User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by Crushr




You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



So luck is the reason behind people who are successful? If you work just as "hard" and struggle maybe you are 1) not working as hard as you think or 2) your ability is just not on par with others. So the people who work at McDonald should get paid just as much as doctors and lawyers because they "work just as hard"? Which world are you living in?


In a situation like the one being discussed, where 6-8 teams are extremely close in talent, etc., "luck" can play a significant role in where those teams end up.


Yes, there are certainly some luck involved in this game. But that usually tend to even itself out in the long run. Just like in life, you deal with your luck. Since when do people have to share the burden of other people's bad luck?
 
Iktomi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by tmoon

Crushr

I didn't realize it was a debate. I was not debating. You assumed it was a debate, you were debating. When you said "I don't need any advice from you" I took it as an insult because I am the smartest man in the universe and anyone in their right mind would take advice from the smartest man in the universe. So you insulted me first

Arguement wise most players and owners will want revenue sharing. Most people want socialized health care and social security. If you want to give me free money, hey thats great, which line do I stand in... how much is the good old greenback worth now? I was just hoping that there were people out there that still had some pride in themselves and the work they put forth. "They cheated, we weren't boosted, Bort changed the game."



Well, I have to disagree with at least one point. When you say that 'I was just hoping that there were people out there that still had some pride in themselves and the work they put forth' are you saying that any team that finishes below the top 4 should be ashamed of the effort they put forth? The league I am in is tough. Sure there are about 5 or 6 teams league wide that struggle. Last year I was one of them. I am now in the mid level tier of my league(at least I hope). If the end of the season comes and I miss the playoffs by 1 or 2 teams, I can assure its not because I haven't given it all I could to get into the playoffs and I will be proud of the effort I put forth. This issue has nothing to do with socialized healthcare or anything outside of GLB economics. Can you draw a correalation between them? Sure why not. But they have different issues and different consequences. 1 is real the other is a game so I think that is just a red herring to muddy the debate on the topic. Answer me this and I'll let it go. Do you really feel like its fair that the 1-4 teams get 30 times the cash that the 5-8 teams do? How can those teams be competitive when the top 4 are getting a huge financial advantage? Simple questions and eager to see your response. Thanks!


Do I think it is fair? Hmm, no I do not think it is fair, but that is the way the game has been played for at least the amount of time that you and I have been here. I know that if my team does not make a 1-4 seed then it will be more difficult next season without that revenue. I know that trying to convince your players who want to look out for themselves and wait until the end of the season to boost that if they do that they hurt the team as a collective. Try convincing people in the "me" generation they should take an exp loss so your team makes a better seeding in the playoffs... difficult. I know that I don't give every player I sign a huge bonus and "equipment money" on day one... they need to commit to winning and to the team before I spend the teams money on an individual. Starting to rant again... back to topic...

Is it unfair? Yes. I have adjusted to the current system and built my team around the current system, recruited players and agents and GMs around the current system. If the system changes I will adjust, my team and players will adjust. I am really overwhelmingly against so much constant change. The changes, in my opinion, are making every player, team and agent equal and that just sucks. If all the players, agents and teams are equal then I will have to spend more time helping old ladies across the street and less time playing GLB...

 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Tito716


If every team that missed the playoffs in the first season of every league put a full roster of level 1s on the field and spent all their revenue on stadium upgrades, would anyone in the league be poor?


Yes . . . because those teams would not reap the benefit of playoff revenue.

I'd be willing to bet that if you asked those owners who have maxed out stadiums "What is the #1 factor in completing your stadium build?" the overwhelming majority would not say "fielding a full roster of level ones." They would say, almost across the board . . . "Playoff Revenue."



Wrong. I GM'ed a gutted team, we have not made playoff in 3 seasons, the most we have won was 6 games in a season, but we still manage to build our stadium and are getting competitive without asking or receiving handouts. We are going to complete the level 2 at the beginning of next season. Playoff Revenue is nice, but not having it is not the end of the world. The #1 reason teams can't build their stadiums is because they pay insane amount of salaries to shitty players.


Wrong. You are not even the exception. I am owner of a successful team that has never been less than a #2 seed. Where it took you 4 seasons to complete you 2nd level, it took us two. At the end of season 4, we'd complete our entire stadium. All while giving out huge bonuses and generous salaries.

Why? Because of Playoff income.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by Tito716



If every team that missed the playoffs in the first season of every league put a full roster of level 1s on the field and spent all their revenue on stadium upgrades, would anyone in the league be poor?


Yes . . . because those teams would not reap the benefit of playoff revenue.

I'd be willing to bet that if you asked those owners who have maxed out stadiums "What is the #1 factor in completing your stadium build?" the overwhelming majority would not say "fielding a full roster of level ones." They would say, almost across the board . . . "Playoff Revenue."



Wrong. I GM'ed a gutted team, we have not made playoff in 3 seasons, the most we have won was 6 games in a season, but we still manage to build our stadium and are getting competitive without asking or receiving handouts. We are going to complete the level 2 at the beginning of next season. Playoff Revenue is nice, but not having it is not the end of the world. The #1 reason teams can't build their stadiums is because they pay insane amount of salaries to shitty players.


Wrong. You are not even the exception. I am owner of a successful team that has never been less than a #2 seed. Where it took you 4 seasons to complete you 2nd level, it took us two. At the end of season 4, we'd complete our entire stadium. All while giving out huge bonuses and generous salaries.

Why? Because of Playoff income.


You are missing the point here. I too GM a very successful team that has won the league each year, so I know how much we can make during the playoffs. My point here is that even if you don't make the playoffs, you can still be financially responsible and compete. If there were NO CHANCE for lower teams to compete, I would say there is something wrong. But that is not the case. If the economy is tough and there are just no jobs around, yeah, I would support the welfare system. But if there are plenty of jobs around, and people are just lazy or looking for handouts, you bet I'll be against the welfare system.

BTW, we could have completed the level 2 this season had we not made a mistake in building sections. Building a stadium is not as hard as people making it sounds, a team that have never had a winning season can still build their stadium and be financially sound. People need to stop coming up with excuses for their failures, or "nerf" others so they can be "better".
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 17:03:24
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
With all due respect, I am not missing the point. In your example, the team you GM has been financially responsible in focusing on building a stadium. Good for you. However, you admit that this focus has prevented you from being competitive, going on 4 seasons now. So here you sit as a lower tier team, which is financially responsible and presumably "working hard" at recruiting and game planning and player building, and after four seasons you still are not competing.

Meanwhile, teams like mine, who played home playoff games, have a 100% complete stadium, unlimited income, and 4 years of success, primarily due to being able to attract and keep agents with big salaries and bonuses.

And this strikes you as fair? We're killing you, and I would go so far as to project that at current rates of "growth", you will not be competitive for at least another 4 seasons, because that's how long it will take you to complete your stadium and begin bringing in the necessary revenue to compete for free agents.
 
Groucho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lafCowboy
I love how teams that make the top 4 are run by financial wizards carefully planning and earning their financial windfall while teams that are 5-8 are run by johnny-come-latelies who somehow managed to schlep their way into the playoffs despite horrible fiscal waste, general lack of planning, and terrible management.

No way the reality could be that generally the top 1-8 teams are all well run but guys in the 1-4 are looking to keep their 30x income bonus for being a little more successful than the guys just short of that. Couldn't possibly be that.


Come on. Every league I've been in there's been a HUGE difference between the #1 seed and the #8 seed.
 
Razor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Razor
What about a winner take more than the loser of a game.....

The home team determines the income based on their stadium, but money isn't distributed until after the game. The winner of the game gets a percentage (say 65%) and the loser gets (say 35%). The home team keeps concessions no matter what the outcome of the game. So the probable out come either way is that money is split but the higher seed (the one that is "supposed" to win the game) comes out ahead either way.

Right now the owner's money income situation sucks, especially for new teams. The amount of money required for level 40+ gear is outrageous. Their is few teams that can handle lvl 40 gear and if the current trend of money required for lvl 48+ gear continues. There isn't enough headroom in the game for any owner to afford it.

I think addressing the "bigger" money issue is more important, in the long run, than playoff revenue sharing.

IMHO


 
The Lurker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Groucho
Originally posted by lafCowboy

I love how teams that make the top 4 are run by financial wizards carefully planning and earning their financial windfall while teams that are 5-8 are run by johnny-come-latelies who somehow managed to schlep their way into the playoffs despite horrible fiscal waste, general lack of planning, and terrible management.

No way the reality could be that generally the top 1-8 teams are all well run but guys in the 1-4 are looking to keep their 30x income bonus for being a little more successful than the guys just short of that. Couldn't possibly be that.


Come on. Every league I've been in there's been a HUGE difference between the #1 seed and the #8 seed.


What about the #4 seed and the #5 seed?
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Groucho
Originally posted by lafCowboy

I love how teams that make the top 4 are run by financial wizards carefully planning and earning their financial windfall while teams that are 5-8 are run by johnny-come-latelies who somehow managed to schlep their way into the playoffs despite horrible fiscal waste, general lack of planning, and terrible management.

No way the reality could be that generally the top 1-8 teams are all well run but guys in the 1-4 are looking to keep their 30x income bonus for being a little more successful than the guys just short of that. Couldn't possibly be that.


Come on. Every league I've been in there's been a HUGE difference between the #1 seed and the #8 seed.


Not in Oceania Pro.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by datongw


Originally posted by McGruffHawk



Originally posted by Tito716




If every team that missed the playoffs in the first season of every league put a full roster of level 1s on the field and spent all their revenue on stadium upgrades, would anyone in the league be poor?


Yes . . . because those teams would not reap the benefit of playoff revenue.

I'd be willing to bet that if you asked those owners who have maxed out stadiums "What is the #1 factor in completing your stadium build?" the overwhelming majority would not say "fielding a full roster of level ones." They would say, almost across the board . . . "Playoff Revenue."



Wrong. I GM'ed a gutted team, we have not made playoff in 3 seasons, the most we have won was 6 games in a season, but we still manage to build our stadium and are getting competitive without asking or receiving handouts. We are going to complete the level 2 at the beginning of next season. Playoff Revenue is nice, but not having it is not the end of the world. The #1 reason teams can't build their stadiums is because they pay insane amount of salaries to shitty players.


Wrong. You are not even the exception. I am owner of a successful team that has never been less than a #2 seed. Where it took you 4 seasons to complete you 2nd level, it took us two. At the end of season 4, we'd complete our entire stadium. All while giving out huge bonuses and generous salaries.

Why? Because of Playoff income.


You are missing the point here. I too GM a very successful team that has won the league each year, so I know how much we can make during the playoffs. My point here is that even if you don't make the playoffs, you can still be financially responsible and compete. If there were NO CHANCE for lower teams to compete, I would say there is something wrong. But that is not the case. If the economy is tough and there are just no jobs around, yeah, I would support the welfare system. But if there are plenty of jobs around, and people are just lazy or looking for handouts, you bet I'll be against the welfare system.

BTW, we could have completed the level 2 this season had we not made a mistake in building sections. Building a stadium is not as hard as people making it sounds, a team that have never had a winning season can still build their stadium and be financially sound. People need to stop coming up with excuses for their failures, or "nerf" others so they can be "better".


No offense man, but if the team you GM on is the Angola Dream then you did not receive the ridiculous financial windfall that comes with being a 1 seed throughout the playoffs. Sure, you guys won and I have the utmost respect for your team, but I believe you were the 3 seed and I believe had 2 home games (game 1 and the league championship). I actually think the biggest problem with the current system is NOT the financial weakness of the lower teams, it's the ridiculous financial advantage that getting home playoff games is. My A team last season actually received more revenues from 4 home playoff games than from our 8 regular season games. You tell me how that system makes sense.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Groucho

Originally posted by lafCowboy


I love how teams that make the top 4 are run by financial wizards carefully planning and earning their financial windfall while teams that are 5-8 are run by johnny-come-latelies who somehow managed to schlep their way into the playoffs despite horrible fiscal waste, general lack of planning, and terrible management.

No way the reality could be that generally the top 1-8 teams are all well run but guys in the 1-4 are looking to keep their 30x income bonus for being a little more successful than the guys just short of that. Couldn't possibly be that.


Come on. Every league I've been in there's been a HUGE difference between the #1 seed and the #8 seed.


Not in Oceania Pro.


A #8 seed won promotion in Canada A #7 last season. I've witnessed many #8 seeds beat #1s.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Wow..After all this discussion we still have many of you guys who willingly admit that the current system is not fair but we should keep it because its either a) what you are used to or b) you had to deal with it. If we took that approach to everything, everything would go to hell in a handbasket.. Just sayin.....!
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
OK arguments are getting repeated over and over but here's my take on it (Hell, I might as well dive in the pool....)

(1) All the talk about who outworked whom is a waste of time. No one should really be arguing about the level of effort--or lack thereof--in this discussion. The financial rewards for the playoffs are for PERFORMANCE, not EFFORT!!! You go to the Olympics, sprain your ankle before your event and have to drop out. You don't get an honorary medal. And no one says you didn't work your ass off to get there. You worked hard, just as hard or harder than the gold medalist, but the medal goes to the person who PRODUCED RESULTS whether by superior game planning or Immaculate Reception. CONCLUSION: 5-8's should realize they won't get as much as 1-4's regardless of how hard they worked, and correspondingly non-playoff teams should not expect anything at all for not accomplishing the goal of ALL teams at the start of the season (advancing to playoffs).

(2) Very few (no one?) is arguing that the current discrepancy in playoff revenue between 1-4's and 5-8's is fair--they are arguing about HOW TO FIX IT. It boils down to two general themes: (a) take some $$$ from the 1-4's and give it to the 5-8's or (b) give the 5-8's more money via some alternative revenue generating device. Most of the drama centers around theme (a), probably because it invokes an emotional response between those who feel money is being "taken" from them and those who feel that money is being "hoarded".

I find it ironic that one of the most vocal proponents of revenue sharing states in one post that he doesn't want to tell a team how to spend its money when that's EXACTLY what he's doing since the 1-4's consider the playoff revenue to be their (as yet uncollected) money. So we won't tell them what kind of contract to offer, but we WILL tell them that they need to spend $1,5000,000 to help out their competitors? (It can be argued that these teams should not be allowed to consider this money as theirs, but the manner in which playoff revenue has been distributed for a number of seasons suggests that this was not an unreasonable assumption.)

Having said that, I fail to see why we can't just agree on option (b) which preserves the home playoff revenue stream for the 1-4's in its entirety, while providing the 5-8's with a reasonable reward for making the playoffs. They would likely end up with even MORE money than if the playoff revenue "pot" needed to be split. This would address the discrepancy issue, keep the 1-4's happy since they get to keep all of their "deserved" revenue, & also would address the issue of rewarding 5-8's for having made the playoffs in the first place. It seems like it would make everybody happy. Why isn't this option being championed?

Bort initially framed it as 5-8's having playoff revenue from their own stadium at reduced ticket prices for their fans to watch on the Jumbotron. OK, it doesn't happen in the NFL, but I know it happens in college football because I went to a game that utilized this very same concept. It also happens quite a bit in college basketball. It's not as outlandish as it sounds and since it addresses all the practical concerns about playoff revenue, I think it sounds like a terrific idea! The details about how much the visiting playoff teams would be allowed to charge for their Jumbotron broadcast and whether there would be a cap to prevent 5-8's from earning more than 1-4's can be worked out, but it takes a lot of the personal angst out of the argument, at least for me.

Last edited Sep 30, 2008 18:59:04
 
enasty19
offline
Link
 
Maybe for seating, you could do like college. Sorry if this was already suggested, but i didn't feel like reading through 4-5 pages of this. But like College, you could put apart a small amount of the stadium for the away team and they'd get their ticket income from that. Sure the home team would get penalized a bit, but it's sure as hell better than sharing revenue. Also somewhat like the idea of TV contracts, but if one team sells gear, so does the other. That's the only way to make it fair for both sides. Personally, i think splinting it anyway is horrible. Reason being is that the 1-4 seeds recruited and spent all the hard work in the off-season trying to get the top 4 seeds for money and now it's gunna be taken away from them. I just hope this doesn't turn out like the new equipment threads.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by laxdawg
Maybe for seating, you could do like college. Sorry if this was already suggested, but i didn't feel like reading through 4-5 pages of this. But like College, you could put apart a small amount of the stadium for the away team and they'd get their ticket income from that. Sure the home team would get penalized a bit, but it's sure as hell better than sharing revenue. Also somewhat like the idea of TV contracts, but if one team sells gear, so does the other. That's the only way to make it fair for both sides. Personally, i think splinting it anyway is horrible. Reason being is that the 1-4 seeds recruited and spent all the hard work in the off-season trying to get the top 4 seeds for money and now it's gunna be taken away from them. I just hope this doesn't turn out like the new equipment threads.


How is selling tickets to the away team better than sharing? Its the same thing, just from a different end of the stream.

Bort's idea is okay, but a bit unrealistic. The best idea so far IMO is the selling of merchandise for away teams. Teams sell more merchandise through team stores during the playoffs.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.