User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Oh please god don't lol, but you can send your WR to Stockholm


lol, ALMOST
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
I've said it before: Bort is obviously a smart guy but he makes some really bad business decisions. The fact that he gave some users access to some tools that gave them a massive advantage over others without putting in some controls or providing full disclosure was a big one.

Since he can't undo that, he now needs to be doing damage control. That means not just providing a solution moving forward, as he has done, but realizing that his customer base is upset and angry and apologizing to them, not treating them like dirt and either condoning or instructing his mods to crush any discussion of the matter.

Bort - be a man (and a businessman) and admit to your customer base that you handled this badly and you apologize. Disclose why you did things that way and disclose how testers were chosen (I for one, amvery interested in that. From purely a personal standpoint, I have played this game from the early days of "beta" and have made several suggestions that have been implemented in both the sim mechanics and that have become major features of the game. If a contributor like me was not approached to test, who were these people and what criteria did you use?)


Drifter,

This is purely conjecture, but I would assume, and this might be the way I do things, is to go and see,

A. who has a good grasp on the game based on posts in the bugs/FAQ thread etc,

B. double check those against the FFA,TT, and other forums to see who just stirs up shit, etc,

Any remaining, vet them even more with a questionnairre, and you have your testers.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Originally posted by sjmay

Oh please god don't lol, but you can send your WR to Stockholm


lol, ALMOST


Damn lol
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by drifter

I've said it before: Bort is obviously a smart guy but he makes some really bad business decisions. The fact that he gave some users access to some tools that gave them a massive advantage over others without putting in some controls or providing full disclosure was a big one.

Since he can't undo that, he now needs to be doing damage control. That means not just providing a solution moving forward, as he has done, but realizing that his customer base is upset and angry and apologizing to them, not treating them like dirt and either condoning or instructing his mods to crush any discussion of the matter.

Bort - be a man (and a businessman) and admit to your customer base that you handled this badly and you apologize. Disclose why you did things that way and disclose how testers were chosen (I for one, amvery interested in that. From purely a personal standpoint, I have played this game from the early days of "beta" and have made several suggestions that have been implemented in both the sim mechanics and that have become major features of the game. If a contributor like me was not approached to test, who were these people and what criteria did you use?)


Drifter,

This is purely conjecture, but I would assume, and this might be the way I do things, is to go and see,

A. who has a good grasp on the game based on posts in the bugs/FAQ thread etc,

B. double check those against the FFA,TT, and other forums to see who just stirs up shit, etc,

Any remaining, vet them even more with a questionnairre, and you have your testers.


No doubt - but wouldn't the guy who suggested the things that have become the advanced energy situational overrides, the VA points and the soon to be implemented lockerroom attributes as well as the guy who provided the logic for the algorithm that fixed some (not all) of the issues with long range pathing a couple seasons back, fall into that category?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by drifter


I've said it before: Bort is obviously a smart guy but he makes some really bad business decisions. The fact that he gave some users access to some tools that gave them a massive advantage over others without putting in some controls or providing full disclosure was a big one.

Since he can't undo that, he now needs to be doing damage control. That means not just providing a solution moving forward, as he has done, but realizing that his customer base is upset and angry and apologizing to them, not treating them like dirt and either condoning or instructing his mods to crush any discussion of the matter.

Bort - be a man (and a businessman) and admit to your customer base that you handled this badly and you apologize. Disclose why you did things that way and disclose how testers were chosen (I for one, amvery interested in that. From purely a personal standpoint, I have played this game from the early days of "beta" and have made several suggestions that have been implemented in both the sim mechanics and that have become major features of the game. If a contributor like me was not approached to test, who were these people and what criteria did you use?)


Drifter,

This is purely conjecture, but I would assume, and this might be the way I do things, is to go and see,

A. who has a good grasp on the game based on posts in the bugs/FAQ thread etc,

B. double check those against the FFA,TT, and other forums to see who just stirs up shit, etc,

Any remaining, vet them even more with a questionnairre, and you have your testers.


No doubt - but wouldn't the guy who suggested the things that have become the advanced energy situational overrides, the VA points and the soon to be implemented lockerroom attributes as well as the guy who provided the logic for the algorithm that fixed some (not all) of the issues with long range pathing a couple seasons back, fall into that category?


True, true,

But on the other hand, and not that I can prove it with the forum search But wouldn't any poster of CPL be apart of that 2nd group? lol

I don't know how much of a shit disturber you are, I don't know you from jack in fact, but any posts that cause trouble, would disqualify anyone in my game, from being a tester,

Having said that let me reiterate, I don't know if you are or have ever been a shit disturber in this game, it is very possible to contribute great ideas, and cause shit
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by drifter



I've said it before: Bort is obviously a smart guy but he makes some really bad business decisions. The fact that he gave some users access to some tools that gave them a massive advantage over others without putting in some controls or providing full disclosure was a big one.

Since he can't undo that, he now needs to be doing damage control. That means not just providing a solution moving forward, as he has done, but realizing that his customer base is upset and angry and apologizing to them, not treating them like dirt and either condoning or instructing his mods to crush any discussion of the matter.

Bort - be a man (and a businessman) and admit to your customer base that you handled this badly and you apologize. Disclose why you did things that way and disclose how testers were chosen (I for one, amvery interested in that. From purely a personal standpoint, I have played this game from the early days of "beta" and have made several suggestions that have been implemented in both the sim mechanics and that have become major features of the game. If a contributor like me was not approached to test, who were these people and what criteria did you use?)


Drifter,

This is purely conjecture, but I would assume, and this might be the way I do things, is to go and see,

A. who has a good grasp on the game based on posts in the bugs/FAQ thread etc,

B. double check those against the FFA,TT, and other forums to see who just stirs up shit, etc,

Any remaining, vet them even more with a questionnairre, and you have your testers.


No doubt - but wouldn't the guy who suggested the things that have become the advanced energy situational overrides, the VA points and the soon to be implemented lockerroom attributes as well as the guy who provided the logic for the algorithm that fixed some (not all) of the issues with long range pathing a couple seasons back, fall into that category?


True, true,

But on the other hand, and not that I can prove it with the forum search But wouldn't any poster of CPL be apart of that 2nd group? lol

I don't know how much of a shit disturber you are, I don't know you from jack in fact, but any posts that cause trouble, would disqualify anyone in my game, from being a tester,

Having said that let me reiterate, I don't know if you are or have ever been a shit disturber in this game, it is very possible to contribute great ideas, and cause shit


I won't say I haven't made waves - but always in the interest of making this game better. I never cause crap just for the sake of causing trouble.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
I tried then lol, got no idea how they picked testers, just laying it out there how I would have done.
Last edited Feb 14, 2009 02:32:10
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
from my experience on the test server I will tell you this.....speed is a good attribute for WR's.

You'll thank me later
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
LMAO
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
i've been drinking
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Has the actual time frame in which these people had access to the test server been disclosed?

I have a post made on a public forum, where someone posted the builds of every player on an entire team that they were not associated with in any way. Not only were the vast majority of the builds closed to all but teammates, but a number of them have been confirmed to have been entirely closed at that time.

When I pursued this through admins I was told it was being handled and never given any real indication of how that information was gathered or exactly how it was being dealt with.

At the time I was more then willing to let it lie, but after this...

So, has anyone come out and said when people first were given access to this server?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Apparently the consensus is Feb 1st, but then again, this is from people who think that the testing is new.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
I will name some of the other testers before I go:
1) http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=611
2) http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=48757
3) http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=3553
4) http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=1751
5) since feb 4th http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=2248

trust me. None of these gentlemen learned anything that give them or their teams an advantage over others.

PM them repeatedly if you have more questions regarding the test servers.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
LMAO man you are living up to your name tonight.
 
Keiichi
offline
Link
 
What happened to the original thread that was going last night? It's morning here and now it's gone.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.