maybe you shouldn't let people sell teams mid season. if they decide they don't want it halfway through, it gets passed to a volunteeer from the team at no charge to the volunteer. that way, if the original owner doesn't get a rebate or however it works, maybe they'll think twice about committing in the first place.
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
dragon4644
offline
offline
Originally posted by kretchfoop
#2: could you offer the GMs a shot at owning the team for the rest of that season at no cost? You would see the same revenue as the making it an all CPU, cupcake team for the season. This temp owner would then be allowed to purchase the team the following season.
GMs would be offered the spot at random until one accepts. Or they would all be offered and the first to accept gets the owner spot for the season. If no GM accepts, the team is then (and only then) converted into a CPU cupcake.
I like this idea and if it is a gutted team then it just becomes a cupcake team. When a team is sold or taken from the owner it sometimes becomes a cupcake team anyway depending on the circumstances in which it was done. If it becomes a cupcake team then the players have the option of staying on a high level d league basically or moving on if they get offered a contract.
#2: could you offer the GMs a shot at owning the team for the rest of that season at no cost? You would see the same revenue as the making it an all CPU, cupcake team for the season. This temp owner would then be allowed to purchase the team the following season.
GMs would be offered the spot at random until one accepts. Or they would all be offered and the first to accept gets the owner spot for the season. If no GM accepts, the team is then (and only then) converted into a CPU cupcake.
I like this idea and if it is a gutted team then it just becomes a cupcake team. When a team is sold or taken from the owner it sometimes becomes a cupcake team anyway depending on the circumstances in which it was done. If it becomes a cupcake team then the players have the option of staying on a high level d league basically or moving on if they get offered a contract.
Caiderman98
offline
offline
Make a level cap for each league at being signed.
I.E. these are the level caps
BBB=L. 10
BB=L. 11-17
B=L. 17-21
A=21-22
AA=23-26
AAA=27-28
PRO LEAGUE=No Cap
I.E. these are the level caps
BBB=L. 10
BB=L. 11-17
B=L. 17-21
A=21-22
AA=23-26
AAA=27-28
PRO LEAGUE=No Cap
Falanor
offline
offline
Originally posted by Caiderman98
Make a level cap for each league at being signed.
I.E. these are the level caps
BBB=L. 10
BB=L. 11-17
B=L. 17-21
A=21-22
AA=23-26
AAA=27-28
PRO LEAGUE=No Cap
Like the levels, but the tiers are a bit off for your B leagues:
B
BB
BBB
Unless you are also talking about bumping the BBB below their current position as well.
Make a level cap for each league at being signed.
I.E. these are the level caps
BBB=L. 10
BB=L. 11-17
B=L. 17-21
A=21-22
AA=23-26
AAA=27-28
PRO LEAGUE=No Cap
Like the levels, but the tiers are a bit off for your B leagues:
B
BB
BBB
Unless you are also talking about bumping the BBB below their current position as well.
sois
offline
offline
I think discussion has gotten off topic.
I still have not heard a feasible scenario for sending a team down. Here is my idea, reposted:
1. There has to be a way to rank league teams 1-32. Consolation brackets for playoff teams would give defined 1-16 positions for playoff teams. Non playoff teams already have rankings from end of regular season.
2. Intraleague matchups should occur to determine which feeder league team will be promoted. #3 vs #3, #4 vs #4 .... etc. That way, there is a clear order in which to promote teams. This will result in the two feeder league member teams being ranked 1-64.
3. Bump sold team to lowest level. Put them in the league with the LOWEST AVERAGE LEVEL. That is the best way to decide their destination. Least programming headaches.
4. Process promotions based on results of #2.
I still have not heard a feasible scenario for sending a team down. Here is my idea, reposted:
1. There has to be a way to rank league teams 1-32. Consolation brackets for playoff teams would give defined 1-16 positions for playoff teams. Non playoff teams already have rankings from end of regular season.
2. Intraleague matchups should occur to determine which feeder league team will be promoted. #3 vs #3, #4 vs #4 .... etc. That way, there is a clear order in which to promote teams. This will result in the two feeder league member teams being ranked 1-64.
3. Bump sold team to lowest level. Put them in the league with the LOWEST AVERAGE LEVEL. That is the best way to decide their destination. Least programming headaches.
4. Process promotions based on results of #2.
shadowmane
offline
offline
My idea here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=921389
would help this out. If the owner abandoned the team, the GM could take over until a the team is sold, or until the end of the season, when the team would be sold anyway. I had d-league teams in mind when I posted that, but this situation seems custom made for my idea.
If you would create different management levels, for instance, Head Coach, Defensive Coordinator, Offensive Coordinator instead of/in addition to just the General Manager position, it could help the team out if the owner abandoned the team. The team could theoretically go on for the rest of the season without the owner's input. The GM would be come the interim owner until the team is sold.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=921389
would help this out. If the owner abandoned the team, the GM could take over until a the team is sold, or until the end of the season, when the team would be sold anyway. I had d-league teams in mind when I posted that, but this situation seems custom made for my idea.
If you would create different management levels, for instance, Head Coach, Defensive Coordinator, Offensive Coordinator instead of/in addition to just the General Manager position, it could help the team out if the owner abandoned the team. The team could theoretically go on for the rest of the season without the owner's input. The GM would be come the interim owner until the team is sold.
sois
offline
offline
shadow, your idea is good, but it really doesn't focus on the issue of "move sold team to bottom tier"
shadowmane
offline
offline
I addresses the issue of the owner that has abandoned his team, which makes the team have to be sold. It answers the question of what to do with the team until it is sold.
sois
offline
offline
the thread is about finding the best way to move teams to the bottom tier AFTER it is sold.
i agree with you 100%, abandoned teams need to be addressed, but this is a different topic.
i agree with you 100%, abandoned teams need to be addressed, but this is a different topic.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 12:31:39
shadowmane
offline
offline
I would say it should depend on the team. If it is a competitive team, with competitive players, it should remain so. If, instead, it is gutted, then move it to the bottom tier so the owner has a chance to rebuild it without getting beat every single game.
sois
offline
offline
Originally posted by shadowmane
I would say it should depend on the team. If it is a competitive team, with competitive players, it should remain so. If, instead, it is gutted, then move it to the bottom tier so the owner has a chance to rebuild it without getting beat every single game.
My only issue with this is the definition of "competitive". From a programming standpoint, its easier to remain consistent. Use the same logic for all sold teams.
If you think about what is happening, the situation doesn't mirror real life. In leagues, when teams are sold, they are generally sold to an interested party. Someone who wants to continue ownership. The new owners usually pay a premium for the accumulated assets.
Here, the teams are sold back to GLB. Each team costs the same so there is no representation of the valuation of a team and negotiation of a sale price. Since this is not represented, and will never be represented, it would be best to scrap the team and start over.
I would say it should depend on the team. If it is a competitive team, with competitive players, it should remain so. If, instead, it is gutted, then move it to the bottom tier so the owner has a chance to rebuild it without getting beat every single game.
My only issue with this is the definition of "competitive". From a programming standpoint, its easier to remain consistent. Use the same logic for all sold teams.
If you think about what is happening, the situation doesn't mirror real life. In leagues, when teams are sold, they are generally sold to an interested party. Someone who wants to continue ownership. The new owners usually pay a premium for the accumulated assets.
Here, the teams are sold back to GLB. Each team costs the same so there is no representation of the valuation of a team and negotiation of a sale price. Since this is not represented, and will never be represented, it would be best to scrap the team and start over.
shadowmane
offline
offline
Under that situation, I would agree. Release all the players, kill the team and allow someone to start another one in its place.
Tito716
offline
offline
Release all players from sold teams and fill the team with improved CPU players.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=924667
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=924667
bignath87
offline
offline
If teams are going to be moved to the bottom teir when they are sold the competitiveness issue needs to be addressed. There are a few options, some of which i feel would benefit Goal Line Blitz as a whole. I must admit that i havent read all 21 pages of peoples comments because quite often it involves the same idea being ripped and rebuilt by 3 different people so i apologise now if this has already been suggested.
1) Teams should not be sold mid-season, they should be bought in the off season and traded away during the off season. I believe this because no owner is going to want a CPU populated team in the same respect, a team is not going to want a CPU run team.
2)There should be more available buyout clauses for active players on teams to purchase a team from the owner should they not want to sink more money into the game. Such as a GM or an agent with a significant interest in the team. Active on the forums or multiple players on the team.
3)Should a team be regarded as competitive, a more than 25/75 win/loss (or there abouts) ratio, it should be offered as a complete team sale should the players desire it. Now i know that a lot of team players are not active in the capacity that they vote, however a voting code is relatively easy to implement and the active players could make a collective decison on whether to stay in the league and compete.
OR
4)When a team is moved to a bottom tier its players are collectively put out onto the market as free agents. This will solve the problem of there not being enough players to purchase, to a certain extent. Obviously the most sucessful teams will not sell their players but the rumors i have heard of a team roster cap (58 players or something) would prevent these sucessful teams from hoarding the best players.
5)This was someone elses idea but i feel it should be re-raised, as it could be implemented, Team levels. Peewee (D-leagues), High School, College and Professional. These can be used in 2 catagories.
A)League caps, players can only be recruited to a certain level in each level team eg. 8 in PW, 13 in HS, 21 in C, and Uncapped in Pro. This would even out the leagues and create opportunitys for player growth without getting dumped to the bottom of the roster and if the teams average level exceeds the league cap, they will obviously be successful and be promoted or be "forced" through penalties to sell their players. This will also remove the 6 season contracts that take up players entire careers.
B)It would allow the market place to be sorted by players relevant to what you need and increase competitiveness in contract negotiations and team depth.
Mainly in point 5 I am straying away from the subject of teams being moved to the bottom teir and am looking at competitiveness amoung leagues and distribution of players. I would like to reiterate the idea of the roster caps such as the ones faced in the NFL to control the quantity of players on a team.
I would like to apologise once again for the repitition, and the bad spelling. I put quite some thinking into this idea which is rare for me so would appreciate constructive feedback rather then "douch, this has already been said" or "bad idea -1"
1) Teams should not be sold mid-season, they should be bought in the off season and traded away during the off season. I believe this because no owner is going to want a CPU populated team in the same respect, a team is not going to want a CPU run team.
2)There should be more available buyout clauses for active players on teams to purchase a team from the owner should they not want to sink more money into the game. Such as a GM or an agent with a significant interest in the team. Active on the forums or multiple players on the team.
3)Should a team be regarded as competitive, a more than 25/75 win/loss (or there abouts) ratio, it should be offered as a complete team sale should the players desire it. Now i know that a lot of team players are not active in the capacity that they vote, however a voting code is relatively easy to implement and the active players could make a collective decison on whether to stay in the league and compete.
OR
4)When a team is moved to a bottom tier its players are collectively put out onto the market as free agents. This will solve the problem of there not being enough players to purchase, to a certain extent. Obviously the most sucessful teams will not sell their players but the rumors i have heard of a team roster cap (58 players or something) would prevent these sucessful teams from hoarding the best players.
5)This was someone elses idea but i feel it should be re-raised, as it could be implemented, Team levels. Peewee (D-leagues), High School, College and Professional. These can be used in 2 catagories.
A)League caps, players can only be recruited to a certain level in each level team eg. 8 in PW, 13 in HS, 21 in C, and Uncapped in Pro. This would even out the leagues and create opportunitys for player growth without getting dumped to the bottom of the roster and if the teams average level exceeds the league cap, they will obviously be successful and be promoted or be "forced" through penalties to sell their players. This will also remove the 6 season contracts that take up players entire careers.
B)It would allow the market place to be sorted by players relevant to what you need and increase competitiveness in contract negotiations and team depth.
Mainly in point 5 I am straying away from the subject of teams being moved to the bottom teir and am looking at competitiveness amoung leagues and distribution of players. I would like to reiterate the idea of the roster caps such as the ones faced in the NFL to control the quantity of players on a team.
I would like to apologise once again for the repitition, and the bad spelling. I put quite some thinking into this idea which is rare for me so would appreciate constructive feedback rather then "douch, this has already been said" or "bad idea -1"
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























