User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagle0415
Solution you speak of does not do a thing for me. Reason being is i already spent the flex on CE so why should i have to take the hit on 49 players all my own thats a huge cost to me over 4400 flex which i don't feel i should have to give up because we keep changing the way the game is done. And i am not disagreeing this isnt a good move i just dont feel i should have to lose so much in flex


First, you might want to get on equipping that CE if you bought it because I don't see a single guy on your team currently equipped and your first game is in less than 4 hours.

Also, you get to use that CE this season regardless of whether or not you keep the guys. How is it fair to other people that you get to use CE on 49 of your players for the entire season and then just get the entire sum returned to you? You really don't think you should have to pay anything for the having the advantage of CE this season?

Now, if you're willing to completely give up the CE and never use it in a game that's one thing. If that's the case, I'd probably agree that you should be given a 100% refund for the money you spent on that CE, and I'd attempt to contact support or possibly Catch22 to explore the possibility.
 
Tigam
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37
As for my argument against complete customization, it basically comes down to the fact that you can't have the best possible combination of majors and minors at any single position with the system we're currently discussing. Therefore people are forced to weigh pros and cons of different archetypes and decide how they want to build. If we could just choose anything we wanted you'd end up with the vast majority of people just choosing the best possible combo of majors and minors and working from there. That isn't possible in this system.

I'm confused as to why you would think that people just won't choose the same archetype based on the same logic you just laid out.
 
Mathias82
offline
Link
 
Damn Bort just made be bend over and made me his bitch. I have 26 players to retire and get to remake. I just hope I can convese the rest of my team to do the same or I'll be rolling a lot more then 26 players.
 
Eagle0415
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37
Originally posted by Eagle0415

Solution you speak of does not do a thing for me. Reason being is i already spent the flex on CE so why should i have to take the hit on 49 players all my own thats a huge cost to me over 4400 flex which i don't feel i should have to give up because we keep changing the way the game is done. And i am not disagreeing this isnt a good move i just dont feel i should have to lose so much in flex


First, you might want to get on equipping that CE if you bought it because I don't see a single guy on your team currently equipped and your first game is in less than 4 hours.

Also, you get to use that CE this season regardless of whether or not you keep the guys. How is it fair to other people that you get to use CE on 49 of your players for the entire season and then just get the entire sum returned to you? You really don't think you should have to pay anything for the having the advantage of CE this season?

Now, if you're willing to completely give up the CE and never use it in a game that's one thing. If that's the case, I'd probably agree that you should be given a 100% refund for the money you spent on that CE, and I'd attempt to contact support or possibly Catch22 to explore the possibility.


I dont think you are getting my point. I spent money on CE on 49 players regardless of weather it is equiped yet or not. I created these players the way the system is now not for the new system they want to implement. As for thinking i should play entire season with CE and not pay anything for it. If you dont see them equiped it because i have not equiped them and dont plan on it till next season i purchased the CE in advance so i had it done i dont feel it would benifet me this first season even if it was equiped so i didnt equip them but, keep in mind if we change the way a player is created i would retire current players as is and rebuild them with new system and in that case i dont feel i should be penalized by losing 10% on what i spent if they wanna give me a full refund now i would sell every piece of CE but i want it at full price and end of season ill retire and recreate new players with new system
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tigam

I'm confused as to why you would think that people just won't choose the same archetype based on the same logic you just laid out.


This.

And nixa -- I wasn't the one arguing for being able to choose majors/minors. I do believe that...

A. A larger list of SA's, some position specific

and

B. The ability to customize one's own trees (outside of the mandated SA's by archetype)

Would lead to far more variation in player building, esp. when you add VA's and AEQ on top of that (though both need some work as well imo).

I'm not arguing against the new system, I'm just saying it does not go far enough...its just plugging a hole while the pressure builds up and creates new ones...or as it was put before, its window dressing that tries to hide some of the major underlying flaws.
 
simmjer
offline
Link
 
Im not reading 15 pages.. but this seems to be just making it to easy to create players.. for us who have been playing since pretty much the start or from the start - and have taken time to figure out which way of creating a players is good and bad - just seems to take the fun out it. now it seems like all the players are pretty much going to be the same builds.. like a bunch of teams playing themselves over and over? Is this not right? Or am i reading into to this all wrong?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagle0415
I dont think you are getting my point. I spent money on CE on 49 players regardless of weather it is equiped yet or not. I created these players the way the system is now not for the new system they want to implement. As for thinking i should play entire season with CE and not pay anything for it. If you dont see them equiped it because i have not equiped them and dont plan on it till next season i purchased the CE in advance so i had it done i dont feel it would benifet me this first season even if it was equiped so i didnt equip them but, keep in mind if we change the way a player is created i would retire current players as is and rebuild them with new system and in that case i dont feel i should be penalized by losing 10% on what i spent if they wanna give me a full refund now i would sell every piece of CE but i want it at full price and end of season ill retire and recreate new players with new system


Go equip all 49 players with their CE so that we can all believe your story. If true, I will gladly support you in your cause. Until you equip them, its just hot air.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mathias82
Damn Bort just made be bend over and made me his bitch. I have 26 players to retire and get to remake. I just hope I can convese the rest of my team to do the same or I'll be rolling a lot more then 26 players.


+1
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
would be pretty unusual to buy custom equipment (600 flex) for 48 players (28,800) with no intention of using it for at least a full season..
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
I'm super pumped that what I've been doing EVERY SEASON since season 8 is finally going to cost me next to nothing. Shit... I retire 40 Pee Wee players that are fully boosted and buy custom EQ every season, this season I'm going to get much more back, which is awesome.

Maybe I'll even use some of that flex to build a couple of long term players....
 
NY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TXSteve
would be pretty unusual to buy custom equipment (600 flex) for 48 players (28,800) with no intention of using it for at least a full season..


Well would be pretty unusual for you to say that..you don't have 55 Players..you don't
know how much time that takes..and some people do that ahead of time so everything
would be ready for next season.
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
Here is the problem as I see it ... flame me if I am not 100% correct ... whatever.

Here is a QB I created for one season (pee wee) ... assume for argument sake he played this year (even though he played in season 8).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1257703

When I rolled him, he these skills at minimum: jumping, carrying, catching ... all at 10.

end of season, he went up 2 in each category ... from leveling.

... the Archtype S15 QB ... wouldn't have meaningless points dumped into jumping, carrying, catching for a Pocket Passer.

So, his core attributes would be more efficient.

The S12 and S13 QB would be even more inefficient (older, yes ... but still a "bad" build relative to the new ArchType).

... so, it just seems to encourage everyone to retire all their S12-S14 created players? Why not total reset while we are at it?

Only reason to keep say a S14 QB is for bragging rights to say my QB can jump higher than your S15 QB?
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tigam

I'm confused as to why you would think that people just won't choose the same archetype based on the same logic you just laid out.


Because the archetypes were created in such a way that no one archetype at a position has significant advantages in terms of what majors and minors are available. Its the reason there is no combo OL (would basically require blocking, agility, and strength as majors which would be overpowered) and the reason the combo HB has vision instead of agility (speed, agility, strength, and carrying would be overpowered).

Essentially, the best possible combos of majors/minors were eliminated as possible options by the archetype system.
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eagle0415
I dont think you are getting my point. I spent money on CE on 49 players regardless of weather it is equiped yet or not. I created these players the way the system is now not for the new system they want to implement. As for thinking i should play entire season with CE and not pay anything for it. If you dont see them equiped it because i have not equiped them and dont plan on it till next season i purchased the CE in advance so i had it done i dont feel it would benifet me this first season even if it was equiped so i didnt equip them but, keep in mind if we change the way a player is created i would retire current players as is and rebuild them with new system and in that case i dont feel i should be penalized by losing 10% on what i spent if they wanna give me a full refund now i would sell every piece of CE but i want it at full price and end of season ill retire and recreate new players with new system


1. I understood your point just fine, I was just pointing out why its ridiculous to expect to get "free" CE for a season.

2. You shouldn't have invested money you knew you couldn't get a complete refund on until you needed to. What if you didn't like a particular build after this season or something and wanted to retire a guy or two? You'd have to eat the loss then whether or not you used to CE

3. Like I said, if you really aren't going to use the CE at all, I have no problem with you getting a full refund.
 
Eagle0415
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by nixa37

How naive are you guys? Do you really think there won't be a "best way" to build with completely customizable SA trees if there's a best way to build based on the new ALG's? Do you really think that not allowing player's to choose the most dominant combination of majors/minors (and therefore forcing them to decide which are the most important majors and minors for what they want to do) is going to lead to less diversity in builds? Do you really believe there will be one best archetype and one best way to build that archetype for each position? Regardless of how said player will be used?

For the love of God, there won't even necessarily be a best way to build any particular archetype, let alone a most dominant archetype at every single position.


So...what is your argument?


For those who don't beleive me i equipped Defense side only with the CE but i do have it for Offense as well i will be unequipping them in 30 minutes so feel free to take a look for those who thought it was all hot air
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.