User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by SAVAGE OPS

If you're team is so bad that it gets relegated than maybe they should lose XP


Or maybe they should quit and stop spending on the site. How does that benefit people again?

By the way Ops, strange position considering you're a team stacker that prompted the rule change.


If crap rules like this keep up Bort can expect about $200 less a month from me.
 
Scoot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Leahmic223
Originally posted by Scoot

Originally posted by Bort


You cannot trust some gamers to work it out on their own. There will be a-holes who will exploit wherever they can.


it's about time IMO. the gaming updates can wait as long as it takes, the first priority after creating the game is establishing a player structure. that step was skipped and every main forum on this website is an example of it. lay down the law, set exact guidelines now and during every update and addition so that there is no confusion. players will bitch because they always bitch, but it beats the hell out of thousands of "i just got screwed over" pm's and topics.



Hey Scoot...would you by chance be from the Texanstalk forums BTW?


yup yup
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
People need to stop using real football analogies to support this update. In-game experience in real football is much less significant than it is in GLB. Talented rookies in the NFL don't start off 1/5th as fast or strong as veterans. Top freshmen in college aren't any slower or weaker than seniors.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 02:12:45
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dudeamis
Originally posted by secondeye

Originally posted by SAVAGE OPS


If you're team is so bad that it gets relegated than maybe they should lose XP


Or maybe they should quit and stop spending on the site. How does that benefit people again?

By the way Ops, strange position considering you're a team stacker that prompted the rule change.


If crap rules like this keep up Bort can expect about $200 less a month from me.


cosign!
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
I would suggest that the median level have a hard floor, such that it cannot fall during the season. This helps protect those players from suffering if a few teams fall apart and get gutted, bringing median league level down precipitously.

A big part of the difficulty here is simply the youth of the leagues.

In the longer run, I would suggest setting hard caps and floors to these numbers for lower level leagues.

For instance, it is probably not unreasonable for a level 60 player to play in a level 45 league...the gap in talent will be ( I suspect) much less than one would imagine, and build will have a lot more impact than raw skills.

I suspect is has more to do with the rather steep curve that exists at lower levels...level 8 to level 16 is quite a jump.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 02:13:45
 
Leahmic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Scoot
Originally posted by Leahmic223

Originally posted by Scoot


Originally posted by Bort



You cannot trust some gamers to work it out on their own. There will be a-holes who will exploit wherever they can.


it's about time IMO. the gaming updates can wait as long as it takes, the first priority after creating the game is establishing a player structure. that step was skipped and every main forum on this website is an example of it. lay down the law, set exact guidelines now and during every update and addition so that there is no confusion. players will bitch because they always bitch, but it beats the hell out of thousands of "i just got screwed over" pm's and topics.



Hey Scoot...would you by chance be from the Texanstalk forums BTW?


yup yup


Lol I thought so. I visit those forums during the football season. I saw your dancing baby avatar and the name and I thought I saw it somewhere

 
Ra4xGambit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
People need to stop using real football analogies to support this update. In-game experience in real football is much less significant than it is in GLB. Talented rookies in the NFL don't start off 1/5th as fast or strong as veterans. Freshmen in college aren't any slower or weaker than seniors.


People need to stop whining, too. But it doesn't look like it's going to happen...
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
People need to stop using real football analogies to support this update. In-game experience in real football is much less significant than it is in GLB. Talented rookies in the NFL don't start off 1/5th as fast or strong as veterans. Freshmen in college aren't any slower or weaker than seniors.


yes they are...this ruling equates your starting NFL players to the rookie H/S players...
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 02:13:43
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Leahmic223
Originally posted by Ra4xGambit

Am I th eonly one who thinks the update is completely logical, anyway? Does Charles Woodson get as much practice covering the 11th grade second-stringer as he does lining up against Terrel Owens? No, he doesn't.

It's completely parallel to the xp system in every RPG across the universe... better xp for stronger opponents. Little (or no in some games) xp for facing things you really shouldn't even be wasting your time on in the first place.


Lol, you are exactly right. It is the same as every other MMO.

If you are a lvl 50 Warlord you don't get jack squat for going to the noob area and trying to grind....



And Charles Woodson isn't forced to play with one hand tied behind his back when he's covering Troy Williamson.. And the Warlord doesn't have his Season 3 epic daggers taken away when he fights a holy priest.
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ra4xGambit
Originally posted by cbarge

People need to stop using real football analogies to support this update. In-game experience in real football is much less significant than it is in GLB. Talented rookies in the NFL don't start off 1/5th as fast or strong as veterans. Freshmen in college aren't any slower or weaker than seniors.


People need to stop whining, too. But it doesn't look like it's going to happen...


yeah.
 
Link
 
This still has flaws, have an AAA team that's a few years away from competing or just assigned? Fill it up with level 1's screw over the top teams by dropping the league average and then get knocked down a league and rebuild.


If this comes into affect I think ANYTHING that slightly even resembles gutting collusion needs to result in a site ban as that could potentially affect a leagues average
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
From Bort's post, emphasis mine"

Originally posted by
I can hear the complaints coming already, but if you're playing in a fair way (in the spirit of the game, and you know very well what it is) and are around the right level to compete with your league, you will see ZERO to little effect on your team and players


You could STILL be effected EVEN if you are "around the right level."

Total crap.

How is it realistic to tell people to choose between winning and maximizing player performance? Those things should go hand-in-hand, not be forced into opposition.
 
Ra4xGambit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by Leahmic223

Originally posted by Ra4xGambit


Am I th eonly one who thinks the update is completely logical, anyway? Does Charles Woodson get as much practice covering the 11th grade second-stringer as he does lining up against Terrel Owens? No, he doesn't.

It's completely parallel to the xp system in every RPG across the universe... better xp for stronger opponents. Little (or no in some games) xp for facing things you really shouldn't even be wasting your time on in the first place.


Lol, you are exactly right. It is the same as every other MMO.

If you are a lvl 50 Warlord you don't get jack squat for going to the noob area and trying to grind....



And Charles Woodson isn't forced to play with one hand tied behind his back when he's covering Troy Williamson.. And the Warlord doesn't have his Season 3 epic daggers taken away when he fights a holy priest.


Once again... you are assuming far too much. As is everyone in this thread.
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by Leahmic223

Originally posted by Ra4xGambit


Am I th eonly one who thinks the update is completely logical, anyway? Does Charles Woodson get as much practice covering the 11th grade second-stringer as he does lining up against Terrel Owens? No, he doesn't.

It's completely parallel to the xp system in every RPG across the universe... better xp for stronger opponents. Little (or no in some games) xp for facing things you really shouldn't even be wasting your time on in the first place.


Lol, you are exactly right. It is the same as every other MMO.

If you are a lvl 50 Warlord you don't get jack squat for going to the noob area and trying to grind....



And Charles Woodson isn't forced to play with one hand tied behind his back when he's covering Troy Williamson.. And the Warlord doesn't have his Season 3 epic daggers taken away when he fights a holy priest.


No-ones taking anything-other than Xp gain away from the high levels. They WILL still dominate.

IN a season or two of this though, they will no longer be all dominant, the lesser teams will have caught them if they don't promote.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 02:15:29
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
As I said, I don't have time to read the whole thread. But I'm feeling better because the scale involves how long the player has stayed on the team.

I do think the penalty should be reduced for this season though because it came in late (doesn't really affect the Elves if Bort is right in that players who have been there since offseason of season 1 won't really affected), but next season, should be in full force.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.