User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Team Loans, Chemistry
Page:
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shortstack
Originally posted by Tank Basterson

I think people are overreacting to the Team Chemistry penalties for moving players. There's a text sim called Front Office Football that has something similar called Cohesion. As a manager, you know your cohesion is going to go down when you make roster moves, but you also know your roster moves are going to benefit your team, so you take the temporary hit and roll with it.

It's a bit different when you are talking about players who want to go somewhere else, like to their own or a buddy's team, but to me that's a part of what adds a level of human interest to this game that is entirely absent from a text sim.


Bingo, you hit the nail on the head. Part of owning a team is dealing with the human factor. Now people get a real simulation where they are managing people instead of CPU players and they are complaining about it. Learn how to deal with and manage real people my friends!!!


But managing real people includes not being a dick and holding guys ransom who would enjoy the game more if they were playing on their friends team.

I'm assuming it doesn't, Does the 3 day grace period for new teams apply for the team trading with them as well as the new team?
 
Korak
offline
Link
 
The chemistry hits could be executed on a per day hit. If you make a move either trade or signings you take a hit of -3 for that day and if you want a -1 per player involved. This would mean if you made all moves during one day involving 6 players it would cost -9 versus -18 as proposed. ( Bad PR and then finished ). Allows for more movement without large penalties
 
DR_EVL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
How about you penalize negative posters -1 chemistry. I know, brilliant idea. This post is growing faster than the rash DD gave me after that vigorous HJ.


-2 for grumpy posters...
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
People can help fund the game by making players that play on other teams. You don't need to fill half of your team with your own players to do this.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
Since there are already penalties for adding and dropping individual players, shouldn't you get a chemistry point every day regardless of whether you make any moves.


Yea, that makes sense because with the current system, the penalty for trading/releasing a player is actually 4 points, not the 3 advertised.

So this helps the farm teams because they lose less chemistry for trading all their players on the same day which they are likely to do as opposed to a normal team which might make just one trade a day on a few different days.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 21:12:32
 
shortstack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
Since there are already penalties for adding and dropping individual players, shouldn't you get a chemistry point every day regardless of whether you make any moves.

Say Team A and Team B start out at 70 chem points.

Day 1: Team A adds a player
Day 2: Team A adds a player
Day 3: Team A adds a player
Day 4: Team A adds a player
Day 5: Team A adds a player; Team B adds 5 players

The result under the current system:

Team A: 60 chemistry points
Team B: 64 chemistry points

Both had the same amount of roster turnover. The current system says that it is better to make one wholesale change than multiple minor changes. I don't necessarily agree that this is true (or that it has the intended effect of deterring stacking).

If you just give each team 1 chemistry point every day regardless of moves, both teams end up with 65 chemistry points.

Originally posted by shortstack

Again the guys who own all the players on their team are investing enough money in this game to deserve a slight edge in a game.


The clone armies already have more than a slight edge. They can pay their players whatever they want with no problems (thus upgrade faster). They never have to worry about keeping players happy. They never have to worry about losing players. They never have to worry about inactives. They have full control over all team and player tactics. They have full control over player builds.

This would be just another advantage. It starts to get to be too much.

Originally posted by shortstack


It's because of those team owners that dump all that money into the game that so many can play the game for free. Get over it.


Players with farm teams help fund the game, too, but that doesn't stop considerations of game integrity from coming in.


Well if those guys want to spend $1,000 a month to win the championship so be it.
 
DR_EVL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shortstack
Originally posted by CRich

Here is what everyone is thinking. Why dont we start the whole chemistry thing at the end of the preseason so that all of the people who are about to get their teams can have their players on their own team. The only problem is, there will probably be another 750 teams coming next offseason, what then. It sucks, because I am one of the guys who wants off my team after the playoffs so I can move to my hopefully soon to be team.


New teams get a 3-day grace period. So you will have time to get your players on your new team without penalty to team chemistry.



and to those who aren't new teams?
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
Since there are already penalties for adding and dropping individual players, shouldn't you get a chemistry point every day regardless of whether you make any moves.

Say Team A and Team B start out at 70 chem points.

Day 1: Team A adds a player
Day 2: Team A adds a player
Day 3: Team A adds a player
Day 4: Team A adds a player
Day 5: Team A adds a player; Team B adds 5 players

The result under the current system:

Team A: 60 chemistry points
Team B: 64 chemistry points

Both had the same amount of roster turnover. The current system says that it is better to make one wholesale change than multiple minor changes. I don't necessarily agree that this is true (or that it has the intended effect of deterring stacking).

If you just give each team 1 chemistry point every day regardless of moves, both teams end up with 65 chemistry points.

Originally posted by shortstack

Again the guys who own all the players on their team are investing enough money in this game to deserve a slight edge in a game.


The clone armies already have more than a slight edge. They can pay their players whatever they want with no problems (thus upgrade faster). They never have to worry about keeping players happy. They never have to worry about losing players. They never have to worry about inactives. They have full control over all team and player tactics. They have full control over player builds.

This would be just another advantage. It starts to get to be too much.

Originally posted by shortstack


It's because of those team owners that dump all that money into the game that so many can play the game for free. Get over it.


Players with farm teams help fund the game, too, but that doesn't stop considerations of game integrity from coming in.



Thats not right. Team B 5x3 is 15, 65-15 is 50 not 64.


 
Hagetaka
offline
Link
 
Since most of the feedback on team chemistry is negative so far, let me say to Bort and DD;

with the 3 day grace period after buying a CPU team, and the lack of a hit for level 5 and below players, and the grace period to set a team up this offseason- I think it's a great idea, you eliminate all the problems that needed to be, it's a good addition to the game, and as long as it doesn't get overpowered and throw the game engine out of whack, I think it's a nifty variable. Good show.
 
DR_EVL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gott
Originally posted by Serrao


why not make the off season not effect chemistry. You should be able to tinker with your team in the off season.


You can tinker, but it will affect your chemistry. I wouldn't want them giving these shady owners one last chance to move their players back.


bitterness my friend... would you rather have them get on track, or would you rather just be spiteful?
 
shortstack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DR_EVL
Originally posted by shortstack

Originally posted by CRich


Here is what everyone is thinking. Why dont we start the whole chemistry thing at the end of the preseason so that all of the people who are about to get their teams can have their players on their own team. The only problem is, there will probably be another 750 teams coming next offseason, what then. It sucks, because I am one of the guys who wants off my team after the playoffs so I can move to my hopefully soon to be team.


New teams get a 3-day grace period. So you will have time to get your players on your new team without penalty to team chemistry.



and to those who aren't new teams?


For the teams that aren't new, you get the 3 days in between seasons to make moves without penalty. We've been over this already.
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
Originally posted by krwynn

Can someone make cyberjelly change that pic. It freaks me the f**k out. Its affecting my chemistry.


Cablejelly?




 
methomps
offline
Link
 
To prevent the unintended side effect of owners holding players hostage and buried on the depth chart instead of just dropping them, shouldn't the team chemistry hit be the same (or at least something) for contracts that expire? Especially if the player has a very cheap salary, the owner who previously would've just dropped the player (or traded him away) may just hold on for chemistry purposes.

Besides, its not like a team's chemistry isn't affected IRL by players who leave in free agency.

Originally posted by shortstack


Well if those guys want to spend $1,000 a month to win the championship so be it.


The same argument applies to stackers and to players who gut teams.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by methomps

Since there are already penalties for adding and dropping individual players, shouldn't you get a chemistry point every day regardless of whether you make any moves.

Say Team A and Team B start out at 70 chem points.

Day 1: Team A adds a player
Day 2: Team A adds a player
Day 3: Team A adds a player
Day 4: Team A adds a player
Day 5: Team A adds a player; Team B adds 5 players

The result under the current system:

Team A: 60 chemistry points
Team B: 64 chemistry points

Both had the same amount of roster turnover. The current system says that it is better to make one wholesale change than multiple minor changes. I don't necessarily agree that this is true (or that it has the intended effect of deterring stacking).

If you just give each team 1 chemistry point every day regardless of moves, both teams end up with 65 chemistry points.

Originally posted by shortstack


Again the guys who own all the players on their team are investing enough money in this game to deserve a slight edge in a game.


The clone armies already have more than a slight edge. They can pay their players whatever they want with no problems (thus upgrade faster). They never have to worry about keeping players happy. They never have to worry about losing players. They never have to worry about inactives. They have full control over all team and player tactics. They have full control over player builds.

This would be just another advantage. It starts to get to be too much.

Originally posted by shortstack



It's because of those team owners that dump all that money into the game that so many can play the game for free. Get over it.


Players with farm teams help fund the game, too, but that doesn't stop considerations of game integrity from coming in.



Thats not right. Team B 5x3 is 15, 65-15 is 50 not 64.




It is right.

Everyone starts at 70

Team B
70
+1
+1
+1
+1
-10 (5x2)
=64
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Bort,
Seems like team chemistry should have a "player chemistry" component...if all the players are happy, then the team will play better. This could be another component of the rating...

Thought is if an owner isn't responding to player requests (ignoring his team), the players are unhappy and want out, but the owner refuses and continues to ignore the players, but "signs in" to avoid inactivity...

If pay isn't enough to train at normal, player chemistry drops...

Just thinking about things that would make real world players unhappy...

I think this is a good start, but need some way of players to affect team chemistry...low-chemistry players released/traded could improve team chemistry...

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.