when you think about it CBs are made to cover, stick, keep thier reciver, thier not suppost to be these returner speed demons, and when you think about it, an int return and a PR/KR are two totally diffrent things
Forum > Suggestions > CB return specialist skill
Randisco
offline
offline
Originally posted by rockstrr
when you think about it CBs are made to cover, stick, keep thier reciver, thier not suppost to be these returner speed demons, and when you think about it, an int return and a PR/KR are two totally diffrent things
noted, but the way the sim was built was that CBs have the KR/PR specialist SA, thus using the confines of the game they can be made to be a returner speed demon
a lot of this chain echoes a desire to see if that SA works or if they have plans to make it work as those of us who have spent time and money making a return specialist would like to know if we should either retire the player or shift their builds
when you think about it CBs are made to cover, stick, keep thier reciver, thier not suppost to be these returner speed demons, and when you think about it, an int return and a PR/KR are two totally diffrent things
noted, but the way the sim was built was that CBs have the KR/PR specialist SA, thus using the confines of the game they can be made to be a returner speed demon
a lot of this chain echoes a desire to see if that SA works or if they have plans to make it work as those of us who have spent time and money making a return specialist would like to know if we should either retire the player or shift their builds
Serenity
offline
offline
Originally posted by Randisco
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue
That's probably a great call.
Thanks Serenity,
so is this saying pretty much we should stop any and all CB builds as a return specialist? is this the insider info?
do you or Bort think this will be addressed in the upcoming seasons?
cheers
Well I seem to remember saying that one of the reasons that CB's have the return specialist skill is to make up for the fact that they lack any SA's that allow them to fake out other players.
The main reason I'm not going to use a CB as a returner is that to do so they work on skills that have no benefit on playing defense thus becoming somewhat of a liability at times.
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue

That's probably a great call.
Thanks Serenity,
so is this saying pretty much we should stop any and all CB builds as a return specialist? is this the insider info?
do you or Bort think this will be addressed in the upcoming seasons?
cheers
Well I seem to remember saying that one of the reasons that CB's have the return specialist skill is to make up for the fact that they lack any SA's that allow them to fake out other players.
The main reason I'm not going to use a CB as a returner is that to do so they work on skills that have no benefit on playing defense thus becoming somewhat of a liability at times.
pahs1994
offline
offline
+1
I was just thinking about the skill being used for interception returns today. I just spent points on return abilities because my team was using me for returns. 2 days later our new DC took me off of the KR duties. It would be nice if i didn't waste my points on nothing
I was just thinking about the skill being used for interception returns today. I just spent points on return abilities because my team was using me for returns. 2 days later our new DC took me off of the KR duties. It would be nice if i didn't waste my points on nothing
Randisco
offline
offline
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by Randisco
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue
That's probably a great call.
Thanks Serenity,
so is this saying pretty much we should stop any and all CB builds as a return specialist? is this the insider info?
do you or Bort think this will be addressed in the upcoming seasons?
cheers
Well I seem to remember saying that one of the reasons that CB's have the return specialist skill is to make up for the fact that they lack any SA's that allow them to fake out other players.
The main reason I'm not going to use a CB as a returner is that to do so they work on skills that have no benefit on playing defense thus becoming somewhat of a liability at times.
I agree that to have a CB as a returner you definitely have to work on skills that are not traditional for a CB (Carrying for example), however I think that is the draw to building a specialist player... you are devoting the build to something that is a rarity. Those stats along with the Kick Returner SA should make a formidable combo. I guess my real question, and one that i think has been asked before in this chain, is if the Kick Returner SA actually does anything. Some say it is broken and will not be fixed, if so, that is rough and i will adjust the build of my player. However if it is not, then all hope is not lost and we will just have to look into the PR pathing issue and everything should be fine.
i think the other question that started this chain, but was not directly dealt with, was if the Returner SA increased the returners ability on interceptions.
do you have any insight into either of those questions (does the KR SA actually work, and does it/will it help with interceptions)?
many thanks for taking the time
cheers
Originally posted by Randisco
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue

That's probably a great call.
Thanks Serenity,
so is this saying pretty much we should stop any and all CB builds as a return specialist? is this the insider info?
do you or Bort think this will be addressed in the upcoming seasons?
cheers
Well I seem to remember saying that one of the reasons that CB's have the return specialist skill is to make up for the fact that they lack any SA's that allow them to fake out other players.
The main reason I'm not going to use a CB as a returner is that to do so they work on skills that have no benefit on playing defense thus becoming somewhat of a liability at times.
I agree that to have a CB as a returner you definitely have to work on skills that are not traditional for a CB (Carrying for example), however I think that is the draw to building a specialist player... you are devoting the build to something that is a rarity. Those stats along with the Kick Returner SA should make a formidable combo. I guess my real question, and one that i think has been asked before in this chain, is if the Kick Returner SA actually does anything. Some say it is broken and will not be fixed, if so, that is rough and i will adjust the build of my player. However if it is not, then all hope is not lost and we will just have to look into the PR pathing issue and everything should be fine.
i think the other question that started this chain, but was not directly dealt with, was if the Returner SA increased the returners ability on interceptions.
do you have any insight into either of those questions (does the KR SA actually work, and does it/will it help with interceptions)?
many thanks for taking the time
cheers
whoshotjr
offline
offline
My only comment is that if everything continues the same, the skill will be more worthless next year.
- PR for CBs have been largely broken for 1.5 seasons now**
- KR will become broken as more kickers reach higher levels. The top kickers are already putting most if not all their kickoffs out the back of the endzone.
** Assumes higher levels, even competition, and properly configured PR coverage teams. Just putting this in for the "works great for my guy" mensas. On rare occasions you may get lucky and break 2 or 3 tackles for a good return, but that does not mean there is not a problem
- PR for CBs have been largely broken for 1.5 seasons now**
- KR will become broken as more kickers reach higher levels. The top kickers are already putting most if not all their kickoffs out the back of the endzone.
** Assumes higher levels, even competition, and properly configured PR coverage teams. Just putting this in for the "works great for my guy" mensas. On rare occasions you may get lucky and break 2 or 3 tackles for a good return, but that does not mean there is not a problem
tjsexkitten82
offline
offline
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue
Can you please PLEASE bring this up on the mod board? I mean, the fact that WR and HBs are so NOTABLY better at returning just proves that this SA needs to be reformed. And this suggestion to make the SA more functional should be incorporated.
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue

Can you please PLEASE bring this up on the mod board? I mean, the fact that WR and HBs are so NOTABLY better at returning just proves that this SA needs to be reformed. And this suggestion to make the SA more functional should be incorporated.
Adderfist
offline
offline
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue
Can you please PLEASE bring this up on the mod board? I mean, the fact that WR and HBs are so NOTABLY better at returning just proves that this SA needs to be reformed. And this suggestion to make the SA more functional should be incorporated.
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue

Can you please PLEASE bring this up on the mod board? I mean, the fact that WR and HBs are so NOTABLY better at returning just proves that this SA needs to be reformed. And this suggestion to make the SA more functional should be incorporated.
Skanker irl
offline
offline
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue
Can you please PLEASE bring this up on the mod board? I mean, the fact that WR and HBs are so NOTABLY better at returning just proves that this SA needs to be reformed. And this suggestion to make the SA more functional should be incorporated.
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by Serenity
I'm planning on using a WR or HB as a returner when I get my team partly because of this issue

Can you please PLEASE bring this up on the mod board? I mean, the fact that WR and HBs are so NOTABLY better at returning just proves that this SA needs to be reformed. And this suggestion to make the SA more functional should be incorporated.
Skanker irl
offline
offline
Originally posted by littlemac820
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by tjking82
bump
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by tjking82
bump
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























