Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by vrshah
Originally posted by Bort
It's pretty hard to program AI as to when it's "safe" to go for the pick as to a PD, etc.
I mean, it's easy for us to look at it and say "he shoulda gone for it" but you have turn that into a discrete set of rules the computer can follow.
So the sim has a calculation that tells it based on a CB's attributes and setings, whether or not there will be a PBU or INT or the WR getting wide open.
Make it so someone with 11 supervision can calculate to say 80% of accuracy the percent chances of the PBU, the INT, or the WR beating the CB that the sim itself would calculate (so it's like seeing the future 80% accurately) and then make a decision based on that calculation and coverage settings.
So for a given play where the CB would be guranteed 100% that he will get an INT, a CB with 11 supervision will calculate that he has 80% chance to intercept the ball...etc. and then switch or retain the coverage setting based on that.
I think that's way too strong, and at the very least should have other vectors in the calculation (confidence?)
In real life, a CB doesn't know his chances when he jumps a rooute, he just thinks he can make a play and goes for it. If he is good, he makes it. Set it for aggressive if you are good at it, and take your chances. The picks will pay for themselves. Even on aggressive, they don't jump EVERY route...
But a good CB has a pretty good idea, whether or not he can make the pick. Because if he whiffs, he ends up giving up a huge play.
So yeah, maybe they don't have a certain percentage in their head, but they do have a good idea on when they can make the INT, compared to when they can't.
Originally posted by vrshah
Originally posted by Bort
It's pretty hard to program AI as to when it's "safe" to go for the pick as to a PD, etc.
I mean, it's easy for us to look at it and say "he shoulda gone for it" but you have turn that into a discrete set of rules the computer can follow.
So the sim has a calculation that tells it based on a CB's attributes and setings, whether or not there will be a PBU or INT or the WR getting wide open.
Make it so someone with 11 supervision can calculate to say 80% of accuracy the percent chances of the PBU, the INT, or the WR beating the CB that the sim itself would calculate (so it's like seeing the future 80% accurately) and then make a decision based on that calculation and coverage settings.
So for a given play where the CB would be guranteed 100% that he will get an INT, a CB with 11 supervision will calculate that he has 80% chance to intercept the ball...etc. and then switch or retain the coverage setting based on that.
I think that's way too strong, and at the very least should have other vectors in the calculation (confidence?)
In real life, a CB doesn't know his chances when he jumps a rooute, he just thinks he can make a play and goes for it. If he is good, he makes it. Set it for aggressive if you are good at it, and take your chances. The picks will pay for themselves. Even on aggressive, they don't jump EVERY route...
But a good CB has a pretty good idea, whether or not he can make the pick. Because if he whiffs, he ends up giving up a huge play.
So yeah, maybe they don't have a certain percentage in their head, but they do have a good idea on when they can make the INT, compared to when they can't.





























