User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
decribb83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatsFan94
Another episode that I don't know to make of. I mean it was good in terms of entertainment value but did absolutely nothing to progress the story at all.


The battle for the leader spot is really starting to heat up, Daryl's issues with Merle and his place in the group were addressed, a romantic relationship with Maggie and Glenn is strongly developing, and The old man has a bunch of walkers that are probably friends and family locked in his barn. I would say lots of key stuff got addressed and the story is certainly advancing even though they are still on the farm.......
 
Rick Blaine
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rick Blaine
Do we know for sure that Merle is returning? I saw one preview, in which Merle was shown, but I couldn't help thinking it could either be a flashback or Daryl, laying on the ground bleeding, imagining his brother there yelling at him to get up.


I wonder if I should go out and buy a lottery ticket.


Originally posted by decribb83
The battle for the leader spot is really starting to heat up, Daryl's issues with Merle and his place in the group were addressed, a romantic relationship with Maggie and Glenn is strongly developing, and The old man has a bunch of walkers that are probably friends and family locked in his barn. I would say lots of key stuff got addressed and the story is certainly advancing even though they are still on the farm.......


Yeah, and the zombies in the barn sets up a potential problem. If they're to escape, they could cause a lot of problems. Maybe that's what will get the group moving along.
 
Staxic
offline
Link
 
Why don't they put the zombies in the barn on treadmills, and use the treadmill turning action to create some electricity? Put those free-loading zombies to some work!
If they refuse, burn the barn! Everyone likes a good barn burning!
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
The whole Daryl getting shot by Andrea sequence was so lame.

The "tension" build up was a bunch of garbage, anyone with half a brain knew they weren't going to kill off Daryl...and to me this is where the show just doesn't capture the essence of the comic. In the comic they would have actually killed off Daryl, just like that. Ruthless, quick and no "goodbyes"...he would have just been gone. No one is safe in the comics, which leads to a constant sense of dread.

So far the show feels like every other show, a cast of untouchable characters surrounded by minor characters who are "allowed" to be killed off occasionally. Don't get me wrong its still fun television but it is far from a groundbreaking take on the genre.

With that said the zombie kills in the woods were pretty fucking rad.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cannons call
The whole Daryl getting shot by Andrea sequence was so lame.

The "tension" build up was a bunch of garbage, anyone with half a brain knew they weren't going to kill off Daryl...and to me this is where the show just doesn't capture the essence of the comic. In the comic they would have actually killed off Daryl, just like that. Ruthless, quick and no "goodbyes"...he would have just been gone. No one is safe in the comics, which leads to a constant sense of dread.

So far the show feels like every other show, a cast of untouchable characters surrounded by minor characters who are "allowed" to be killed off occasionally. Don't get me wrong its still fun television but it is far from a groundbreaking take on the genre.

With that said the zombie kills in the woods were pretty fucking rad.


Serious question, do actually think this TV show can or ever will come close to being able to tell the story the book does?
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
Serious question, do actually think this TV show can or ever will come close to being able to tell the story the book does?


I think with the right writers/director it could have come very close. Remember this is based off a comic, not a novel. The comic was written in an extremely cinematic fashion, it's basically the exact same thing as a storyboard used when creating a movie or tv show. Considering the source material, this should have been much easier to translate to the screen than most novels and even most plays.

Don't get me wrong i'm totally fine with them swaying away from the comics storyline. I just don't think they have really captured the feel or atmosphere of the comic, and i've come to the realization they probably never will.

Edited by cannons call on Nov 14, 2011 10:05:58
 
Link
 
I mean comic when I say book. I think there is just no way they can get that crazy on film, it couldn't be accomplished nearly as effectively as it is in print. The swings are too drastic to carry over to a TV series. While the comic is essentially a giant storyboard, it's not a screenplay, it's not really a blueprint either, more of a foundation. I think the second season has gone much further in capturing the essentials of the theme and mood of the story in Miles Behind Us while telling a altered version of it.

The only format that would of been able to do the Comics true justice would of been animation, live action though provides a very different experience. The recipe of the comic told too closely in the live action TV show would of failed.
 
quidjibo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter

Serious question, do actually think this TV show can or ever will come close to being able to tell the story the book does?


nobody wants to see Andrea and the old man hook up

 
Arawn
offline
Link
 
I ordered the first edition to the comic today
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
Serious question, do actually think this TV show can or ever will come close to being able to tell the story the book does?


The comic has some pretty inappropriate situations for TV, so no. I think that if the comic had been picked up by HBO or Showtime, they might have had a chance.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
The comic has some pretty inappropriate situations for TV, so no. I think that if the comic had been picked up by HBO or Showtime, they might have had a chance.


Considering the show is already pushing the limits who knows. The used real body parts/guts in a couple episodes.
 
lVlellovv
offline
Link
 
haha....that last episode.
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
The comic has some pretty inappropriate situations for TV, so no. I think that if the comic had been picked up by HBO or Showtime, they might have had a chance.


I really don't see what situation the comic has that couldn't be portrayed on the show. Obviously not everything could be explicitly shown, but they could easily get the point across with creative cinematography.

Shows like Breaking Bad have proven that a cable show can easily portray adult subject matter and push the limits of what is "acceptable".
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
I mean comic when I say book. I think there is just no way they can get that crazy on film, it couldn't be accomplished nearly as effectively as it is in print. The swings are too drastic to carry over to a TV series. While the comic is essentially a giant storyboard, it's not a screenplay, it's not really a blueprint either, more of a foundation. I think the second season has gone much further in capturing the essentials of the theme and mood of the story in Miles Behind Us while telling a altered version of it.

The only format that would of been able to do the Comics true justice would of been animation, live action though provides a very different experience. The recipe of the comic told too closely in the live action TV show would of failed.


I don't see any reason why they couldn't be as fearless on the television show as they are in the comic. The comic breaks almost every horror cliche, while the show is still pretty much going with the same old formula. I understand why they did it, because the masses probably couldn't handle seeing their favorite characters dying off without warning but I still consider it the safe route.
 
RagingBoredom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cannons call
The whole Daryl getting shot by Andrea sequence was so lame.

The "tension" build up was a bunch of garbage, anyone with half a brain knew they weren't going to kill off Daryl...and to me this is where the show just doesn't capture the essence of the comic. In the comic they would have actually killed off Daryl, just like that. Ruthless, quick and no "goodbyes"...he would have just been gone. No one is safe in the comics, which leads to a constant sense of dread.

So far the show feels like every other show, a cast of untouchable characters surrounded by minor characters who are "allowed" to be killed off occasionally. Don't get me wrong its still fun television but it is far from a groundbreaking take on the genre.

With that said the zombie kills in the woods were pretty fucking rad.


I can understand where you're coming from but if Angela had actually killed him, it would have destroyed her. And she's an essential character so they couldn't have gone that route. I fully believe that when the story gets moving along more, we'll start to see that anyone is fair game from then on out. I very well could be wrong though. We'll just have to wait and see. But just try to give it until after the prison storyline is underway before you start to criticize it on that front because we are SO early into the story right now and it makes sense to keep a core group of people alive for a while. The more attached people are to a character when they die, the bigger the impact their death has on the viewer.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.