Originally posted by Daddy Warbucks
People who think there is an x factor don't have a good argument.
End of story.
Comparing two players is pointless unless they're the same player in the same game, same scheme, same opponent with the same players and you get the same randomly generated numbers on every one of your same play calls at the same time in the game with the same amount of points scored and the same amount of success/failure offensively as well as the same amount of success/failure on defense for both teams.
And even in that case, one game is a tiny sample size. You'd need to replicate the test over and over again to get even remotely accurate data.I have two OTs that play the same position on the same team the since season 7:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=329551http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=329702The guy with less pancakes actually have +3 strength/+4 blocking/+3 agility than the OT with more pancakes. The guy with more pancakes has 10 more vision (but that hasn't always been the case). Anyhow, their builds are very similar, but the results are just not the same. The OT with more pancakes play a bit more than the other OT (about 20% more), but he gets a lot more pancakes.
I have also see guys put up huge numbers and then when I see the build it's not all that special (ie. a lot other guys has similar builds, but just not the same production). There has to be a X factor somewhere.