a little more respect for those of us that don't use the word. Besides everyone should keep in mind that there are kids on this game.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.
I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:
1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.
And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".
In summary, you're disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.
Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.
i think you might be surprised to find that many of the people disagreeing with you here are not atheists. me, for example.
there is no such thing as a "christian race".
i'm not defending islam... i'm defending facts. islam has had its troubled/dark past, too. but let's call a spade a spade and cut each side equal slack.
most of your facts are way off.
also: ever been to turkey? you're confusing theocracy with religion. keep in mind that many of those "facts" were also true of the united states even into the 20th century (and in some states, even today). is that somehow not a reflection on american democracy?
you're also conflating the classical liberalism of modernity with the religion that just happened to be there at the time. and sure, you could make a weberian argument about the protestant ethic, but there are many, many counterarguments against that.
you're also not taking note of the fact that most of the currently islamic nations were little more than colonies a while back... take a look at the track record of the decolonizing world, and you'll see the struggle of people against modernity. how is this any different? the colonizers (england/france/america) deserve most of the blame for the current status of the middle east. don't conflate the decolonization process with the religion that also just happens to be there.
as far as perspective goes, i think you should heed your own advice. you cut christianity all sorts of slack because you understand it with nuance... perhaps you should learn more about islam so that you too could gain a proper/factual "perspective".
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.
I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:
1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.
And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".
In summary, you're disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.
Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.
i think you might be surprised to find that many of the people disagreeing with you here are not atheists. me, for example.
there is no such thing as a "christian race".
i'm not defending islam... i'm defending facts. islam has had its troubled/dark past, too. but let's call a spade a spade and cut each side equal slack.
most of your facts are way off.
also: ever been to turkey? you're confusing theocracy with religion. keep in mind that many of those "facts" were also true of the united states even into the 20th century (and in some states, even today). is that somehow not a reflection on american democracy?
you're also conflating the classical liberalism of modernity with the religion that just happened to be there at the time. and sure, you could make a weberian argument about the protestant ethic, but there are many, many counterarguments against that.
you're also not taking note of the fact that most of the currently islamic nations were little more than colonies a while back... take a look at the track record of the decolonizing world, and you'll see the struggle of people against modernity. how is this any different? the colonizers (england/france/america) deserve most of the blame for the current status of the middle east. don't conflate the decolonization process with the religion that also just happens to be there.
as far as perspective goes, i think you should heed your own advice. you cut christianity all sorts of slack because you understand it with nuance... perhaps you should learn more about islam so that you too could gain a proper/factual "perspective".
True atheists never argue about which god or religious cult we believe in the least. They are all daft.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by burn_209
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.
a large portion of al'queda is illiterate... their only direct exposure to the words of the Qur'an is through clerics.
much like most of western europe until the 1600s...
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.
a large portion of al'queda is illiterate... their only direct exposure to the words of the Qur'an is through clerics.
much like most of western europe until the 1600s...
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by burn_209
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.
I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:
1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.
And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".
In summary, you're disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.
Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.
WOW thats a hell of a point.
too bad it's 80% wrong and 20% distorted.
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.
I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:
1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.
And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".
In summary, you're disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.
Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.
WOW thats a hell of a point.
too bad it's 80% wrong and 20% distorted.
EmpYllek
offline
offline
I wonder how many Muslim people this guy knows? I have a lot of Muslim friends that might disagree with my heavy drinking and not really keeping to the "no pre-marital sex" nonsense rule but thats the same with a lot of Christians.
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by burn_209
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.
Go read my list again (10 issues found in any Islamic-governed country) and give me the exception to that list. When you give up and can't find one (others have tried), ask yourself "Why would such a allegedly peaceful religion have not a single place on the globe where women are treated as equals, where the right to assembly, speech and press is absolute, where the right to question Mohammed and Islam exists, and where folks can decide for themselves whom they may have sex with?"
once again, turkey. they gave women the right to vote in 1926 (effectual around 1930). note that france didn't extend women suffrage until 1945.
Originally posted by burn_209
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.
Go read my list again (10 issues found in any Islamic-governed country) and give me the exception to that list. When you give up and can't find one (others have tried), ask yourself "Why would such a allegedly peaceful religion have not a single place on the globe where women are treated as equals, where the right to assembly, speech and press is absolute, where the right to question Mohammed and Islam exists, and where folks can decide for themselves whom they may have sex with?"
once again, turkey. they gave women the right to vote in 1926 (effectual around 1930). note that france didn't extend women suffrage until 1945.
Larry Roadgrader
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by burn_209
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.
I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:
1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.
And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".
In summary, you're disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.
Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.
WOW thats a hell of a point.
too bad it's 80% wrong and 20% distorted.
Name the country then. You can come up with lots of sentences explaining WHY the country doesn't exist that grants those 10 things that most "Christian" countries offer (like you did above with the "they used to be colonies" stuff in the post above), but those pretty sentences don't make life for the victims, er, citizens of those countries any easier.
Originally posted by burn_209
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.
I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:
1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.
And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".
In summary, you're disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.
Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.
WOW thats a hell of a point.
too bad it's 80% wrong and 20% distorted.
Name the country then. You can come up with lots of sentences explaining WHY the country doesn't exist that grants those 10 things that most "Christian" countries offer (like you did above with the "they used to be colonies" stuff in the post above), but those pretty sentences don't make life for the victims, er, citizens of those countries any easier.
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 16:53:38
Blitz81
offline
offline
Originally posted by EmpYllek
I wonder how many Muslim people this guy knows? I have a lot of Muslim friends that might disagree with my heavy drinking and not really keeping to the "no pre-marital sex" nonsense rule but thats the same with a lot of Christians.
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
LOL, that's alright friend. Just a friendly reminder. Thank you for your consideration though!!!
I wonder how many Muslim people this guy knows? I have a lot of Muslim friends that might disagree with my heavy drinking and not really keeping to the "no pre-marital sex" nonsense rule but thats the same with a lot of Christians.
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
LOL, that's alright friend. Just a friendly reminder. Thank you for your consideration though!!!
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
No, you've helped me establish that nothing about "The Crusades" was as shocking as folks wish to pretend that it was. Thanks.
doesn't make it right. like hume said, you can't derive an "ought" from an "is". and if we're making sweeping moral statements here, it's all within our purview.
further, how can you possibly excuse christian atrocities as not shocking while at the same time condemning muslims for the past actions of some islamic arabs?
I would never attempt to "justify" them--I was speaking merely of historical perspective.
Further, the state of life in the year 2008 for folks living in Islamic-governed countries contrasts sharply with those of secular and/or "Christian" countries in the year 2008. I think that's telling in many ways--much more so than what did or didn't take place 800 years ago.
sure, but if you think that's primarily due to religion, you're delusional.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
No, you've helped me establish that nothing about "The Crusades" was as shocking as folks wish to pretend that it was. Thanks.
doesn't make it right. like hume said, you can't derive an "ought" from an "is". and if we're making sweeping moral statements here, it's all within our purview.
further, how can you possibly excuse christian atrocities as not shocking while at the same time condemning muslims for the past actions of some islamic arabs?
I would never attempt to "justify" them--I was speaking merely of historical perspective.
Further, the state of life in the year 2008 for folks living in Islamic-governed countries contrasts sharply with those of secular and/or "Christian" countries in the year 2008. I think that's telling in many ways--much more so than what did or didn't take place 800 years ago.
sure, but if you think that's primarily due to religion, you're delusional.
Larry Roadgrader
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by burn_209
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.
Go read my list again (10 issues found in any Islamic-governed country) and give me the exception to that list. When you give up and can't find one (others have tried), ask yourself "Why would such a allegedly peaceful religion have not a single place on the globe where women are treated as equals, where the right to assembly, speech and press is absolute, where the right to question Mohammed and Islam exists, and where folks can decide for themselves whom they may have sex with?"
once again, turkey. they gave women the right to vote in 1926 (effectual around 1930). note that france didn't extend women suffrage until 1945.
So homosexuality is openly tolerated in Turkey? No.
So one can say or print "Mohammed wasn't a prophet and there is no God or Allah" in Turkey? No.
You're wasting time folks--I've played this particular exercise before. I know how it ends.
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by burn_209
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.
Go read my list again (10 issues found in any Islamic-governed country) and give me the exception to that list. When you give up and can't find one (others have tried), ask yourself "Why would such a allegedly peaceful religion have not a single place on the globe where women are treated as equals, where the right to assembly, speech and press is absolute, where the right to question Mohammed and Islam exists, and where folks can decide for themselves whom they may have sex with?"
once again, turkey. they gave women the right to vote in 1926 (effectual around 1930). note that france didn't extend women suffrage until 1945.
So homosexuality is openly tolerated in Turkey? No.
So one can say or print "Mohammed wasn't a prophet and there is no God or Allah" in Turkey? No.
You're wasting time folks--I've played this particular exercise before. I know how it ends.

burn_209
offline
offline
Originally posted by EmpYllek
I wonder how many Muslim people this guy knows? I have a lot of Muslim friends that might disagree with my heavy drinking and not really keeping to the "no pre-marital sex" nonsense rule but thats the same with a lot of Christians.
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
I know some Indian Muslims that drink. She's a woman as well
I wonder how many Muslim people this guy knows? I have a lot of Muslim friends that might disagree with my heavy drinking and not really keeping to the "no pre-marital sex" nonsense rule but thats the same with a lot of Christians.
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
I know some Indian Muslims that drink. She's a woman as well
SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Originally posted by EmpYllek
I think youll find that the nation of Kosovo in eastern europe is a predominantly Islamic state where all of those things either exist already or will exist when they elect their first proper parliament. Albania should be there soon as well actually.
Surely you aren't using Kosovo as a good example given the history of that region.
lol.
I think youll find that the nation of Kosovo in eastern europe is a predominantly Islamic state where all of those things either exist already or will exist when they elect their first proper parliament. Albania should be there soon as well actually.
Surely you aren't using Kosovo as a good example given the history of that region.
lol.
Larry Roadgrader
offline
offline
Originally posted by EmpYllek
I wonder how many Muslim people this guy knows? I have a lot of Muslim friends that might disagree with my heavy drinking and not really keeping to the "no pre-marital sex" nonsense rule but thats the same with a lot of Christians.
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
I'm not speaking of Muslims within non-Muslim countries--their track record is well known.
I'm speaking of Islamic-governed countries. Try the list and get back to me when you find the exception to the rule.
I wonder how many Muslim people this guy knows? I have a lot of Muslim friends that might disagree with my heavy drinking and not really keeping to the "no pre-marital sex" nonsense rule but thats the same with a lot of Christians.
Yes youll meet some Muslims who fit into the fundamentalist mould. Most dont though. Catallus has it right - a lot depends on where theyre from. Most Muslim guys I know from India do everything I do other than drink. Get out there and visit the world and youll be amazed at what you see.
As for my language - I apologise. Im Scottish so a sentence sort of feels naked without at the very least some sort of "bad language".
I'm not speaking of Muslims within non-Muslim countries--their track record is well known.
I'm speaking of Islamic-governed countries. Try the list and get back to me when you find the exception to the rule.EmpYllek
offline
offline
If you read back a few posts I name two countries! But hey not like you to do a little selective reading!
Ohh yeah to those who dont consider Kosovo a country. Its a country. Just because the Russians refuse to acknowledge it just to stop a bunch of the people they oppress doing the same thing doesnt mean its not a country. Yes Im using Kosovo. It was the Christian Serbs who were the evil ones there.
Ohh yeah to those who dont consider Kosovo a country. Its a country. Just because the Russians refuse to acknowledge it just to stop a bunch of the people they oppress doing the same thing doesnt mean its not a country. Yes Im using Kosovo. It was the Christian Serbs who were the evil ones there.
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 16:55:31
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























