User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Melancholy
So, was this fixed? There was an announcement about being close to a fix, but did that fix actually go out?


Its a secret.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Latest Game.. Incompletes without a drop/deflection and where play stops (appears ball was going to hit the ground on that tic)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145715&pbp_id=5263599
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145715&pbp_id=5266120

I had switched to bullet passing but this teams pass defense was such though I thought I would see if the Medium passing effects had been toned down yet.

I understand where you are coming from Bort, but at the same time, I believe the receiver should have a chance to catch the ball before the check for it hitting the ground is made.

It generally occurs on plays when the defense really should get burned and you are taking that away from teams, essentially giving a nice handicap to defenses.
 
Sahoj
offline
Link
 
I just had a lower level team average 68 and 79% completion percentages
against my defense, despite suffering 8 hurries, 2 INT's and 5 sacks.

Maybe passing is not as broken as you folks are making out?

Cheers,
Sahoj
Last edited Oct 6, 2008 07:56:06
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sahoj
I just had a lower level team average 68 and 79% completion percentages
against my defense, despite suffering 8 hurries, 2 INT's and 5 sacks.

Maybe passing is not as broken as you folks are making out?

Cheers,
Sahoj


Please read the thread before posting this stuff. This is an issue with higher level players who are too fast. Bort acknowledges that the frame rate that calculates the play is part of the reason.
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
If the OP could post some of Bort's responses in the.. OP, that would be very helpful. This thread has become too big to read all the way through w/in a reasonable timeframe
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
We had a scrimmage today as well..

Some more examples of Medium Passing, no deflection, no drop.. likely hit the ground in that same tic. It looks like when you are tossing in a higher arc to drop it in on the receiver this happens too often as they would be considered awesome passes in a real NFL game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195258&pbp_id=5316131
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195258&pbp_id=5317887
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195258&pbp_id=5320540

In each case the ball doesn't travel past the receiver , there is no drop and there is no deflection. This tends to indicate ball was thrown in such a way that it was going to hit the ground on that tic. Balls seems to be angled to avoid coverage, so I think that steeper angle is causing these passes which should at least have a catch attempt made determined by the sim to hit the ground first.

What is the point then of having good touch as a QB? Compared to my last game when I was throwing bullets (two days ago) its an entirely different game when using Medium Passing.

Please address this Bort.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=182401&pbp_id=5022195
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=182401&pbp_id=5022519

That's a lv. 3 QB throwing to a lv. 8 WR! Obviously, the great throwing strength of the QB and the huge speed of the WR cause the problem!!! It needs to be stopped immediately!!!

(Honestly, a few passes actually might just be bad throws. Don't blame the SIM for every untouched pass.)
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=182401&pbp_id=5022195
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=182401&pbp_id=5022519

That's a lv. 3 QB throwing to a lv. 8 WR! Obviously, the great throwing strength of the QB and the huge speed of the WR cause the problem!!! It needs to be stopped immediately!!!

(Honestly, a few passes actually might just be bad throws. Don't blame the SIM for every untouched pass.)


Except that in my own case, the QB on 'Bullet' passing never has a pass like this, but if he moves over to Medium, they crop up more frequently. Indicating that its likely related to the _Bort Acknowledged_ issue.

I was just providing more data for Bort to look at.

You really need to maybe consider when its necessary to post and when you may perhaps just might be being too contrary for the sake of contrariness.

I have made plenty of bad throws over the course of 5 seasons. I'm not complaining about those. I am providing data for those throws where the ball stops without a deflection or a drop and it appears the pass was directly on target. Indicating it might fall under what BORT already said he caught as an issue.

 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Why is there no update on this?

Half the season is already over.
 
lazloth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Why is there no update on this?

Half the season is already over.


People stopped talking about it?

 
amo368
offline
Link
 
Started using different pass settings... seemed to work out well...
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amo368
Started using different pass settings... seemed to work out well...


Yeah, incompletions for no reason seemed to have dropped off but distance per completion also tends to drop off. I still think Bort needs to address this, change the order of the checks and then just dial back the CB's a little closer to where they were, making QB's happy for actually being able o burn the defense with a good play and the CB's happy for being a little better after their gutting.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Sad. Want fixed.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim

Even on the plays that the ball goes threw the CB's dot? so could the passes that are not being caught be a vision catch check that the WR's are not making?


No, WR's don't have to make that same check to see if they "see" the ball to react to it in time. They just have to make a "can I catch it" check, since they know it's coming.


Hang on a second. Shouldn't the receiver be looking for the ball at some point? This makes me think the WRs here just sprint as fast as they can and the ball either hits their catching radius or it doesn't. The factors should be:

1. Primary receiver should be more likely to know the ball is coming
2. Receivers should be making adjustments to get to the ball, and this may mean slowing down and possibly being caught by a defender before the ball arrives
3. secondary receivers can't just run a route and have the ball drop into their hands - they don't know its coming, and usually the ball will arrive after their basic route been run and they are past the point where they would normally see the ball if they were the primary receiver.
4. Secondary receivers need to adjust to the play, and that takes vision.

Wow...I'm quite possibly over-simplifying or reading too much/little into your comment, Bort, but your comments here lead me to believe that the interaction between the WR, the QB, and the ball is way way way too simplified for a simulation.
Last edited Oct 7, 2008 15:34:13
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Another friendly scrimmage.. Again still running medium passing. Incompletions way up, interceptions up. I'm not liking being forced to do bullets because I can angle a pass perfectly to be where the receiver is going to be but you decide it will hit the ground in the same tic so no catch attempt is made.

Again, these have no drop, no deflection. No attempt on the ball at all. Generally there is a defender between the Qb and intended target and it appears the ball is given some loft.

QB's are being penalised for throwing good passes.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195366&pbp_id=5526515
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195366&pbp_id=5529273

Here on the other hand is an example of a really bad pass.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195366&pbp_id=5529445

Ball kept going well outside of the range of anyone to be able to touch it. Presumably from Bort's commentary this means it took that long for the ball to hit the ground.

Bort Please Fix.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.