User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djm13
I think the team chemistry is way overrated personally. That's the same thing people said about the celtics. There's something to be said about getting an infusion of talent. I could see how a mid-year trade could hurt a team initially, but likely would be beneficial to them within a couple games. I also disagree that every player traded necessarily hurts its team chemistry - sometimes just the opposite may be true. Now owners are rewarded (or not penalized) for keeping mal-contents who may actually be causing a lack of actual chemistry on the team's board or what have you.

Or maybe I am just not accurate with this...





I agree 100 percent
 
trojans4me
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djm13
I think the team chemistry is way overrated personally. That's the same thing people said about the celtics. There's something to be said about getting an infusion of talent. I could see how a mid-year trade could hurt a team initially, but likely would be beneficial to them within a couple games. I also disagree that every player traded necessarily hurts its team chemistry - sometimes just the opposite may be true. Now owners are rewarded (or not penalized) for keeping mal-contents who may actually be causing a lack of actual chemistry on the team's board or what have you.

Or maybe I am just not accurate with this...


Basketball is a different game than football though. A player with talent in basketball can dominate a game more than one great player in football can dominate a game. Football is just way more a team sport than basketball in my opinion. This is why most of the trades that make an impact in real football are done before the season starts so that those players being traded can have time to learn an offense or a defense.

Looking at it now though I don't think team chemistry really effects games as much as we might think in this game.
Last edited May 12, 2008 14:12:05
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
I've made a couple of suggestions about chemistry in the past but I don't think it's going to change anything. I've met resistance to almost every arguement and some of it is based on those who would cheat if chemistry worked how it I feel it should.

An example of that is cutting a backup QB. We lose 3 on offense but in reality, how much is a team affected by losing a Jim Sorgi or Matt Cassell? The suggestion was that backups "cost" less to lose/add but then we're faced with people putting starters in a backup role for trades. There were a couple of suggestions to avoid this such as avg. playing time defining starters or avg lvl comparison for the team but nothing really came of it.

My biggest concern was/is the overall chemistry hits. We lose overall chemistry in a Cumulative fashoin (ie -3 defense and -2 offense = -5 overall) but only regain it in an averagng fashion per night (+1 defense and +1 offense DIVIDED BY 2 = +1 overall).

We at least need to use the same formula for both directions.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
you lose chemistry on defense if you trade a QB? That is ridiculous.

And the idea of avg. playing time is brilliant and seemingly simple.

Regardless, chemistry does have a big effect if you make too many moves -- our chemistry for offense is at 80 or so now and we are clicking like crazy. Our defense has never been below the low 60's after some mid-season cuts of inactive chaff that wanted out.

Hearing that some teams got chemistry down into the 20's, that should (and appears to have) had a severe effect. Understanding how it works is key, and we can all work from within the game rules to succeed.
 
djm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trojans4me
Originally posted by djm13

I think the team chemistry is way overrated personally. That's the same thing people said about the celtics. There's something to be said about getting an infusion of talent. I could see how a mid-year trade could hurt a team initially, but likely would be beneficial to them within a couple games. I also disagree that every player traded necessarily hurts its team chemistry - sometimes just the opposite may be true. Now owners are rewarded (or not penalized) for keeping mal-contents who may actually be causing a lack of actual chemistry on the team's board or what have you.

Or maybe I am just not accurate with this...


Basketball is a different game than football though. A player with talent in basketball can dominate a game more than one great player in football can dominate a game. Football is just way more a team sport than basketball in my opinion. This is why most of the trades that make an impact in real football are done before the season starts so that those players being traded can have time to learn an offense or a defense.

Looking at it now though I don't think team chemistry really effects games as much as we might think in this game.


If one player can dominate in basketball more easily than in football then it seems to me that a trade in football is going to have less change on a team than basketball. My main argument though is just that chemistry is solely based around having the same guys around (as far as I know)...but to me that doesn't mean a team has good chemistry. I'm not really sure how else you could determine team chemistry but I'd say it shouldn't be a very powerful thing yet (it seems to me anyway) it has a big impact on the games.
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
you lose chemistry on defense if you trade a QB? That is ridiculous.

And the idea of avg. playing time is brilliant and seemingly simple.

Regardless, chemistry does have a big effect if you make too many moves -- our chemistry for offense is at 80 or so now and we are clicking like crazy. Our defense has never been below the low 60's after some mid-season cuts of inactive chaff that wanted out.

Hearing that some teams got chemistry down into the 20's, that should (and appears to have) had a severe effect. Understanding how it works is key, and we can all work from within the game rules to succeed.




Indirectly....you lose the chemistry in the "overall" catagory but it will affect the team as a whole because it's, well....overall!
 
Leksington
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djm13
I think the team chemistry is way overrated personally. That's the same thing people said about the celtics. There's something to be said about getting an infusion of talent. I could see how a mid-year trade could hurt a team initially, but likely would be beneficial to them within a couple games. I also disagree that every player traded necessarily hurts its team chemistry - sometimes just the opposite may be true. Now owners are rewarded (or not penalized) for keeping mal-contents who may actually be causing a lack of actual chemistry on the team's board or what have you.

Or maybe I am just not accurate with this...

Look at the Phoenix Suns and the Shaq trade.

It took over 10 games for them to get on the same page which killed them in the western conference playoff seeding. To top it off, Shaq didn't fit D'Antoni's offense at all.

Dallas clearly had chemistry problems with Jason Kidd, especially in regards to his 'player coach' style and how it conflicted with Avery Johnson's micro managment coaching style. You need look no further than seeing Jason Kidd on the bench near the the end of close games as proof of chemistry issues.


As far as he Celtics, don't be too sold on them yet. They have yet to win a road playoff game in this post season, despite playing the terrible Hawks. If Le'Bron doesn't play absolutely horrible, they could be in serious trouble.
 
Leksington
offline
Link
 
As far as football, there is definately alot of chemistry involved. Offensive lines play tons better when they have played together for a while, so do defensive secondaries. QBs definately benefit from developing a relationship with their WRs.

Raw talent can overcome minor chemistry issues, just like they can in GLB. However when chemistry becomes a huge issue, like what the eagles suffered through during TOs second season on the team, you can see it tear teams apart and effect the whole team's play.

I think chemistry is fine, and a team should see significant benefits from keeping their core group of players together.
 
Notor
offline
Link
 

Unlike games like baseball where team chemistry is a bunch of baloney, it is a real thing in football. Players joining a new team in the middle of the season would be unfamiliar with that team's playbook and that is at least somewhat detrimental to their performance and the other people on the team who depend on their performance. Any players you add/drop in the offseason won't hurt your chemistry, and that makes sense because those players have the offseason to get used to their new teammates/learn the plays, but in the middle of a season it makes a lot of sense for it to hurt your teams ability to execute a little.

There are some positions that I think shouldn't hurt your chemistry though, like replacing a Kicker/Punter or some backups really wouldn't have that much of an impact on a team beyond that person's individual performance.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Notor

Unlike games like baseball where team chemistry is a bunch of baloney, it is a real thing in football. Players joining a new team in the middle of the season would be unfamiliar with that team's playbook and that is at least somewhat detrimental to their performance and the other people on the team who depend on their performance. Any players you add/drop in the offseason won't hurt your chemistry, and that makes sense because those players have the offseason to get used to their new teammates/learn the plays, but in the middle of a season it makes a lot of sense for it to hurt your teams ability to execute a little.

There are some positions that I think shouldn't hurt your chemistry though, like replacing a Kicker/Punter or some backups really wouldn't have that much of an impact on a team beyond that person's individual performance.


I think the main complaint is that people think it affects teams too much. However, unless you are turning over massive amounts of players during the season, I don't think its a big deal to at least stick around 70 or so.
 
djm13
offline
Link
 
Yeah well we were one of those teams that got overhauled so we're around 20 I think. I don't think that scenerio is really all that inaccurate. If a team was gutted mid-season and replaced by a bunch of low-level guys the team is probably going to get destroyed and have no chemistry all year.

However, you guys bring up the Shaq and Kidd trades...again I'm not saying a trade can't hurt a team's chemistry...but the fact is you're not mentioning many cases in which trading for a player helps a team's chemistry...The Yankees made numerous trades for guys like strawberry and justice en route to winning the World Series numerous times (just figured we might as well use another sport)...How about the Shaq to Miami trade? Chris Chambers didn't seem to hurt the Chargers this year. I'm just saying I don't think it should always hurt. Either players could be forced to use skill points in a category such as team player and those with lower ratings bring their teams down and the ones with the high ratings bring team chemistry up. I don't know...I'm not saying it;s a major problem...I'm not even sure what percentage team chemistry has on the outcome of games...
Last edited May 12, 2008 21:37:19
 
Notor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Notor


Unlike games like baseball where team chemistry is a bunch of baloney, it is a real thing in football. Players joining a new team in the middle of the season would be unfamiliar with that team's playbook and that is at least somewhat detrimental to their performance and the other people on the team who depend on their performance. Any players you add/drop in the offseason won't hurt your chemistry, and that makes sense because those players have the offseason to get used to their new teammates/learn the plays, but in the middle of a season it makes a lot of sense for it to hurt your teams ability to execute a little.

There are some positions that I think shouldn't hurt your chemistry though, like replacing a Kicker/Punter or some backups really wouldn't have that much of an impact on a team beyond that person's individual performance.


I think the main complaint is that people think it affects teams too much. However, unless you are turning over massive amounts of players during the season, I don't think its a big deal to at least stick around 70 or so.


Yeah, I really don't think it's too severe though. It doesn't hurt your team that much if you don't move a crapload of players around. Imagine a real NFL team replacing 1/4 of their starters over the course of one season, of course that would have a huge impact on their performance as a team....And there are a lot of teams practically doing just that here.

I guess my point is, if you're going to make a ton of roster moves, you're supposed to be doing that in the offseason. If you're drastically altering your roster midseason, you should expect a drastic drop in team execution, it makes perfect sense.....And you have to move a LOT of players to get your chemistry down to where it's really hurting you (40's-low 50's).

Though, IMO, glory positions like QB or WR take longer to get adjusted to a new team than non-glory positions (Like an O-lineman can pretty much contribute right away, but a QB has to learn the playbook), so you should lose less chemistry when moving non-glory players and more when moving the glory folks.
Last edited May 12, 2008 23:47:42
 
Link
 
I like the way chemistry is working. The stable teams have a slight advantage over people who are constantly changing.
 
Polished Rock
offline
Link
 
Somewhat less compelling match-ups today than previous "weeks"

The best are in the Alpha:
Aberystwyth @ Pittsburgh
East Coast @ Western
Palau @ Vanuatu

Sydney @ Tasmania makes me nervous. The Dragons seem better than their record. Pelicans will have a fight.
Last edited May 15, 2008 09:54:11
 
vetsgt02
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djm13
Yeah well we were one of those teams that got overhauled so we're around 20 I think. I don't think that scenerio is really all that inaccurate. If a team was gutted mid-season and replaced by a bunch of low-level guys the team is probably going to get destroyed and have no chemistry all year.

However, you guys bring up the Shaq and Kidd trades...again I'm not saying a trade can't hurt a team's chemistry...but the fact is you're not mentioning many cases in which trading for a player helps a team's chemistry...The Yankees made numerous trades for guys like strawberry and justice en route to winning the World Series numerous times (just figured we might as well use another sport)...How about the Shaq to Miami trade? Chris Chambers didn't seem to hurt the Chargers this year. I'm just saying I don't think it should always hurt. Either players could be forced to use skill points in a category such as team player and those with lower ratings bring their teams down and the ones with the high ratings bring team chemistry up. I don't know...I'm not saying it;s a major problem...I'm not even sure what percentage team chemistry has on the outcome of games...


A trade that helped team Chemistry? How about Gasol to the Lakers? That has helped a ton with team Chem
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.