User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
NutsNutsNutz
offline
Link
 
Snypah
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
I dont like it because people were under the impression that size had very little affect on their performance and my HB is over 200 pounds. It should be by position not size imo
 
MrHitz
offline
Link
 
I like this bort. Because a devin hester say with 80 speed and a 350 pound Dt with 80 speed should not keep up with it, This will really help the game, make it realist
 
SportsFrk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrHitz
I like this bort. Because a devin hester say with 80 speed and a 350 pound Dt with 80 speed should not keep up with it, This will really help the game, make it realist


ic.
 
SportsFrk
offline
Link
 
If this is added, you should be allowed to train and gain or lose weight
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sportsfrk51790
If this is added, you should be allowed to train and gain or lose weight


he already said he could make that a Normal training option
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Needs tweaking but definitely needed. 270 lb. DE's with 95 speed shouldn't be chasing down 170 lb. WR's even if their speed is the same.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
I dont think this will change anything, because everyone will just make their WR's 159 pounds...and all their other non line players too probably...

STR needs to play a bigger role, it takes a special WR who is less than 160 pounds to make it in the NFL, due to injury and just getting the living shit kicked out of you.

If there are weight classes, you are going to have to REALLY think about how this will affect fumbling, confidence, stamina.... for example:

If you make weight classes, and give a bonus in speed to small guys, there should also be heavy penalties if you should happen to get hit by a big guy. You should fumble more, lose morale, and probably drop down in energy big time....there needs to be more of a reason to be 190 pounds and a wr....

This change just seems so massive, and a -% to run blocking doesnt make up for the speed/agility boost...there has to be more IMHO.

I think this will just complicate things and lead to more problems than it solves...

A much simpler way would be to say something like:

100 Speed WR runs the 40 in 4.1
100 speed HB runs the 40 in 4.3
100 Speed OL runs the 40 in 4.7

etc...

Then you could make weight do other things like cause fumbles, take away energy when collisions happen, make heavier guys tire faster....other things liek that
Last edited Dec 8, 2008 02:06:17
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I don't like the idea that one player with 100 speed is faster than another player with 100 speed.

Originally posted by TrevJo
Actually, here's a new idea. I think it would be very practical, and would make shorter/taller or lighter/heavier players interesting. Might not work with the idea of players being able to gain or lose weight, though...

The idea:
Change the ability soft caps depending on the height and weight of the player. Actually now that I think about this I don't know why it wasn't done this way in the first place. For example:
Strength - Slightly lower for taller players, much higher for heavier players
Speed soft caps - Slightly higher for taller players, lower for heavier players
Agility soft caps - Lower for taller players, lower for heavier players
Jumping - Slightly higher for taller players, much lower for heavier players
Stamina - Slightly lower for taller players, much lower for heavier players
Vision - Slightly higher for taller players, unaffected by weight
Confidence - Unaffected by height and weight

So for example. Take a player that is 6'2" 220#. Does't matter what his position is. Soft caps might be:
Strength - 48
Speed - 52
Agility - 47
Jumping - 48
Stamina - 48
Vision - 50

On the other hand, a player that is 6'5" 300# might have the following soft caps:
Strength - 60
Speed - 45
Agility - 41
Jumping - 45
Stamina - 44
Vision - 52

And a player that is 5'9" 190# might have the following soft caps:
Strength - 43
Speed - 51
Agility - 57
Jumping - 50
Stamina - 53
Vision - 47

So the soft caps are determined by height and weight. You could have a button next to the rolls (and also on the player page later) where the user can just click it to see what their soft caps are at that height and weight. I think you could incorporate gaining and losing weight by allowing players to adjust their weight until they hit a soft cap. Once they hit a soft cap they are set, which IMO is fairly realistic because you rarely see NFL players change their weight significantly after their rookie year. (The only exception is at the end of careers you often see guys lose weight just because they can't stay fit at heavier weights anymore.)

Meanwhile, the player's automatic level gains are still determined by their position, because of what they do in practice. And with a new system more carefully tuned to each position rather than trying to fit the major/minor system.

So for a WR, automatic level gains something like:
Speed +.4 Catching +.4 Agility +.3 Jumping +.3 Stamina +.3 Vision +.2 Confidence +.2 Carrying +.2 Strength +.1 Blocking +.1 Throwing +.1 Tackling +.1

For a LB, automatic level gains something like:
Tackling +.4 Strength +.3 Agility +.3 Vision +.3 Confidence +.3 Stamina +.2 Jumping +.2 Speed +.2 Catching +.1 Carrying +.1 Blocking +.1

Those might not add up to 3 or whatever, but you get the idea. If you are making big changes, the strict majors/minors system really ought to go.

So if a guy really wants to make a linebacker that is 6'4" and quicker and faster than Randy Moss, he can do it, but it will cost him a lot more SP to do it than the guy who creates a 6'0" WR, and it will cost him even more SP to do it if he also makes the guy 250#.

If you want to re-vamp things, be it for new players only or whatever, in my humble opinion this is the way to do it.


bump
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
I like seeing 90 speed and knowing that 90 is 90. If my opponent has a WR with an open build and 80 speed, I want to know that I can line a player with 80 speed up on him and be okay. I don't want to have to guess at whether I can line a 100 speed LB up on him and be okay.

Further, we built our players under the impression that the values were absolute across positions. To change that now would be to make a mockery of many of our builds. If I invested ALL my SP in agility as a DT, and now you change the game and say that my 100 agility is only worth 50 agility, then I wasted a whole bunch of SP that would have better placed elsewhere.

This isn't the same as making things work the way they're supposed to work. This is changing the players we've created into something we didn't intend them to be.

I think the better way to go about this is to keep fixing the interactions, so that DEs need more strength, vision is more effective, qbs can't throw the ball as far, blocking and catching aren't omnidirectional, etc. etc.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
* if you make the fixes this way, people will build players they way they realistically should be built, and you won't have to obfuscate the game in the process.
 
asdfasdfasdfa
offline
Link
 
Last edited Dec 10, 2008 19:47:28
 
Darth Pinky
offline
Link
 
Last edited Dec 10, 2008 19:47:44
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
Last edited Dec 10, 2008 19:47:32
 
FoF
offline
Link
 
Last edited Dec 10, 2008 19:47:37
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.