User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by vrshah

Originally posted by Bort


It's pretty hard to program AI as to when it's "safe" to go for the pick as to a PD, etc.

I mean, it's easy for us to look at it and say "he shoulda gone for it" but you have turn that into a discrete set of rules the computer can follow.




So the sim has a calculation that tells it based on a CB's attributes and setings, whether or not there will be a PBU or INT or the WR getting wide open.

Make it so someone with 11 supervision can calculate to say 80% of accuracy the percent chances of the PBU, the INT, or the WR beating the CB that the sim itself would calculate (so it's like seeing the future 80% accurately) and then make a decision based on that calculation and coverage settings.


So for a given play where the CB would be guranteed 100% that he will get an INT, a CB with 11 supervision will calculate that he has 80% chance to intercept the ball...etc. and then switch or retain the coverage setting based on that.


I think that's way too strong, and at the very least should have other vectors in the calculation (confidence?)

In real life, a CB doesn't know his chances when he jumps a rooute, he just thinks he can make a play and goes for it. If he is good, he makes it. Set it for aggressive if you are good at it, and take your chances. The picks will pay for themselves. Even on aggressive, they don't jump EVERY route...


But a good CB has a pretty good idea, whether or not he can make the pick. Because if he whiffs, he ends up giving up a huge play.

So yeah, maybe they don't have a certain percentage in their head, but they do have a good idea on when they can make the INT, compared to when they can't.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rocklee711
A question I've had that I'm not sure has been answered or not is this:

In the old Medium Coverage, basically it was switched to playing loose essentially if there was no help over the top.

My question is what exactly constitutes "help over the top?" Does a safety or another CB need to be directly behind the CB or does that mean he can have help with a certain radius?

For example, in a game I had today, I played a lot more Cover 2 man to put safeties over the top of my CB's... thinking that would constitute "help over the top" but in some situations the CB's played too loose with that coverage.



Also, I do agree, I'm hoping Vision/Supervision allows DB's that play on either Medium/Semi-aggressive to make their own calculations in terms of whether or not they make a break on the ball to either just deflect it or go for the int.


They have to be within a certain distance to "count" - a guy 40 yards away doesn't count as over the top even if he's behind him.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
After looking at the description of the new tactic, i still say it should just go back to how it was. The whole "play loose" seems to be the problem. With aggresive, to often the CB steps in front of the reciever and freezes as the ball goes over his head, with the old medium the CB stayed tight on the WR with the occasional step up and freeze thing (as if they were on aggresive). With the new medium the CB plays way too far off. I was under the impression that the fix was supposed to cut out that whole step in front thing while on medium, im pretty sure thats what the original complaint was about. The way these changes are shaping up id rather have my teams CBs on the old medium with the occasional step in front. I dont EVER want my CBs "playing loose" and i dont want them to ever "dont worry about the INT". With the exception of the occasional step up and freeze, the old medium was just fine. Id say at this point the best course of action would be to just go back.


he really could have just kept three choices and removed the loose option and made the new medium that one...
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY
Originally posted by odg62

After looking at the description of the new tactic, i still say it should just go back to how it was. The whole "play loose" seems to be the problem. With aggresive, to often the CB steps in front of the reciever and freezes as the ball goes over his head, with the old medium the CB stayed tight on the WR with the occasional step up and freeze thing (as if they were on aggresive). With the new medium the CB plays way too far off. I was under the impression that the fix was supposed to cut out that whole step in front thing while on medium, im pretty sure thats what the original complaint was about. The way these changes are shaping up id rather have my teams CBs on the old medium with the occasional step in front. I dont EVER want my CBs "playing loose" and i dont want them to ever "dont worry about the INT". With the exception of the occasional step up and freeze, the old medium was just fine. Id say at this point the best course of action would be to just go back.


he really could have just kept three choices and removed the loose option and made the new medium that one...


There may be some folks who want loose...don't nerf other peoples CBs just because they aren't here. Thats what led us to this point
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY
Originally posted by odg62

After looking at the description of the new tactic, i still say it should just go back to how it was. The whole "play loose" seems to be the problem. With aggresive, to often the CB steps in front of the reciever and freezes as the ball goes over his head, with the old medium the CB stayed tight on the WR with the occasional step up and freeze thing (as if they were on aggresive). With the new medium the CB plays way too far off. I was under the impression that the fix was supposed to cut out that whole step in front thing while on medium, im pretty sure thats what the original complaint was about. The way these changes are shaping up id rather have my teams CBs on the old medium with the occasional step in front. I dont EVER want my CBs "playing loose" and i dont want them to ever "dont worry about the INT". With the exception of the occasional step up and freeze, the old medium was just fine. Id say at this point the best course of action would be to just go back.


he really could have just kept three choices and removed the loose option and made the new medium that one...


Yeah, I think everyone is just going to end up playing Aggressive now.

People aren't going to like not being able to pick ANY passes off, on any choice other than Aggressive.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
btw way Bort, thanks for letting us all help with these changes.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
If possible, three separate setting:
1) Coverage distance
2) Coverage style with no help over the top
3) Coverage style with help over the top


Cover distance - Loose, medium, Close

Cover style- Loose, Medium, Semi-aggessive (play from behind but stay tight and on top), aggressive(jump route if possible).


These would cover all needs, I think.


That's not a bad idea. Would require a bit more work to get going and tested, though, since it's a whole new set of variables.

The new setting at least lets you make the guy react like many of you wanted with the old, broken, medium setting, and those who liked the corrected version can use it too.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by odg62


After looking at the description of the new tactic, i still say it should just go back to how it was. The whole "play loose" seems to be the problem. With aggresive, to often the CB steps in front of the reciever and freezes as the ball goes over his head, with the old medium the CB stayed tight on the WR with the occasional step up and freeze thing (as if they were on aggresive). With the new medium the CB plays way too far off. I was under the impression that the fix was supposed to cut out that whole step in front thing while on medium, im pretty sure thats what the original complaint was about. The way these changes are shaping up id rather have my teams CBs on the old medium with the occasional step in front. I dont EVER want my CBs "playing loose" and i dont want them to ever "dont worry about the INT". With the exception of the occasional step up and freeze, the old medium was just fine. Id say at this point the best course of action would be to just go back.


he really could have just kept three choices and removed the loose option and made the new medium that one...


Yeah, I think everyone is just going to end up playing Aggressive now.

People aren't going to like not being able to pick ANY passes off, on any choice other than Aggressive.


They are going to get beat a lot and complain even more. There are too many people that built their CBs wrong (speed heavy).
 
cowcards
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the change Bort. People stop complaining as you got what you want. You've spent all day complaining for this semi aggressive option and now your complaing you want more when you get it. Let Bort get back to improving the game please.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by odg62


After looking at the description of the new tactic, i still say it should just go back to how it was. The whole "play loose" seems to be the problem. With aggresive, to often the CB steps in front of the reciever and freezes as the ball goes over his head, with the old medium the CB stayed tight on the WR with the occasional step up and freeze thing (as if they were on aggresive). With the new medium the CB plays way too far off. I was under the impression that the fix was supposed to cut out that whole step in front thing while on medium, im pretty sure thats what the original complaint was about. The way these changes are shaping up id rather have my teams CBs on the old medium with the occasional step in front. I dont EVER want my CBs "playing loose" and i dont want them to ever "dont worry about the INT". With the exception of the occasional step up and freeze, the old medium was just fine. Id say at this point the best course of action would be to just go back.


he really could have just kept three choices and removed the loose option and made the new medium that one...


There may be some folks who want loose...don't nerf other peoples CBs just because they aren't here. Thats what led us to this point

the new medium looks pretty loose to me. I can't imagine anyone on this game choosing the 4th option now...
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowcards
Thanks for the change Bort. People stop complaining as you got what you want. You've spent all day complaining for this semi aggressive option and now your complaing you want more when you get it. Let Bort get back to improving the game please.


Yes, I think this is good. Thanks, Bort.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
People aren't going to like not being able to pick ANY passes off, on any choice other than Aggressive.


You're still going to see picks. One just happened in a test on the new setting LOL.

A lot of interceptions happen not when the route gets jumped but when the receiver bobbles or tips the ball and the CB's there to pick it up.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

If possible, three separate setting:
1) Coverage distance
2) Coverage style with no help over the top
3) Coverage style with help over the top


Cover distance - Loose, medium, Close

Cover style- Loose, Medium, Semi-aggessive (play from behind but stay tight and on top), aggressive(jump route if possible).


These would cover all needs, I think.


That's not a bad idea. Would require a bit more work to get going and tested, though, since it's a whole new set of variables.

The new setting at least lets you make the guy react like many of you wanted with the old, broken, medium setting, and those who liked the corrected version can use it too.


I think if you could give us back the old "broken" medium setting for now, and work on the three-way for next season, folks would be pretty happy. I know I would

 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

If possible, three separate setting:
1) Coverage distance
2) Coverage style with no help over the top
3) Coverage style with help over the top


Cover distance - Loose, medium, Close

Cover style- Loose, Medium, Semi-aggessive (play from behind but stay tight and on top), aggressive(jump route if possible).


These would cover all needs, I think.


That's not a bad idea. Would require a bit more work to get going and tested, though, since it's a whole new set of variables.

The new setting at least lets you make the guy react like many of you wanted with the old, broken, medium setting, and those who liked the corrected version can use it too.


yeah i do agree that this idea is the best for everyone...as long as vision plays a part in making the right decision.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by odg62


After looking at the description of the new tactic, i still say it should just go back to how it was. The whole "play loose" seems to be the problem. With aggresive, to often the CB steps in front of the reciever and freezes as the ball goes over his head, with the old medium the CB stayed tight on the WR with the occasional step up and freeze thing (as if they were on aggresive). With the new medium the CB plays way too far off. I was under the impression that the fix was supposed to cut out that whole step in front thing while on medium, im pretty sure thats what the original complaint was about. The way these changes are shaping up id rather have my teams CBs on the old medium with the occasional step in front. I dont EVER want my CBs "playing loose" and i dont want them to ever "dont worry about the INT". With the exception of the occasional step up and freeze, the old medium was just fine. Id say at this point the best course of action would be to just go back.


he really could have just kept three choices and removed the loose option and made the new medium that one...


There may be some folks who want loose...don't nerf other peoples CBs just because they aren't here. Thats what led us to this point


No its not what led us to this point, the fact that sometimes CBs on Medium would sometimes look like they were on aggresive is what origanally started all this. And for the people who want loose, the last time i checked there is and always has been a loose setting for the people who want it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.