User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
Why would Bort release a list of people on the test server to a bunch of angry people?


Cuz it needs done.
 
C37
offline
Link
 
yes, the cover up is worse than the crime
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by jrry32

But they wouldn't be as pissed off


Lol. Yes they would.


Yet you choose to ignore the other parts of the post where I pointed out to you that we would be in the same place now except without all the deleted threads.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Catullus 16

the main issue here was that the server was secret.

if there had been full disclosure from the get-go, this wouldn't be an issue. if the server really is a non-advantage, prove it to us and we'll believe you... but if you constantly/consistently hide things, what are we to think?

in other words, it won't work for you testers to keep claiming that the test server is to no advantage until you explain why it was secret in the first place.

i repeat: the main issue here was that the server was secret.


Well said.


Wasn't a secret that there was a test server. Bort has mentioned test servers from the beginning of this game being released to the public. The only thing that might be construed as a secret was the fact that there were non developers with access to this test server that were testing the game.

This thread seriously makes me laugh. I'm on teams with numerous moderators and not once have I ever seen them share any super secret information.

Conspiracy theories ftl
 
fuller7586
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
Why would Bort release a list of people on the test server to a bunch of angry people?


Yea this wont happen. I just want to know if the testers can test unlimited amounts of builds.
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fuller7586
Regardless of how this turns out it hurt the integrity of the game.

indeed

 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AgentTBC
Originally posted by Thorn

Originally posted by britdevine316

Do you not see how huge of an advantage the test server is

Yes, it is a huge advantage for the entire community. Allowing us to get most bugs and balanced figured out before things go live is a huge advantage. I'm glad you can see this.
-Thorn

I've been in your position; it's easy to get defensive because you know most people are trying to help the game as best they can and thus ignore the very real potential for abuse this provides the testers. I hope you don't fall into that trap.

The thing you and the mods are ignoring is that it is possible to both actively want to improve the game and work towards that goal AND to use knowledge you gain on a test server to gain an unfair advantage for your players and possibly your friends.

If you run a lot of tests on various builds and it turns out that increasing vision on a halfback from 40 to 70 provides very little improvement in performance (note: NUMBERS MADE UP) you can't forget that information when building your player. If you have a halfback, you're going to put those points somewhere else. Someone who isn't a tester won't have that inside information any may "waste" those points.

You can't handwave that away by addressing only the crazy ranters.


Again, great post and point.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by AgentTBC

Excellent, thanks.

I posted in another thread that I've been involved in online games (MMORPGs, etc) in one way or another for most of two decades. Some of that was in a dev-like environment where I had access to the game code and such. With that background, I can guarantee you that you're underestimating how many people are using knowledge they are getting to their advantage.

I'm not saying they're going out of their way to cheat or anything; I'm saying that they will have done things like test two players with virtually the same stats except one has 30 more vision or 30 more confidence than the other, and they will have seen how much better the guy with extra vision plays. Then they'll have mentioned to their friends, in passing, "hey vision really is underrated/overrated" at that position", and their friends will know they're basing this on first-hand knowledge.

Is that absolutely game-breaking? No. Are you underplaying the potential and actuality of abuse? Almost certainly. It doesn't matter how honest the testers are; if they're also players they'll use it to their advantage, in a major way or a minor one.

The way to lessen than is to keep logs of all the tests they run. Somebody constantly testing how players with 200 strength, agility, and speed will break the game are not finding advantages. Testers who are running a lot of sims where players are similar but some have slightly higher of various stats ARE finding advantages. It's not that hard to tell; take it from me, I used to find people doing similar things.

My guess is that nobody is bothering to do that sort of oversight.



Good Post AgentTBC..

Anyone testing software has an advantage over those that aren't involved in the testing.. If you don't think they do, your either very naive or don't want to admit it. Having been a software tester and programmer for over 3 decades (30yrs), I can guarantee you that I learned more about the software, how it works, what doesn't work and how to exploit its logic.

Thus all of the testers have an advantage over those that don't. period. And they say all they want that they don't but they are just flat out lying.
 
C37
offline
Link
 
nice to know why these mod coalitions with level 30s constantly beat level 40 filled teams
servergate
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
i just think this is a massive thing -

it seems clear that there is inside information that CERTAINLY gives some advantage in either player builds or tactics...

so how many testers are there? based on that number; how many teams are affected?


Picking only on Norsemanvike - (simple because he was the closest guy to check)

he owns 1 team and GM's 16...


So he is involved with 17 teams....

now pretend that is average (it's probably too high for average; but pretend)

30 testers - 17 teams each - over 500 teams getting access to whatever 'advanced' knowledge there is...

not to mention things like were VETERAN ABILITIES tested on the test server?? while us schmoe's were wasting points in clutch and others......testers got full use of their since they got to play with them


I'd like to respond to some of these.

Of the teams that I GM, I am only active in 1 regarding all aspects. Most of the others I'm there to consult with finances, and player management (not build advice) and a few more are for the sole purpose of causing banter in the team forum.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crawlins
No matter what a Mod posts in this thread...or even if it is fair or unfair...the fact remains there are many people who feel let down by this information and it is not good when customers are unhappy. And it is REALLY not good when the unhappy customers are met with argumentative mods on why the customer is wrong.



Mods are you reading this?
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by Catullus 16

the main issue here was that the server was secret.
if there had been full disclosure from the get-go, this wouldn't be an issue. if the server really is a non-advantage, prove it to us and we'll believe you... but if you constantly/consistently hide things, what are we to think?
in other words, it won't work for you testers to keep claiming that the test server is to no advantage until you explain why it was secret in the first place.
i repeat: the main issue here was that the server was secret.

The server wasn't a secret.


um... WHAT?!?Originally posted by Voltron

Because the test server wasn't suppose to be public info.



hahahahaha

voltron 1
voltron's alter ego 0
 
Skeptikal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
So basically I can create any type of player I want, say I wanted to make this guy

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=730931


So I make him and play him for a few games

Then I want to cap his carry + conf in the test server, so I make a whole new player just like that but with capped carry and conf. Then I test him and see if he performs better.


HOW THE FUCK IS THAT NOT A HUGE ADVANTAGE


 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron

The server wasn't a secret.


Originally posted by Voltron

Because the test server wasn't suppose to be public info.


DOH!
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by britdevine316


Do you not see how huge of an advantage the test server is


Yes, it is a huge advantage for the entire community. Allowing us to get most bugs and balanced figured out before things go live is a huge advantage. I'm glad you can see this.
-Thorn


Were VA's tested, different builds tested, situations tested, SA's tested?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.