User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
im telling you that in S.America my team will never catch up to the top 3 or 4 teams there...just not happening...the way for my team to win a title is for those guys to slowly win and move up...they have the classic first mover advantage...until there are limits to the money you can spend on a roster nothing changes...the extra playoff money from season 1, 2, or 3 is enough to doom the other 12 teams in the conference...

and i will get over the hump at some point...probably when i bring in a couple more of my own high level well-built players...but that isnt the point here...without taking those steps it isnt going to happen...
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by papabear
what are the simple fixes?? Ideas to fix problems generate more than nameing problems that there is no fix for.

Lets say I have a 150 foot redwood in my front yard. Cutting it down isn't an option it would crush my neighbors house, not to mention i would get some political involvement about cutting it down. Standing there and yelling at the tree won't work, complaining about won't make it move. So I either learn to live with the tree being a pain, or i work around it. So now my driveway goes around a 150 foot tree. Plus Since the tree is on my families property and has been for 100's of years, I charge admission to come look at the neighborhoods oldest tree.


Which of the GLB bigwigs are you when you're on your normal account?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by shield.bearer


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by Ming Sao





VT, and you wonder why I bring up PR?

The best customer is the one you already have. Why? Because it's easy to evaluate what they will do in the future, if pleased, by what they have done in the past.

Judging by my past, would you say I and many others who appear to be questioning the direction of GLB are worth saving or deserve the door knob?


What is this about? Bort isn't telling you to leave, but there's a point at which expectations stop being possible/rational/workable, and those have to be ignored. It's impossible to please everyone.


What is impossible/irrational/unworkable about expecting responsive customer service and a simple fix to huge problems?

Most of these "gripes" have simple fixes. Fix them...


No people simply think they're easy, without really thinking out the repercussions. That's not at all suprising when you consider you're dealing very often with players that leave at the first hint of difficulty.

I'm also not sure what people really expect, or rather, what they think Bort is doing. Why they think he isn't working I'll never know.


I don't think Bort's not working. Evertime a game sims, I am reminded how much work he's doing that we never get told about until after the fact.

Look, it's simple. If you want to stop gutting there are two very simple ways to do it.

1. Make it impossible for an owner to cut more than (arbitrary number alert) 10% of his roster in a given seson. 2. Then, shut down all firesale threads and immediately lock the roster as it was at the beginning of the day. 3. Give GM's on the team right of first refusal to take the team over. 4. Then, if no one is interested, set all contracts to Day 40 and return the team to the pool at the end of the season. 5. Return it to one of the new leagues and promote the most deserving team from the feeder league. Amazing, gutting solved. Now, what are the "ramifications" I haven't thought of and how will they negatively impact GLB? More importantly, will those unthought of "ramifications" do enough damage to counterbalance the good this change is creating?


I went ahead and numbered all of your points, but for the record, 3 solves gutting and doesn't require any arbitrary fixes.
 
Phil147
offline
Link
 
Just an idea, perhaps put in a little xp or monetary bonus if you sign with a non-playoff team, which would increase as ranking of that team gets lower and lower. Perhaps this would make people want to join weaker teams, and avoid stockpiling players on playoff teams only.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
For a GM to take over a team with first rights of refusal, how much XP are they paying btw?
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 13:03:03
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
3 doesn't solve gutting if the team doesn't have any GM's.
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by CMONBRENT

How about some salary caps. I think everything should be controlled by that. Just like the economics of sports


There's a natural cap when it costs 32mil to equip 40 level 32 players.


not really...the teams that go to the playoffs with home games will have the money...the others wont...it will only widen the gap...thats the point guys are missing...and those playoff appearances 1 and 2 seasons ago that drove revenue (if spent on stadium) is what drives the ability for the dominant teams to be even more dominant...

i have a team where i hosted 2 games in season 2 and that extra advantage is paying off today...i have about 1/4 of the team paid for level 32 and will have huge revenue stream next season to have 40+ guys at level 32...now whether we can swing level 40 or not who knows...but for a team that was a home playoff team in season 2 and 3 and now 4 that isnt a question...level 40 is a no problem...



 
Cylon
offline
Link
 
Simple fixes is a phrase that scares me often. Some thoughts that might help move the discussion though:

Impose restrictions on selling a team back like there's a 3 day wait after you click sell and put a "sale pending" next to the owners name so players don't get blindsided.

Maybe a deadline every season where owners have to put in a request to sell by like the trade deadline. If you want to sell at the end of the season then submit it by a deadline like end of the regular season or a week before. Might deter some of the one season owners.

Maybe a roster size cap to go with the minimum. Might open the market more, make it so people can't keep too many players hostage. They either have to decide to trade/drop that player or keep from getting the player they want.

Just some quick thoughts I just came up with that probably have holes and good counter arguments but a base for ideas.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 13:03:35
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by shield.bearer


I don't think Bort's not working. Evertime a game sims, I am reminded how much work he's doing that we never get told about until after the fact.

Look, it's simple. If you want to stop gutting there are two very simple ways to do it.

1. Make it impossible for an owner to cut more than (arbitrary number alert) 10% of his roster in a given seson. 2. Then, shut down all firesale threads and immediately lock the roster as it was at the beginning of the day. 3. Give GM's on the team right of first refusal to take the team over. 4. Then, if no one is interested, set all contracts to Day 40 and return the team to the pool at the end of the season. 5. Return it to one of the new leagues and promote the most deserving team from the feeder league. Amazing, gutting solved. Now, what are the "ramifications" I haven't thought of and how will they negatively impact GLB? More importantly, will those unthought of "ramifications" do enough damage to counterbalance the good this change is creating?


I went ahead and numbered all of your points, but for the record, 3 solves gutting and doesn't require any arbitrary fixes.


Except in the instances where the owner doesn't tell anyone what he is doing or when none of the GM's can/wants to buy the team. Therefore, the entire fix.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ming Sao
For a GM to take over a team with first rights of refusal, how much XP are they paying btw?


Prorated based on the point of the season. Alternatively, the GM is the "interim" owner and takes over at the end of the season. This would cost 1000 FP's, just like owners pay now. Basically, the GM get's a partial season for free and GLB get's stability.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by Ming Sao

For a GM to take over a team with first rights of refusal, how much XP are they paying btw?


Prorated based on the point of the season. Alternatively, the GM is the "interim" owner and takes over at the end of the season. This would cost 1000 FP's, just like owners pay now. Basically, the GM get's a partial season for free and GLB get's stability.



Thanks.

So no incentive given to the GM to keep the team intact. Taking the hit and offering the team for 500 Flex could increase the opportunity for eager GM's to step up.

I assume because this is a cash first, experience second site incentives of the like will never be implemented.
 
Phil147
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil147
Just an idea, perhaps put in a little xp or monetary bonus if you sign with a non-playoff team, which would increase as ranking of that team gets lower and lower. Perhaps this would make people want to join weaker teams, and avoid stockpiling players on playoff teams only.


Anyone wish to critique this idea?
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 13:14:23
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
The most basic answer to why people are leaving is because they cannot win and do not have any hopes of winning any time soon.

The game needs to do more to get people into a competitive position as fast as possible. The best owners need to be competing against the best owners. The medicore ones against mediocre, etc...

Right now, its incredibly hard to turn things around once things go south. I have seen things from a lot of perspectives- first as a new team owner. It was incredibly hard to just get people to sign on. I had to do tons of work weeding the team down to people who I knew would be good long term and those who wouldn't. I had a losing record after the first season, but made the playoffs. I still had to work very hard to get people to sign onto my team again. The next season my team was very good, and it became a ton easier to get more people on my team. This season my team is the best yet I've fielded, and I would have a much easier time adding people. I've had to turn down some pretty solid players because I have no room for them.

There are a couple of ways to make things more competitive faster. The first is to do more promotion/relegation. Or to drop teams sold down to the lowest level, and add some system to promote other teams up (maybe make some kind of tournament for it).

Another idea is to make it easier to "catch up" at lower divisions. Setting a player age limit on the lower leagues could easily do this. If you are in a BBB league, and your league has a 3 season limit, it's a lot easier to tell your prospective players you'll be able to catch up some day. Players who become too "old" for your league then get released at the end of the season, and can move up to a higher level league, or retire and start over again.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ming Sao
Originally posted by shield.bearer

Originally posted by Ming Sao


For a GM to take over a team with first rights of refusal, how much XP are they paying btw?


Prorated based on the point of the season. Alternatively, the GM is the "interim" owner and takes over at the end of the season. This would cost 1000 FP's, just like owners pay now. Basically, the GM get's a partial season for free and GLB get's stability.



Thanks.

So no incentive given to the GM to keep the team intact. Taking the hit and offering the team for 500 Flex could increase the opportunity for eager GM's to step up.

I assume because this is a cash first, experience second site incentives of the like will never be implemented.

I was assuming as much, which is why my "interim" idea was listed second...
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil147
Originally posted by Phil147

Just an idea, perhaps put in a little xp or monetary bonus if you sign with a non-playoff team, which would increase as ranking of that team gets lower and lower. Perhaps this would make people want to join weaker teams, and avoid stockpiling players on playoff teams only.


Anyone wish to critique this idea?


I agree that more should be done to help non-playoff teams. I know in my league (the Ocho!) there are some really quality teams/owners who are just on the cusp of the playoffs. I'd love to have some sort of encouragement for these guys, so that their teams don't give up.

However, I'm not convinced that giving an XP bonus would help, because then you'd have teams purposely tanking to avoid the playoffs. And it doesn't make much sense to reward a 9th place team over an 8th place team, imo.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.