User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Nike-Joe
offline
Link
 
I haven't read all 19 pages of this thread, so i'm commenting on the original idea. I don't like it. it still punished better teams. it punishes a team for having better players. but isn't that what we are supposed to be doing with recruiting? Getting better players?

and it discourages players from wanting to play for a good team. any good team will have better players then their competition. now players will only want to play above their ability. everything will be crazy.

why can't we just buck up and deal with the cheaters using old fashioned elbow grease and enforcement work?
 
douglasiv
offline
Link
 
"2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg."

If you go this route, how often would the average be updated? Will the average be updated everyday? Also would Free Agents be able to easily find this magic number without having to research each team? Maybe on the League homepage there could be something that tells what the current average is to help Free agents decide.

I haven't read all 20 pages, but those are some of my concerns.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nike-Joe
I haven't read all 19 pages of this thread, so i'm commenting on the original idea. I don't like it. it still punished better teams. it punishes a team for having better players. but isn't that what we are supposed to be doing with recruiting? Getting better players?

and it discourages players from wanting to play for a good team. any good team will have better players then their competition. now players will only want to play above their ability. everything will be crazy.

why can't we just buck up and deal with the cheaters using old fashioned elbow grease and enforcement work?


Agree, why should my players be punished for me being a better recruiter than the other owners?
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
As for exploits, won't teams just be encouraged to trap players of the lowest level that will skew their team's average for the sake of boosting their real players? How complicated do you want to get with the system that determines a team level average? Total sum of player-level fielded for all plays divided by number of plays divided by 11?

I'm definitely for getting teams out of the basement. A bonus on underleveled teams will definitely create a draw towards them in the free agent market.

Balances shouldn't encourage teams to all look the same, they should encourage owners to decide where to invest their limited capital. These suggestions, while i don't oppose them, are stop gaps and work arounds to the much cooler solution that is whipping the GLB dollar into shape.

I think, as a stop gap until play levels start to peak, these suggestions are interesting and gentle, i like them more than the lame level caps on signings, but less than the coming salary cap.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dudeamis
Originally posted by Nike-Joe

I haven't read all 19 pages of this thread, so i'm commenting on the original idea. I don't like it. it still punished better teams. it punishes a team for having better players. but isn't that what we are supposed to be doing with recruiting? Getting better players?

and it discourages players from wanting to play for a good team. any good team will have better players then their competition. now players will only want to play above their ability. everything will be crazy.

why can't we just buck up and deal with the cheaters using old fashioned elbow grease and enforcement work?


Agree, why should my players be punished for me being a better recruiter than the other owners?


Uh, only the players who shouldn't have joined a low level league in the first place.

It would be the players who are, say, level 18 and signed to play in a league where most starters are level 10 or something who'd get less exp. Their level 10 (or 11 or 12) teammates would still get normal experience.

The punishment goes to the player who went to a league to power game and dominate rather than one to compete.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
i like this for helping out the lower level teams facing tougher competition, as they should get more XP (15% might be high...not sure) for facing tough teams, but I don't think a team should get punished for being good.
 
ipstaff
offline
Link
 
I think it's great - though I guess no surprise since I posted in favor of something like this in the other thread about how to deal with this problem. :-)

I'd use likely "league average level" rather than average level of the opposing team to determine how XP gets impacted, as the league average is what drives a player toward a particular team.

Yes, it will encourage players to try to "play up" into higher brackets, where they are lower than the average level - but isn't that a good thing? Those teams will be able to recruit top talent, and they still only have so many roster spots - and besides, since XP is still a function of playing time, the players will want to play up, but not so far up that they're just benchwarmers. It will push players toward leagues where they can get substantial PT, which is most likely where they are around the league average for levels.

It's a simple, self-enforcing solution.

And capping it at a 15% change will mean that players who really want to stay with a particular team, despite it being in a lower division, means they can make that choice if they want to do so.

The key is figuring out the scale. If it's XP-neutral as long as a player is within a reasonable number of levels of league average - I dunno, say, three levels as a guess? - and then kicks in gradually, but then accelerates when the player is way out of average, then it will really only impact those who have no business in the league.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
I love this idea. And, it makes sense. You learn more from playing people better than you and you really don't learn a whole lot by beating up on those who are far inferior. This mirrors real life learning and gaming. Plus, I think it would help mitigate some of the problems--not all though.

Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so here's a positive reinforcement idea instead of level caps, to "encourage" parity instead of force it. This has been brought up before, but I'm posting it here for further review:

(note this is in "suggestions," not "announcements")

Power gamers and those looking for loopholes to pwning n00bs care about one thing: XP. They want to be uber player, gain the max XP possible, and look at their pretty attributes.

1) For every game you play, the experience an individual player gains is modified based on the levels of your opponents (or of the league) compared to your own, with say, up to a 15% modifier.

2) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's around the same level as you, you get the same XP as you get now.

3) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's better than you, you get an XP bonus.

4) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's worse than you, you get less XP.

Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?


 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Impossible! A player who do not boost can't catch a player who do.



This 3 lvl boost is an amazing advantage past lvl 20...


You obviously didn't read what I wrote.

Bravo to Bort and DD for putting a hard level cap on tonight's new teams. It was not only the most intelligent solution to the problem; it was the simplest.

Now, if we only had definitive rules on collusion, gutting, and farming...

Last edited Jun 8, 2008 23:47:49
 
zigzag21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxedge72x
I don't know if anyone posted this as an idea... but instead of an XP bonus how about a salary cap (as opposed to another post which proposed a level cap).

Teams need to pay for higher level players... if there are scaling salary caps depending on the league type, then they will be forced to keep down the number of high profile players they bring in. In this system, Pro leagues wouldn't be affected by a salary cap, but everything below them (AAA, AA, A, BBB, etc.) would have salary based caps. The AAA would get a much higher salary cap than AA, and AA more than A, etc.

Combine salary caps with relegation and eventually a widened level gap, then teams should be able to manage their salary caps and get them upgraded once they do well enough in a league to get relegated upwards.

The only potential problem is for a team that spends close to cap and then gets relegated downwards... all I can say is that team probably is not spending its money wisely to spend that much and do that poorly, and will have to seriously reevaluate its roster and contracts in order to rebuild.


I agree. This set of ideas seems like it would have the best effect over the long run.
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise


That sounds perfect. Finding a way to make guys learn less XO just gives the guys who were here the first 2 seasons that much bigger advantage.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
I just don't understand why parity is trying to be forced by punishing the good teams. The only thing that has to be done is allow more than 1 team to move up and down in each division and it will solve all these problems, reward the good teams and give the bad motivation to get better and the problem is solved.

If everyone goes .500 every season then what is the point?


This idea is not "punishing good teams," as keeps coming up as an argument. It's encouraging good players who play in crappy divisions where they have no business playing to try and find somebody their own size to pick on.

Everyone who doesn't like any of these ideas: You're honestly going to tell me that you would be ok with it if you got a new team in Eastern Europe CCC #4, where you start with some Lv 6 CPU's, and some team of lv 50's wants to come in and beat you up?

Honestly, I think the fact that this is met with dissent is proof that it strikes exactly where I thought it would: where people care. People don't seem to care much about cash, but DON'T TOUCH MY XP! That's why I think something involving XP would be so effective as a "gentle encouragement" to play in the way that we would like.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

This idea is not "punishing good teams," as keeps coming up as an argument. It's encouraging good players who play in crappy divisions where they have no business playing to try and find somebody their own size to pick on.

Everyone who doesn't like any of these ideas: You're honestly going to tell me that you would be ok with it if you got a new team in Eastern Europe CCC #4, where you start with some Lv 6 CPU's, and some team of lv 50's wants to come in and beat you up?

Honestly, I think the fact that this is met with dissent is proof that it strikes exactly where I thought it would: where people care. People don't seem to care much about cash, but DON'T TOUCH MY XP! That's why I think something involving XP would be so effective as a "gentle encouragement" to play in the way that we would like.


I think you have the right idea with the recent "first season" level caps.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Bort is totally right. The more some complain without arguments, the more weight this measure will have.
 
LordMortis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

I just don't understand why parity is trying to be forced by punishing the good teams. The only thing that has to be done is allow more than 1 team to move up and down in each division and it will solve all these problems, reward the good teams and give the bad motivation to get better and the problem is solved.

If everyone goes .500 every season then what is the point?


This idea is not "punishing good teams," as keeps coming up as an argument. It's encouraging good players who play in crappy divisions where they have no business playing to try and find somebody their own size to pick on.

Everyone who doesn't like any of these ideas: You're honestly going to tell me that you would be ok with it if you got a new team in Eastern Europe CCC #4, where you start with some Lv 6 CPU's, and some team of lv 50's wants to come in and beat you up?

Honestly, I think the fact that this is met with dissent is proof that it strikes exactly where I thought it would: where people care. People don't seem to care much about cash, but DON'T TOUCH MY XP! That's why I think something involving XP would be so effective as a "gentle encouragement" to play in the way that we would like.



Perhaps XP punishment should work by team comparison in division then and not by team to team comparison. If the goal is to keep a higher level team out of a lower tiered division then this would make more sense to me and de emphasize a single lower leveled team from making you TOUCH ME XP while at the same time would really curb someone from putting a level 50 set of players into a new league.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.