User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to help with low down GM's trading away players
Page:
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by Knick

I just looked up the word redundancy in the dictionary and lol'd.


I saw see also: oldskool


I saw a link to this thread.

The whole thing has turn into a complete roundabout discussion about 'Should you give GM's trade powers or not?'

Crazy says add X element and yes.
Oldskool says don't give them the power unless you trust them, X element is superfluous.

I just summed up like 21 pages of posting in to like 4 lines. Go me.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 21:45:00
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
See, that's why I dont like this idea. I have a player on the block, a GM approaches me, we negotiate a deal, agree on it and then a few hours later the owner vetos it. That leaves me back to square one with a ton of time wasted that I could have used to find another trading partner, possibly even leaving me a player short for a game.

Either you give people the authority to make a deal, or you don't. Only give GM powers to people you trust to run things while you are not there.
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick

I just summed up like 21 pages of posting in to like 4 lines. Go me.


Lol. How much further will this thread go before its locked??

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gisty
Originally posted by Knick


I just summed up like 21 pages of posting in to like 4 lines. Go me.


Lol. How much further will this thread go before its locked??



Why should it get locked?

Locks are for breaches of the ToS you agreed to. This thread breaches it 0 times.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 21:46:53
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by crazy454



Originally posted by wombat killer




Just PM your owner the trade and he can send it out. Problem solved.


No because by then the player may have already been traded, in most cases you have to act fast on trades.


And in the time you are giving your owner to approve the trade the other owner can work out another deal and cancel your trade.


No it can't because it is an accepted trade.


The other owner can't veto the trade?


Why would they need to veto a trade they accepted? This is for trades that originate between said other owner and a GM.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gisty
See, that's why I dont like this idea. I have a player on the block, a GM approaches me, we negotiate a deal, agree on it and then a few hours later the owner vetos it. That leaves me back to square one with a ton of time wasted that I could have used to find another trading partner, possibly even leaving me a player short for a game.

Either you give people the authority to make a deal, or you don't. Only give GM powers to people you trust to run things while you are not there.


You have to expect that when dealing with a GM. Even now that could happen, though the window of opportunity is smaller. And are you saying that trust is never broken or abused? It's quite the opposite. That's why this thread exists actually...unless it's a complete crap trade, the owner probably won't cancel it. And it's not like this would be a required option to have on. As an owner, you'd still have the choice to enable it or not.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 21:52:35
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by crazy454



Originally posted by wombat killer




Just PM your owner the trade and he can send it out. Problem solved.


No because by then the player may have already been traded, in most cases you have to act fast on trades.


And in the time you are giving your owner to approve the trade the other owner can work out another deal and cancel your trade.


No it can't because it is an accepted trade.


The other owner can't veto the trade?


yeah have to be a GM to owner trade. GM to GM would probably allow both owners to Veto. And if you wasted time you wasted time either way THE OWNER did not want the trade to go down.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 21:55:28
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
And are you saying that trust is never broken or abused? It's quite the opposite. That's why this thread exists actually...


I know it gets abused, and i understand completely that people get royally screwed over by scummy GMs. But do we really need safety net? Don't give random folks from the internet GM powers and it wont happen. It's not GLB's responsibility to protect YOUR team.

Look at guilds/corps in other MMOs. A guild/corp officer is entitled to do whatever they like once the Guild/corp leader gives them the authority to do so. I've seen all sorts of shenannigans in WoW and Eve, but as the admins there say, "It's not our problem, you gave that player the authority, its your problem".

 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gisty
Originally posted by silenthatred

And are you saying that trust is never broken or abused? It's quite the opposite. That's why this thread exists actually...


I know it gets abused, and i understand completely that people get royally screwed over by scummy GMs. But do we really need safety net? Don't give random folks from the internet GM powers and it wont happen. It's not GLB's responsibility to protect YOUR team.

Look at guilds/corps in other MMOs. A guild/corp officer is entitled to do whatever they like once the Guild/corp leader gives them the authority to do so. I've seen all sorts of shenannigans in WoW and Eve, but as the admins there say, "It's not our problem, you gave that player the authority, its your problem".


So are you saying just take your royally screwed by scummy GMs and deal with it? You don't want the safety net, fine, don't use it. No one is saying this would HAVE TO be enabled for everyone. And this isn't WoW or I wouldn't be playing it. I'll present to you the same post I presented oldskool who ran away from it and decided to reply to something else I said afterwards to someone else and see if you have a response for it. Relevant parts in bold:

I've never been involved with an owner who wasn't active everyday. But yes, since you will have knowledge that this can happen before the fact, it definately falls back on you. Right now you don't have ONE FULL DAY and who the hell can afford to be on this site every single hour of the day? It depends on when the trade is accepted. Oh and maybe it's the technology age in me, but I access this site from my cellphone at times. Hell, the internet connection to type this message is being provided by my cellphone.

And it has nothing to do with time and everything to do with the experience of the game. I mean good god, have you ever played a team sport before? Ever heard the word comradeship? Team building? Two heads are better than one? Logic? Why do you assume that because an owner has GMs, they are lazy, or don't know how to do something, or don't have the time to do something? I actually wouldn't GM for an owner such as the one you are describing, but maybe that's just me.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 22:11:14
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by Gisty

Originally posted by silenthatred


And are you saying that trust is never broken or abused? It's quite the opposite. That's why this thread exists actually...


I know it gets abused, and i understand completely that people get royally screwed over by scummy GMs. But do we really need safety net? Don't give random folks from the internet GM powers and it wont happen. It's not GLB's responsibility to protect YOUR team.

Look at guilds/corps in other MMOs. A guild/corp officer is entitled to do whatever they like once the Guild/corp leader gives them the authority to do so. I've seen all sorts of shenannigans in WoW and Eve, but as the admins there say, "It's not our problem, you gave that player the authority, its your problem".



I'll present to you the same post I presented oldskool who ran away from it and decided to reply to something else I said afterwards to someone else and see if you have a response for it. Relevant parts in bold:

I've never been involved with an owner who wasn't active everyday. But yes, since you will have knowledge that this can happen before the fact, it definately falls back on you. Right now you don't have ONE FULL DAY and who the hell can afford to be on this site every single hour of the day? It depends on when the trade is accepted. Oh and maybe it's the technology age in me, but I access this site from my cellphone at times. Hell, the internet connection to type this message is being provided by my cellphone.

And it has nothing to do with time and everything to do with the experience of the game. I mean good god, have you ever played a team sport before? Ever heard the word comradeship? Team building? Two heads are better than one? Logic? Why do you assume that because an owner has GMs, they are lazy, or don't know how to do something, or don't have the time to do something? I actually wouldn't GM for an owner such as the one you are describing, but maybe that's just me.


Double posts I fail.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 22:09:42
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by silenthatred


Originally posted by wombat killer



Originally posted by crazy454




Originally posted by wombat killer





Just PM your owner the trade and he can send it out. Problem solved.


No because by then the player may have already been traded, in most cases you have to act fast on trades.


And in the time you are giving your owner to approve the trade the other owner can work out another deal and cancel your trade.


No it can't because it is an accepted trade.


The other owner can't veto the trade?


yeah have to be a GM to owner trade. GM to GM would probably allow both owners to Veto. And if you wasted time you wasted time either way THE OWNER did not want the trade to go down.


So like I said, the other owner can work out a new trade while waiting for the other owner to approve. If he had other deals in the works he would just have his GM send it out.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
And it has nothing to do with time and everything to do with the experience of the game. I mean good god, have you ever played a team sport before? Ever heard the word comradeship? Team building? Two heads are better than one? Logic? Why do you assume that because an owner has GMs, they are lazy, or don't know how to do something, or don't have the time to do something? I actually wouldn't GM for an owner such as the one you are describing, but maybe that's just me.


This drew me back into the argument.

I totally agree, the joy of sports comes primarily from being on a team and relying on a team effort to accomplish a shared goal. That's what it's all about.

That's why I myself DO give out GM rights. People aren't saying "Dont give GMs trading rights". They are saying, if you want a ZERO PERCENT chance of a GM fucking your shit up, THEN don't give out the rights. Otherwise, take the chance.

In team sports, you just have to put your faith in the other guys sometimes. Would my teammates show up to games hungover sometimes and let us down? Yeah. And guess what, I didn't get an email the night before asking me if my teammate was allowed to get hammered. It's part of the risk/reward aspect of a team game. Sometimes people let you down. Sometimes they don't. On the good teams, they usually don't.

If you want to enjoy the benefits of employing a GM, then take the risk. If you want to ELIMINATE any chance of getting screwed by a bad trade, then don't take the risk and don't give out trading rights.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Comradeship, i.e. comrade =
1. A person who shares one's interests or activities; a friend or companion.
2. A fellow member of a group, especially a fellow member of the Communist Party.

Comradeship, i.e. comrade != "I don't trust you to not screw me over so here's a contract that says everything you do has to go through me, but you can set up whatever you damn well please and waste everyone else's time by sending shitloads of trade offers and free agent contracts & such"
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by crazy454

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by silenthatred



Originally posted by wombat killer




Originally posted by crazy454





Originally posted by wombat killer






Just PM your owner the trade and he can send it out. Problem solved.


No because by then the player may have already been traded, in most cases you have to act fast on trades.


And in the time you are giving your owner to approve the trade the other owner can work out another deal and cancel your trade.


No it can't because it is an accepted trade.


The other owner can't veto the trade?


yeah have to be a GM to owner trade. GM to GM would probably allow both owners to Veto. And if you wasted time you wasted time either way THE OWNER did not want the trade to go down.


So like I said, the other owner can work out a new trade while waiting for the other owner to approve. If he had other deals in the works he would just have his GM send it out.


No it isn't like you said because you can't offer a trade for a player who has a trade pending, which this would be, no matter which owner you are.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
or dont give GM trading privileges


/thread. Stop bumping things that tool454 creates.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.