User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
Page:
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PhireHawk
I don't mind the new changes, don't get me wrong, but it needs to be re-thought.

A QB, for example, should not lose the same amount of energy as an Offensive or Defensive Lineman. Regardless of snaps.

Especially if it's a pocket passing QB.

That's just an example, it shouldn't be limited to just QBs. I've got 24 stamina on my guy, and he lost 40 stamina on 84 plays on Normal Intensity. He didn't get sacked at all, and was only hurried twice.

That's a little ridiculous, IMO


I totally agree. A starting QB should NEVER get benched unless he is injured or there is a blowout. My starting QB got fewer plays than my backup QB last game. That is insane. And my backup threw 3 TDs...arrhhhhh!!!
 
syntaxloa
offline
Link
 
So what's the deal? Does a players stamina get reset to 60 after every game no matter what? This is the question that we need answered by a mod. I'm a new owner and my defense is getting killed with energy loss. If this is indeed the case then I can set my subout to 10% and not have that player below 60 after the game. This has a HUGE impact on whether we need a lot of depth or not. As all new owners know, rooks want Clement and Samuel money, it's hard recruiting just for your starters nevermind backups.
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by porkies

The first thing he says in this post is " You will be able to lose up to 40 energy from your energy from one game, instead of 30".

Last season it was not accumalative. You could go down to 70 in one game. so people were going down in energy to like 10 during the game, but after it was always reset to 70 so you had 2 days to train relaxed to get back to 100.

Same thing, now the lowest we can go to is 60. So you could set your sub rate to really low like 10, but they're reset after the game to 60. Then you can train on relaxed to get to 90.

He did say that he's going to rework the energy so it has more of an effect on your performance if you're not at 100%. But he used the word "slight" which is just a little. And that he'd rework it as necessary.

It is Beta version and I would suggest testing if you're not winning your games. Additionally, I've noticed that owners don't publicly share winning strategies for sub rates. You have to manually watch their games and figure it out.


So why waste points on stamina? If no matter what you're going to drop 60 for a lineman then you're foolish to waste ability points on stamina.



This is exactly what I was thinking. If you will always be at 60 at the end of the game if you have low stamina, and stamina has nothing or little to do with performance, then why even bother? Just let your player end the game at 60, put the sub out/in ratio at 0/10 and let your starters play the entire game.

I think we are all missing something and I wish the admins would write a very long post describing, in detail, the stamina/energy situation. Why can't this be done???
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 15:31:33
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chriztian
Originally posted by tmoon

This reminds me of PEE-WEE football with the "everyone has to play" mentality. Has anyone ever watched a real football game. Starters get 90 per-cent of the snaps, at every position. The only time there are subs are in situations plays (i.e 3rd and long and you want pressure on the QB or 4th and short and you want a double TE set). It is obvious to me this is turning way too quickly into a money thing. The more players that get playing time, the more money GLB makes. Sure make the starters wear out (in my game I had subs in the first quarter, and I had just boosted every position giving them all a minimum of 20 stamina) so the next guy in line gets some plays, good plan if its about money, bad plan if its about football.

One last note and my vent will be complete. Most of you have probably played football at some level in your life. Do you remember H.S.? Most kids play two ways and never come out for a series. And I certainly remember the Giants playing four road games in route to a Superbowl win and still their starter were all over the Patriots in the fourth quarter... subs... no there were none... they played the game.


While that is true that it is an everyone must play mentality, do you really want to be stuck at backup perpetually because you found out about the game halfway through the 1st official season? It is a game, and thus about having fun. Also, NFL starters outside of QB play about 75-80% of snaps, not 90.


They should make the training part more complex so guys who ride the pine have a chance to up their exp in a different way, not just PT. Also, eventually those starter's stats will start declining after year 10 and the backups will start to get PT.
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Chriztian

Originally posted by tmoon


This reminds me of PEE-WEE football with the "everyone has to play" mentality. Has anyone ever watched a real football game. Starters get 90 per-cent of the snaps, at every position. The only time there are subs are in situations plays (i.e 3rd and long and you want pressure on the QB or 4th and short and you want a double TE set). It is obvious to me this is turning way too quickly into a money thing. The more players that get playing time, the more money GLB makes. Sure make the starters wear out (in my game I had subs in the first quarter, and I had just boosted every position giving them all a minimum of 20 stamina) so the next guy in line gets some plays, good plan if its about money, bad plan if its about football.

One last note and my vent will be complete. Most of you have probably played football at some level in your life. Do you remember H.S.? Most kids play two ways and never come out for a series. And I certainly remember the Giants playing four road games in route to a Superbowl win and still their starter were all over the Patriots in the fourth quarter... subs... no there were none... they played the game.


While that is true that it is an everyone must play mentality, do you really want to be stuck at backup perpetually because you found out about the game halfway through the 1st official season? It is a game, and thus about having fun. Also, NFL starters outside of QB play about 75-80% of snaps, not 90.


Wrong. Cleveland had 6 players play on O-line ALL SEASON.



It depends on the position. OL and QB play %100 of the time, baring injury/blowouts. DL play probably %70 of the time as do LBs who come out for nickel packages.
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chriztian
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by porkies


The first thing he says in this post is " You will be able to lose up to 40 energy from your energy from one game, instead of 30".

Last season it was not accumalative. You could go down to 70 in one game. so people were going down in energy to like 10 during the game, but after it was always reset to 70 so you had 2 days to train relaxed to get back to 100.

Same thing, now the lowest we can go to is 60. So you could set your sub rate to really low like 10, but they're reset after the game to 60. Then you can train on relaxed to get to 90.

He did say that he's going to rework the energy so it has more of an effect on your performance if you're not at 100%. But he used the word "slight" which is just a little. And that he'd rework it as necessary.

It is Beta version and I would suggest testing if you're not winning your games. Additionally, I've noticed that owners don't publicly share winning strategies for sub rates. You have to manually watch their games and figure it out.


So why waste points on stamina? If no matter what you're going to drop 60 for a lineman then you're foolish to waste ability points on stamina.



Math...it's fundamental. Being able to lose 40% per game does not mean you end each game at 60%. It means you end each game 40% below where you started at at max. Basically by game 10 if you drop the full 40 each game, you're going to miss a game, even training on relaxed. Thus, stamina plays a roll because it affects how many plays you get in and how low you drop for doing those plays.


Why do people keep saying this? Last season, you would never drop below 70 after a game. Why would you think you would ever drop below 60 after a game this season? People are getting confused and we need a mod to clearify this ASAP.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
I agree, the QB rotation needs to be given some thought. Right now the only way to make sure my starter starts every down is if I have no one on the bench.

But THAT means if he gets injured, then no one comes in for him and he plays hurt. Not to mention my backup QB feels insulted not even suiting up.

I would reccomend that QBs at the very least have a separate stamina chart so I can set it so that he only gets subbed if he is injured (ie energy below 60) while I can still keep a higher stamina rotation for the rest of the squad.

I also would reccomend a Score rotation system, whereby if the point difference in the game should ever be X times the number of minutes left in the game, my starters get benched to avoid injuries and to give snaps to the back ups. Such that if I set X to 3, then if I am winning or losing by 16 points with five minutes to go, I give up and bench my starters. If I set it to 5 then I would only bench them if at five minutes the score difference was 26 or more, etc. Maybe you could have different settings for winning or losing too, so you wont give up on trying to win, but you wont run up the score if you are blowing the bad guys out.
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
I agree, the QB rotation needs to be given some thought. Right now the only way to make sure my starter starts every down is if I have no one on the bench.

But THAT means if he gets injured, then no one comes in for him and he plays hurt. Not to mention my backup QB feels insulted not even suiting up.

I would reccomend that QBs at the very least have a separate stamina chart so I can set it so that he only gets subbed if he is injured (ie energy below 60) while I can still keep a higher stamina rotation for the rest of the squad.


They need to seperate the sub ratio by positions, not the entire team. This would help alot.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 17:09:25
 
fentonscorn
offline
Link
 
Weird things are happening right now.

My team played the from the third period on JUST with CPU benchers. I mean the guys in the last slots of the depth chart. Everyone save the QB and the TE were rotating so much that I guess they ended up with dizzy spells instead of bruises at the end of the game.

Reason for the TE not being subbed was because, of course, there were no others on the depth chart. The QB... I guess he is just a tough guy doing easy things.

This is annoying to say the least. I don't care about having my players exhasuted after a game.. I just think it's ridiculous that the starters just play a few games and from the third period on are just basically spectators!

What is going on here? Should I really think about depleting the depth chart to have my intended formation on the field? And what would be the result of that? Would it be better to force your best player to play exhausted or have your 4th liners crappy replacements get in? It's totally unrealistic either way. I am confused and somewhat bummed down.

>>> They need to seperate the sub ratio by positions, not the entire team. This would help alot.

Yes, that would be a start! But still, no matter how low the stamina of some players is, it's ridicoulous to see your best LB be in 2 plays, without not even getting close to the ball (how can he be tired from that??), and then out for 3 plays apparently too tired to even stand in! And that is just one example out of too many equally disappoiting.

 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Pumchavas28

If it helps... My Team (Legion of Doom) just played it's 1st game... No one on the team was below 75 energy... Everyone played on "HARD" & I had my Sub out/in ratio at 70 Out/95 In...

The only position where the Ratio of Plays for the Starter & Back-Up did not add up, was the QB position....

Both of our QB's played almost the identical # of plays... WHich shouldn't be looking at their Stamina Ratings (JMO)... for the other positions they are close also, but only because the back-ups were in on Special Teams also... Had they not counted Special Teams plays the difference would definetly favor the Starters (Except QB)...

I think if anything, the QB position should be looked at as far as Subs go... JMO...

But overall.. I have no complaints about the new set up for energy/stamina.. JMO comparing the play ratio from this game to last years game.



What if you leave the QB backup off the depth chart? If that works then we might have a work around. So now all these backup lvl 4's wanting as much playing time as a starter can get ZERO.


I'm not going to be an A-Hole like that to one of my players...

Yeah some Players are being A-Holes to Owners & some Owners are being A-Holes to Players... I'm neither...

My back up QB was getting a good rotation last season & he was cool with it, now he's getting split playing time & out of all the positions, that's the only one that did not make sense...

If ANYTHING... I would like to see the Mods add a Position Specific Sub Out/In ability for Owners so that we can better dictate who plays & how often...
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 16:37:03
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fentonscorn

>>> They need to seperate the sub ratio by positions, not the entire team. This would help alot.


Agreed.
 
PhireHawk
offline
Link
 
I don't know about the sub'ing and I've read Bort and whoever else say on here a million times "it's easy to suggest things"

Coding it in and making it work is something else all together.

So, I see a lot of people wanting these complex code scripts where it checks mid-simulation for the score and then decides to sub or not sub in the QB.

Sounds good in theory.

All that aside, I am just curious why I lost 40 Energy handing off the ball 49 times, dropping back to pass a modest 31 times, and not getting sacked once. Also only getting hurried twice.

With 24 stamina, 86 plays of very lite QB type work, and I lose 40 energy?

That needs some attention...

If I was a running QB, and on Hard Intensity for 105 plays, then fine - 40 Energy or whatever I could understand...

I'm a pocket passer. I do not run with the ball, ever!
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
QB seems to be a big issue... Most of us feel your pain PhireHawk.
 
DPGDawg
offline
Link
 
I PMd new guy Thorn and asked him about the Stamina issue
We reall need a clarification on the quick.


I understand most everything about the Stamina issue.
What I want to know , or would like to have clarified , is ...

Does low stamina during a game affect the players performance ?

Lets say you only have 15 Stamina stat and you play for 90 plays in game.
During that game your stamina might drop to 0 for all we know but after the
game it is reset to 60 no matter what it was at games end.

So if you train on Relaxed for 2 days you will start the next game at 90 stamina.
But if Stamina has no real in game effect then it doesnt really matter what you start
out with or how low you go during the game.
So there is no reason to have any backups play.

But if low stamina DOES effect player efficiency in game then you wouldnt want
him to go below a certain stamina level during the game.

So what I , We , need to know is .......

How much , If any , does low stamina effect a player during a game. And EXACTLY how much
and to what degree at various stamina levels ?


Thanks for your attention to this and I am anxiously awaiting a response.
 
fentonscorn
offline
Link
 
Something else I'd love to know is how quickly your players wear out (and recover) DURING a game.

I can't really make up my mind about sub-in sub-out ratio because I have no way to figure out how quick players wear out or recover! I know it's tied to your stamina value (the lower the stamina the quicker they tire and the slower they recover).

Still it looks to me like the actual values are so unrealistic (starters getting benched over and over after playing a couple of plays without not even getting close to the ball) that there's no way to figure out or to have your best team on the field.

I am not concerned about post-game energy depleting, it's my fault if I set them all on HARD intensity. I just want to find a way to realistically field the best team most of the time (as in the real thing).

Having to play in the late third quarter with 11 (eleven!) replacements for two plays is just bizarre.

That said, if someone out there understood the whole thing better than me and just wants to tell me a good sub-in sub-out ratio that respect starters a little more I would be happy.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.