User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
Page:
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Consider the lvl 5 QB here the 14 yr old QB, and the lvl 15 QB a college QB. Bort's point was that the lvl 5 QB on average shouldnt be putting up the same kind of numbers that the lvl 15 QB is, and thats what they were doing. It has nothing to do with the defenses they are playing.

Yes if that lvl 5 has lvl 5+ WRs and is playing a team full of 1s and 2s he should be able to put up high numbers, but if you put the lvl 15 in the same situation his numbers should be significantly superior due to him having better physical skills and vision. The lvl 5 is still apt to throw errant passes, or miss a read, whereas the lvl 15 should have it happening near as often.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by methomps


What plan? I didn't say today's results should be the norm. But it also isn't true that a lvl 50 QB going against a lvl 50 D should necessarily have the same completion % as a level 5 QB going against a lvl 5 D. The level 5 QB should make more errant throws not tied to level of competition.


I never said anything about a level 50 QB vs. a level 5 QB. I made a comment about QB vs RB.



And I said its not true that the RB should be running for less yards. Low-level QBs in real life make unforced errors that result in incompletions (for example, overthrowing a WR). That is a mistake that isn't dependent on the level of competition. Thus, a higher-level QB might have a higher completion % even if he is still facing competition that is at his same level.

Short of RBs tripping over their feet, what mechanism would you say would cause lvl 5 RBs to only have 2 ypc against lvl 5 defenses?


You are really paying attention to what I am saying. I'm not arguing with what you are saying. I am saying this will lead to teams going very run heavy. Is that really what we want to see?
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
Consider the lvl 5 QB here the 14 yr old QB, and the lvl 15 QB a college QB. Bort's point was that the lvl 5 QB on average shouldnt be putting up the same kind of numbers that the lvl 15 QB is, and thats what they were doing. It has nothing to do with the defenses they are playing.

Yes if that lvl 5 has lvl 5+ WRs and is playing a team full of 1s and 2s he should be able to put up high numbers, but if you put the lvl 15 in the same situation his numbers should be significantly superior due to him having better physical skills and vision. The lvl 5 is still apt to throw errant passes, or miss a read, whereas the lvl 15 should have it happening near as often.


ok agreed...but it was too drastic of a change...i see pop warner qbs throw better percentages then 30%....and i dunno i guess that is how i feel...if a qb regardless of lvl 5 or lvl 80...you have a wide open reciever and time in the pocket to eat chunky soup...then you should be able to complete the pass...not throw it 20 yards short and into the sideline.
Last edited May 2, 2008 19:39:06
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
I know exactly where you are coming from wombat, but that is how football is at even a basic level. Running is just easier to be successful with because there is less of a chance for error. In the NFL, 90% of your teams live and die by the run for exactly this reason. Some teams are VERY successful with a heavy passing game, but its not the norm. Bort is trying to make GLB as realistic as possible, so while im sure everyone would like to be able to have an insane passing game, i am fine with them making it more likely for teams to be heavy on the run, and going to a pass heavy offense being a risk and not really advisable without a large pool of exceptional talent on your team.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
I feel ya, but it has happened, and it even happens in the NFL occasionally. I do agree with you that it was a bit overboard, and obviously Bort seceded on the issue because he understood our pov, but it seems a lot of people are overlooking the stuff i pointed out and dont have your same sense of logic
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer


You are really paying attention to what I am saying. I'm not arguing with what you are saying. I am saying this will lead to teams going very run heavy. Is that really what we want to see?


I'm not saying low-level QBs have to be as bad as they were today. But what if we do make it so that today's QBs can perform at a high level of accuracy. As they get better, are they going to become perfect to where ONLY defensive players can cause an incompletion?
 
gnus
offline
Link
 
I think everyone is pretty hopeful that the changeback should help somewhat with the abyssmal completion percentages.

However, has anyone figured out why teams in 0-0 games started hucking the rock as much as possible in the 1st quarter, regardless of Run/Pass ratios? We were set run heavy and threw 30 vs 13 in the first half. No setting should have put us in the position and I've seen multiple posts on this but still haven't seen where anyone has addressed it.

Thanks.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
I'm against anything that is going to turn this game one dimensional on offense.
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
I know exactly where you are coming from wombat, but that is how football is at even a basic level. Running is just easier to be successful with because there is less of a chance for error. In the NFL, 90% of your teams live and die by the run for exactly this reason. Some teams are VERY successful with a heavy passing game, but its not the norm. Bort is trying to make GLB as realistic as possible, so while im sure everyone would like to be able to have an insane passing game, i am fine with them making it more likely for teams to be heavy on the run, and going to a pass heavy offense being a risk and not really advisable without a large pool of exceptional talent on your team.


see i agree 100%...i was just stating which was obviously fixed...that it shouldn't be too drastic of a change...i mean you can't have any qb throwing a 18% completion rate...lol
 
gnus
offline
Link
 
edit for double post
Last edited May 2, 2008 20:02:36
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Wombat dont forget that there is still a lot to be added to the game as far as offensive customization goes. We dont even call our own plays or decide what players go in on certain packages yet. Once we can do that im sure the game will take on a totally new dimension, and while you still probably wont be able to go all out passing, you will be able to have an effective pass game when it is set up properly.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
I dont think anything official has been said about that yet gnus. The other issues with pass quality and faulty sub ins have had the widest spread effect on people so i think they were focused on taking care of those.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
Wombat dont forget that there is still a lot to be added to the game as far as offensive customization goes. We dont even call our own plays or decide what players go in on certain packages yet. Once we can do that im sure the game will take on a totally new dimension, and while you still probably wont be able to go all out passing, you will be able to have an effective pass game when it is set up properly.



This may be true, but for as long as passing effectiveness is going to be worse than running, people will stop passing. I'm sure teams will gladly take their 3 or 4 yards a rush vs. a 35% completion rate with interceptions. Obviously if things are changed and this isn't the case, people will go back to passing.
 
oukurt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bountytaker
How many players who had the pass/run ratio go wacky, with their QB's throwing terribly, tried the new advanced substitution tactics first?

We did...and we threw almost 60 passes, completed only 7, and were set VERY run heavy.


Same here. Scrap these games and play them over after fixing the bug. No way these games should count.
 
claystone
offline
Link
 
Yes, Bort change the passing setting back to the way it was.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.